Car sales surveys unfair?

Car sales surveys unfair?

Author
Discussion

IanCress

Original Poster:

4,409 posts

172 months

Friday 29th July 2016
quotequote all
A week after purchasing an almost new car (65 plate, 2k miles) and I've received a phone call from the saleswoman, asking why I marked her 4 stars out of 5 on the survey. She explains that she felt she did everything right and can't understand why I marked her down by 1 star. She seemed to be taking it quite personally.

Except I didn't mark HER down. The survey explained that I was rating the whole experience, not just the sales woman.

I marked them down because they promise that cars requiring a service in the next 6 months will be serviced before being sold. Mine wasn't serviced, despite being due in 4 months. Apparently this is because it's a 'Ford Direct' car, and comes under different standards. Ford Direct cars are only serviced if they are within 3 months of requiring a service. Nowhere is this explained on their website, and I find it strange that Ford Direct cars are less well looked after than the older cars on their forecourt.

Anyway, now I feel bad as the saleswoman has lost her bonus for this month because of me. But they need to make their surveys clearer.

KTF

9,997 posts

156 months

Friday 29th July 2016
quotequote all
If I was buying a car and it needed a service in 4-6 months time I would hold off until it actually needed a service rather than pulling the interval in by 4-6 months and messing up the service interval dates.

Maybe thats just me though?

OverSteery

3,659 posts

237 months

Friday 29th July 2016
quotequote all
Perhaps you should write to the garage rather than here. Praise your salesperson and slag off their satisfaction survey team.

Ren Esis

419 posts

144 months

Friday 29th July 2016
quotequote all
I find this practice annoying. You've submitted a rating, possibly with an option to explain why you've given that score - then get a phone call where you have to justify your score.

It's the reason I never leave feedback, good or bad.

Motorrad

6,811 posts

193 months

Friday 29th July 2016
quotequote all
In light of a call like that I'd be informing her she just lost another few stars.

raceboy

13,266 posts

286 months

Friday 29th July 2016
quotequote all
I'd have been informing her that the 'last' star on any survey is only achieved if the individual has gone beyond the call of duty, if oral was offered on the test drive then 5 stars. hehe

Toyoda

1,557 posts

106 months

Friday 29th July 2016
quotequote all
IanCress said:
Anyway, now I feel bad as the saleswoman has lost her bonus for this month because of me.
Well boo fking hoo. Not your problem! Her phone call to you wasn't going to change her bonus (or lack thereof) and served no purpose other than to make you feel bad. Maybe the bint should get a proper job.

IanCress

Original Poster:

4,409 posts

172 months

Friday 29th July 2016
quotequote all
raceboy said:
I'd have been informing her that the 'last' star on any survey is only achieved if the individual has gone beyond the call of duty, if oral was offered on the test drive then 5 stars. hehe
She wouldn't have been able to reach. My Wife was occupying the passenger seat so the saleswoman was in the back.

IanCress

Original Poster:

4,409 posts

172 months

Friday 29th July 2016
quotequote all
Toyoda said:
Well boo fking hoo. Not your problem! Her phone call to you wasn't going to change her bonus (or lack thereof) and served no purpose other than to make you feel bad. Maybe the bint should get a proper job.
Well actually, I agreed to bump it up to 5 stars but explain in the comments that the website appears to be deliberately misleading.

anonymous-user

60 months

Friday 29th July 2016
quotequote all
Calling you to discuss in that manor is pretty unprofessional. The person's bonus (or lack of it) is nothing to do with you.

rockford22

361 posts

138 months

Friday 29th July 2016
quotequote all
Virtually all customer satisfaction surveys that impact on staff bonuses consider anything less than 9 or 10 to be a "fail" and often mean the sales staff don't receive their bonus. I had to deal with frustrated sales staff regularly moaning that their customer rated them 8/10 and was perfectly content with the service.

Pretty bad form for her to call you and moan though!


MarkRSi

5,782 posts

224 months

Friday 29th July 2016
quotequote all
IanCress said:
Anyway, now I feel bad as the saleswoman has lost her bonus for this month because of me. But they need to make their surveys clearer.
Nope, it was the websites fault for not explaining the servicing nonsense correctly. Also it's a bit poor that the surveys are not anonymous.

If salesmuppet tried to blame you for it, I'd be tempted to agree with this

Motorrad said:
In light of a call like that I'd be informing her she just lost another few stars.

FD3Si

857 posts

150 months

Friday 29th July 2016
quotequote all
Toyoda said:
Well boo fking hoo. Not your problem! Her phone call to you wasn't going to change her bonus (or lack thereof) and served no purpose other than to make you feel bad. Maybe the bint should get a proper job.
Nice. So, captain superior, 2 questions:
a) Why isn't it a proper job?
b) If you had a 'proper' job where your bonus was dependent on feedback, and for some reason you didn't get the required feedback, would you not try and establish where you went wrong in order to either do a better job next time, or if you want to reduce it to pure financial requirements, how you can maximise your take home.

