Freelander II v Subaru Outback v .....?

[hornetrider]

My old man has let me know that when he comes out of his company car in August he's going to be looking at about 20 bags worth of diesel Freelander II. Now, as I'm 'into my cars' he asked me if this is a good idea and I duly told him I'd do a bit of digging and help him out.

Now, as far as I'm aware the first Freelander wasn't all that well made - but I'm not overly sure on this. Discos of the same era certainly get a panning for reliability. What are they like?

A few years ago he almost went for a Legacy Outback (which I consider the preferable choice here) but at the time they chose a Rav 4. I really like the new shape Outback and think it looks a cracking buy, and it's the car I'd recommend.

Their requirements are 4x4 but not really requiring major offroading ability - its for snowy winters in the depths of Wales and a bit of load carrying capacity.

So... at 20k ish what are the good, intelligent options? Only proviso is no more than 3 years old, 4 at a push if it brings up something special, and should be diesel.

[hornetrider]

Thanks for feedback so far. I've had a word and done some digging and it looks like the Outback is out as they don't do a diesel auto, he wants an auto. What others are in the mix? They also considered an XC60 a while back - are the XC90s any good?

Sorry this topic is wandering a bit isn't it I'm more concernced with FL2 feedback tbh, I don't want him buying a money pit and spending my inheritance on head gaskets

[hornetrider]

None as yet (in this round of car buying). He's overseas at the mo and is looking to buy when he returns - the FL2 is what's ticking the boxes (on paper) so far. I just want to help him come to the right decision (ie not buy a money pit that will spend more time at the dealer).

[hornetrider]

Mark Benson said:

Why go for the Outback if he doesn't need the ground clearance?

TBH they are getting on a bit and Dad has dodgy knees from his rugby/squash days. I think they want to step 'into' rather than 'down to' the seats, if you see what I mean. Also they have a couple of dogs, do a lot of tip runs, house renovation etc. The higher driving position appeals.