Help me! FK8 Type R vs 718 Cayman T

[Recalcitrant]

Hi,

I am currently looking to change my car (a large diesel BMW) and want something more fun. I keep flip-flopping between these two and am really quite torn.

It would be a daily driver and my only car - but I have access to a large car if/when required. Annual mileage is around 12k.

I have looked at and driven all sorts, and these are my two favourites, contrasting though they may be in some respects.

The cars would both be around 2020, used examples. I don't really need much practicality, although I do count it as a slight negative, one being a 2 seater.

In terms of power, both are similar at 300bhp vs 320. I'd also ideally prefer PDK on the 718.

Pro's and cons for me (probably missed some):

718

Pros:

• It's a Porsche which holds a certain appeal
• Looks great
• A pure sports car with a fantastic chassis and balance
• Longer warranty included with approved used compared to Honda (unless you pay)
• High quality cabin and better general refinement

Cons:

• £15k~ more expensive, potentially - although residuals will offset this somewhat etc
• 2 seats and general lack of practicality for large objects, although this is rarely going to be an issue
• I like the engine but it's nothing to get too excited about
• On average, higher costs to run (although the service schedule is longer)
• Specs are very hit and miss

FK8

Pros:

• I love how these look - I know that isn't the case for everyone
• One of the finest cars to drive of its type
• Good level of standard spec (adaptive cruise, CarPlay etc)
• No shortage of performance
• Sounds pretty good although like the 718, engine sound is lacking
• 4 seats and a large boot when needed

Cons:

• Lacks the premium and more grown up image of the 718 - but I don't really care about that in honesty
• More regular service intervals so probably not that much cheaper overall to run in that respect
• It's a Civic underneath, which makes it feel expensive, even though it's another level of engineering entirely

There are many other things/differences but my main line of thinking is (and TLDR) - these are two cars with similar power, both have excellent handling, is the 718 worth the extra...?

[Recalcitrant]

Thanks for the replies.

I’ve tried M2’s, both normal and Comp, great cars but I’ve had a few BMW’s and would like a change.

I get they aren’t obviously comparable, but to me they are.

- similar power and the same engine size
- both designed to be a raw driving experience on a typical B road

Of course the Porsche is a pure sports car, but the FK8 is universally raved about for many of the same reasons.

[Recalcitrant]

CG2020UK said:

Completely fair regarding the M2.

Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio would be similar to Cayman money?

Not that I’m making your life any easier lol

A fine suggestion and I’ve actually driven one - but dealer network and warranty queries don’t fill me with confidence…

[Recalcitrant]

ZX10R NIN said:

This is a heart decision so I won't tell you which one to buy BUT I will say that if you're doing 12k a year in the 718 your residuals won't be as strong as you may have accounted for.

That's another consideration. It needs to be able to take a fair few miles - which it no doubt can, but it's less than ideal on such a car... finance wise.