These surveys can be very unfair on the salespeople. As you've unfortunately noted, it's often that questions that define the salesperson#s 'score' are so badly phrased that they appear not to be a 'score' of the person, but the company in general.

Edited by FD3Si on Friday 29th July 13:07

Landlord

12,689 posts

263 months

Friday 29th July 2016
quotequote all
Would her bonus be decided on literally one customer not giving her the full five stars? So if she sold 100 cars and got 499 stars out of 500 they wouldn't give her the bonus? Really?? (I don't work in sales so I have no idea if it's that cut-throat).

If not, she's just phoned round all the people who didn't give 5 stars and given them the same "it's because of your rating alone" story. Fingers crossed it doesn't work on enough people. Phoning up and telling me off for not giving her the review she wanted would piss me right off. I'd be considering complaining to the DP.

Assuming of course that her tone was resentful or "moaning". If she was just upset and asking what more she could have done then that'd be different.

Did she have a nice rack or not, btw?

SteveSteveson

3,209 posts

169 months

Friday 29th July 2016
quotequote all
The problem is the stty scoring system and the inability of some managers to get that not everything will be perfect for everyone. It's not helped by the large number of people who give 0 or full marks for everything. It's a running point of annoyence within many customer service and sales groups. You get a kicking if any customer gives less than 100% satisfaction. You just need to go and look at a few of the 1 star reviews on Tripadvisor to realise some people are just mental. "Everything was perfect for the two weeks I was there, appart from it rained a 4am on the first wednesday and my rain coat I had left out on the balcony got wet. Therefore the whole thing time was ruined. 1*"

CaptainCosworth

6,249 posts

99 months

Friday 29th July 2016
quotequote all
Bought a new car a few weeks back, we got on really well with the salesman (we bought the OH's car from him last year), and were happy with the service and deal we got. He gave us a heads up that we'd get a survey in the next few days, and was open and honest to say it would reflect on both him (not mentioned but implied bonus) and the dealership, and could we please give maximum ratings. If there was anything else he could do then feel free to call, or if there was any reason why we wouldn't want to give maximum ratings then please let him know.

Was happy to oblige, only took 5 minutes and hopefully kept the salesman on side. Had the car for 6 weeks now with no issues, but if anything does occur then hopefully gained a few points with the guy to help smooth things along.

With regards to the OP's saleswoman, if the survey was that important then perhaps she should have made this clearer in advance?

CaptainCosworth

6,249 posts

99 months

Friday 29th July 2016
quotequote all
SteveSteveson said:
The problem is the stty scoring system and the inability of some managers to get that not everything will be perfect for everyone. It's not helped by the large number of people who give 0 or full marks for everything. It's a running point of annoyence within many customer service and sales groups. You get a kicking if any customer gives less than 100% satisfaction. You just need to go and look at a few of the 1 star reviews on Tripadvisor to realise some people are just mental. "Everything was perfect for the two weeks I was there, appart from it rained a 4am on the first wednesday and my rain coat I had left out on the balcony got wet. Therefore the whole thing time was ruined. 1*"
laugh

Lester H

3,027 posts

111 months

Friday 29th July 2016
quotequote all
IanCress said:
A week after purchasing an almost new car (65 plate, 2k miles) and I've received a phone call from the saleswoman, asking why I marked her 4 stars out of 5 on the survey. She explains that she felt she did everything right and can't understand why I marked her down by 1 star. She seemed to be taking it quite personally.

Except I didn't mark HER down. The survey explained that I was rating the whole experience, not just the sales woman.

I marked them down because they promise that cars requiring a service in the next 6 months will be serviced before being sold. Mine wasn't serviced, despite being due in 4 months. Apparently this is because it's a 'Ford Direct' car, and comes under different standards. Ford Direct cars are only serviced if they are within 3 months of requiring a service. Nowhere is this explained on their website, and I find it strange that Ford Direct cars are less well looked after than the older cars on their forecourt.

Anyway, now I feel bad as the saleswoman has lost her bonus for this month because of me. But they need to make their surveys clearer.
iOh, dear! Don't so many garages love avoiding work on the cars they are selling. ....and Ford Direct supposed to be "premium " too. Do t think many buyers would object to an early service,

X5TUU

12,120 posts

193 months

Friday 29th July 2016
quotequote all
Mega mega unprofessional of her. I wouldn't think twice about forgetting about it all and moving on - plus how dare she ring you and question your personal opinion ... Did I mention how shockingly unprofessional she is?!?

I'd even actually consider writing a complaint about such practices to the DP

f1nn

2,693 posts

198 months

Friday 29th July 2016
quotequote all
This type of scoring system, and the relation to the teams/individual bonus, seems to be common.

Certainly the main dealer I use, the service manager is open and upfront with me about it, and asks if there is anything that would prevent me from giving them full marks, and if so can we resolve it before I leave.

I know some may find this approach pushy maybe, but I don't mind it. We're all just trying to get paid after all, and if a mark on a piece of paper or online survey got the guy an extra couple of quid at the end of the month, I'm happy to do it.