RE: BMW M240i xDrive vs. Birds BMW M235i
RE: BMW M240i xDrive vs. Birds BMW M235i
Sunday 20th March 2022

BMW M240i xDrive vs. Birds BMW M235i

The new straight-six, compact BMW coupe doesn't have a conventional rival - apart from the old one...



Allow us this one, please. Because while this test is skewed in just about every possible way for comparing a pair of BMW 2 Series - new versus used, standard versus modified, rear- versus four-wheel drive - it was impossible to resist pitching new M240i against old M235i. As far back as the 1 Series Coupes, the baby BMWs have always occupied their own space, even in a small coupe market so sparsely populated. The rear seats give them something over a Porsche Cayman, they've all been more interesting to drive than any version of the Audi TT, as well as being classier than a Nissan Z and faster than anything Toyota or Subaru managed. While at the same time getting customers into a straight-six BMW for less than a 3 or 4 Series. Comparing generations just made sense because there's very little like the smallest two-door BMWs with 3.0-litre engines.

For all that BMW (rightly) gets stick for nowadays, its decision to base the latest G42 2 Series on the CLAR architecture also used for the 4 Series (rather than the UKL1 platform that underpins the 1 Series hatch and 2 Gran Coupe) deserves praise. Because doubtless it could have tweaked the underwhelming four-cylinder, xDrive 35i models in those ranges to get something approaching a coupe. But it hasn't. Instead it has given us another relatively compact (we'll come back to that point) two-door coupe with a big straight six up front. And even with standard-fit xDrive, the emphasis is very much on the rear axle.

Moreover, as you've hopefully seen already, BMW has done a great job out of the box with this M Performance 2 Series in a way it never quite managed with the old car. Despite carrying far more mass it manages the kilos better, even in the dampers' standard Comfort mode, and Sport doesn't make it unbearable either (as it can in an M3), instead delivering almost boundless control for wheel and (chunky) body. It deals with bumps, imperfections and direction changes an order of magnitude better than the old generation, making the driver far more confident over a typical British B-road in how it's going to behave.



Which, as it turns out, is very smartly. The steering is more direct than the memory says an old 2 Series was, cutting out any mush and giving the 240i a willingness to turn that belies its kerbweight. The xDrive feels as smartly configured here as in other installations, feeling for all the world like a RWD BMW most of the time - it's the back axle pushing you out of a bend, maybe just overspeeding a tad, never the front pulling the car around. The eight-speed Aisin auto is neat, too, stacking the ratios close and changing decisively. (The reluctance to change down I didn't find, though that might be through relying on a higher gear and the torque more often).

Plus, of course, you're being motored along by a smooth, responsive, powerful engine. The B58 perhaps isn't a BMW icon but, quite frankly, having any kind of straight six in small car is welcome nowadays. And the driver is never in any doubt of that, even if the sound is a little too smooth for its own synthesised good on occasion.

So what's the problem? Well, maybe 'problem' is too harsh a word, but the overriding impression of this M240i xDrive is of a factionally smaller, ever so slightly faster - most certainly uglier - M440i xDrive. No bad thing, you might say, as that means a BMW with a great interior, a fine engine, and accomplished handling. But the hope was that with the rest of the two-door range maturing - the M4 is now what an M6 would have been a few years ago - the 2 Series might offer something a little rowdier as the entry point to the lineup. Perhaps that's a churlish criticism, feeling too much like a more expensive car - not least with an M2 still to come - though in being as well-appointed and refined as it is, the M240i does struggle for that impish sense of fun one might hope to discover in the smallest BMW two-door with almost 400hp.



The weight most certainly counts against it, too, despite the sorted suspension. Where an M3 or M4 remains wildly exciting with xDrive, it has 510hp and 479lb ft to credit for that. An M240i, with 'just' the 374hp and 369lb ft - and only 85kg in its favour - inevitably never delivers quite the same thrill. Perhaps it doesn't need to, as a mere M Performance car - but so adept is the chassis now (and so alarming the kerbweight) that xDrive almost feels surplus to requirements.

