993 vs 996

Author
Discussion

NTY

76 posts

223 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
I can only have 6 MK2 because of its light, still cannot accept MK1's light. I had never laid eyes on 996 until MK2 came around. I kind of like 996's wide body models such as turbo and C4S. Of course I would like to have a 993 but I think 996 is a all round better car. 993 is better valued mainly because of its rarity and not because it is a better car IMO. That's just me so don't kill me.

996 is my first porker and I'll want to experience an air cooled one day to find out what's the fuss about them. Don't get me wrong, I have always love 911 since I was a boy.

Boshly

2,776 posts

238 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
johnycarrera said:
The only 911 fans who like 996's are those who own them !
And? Why is that such a surprising statement? If you like a car, buy one (if you can afford to).

Maybe they're the only real 911 fans as they put their money where their mouth is? (and before the flaming starts no, I don't really believe that biggrin )

laugh

It's a subjective issue, some do some don't, get over it (aimed at everyone smile )

monthefish

20,449 posts

233 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
911p said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Although the MkI does look very, very nice in that pic, IMO it's facelift FTW. Headlights just look so modern on the facelift - ahead of the 997 even.
Totally agree.

The 997 headlight design was a step backward in my book.

guyvert1

1,858 posts

244 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
Personally prefer the 993, but the 996 has its place, the handling is second to none in its now bargain price range, even when the 997 comes down to mid 20's, the 996 will still be popular as it will be even cheaper!.

But the sensible money will always be in the 993's and down, apart from the 'specials' above...

gbrownlow

4,843 posts

172 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
Overrated and over inflated prices for an old banger or modern supercar performance and handling at a bargain price, mmmmmmmmmmm let me think ?

I'll have my fried eggs sunnyside up please lol

truckpdt

216 posts

221 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
gbrownlow said:
Overrated and over inflated prices for an old banger or modern supercar performance and handling at a bargain price, mmmmmmmmmmm let me think ?

I'll have my fried eggs sunnyside up please lol
While your still thinking don't forget to purchase a warranty for your modern "supercar", don't forget the AA for when the intermediate shaft fails or the cylinder walls eventually break down. oh and keep a spare RMS or two as you'll need them as well. Oh and don't forget the continued depreciation....of course that's fine, because money can be chucked away in such a lucrative and stable economy. And if you can get some cheap radiators then pick them up as they'll rust eventually with the stack of leaves that accumulate next to them. Yeah, yeah, I can see the logic in having one. Old banger 993 - well I've had mine 4 years and how many issues have I had - let me see how many hands I need to count the issues on.....oh, uh none, I've not had one single problem....how bizzare for an older banger.

Boshly

2,776 posts

238 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
truckpdt said:
gbrownlow said:
Overrated and over inflated prices for an old banger or modern supercar performance and handling at a bargain price, mmmmmmmmmmm let me think ?

I'll have my fried eggs sunnyside up please lol
While your still thinking don't forget to purchase a warranty for your modern "supercar", don't forget the AA for when the intermediate shaft fails or the cylinder walls eventually break down. oh and keep a spare RMS or two as you'll need them as well. Oh and don't forget the continued depreciation....of course that's fine, because money can be chucked away in such a lucrative and stable economy. And if you can get some cheap radiators then pick them up as they'll rust eventually with the stack of leaves that accumulate next to them. Yeah, yeah, I can see the logic in having one. Old banger 993 - well I've had mine 4 years and how many issues have I had - let me see how many hands I need to count the issues on.....oh, uh none, I've not had one single problem....how bizzare for an older banger.
Oh woe is me, oh woe is me, the sky is falling..............

laugh

yes I know he called the 993 a 'banger' but I think he was just trying to make a point, chill!! I love this thread smile

gerradiuk

1,669 posts

197 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
truckpdt said:
gbrownlow said:
Overrated and over inflated prices for an old banger or modern supercar performance and handling at a bargain price, mmmmmmmmmmm let me think ?

I'll have my fried eggs sunnyside up please lol
While your still thinking don't forget to purchase a warranty for your modern "supercar", don't forget the AA for when the intermediate shaft fails or the cylinder walls eventually break down. oh and keep a spare RMS or two as you'll need them as well. Oh and don't forget the continued depreciation....of course that's fine, because money can be chucked away in such a lucrative and stable economy. And if you can get some cheap radiators then pick them up as they'll rust eventually with the stack of leaves that accumulate next to them. Yeah, yeah, I can see the logic in having one. Old banger 993 - well I've had mine 4 years and how many issues have I had - let me see how many hands I need to count the issues on.....oh, uh none, I've not had one single problem....how bizzare for an older banger.
Ha Ha Ha very good gbrownlow did make me chuckle ,probably because I knew (as you did)the response this would get.
Calm down truckpdt its just a car, he's not insulting your children FGS. Why do people get so precious about there cars ? Drive it & enjoy, what does it matter what other people think... did they paid there money for it ... NO so sod them & there opinions.