Because 380hp or so in a properly set up, two-wheel drive 2 Series is nothing to fear - it's something to relish, as the Birds B2 380 makes abundantly clear, even far from the first flush of youth. This 2015 M235i is kitted out with near enough everything Birds sells for the F22-era 2 Series, and as such a full conversion will cost £5,439 excluding VAT. For that buyers get the Quaife limited-slip differential, the 380hp ECU upgrade and Birds' bespoke tune of Bilstein dampers, paired with its own springs, with days lavished on the set up. The parts are also available individually: 380hp costs £1,100, the suspension £1,561 and the Quaife diff £1,631, all excluding VAT. As with similar work by BBR on MX-5s, it seems like a lot when there are early M235is available for little more than £15k, but with later M240is still on offer with delivery mileage for less than £35,000, the temptation for some optimisation is readily apparent. Especially given the residual strength of M2s, and the near-£50k asked for an M240i...

If you've read anything about Birds-tuned BMWs before, you'll know what to expect from the B2 380 experience. If not, it's best surmised as what these M Performance models really should have been from the get-go; more refined and less boisterous than a full-fat M car, yet with enough extra chassis sophistication to make the most of a sparkling powertrain. As an everyday fast car compromise, it remains a tough one to beat.



Even with sufficient miles to put another suspension refresh on the cards, plus Birds' own forged 19-inch wheels (where 18s would probably offer a smarter compromise), the B2 immediately impresses with its taut pliancy. As standard, the 235i could do both crashy and floaty within yards of each other, and the Birds' Bilsteins near enough eradicate that - without a mode or setting in sight, too.

The Quaife diff sits alongside the suspension as a must have for anyone thinking about modifying an M235i or M240i. Not merely because it allows big silly skids, but because it works with the chassis to better deploy the engine's ample reserves. The inconsistency and unpredictability that can come with a powerful RWD car running an open diff is gone, replaced with much more transparent (and enjoyable) relationship between throttle pedal, steering wheel and rear axle. This is what baby BMWs should feel like, where the coupe experience is enhanced by rear-wheel drive and not overawed or undermined by it. For all its demonstrator miles, the Birds car remains more rewarding to drive than the original ever was when factory fresh.

The engine upgrade is nice to have, too, for feeling as fast as the new one as much as anything, but it's far less essential than the dynamic fettling. Even so, it should be said that the new 2 Series is better resolved when pushed than the old car, with greater stability, control and composure, shrugging off the worst a road can throw at it just when the Birds car just starts to run out of ideas (and suspension travel). It really is that good. For all that its dumpy looks, it's a far more complete coupe out of the gate than the previous generation.



There can be little doubting, however, that the 2 Series has lost something of its rascally nature in growing up and settling down its unwanted body movements. It feels like a 4 Series because it is one, and now there isn't another BMW coupe lower down the range we can look to for that old-school feel. Again, it's hard not to come across old and cantankerous when presented with a new car that makes crucial gains over its predecessor, but a more muted six-cylinder sound, the lack of a manual option and unavoidable all-wheel drive are almost as notable as its unquestionable positives.

Hopefully Birds can work similar magic on this latest 2 Series. The old car is a reminder of what the company does so well, retaining the OEM feel while addressing the known issues with real finesse. Those craving the traditional BMW feel - a rasping straight six and sorted rear-drive chassis - alongside modern amenities ought to love a Birds BMW. Especially when it looks this smart. Even in 2022, you can get a one-owner, sub-30k M235i and add the Dynamics Package (so just standard power) for less than £25,000. On this experience, it'd be really hard to justify spending another £5k on an M2 with more than twice the miles, because Birds closes the gap so well. Now there's a better 2 Series to start with, there's good reason to hope more will come of it soon, because raw potential is in such ample supply. At the very least, the new M2 ought to be something really special.


SPECIFICATION | BMW M240i xDRIVE (G42)

Engine: 2,998cc, straight-six, turbocharged
Transmission: 8-speed automatic, all-wheel drive
Power (hp): 374@5,500-6,500rpm
Torque (lb ft): 369@1,900-5,000rpm
0-62mph: 4.3secs
Top speed: 155mph
Weight: 1,765kg (EU, with driver)
MPG: 34.4 (WLTP)
CO2: 186g/km (WLTP)
Price: £45,415 (as standard, price as tested £48,065, comprised of Technology Pack (Parking Assistant, Head-Up Display, Enhanced Bluetooth with Wireless Charging and WiFi Hotspot) for £1,250, Comfort Pack (Heated steering wheel and Comfort Access) for £500, Aluminium Tetragon interior for £150 and Harmon Kardon Surround Sound Audio System for £750)

SPECIFICATION | BIRDS BMW M235I (F22)

Engine: 2,979cc, turbo straight-six
Transmission: 8-speed automatic, rear-wheel drive
Power (hp): 326@5,800rpm (standard car, Birds 380)
Torque (lb ft): 332@1,300-4,500rpm (standard car, Birds N/A)
0-62mph: 4.8sec
Top speed: 155mph (limited)
Weight: 1,545kg (EU, auto)
MPG: 37.2 (NEDC, standard car)
CO2: 176g/km (NEDC, standard car)
Price: £see text (Full Birds B2 380 conversion £5,439 plus VAT, all parts available individually and compatible with M235i or M240i. Search the former here and latter here.)









Author
Discussion

cerb4.5lee

Original Poster:

45,307 posts

211 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
I wouldn't say no to either of them, and there is a lot to be said about a small(ish) BMW with a lovely straight six turbo engine I reckon. smokin

drpep

1,761 posts

199 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
Not to be Mr Whingy Pants but 1,765kg for a compact, 2+2 seater coupe is remarkably porky. I guess that's the cost of a decent crash structure. I'd take the Birds-fettled car given the choice.

Billy_Whizzzz

2,677 posts

174 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
Think I’m alone in hating the shape of the earlier 2 series (except M2) and preferring the 1er. And, also, quite liking the shape of the newer 240.

NelsonM3

1,777 posts

202 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
Why use an F22 that has been modified to the point you can’t make a useful comparison? It’s like the people on this forum who say, “Why have a Golf R when my remapped 2.0TDI is just as fast and only £1000”.

I’ve owned a manual M240i and it whilst it wasn’t awful it was certainly a disappointment for a car enthusiast. I’ve driven the new M240i and currently drive the new 220i Coupe. It’s a fantastic steer.

The fact it does feel/drive similar to a 4 series, a car universally praised for its handling, is not a hindrance but actually makes it a performance bargain.

Motormouth88

807 posts

91 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
Old 2 series till the cows come home. New one is a design flop much like all bmw designs of late

ducnick

2,293 posts

274 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
Did I read that right? Bmw have done away with the zf8hp and put an 8 speed Aisin Warner box in??? Really? Such a shame they cost cut the gearbox because the Zf8hp really is so good and Aisin, well . They are just about ok for FWD Volvos but it’s no match for the zf8hp.

Edited by ducnick on Saturday 19th March 07:56

Limpet

6,629 posts

192 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
ducnick said:
Did I read that right? Bmw have done away with the zf8hp and put an 8 speed Aisin Warner box in???
I think that’s a mistake in the article. My understanding is that the Aisin unit is used in the transverse engined models (MINI platform stuff, basically) and the ZF in everything else.

cerb4.5lee

Original Poster:

45,307 posts

211 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
Billy_Whizzzz said:
Think I’m alone in hating the shape of the earlier 2 series (except M2) and preferring the 1er. And, also, quite liking the shape of the newer 240.
They've always been a bit on the subtle side for my liking, and I've never got on with the rear lights with them either. I do think that they will be a great all round performance car though.

I love the F82 M4 that I have, but they are a big car though, and the M4 is actually longer than our family SUV! The size is the biggest thing that attracts me to the 2 series, and they are nice and compact I reckon.

I really fell for the new M240i when I saw it in the metal, but I didn't like it from the photos I'd seen though.

Dombilano

1,481 posts

86 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
8 speed Aisin? Nah, it's ZF. Doh.

I 8 a 4RE

575 posts

272 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
I dont understand how this can be even a comparison.

Perhaps for PH editors -would have been racing drivers- who are perpetually lucky to not get booked by the police for reckless driving.

But back in the real world the difference in performance will be too close to call. The main fun for these type of cars is to be had in a manual box and kicking the arse out on wet roundabouts (when traffic conditions quiet of course) a little bit and no more than 20 degree slip angle.

You could never have that type of fun in a 4wd so these cars are not even in the same category.