911p

2,335 posts

182 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
truckpdt said:
1. AA for when the intermediate shaft fails or the cylinder walls eventually break down
2. Keep a spare RMS or two as you'll need them as well.
3. Of course that's fine, because money can be chucked away in such a lucrative and stable economy
4. Get some cheap radiators then pick them up as they'll rust eventually
5. Old banger 993
1. These aren't a case of 'eventually' - many engines last 150k miles and beyond.
2. All 3 996's I know personally - they haven't had any RMS work. Same for many.
3. So I can pick up a 45,000 mile MkII 996 for £19500 - how much for the same mileage 993? 26-27k. What was that about throwing away money?
4. Very rare problem, not many cars get this at all.
5. Obviously this isn't the case, but it is getting on a bit now.

wink

Edited by 911p on Monday 3rd January 11:46

monthefish

20,449 posts

233 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
911p said:
truckpdt said:
1. AA for when the intermediate shaft fails or the cylinder walls eventually break down
2. Keep a spare RMS or two as you'll need them as well.
3. Of course that's fine, because money can be chucked away in such a lucrative and stable economy
4. Get some cheap radiators then pick them up as they'll rust eventually
5. Old banger 993
1. These aren't a case of 'eventually' - many engines last 150k miles and beyond.
2. All 3 996's I know personally - they haven't had any RMS work. Same for many.
3. So I can pick up a 45,000 mile MkII 996 for £19500 - how much for the same mileage 993? 26-27k. What was that about throwing away money?
4. Very rare problem, not many cars get this at all.
5. Obviously this isn't the case, but it is getting on a bit now.

wink

Edited by 911p on Monday 3rd January 11:46
I think that the point he makes concerning the radiators is probably justified (one of the main traders said that they replace at least one of the rads in most of the cars they have for sale), but I agree with the rest of your post.

POORCARDEALER

8,528 posts

243 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
911p said:
truckpdt said:
1. AA for when the intermediate shaft fails or the cylinder walls eventually break down
2. Keep a spare RMS or two as you'll need them as well.
3. Of course that's fine, because money can be chucked away in such a lucrative and stable economy
4. Get some cheap radiators then pick them up as they'll rust eventually
5. Old banger 993
1. These aren't a case of 'eventually' - many engines last 150k miles and beyond.
2. All 3 996's I know personally - they haven't had any RMS work. Same for many.
3. So I can pick up a 45,000 mile MkII 996 for £19500 - how much for the same mileage 993? 26-27k. What was that about throwing away money?
4. Very rare problem, not many cars get this at all.
5. Obviously this isn't the case, but it is getting on a bit now.

wink

Edited by 911p on Monday 3rd January 11:46
The 996 will be worth £12K in 3 years, while the (i agree overpriced) 993 will still be worth 26-27K, so who is actually throwing money away?

guyvert1

1,858 posts

244 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
+15k for the 'S'
+30k for the turbo hehe

911p

2,335 posts

182 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
POORCARDEALER said:
The 996 will be worth £12K in 3 years
A good MkII 996 dropping to 12K? Where's the sudden sledgehammer on their prices coming from? They've stuck around the 20k mark for about 3 years now.

Moosh

1,122 posts

223 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
truckpdt said:
gbrownlow said:
Overrated and over inflated prices for an old banger or modern supercar performance and handling at a bargain price, mmmmmmmmmmm let me think ?

I'll have my fried eggs sunnyside up please lol
While your still thinking don't forget to purchase a warranty for your modern "supercar", don't forget the AA for when the intermediate shaft fails or the cylinder walls eventually break down. oh and keep a spare RMS or two as you'll need them as well. Oh and don't forget the continued depreciation....of course that's fine, because money can be chucked away in such a lucrative and stable economy. And if you can get some cheap radiators then pick them up as they'll rust eventually with the stack of leaves that accumulate next to them. Yeah, yeah, I can see the logic in having one. Old banger 993 - well I've had mine 4 years and how many issues have I had - let me see how many hands I need to count the issues on.....oh, uh none, I've not had one single problem....how bizzare for an older banger.
TROLL!!!!

johnycarrera

1,935 posts

232 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all













Look, you can even be friends with someone who owns a 996 !

Enjoy beer

Edited by johnycarrera on Monday 3rd January 13:20

MrSimba

343 posts

215 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
johnycarrera said:
Look, you can even be friends with someone who owns a 996 !

Enjoy beer

Edited by johnycarrera on Monday 3rd January 13:20
Beautiful car Johny!

& the most sensible post of the last 7 pages!!!

beer

Edited by MrSimba on Monday 3rd January 14:24

gbrownlow

4,843 posts

172 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
Don't get me wrong I like 993 Turbo's and above but they are getting on now and starting to show their age. I think the 996 shape is sleeker and more modern and the performance and handling moved the game on considerably.

I'm not even ageist as I prefer to have a F355 over Ferrari 360 but I do get fed up with 993 owners thinking they have a superior car. Maybe its an age and beard thing with them as most would have been in their 30's when the 993 was new lol and its the car for their generation.
Personally I wouldn't waste the extra money they demand and rather have the more modern and better performing car.

You pays your money and takes your chances

graemel

7,055 posts

219 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
Friends absolutely. I even have mates with 997's




turbo-ww

1,766 posts

218 months

Monday 3rd January 2011
quotequote all
graemel said:
Friends absolutely. I even have mates with 997's


So which one of these is the 997?

roflroflrofl

graemel

7,055 posts

219 months

Tuesday 4th January 2011
quotequote all
The one at the back wink