Shiv_P

3,059 posts

136 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
I think a better comparison would have been a used M2 competition or a new M240i xDrive

Wab1974uk

1,430 posts

58 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
drpep said:
Not to be Mr Whingy Pants but 1,765kg for a compact, 2+2 seater coupe is remarkably porky. I guess that's the cost of a decent crash structure. I'd take the Birds-fettled car given the choice.
Just wait till the only option is a i240. 2.5 Tonnes

nickfrog

25,471 posts

248 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
Wab1974uk said:
Just wait till the only option is a i240. 2.5 Tonnes
I don't think it would be that much. Irrelevant anyway as the extra weight would be low and between the axles so it will probably have a lower CoG and lower polar moment of inertia. Better handling potential while regeneration under braking will help retardation.

Me Alec

115 posts

83 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
I too have wondered about these new compact 3 Series …. wasn't it always the intention that the 3 Series would be a small car?

I have a '58 plated Coupe and whilst I've never parked it next to a 5 Series, the body lengths and structures seem very similar to me.

Water Fairy

6,661 posts

186 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
Previous M2 Comp for me please. It's not just the drive but the styling too.

jbforce10

509 posts

206 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
I 8 a 4RE said:
I dont understand how this can be even a comparison.

Perhaps for PH editors -would have been racing drivers- who are perpetually lucky to not get booked by the police for reckless driving.

But back in the real world the difference in performance will be too close to call. The main fun for these type of cars is to be had in a manual box and kicking the arse out on wet roundabouts (when traffic conditions quiet of course) a little bit and no more than 20 degree slip angle.

You could never have that type of fun in a 4wd so these cars are not even in the same category.
My friend that used to do sideways laps of roundabouts in Colchester in his Integrales would beg to differ.
(Highlighting one of two advantages of driving a LHD in the UK smile with the other being the convenience of exiting the car on the pavement side.)

s m

24,494 posts

234 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
jbforce10 said:
I 8 a 4RE said:
I dont understand how this can be even a comparison.

Perhaps for PH editors -would have been racing drivers- who are perpetually lucky to not get booked by the police for reckless driving.

But back in the real world the difference in performance will be too close to call. The main fun for these type of cars is to be had in a manual box and kicking the arse out on wet roundabouts (when traffic conditions quiet of course) a little bit and no more than 20 degree slip angle.

You could never have that type of fun in a 4wd so these cars are not even in the same category.
My friend that used to do sideways laps of roundabouts in Colchester in his Integrales would beg to differ.
(Highlighting one of two advantages of driving a LHD in the UK smile with the other being the convenience of exiting the car on the pavement side.)
Are we getting the new rwd M240i with manual like some other markets in months to come?

TyrannosauRoss Lex

36,729 posts

243 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
drpep said:
Not to be Mr Whingy Pants but 1,765kg for a compact, 2+2 seater coupe is remarkably porky. I guess that's the cost of a decent crash structure. I'd take the Birds-fettled car given the choice.
With 75kgs driver and also with fuel. Most manufacturers claim a weight without either, so it makes this look a lot heavier in relation to its rivals than it actually is. In reality it'll likely be under 1600kgs.

Water Fairy

6,661 posts

186 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
TyrannosauRoss Lex said:
drpep said:
Not to be Mr Whingy Pants but 1,765kg for a compact, 2+2 seater coupe is remarkably porky. I guess that's the cost of a decent crash structure. I'd take the Birds-fettled car given the choice.
With 75kgs driver and also with fuel. Most manufacturers claim a weight without either, so it makes this look a lot heavier in relation to its rivals than it actually is. In reality it'll likely be under 1600kgs.
So it's still heavy then?

TyrannosauRoss Lex

36,729 posts

243 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
Water Fairy said:
TyrannosauRoss Lex said:
drpep said:
Not to be Mr Whingy Pants but 1,765kg for a compact, 2+2 seater coupe is remarkably porky. I guess that's the cost of a decent crash structure. I'd take the Birds-fettled car given the choice.
With 75kgs driver and also with fuel. Most manufacturers claim a weight without either, so it makes this look a lot heavier in relation to its rivals than it actually is. In reality it'll likely be under 1600kgs.
So it's still heavy then?
Yep, similar to the old E46 M3. It's a 2+2 family coupe, not a Lotus Elise.