Bad news?

Author
Discussion

mikey k

13,012 posts

218 months

Wednesday 28th November 2012
quotequote all
I was in JLR today you would not believe how much money they are spending on all the right things (production lines, AL chassis technology, new models etc)

DB9VolanteDriver

2,615 posts

178 months

Wednesday 28th November 2012
quotequote all
cardigankid said:
FatFrank said:
DB9VolanteDriver said:
A car (or other automotive related company) buying AM as a trophy is just what AM needs. People should remember that Ford bought AM for the very same reason. Once bought, they injected massive amounts of money into AM, which is still bearing fruit at AM today.
It wasn't just the money that Ford poured into Aston that made it what it is today, it was the parts bin. Without the equivalent wealth of resource to draw from it wouldn't be long before whoever invests in Aston either, severly compromises the future product, or chokes on the cost of making new vehicles. Ford brought everything from engines to instrument clusters into our cars. Ultimately we need a company with similar resources to that which Ford had if we want to see the next generation of cars that we all desire. BMW, MB, VAG, JLR or even Toyota with its demonstrated LF-A mindset would be better than M&M.

FF
OK but what did Tata bring to JLR?
Exactly. At the time Ford bought Jaguar and Aston, both companies needed a lot of automotive help (obviously Aston much more so than Jaguar), so Ford provided that manufacturing/engineering know how. Both companies have modern manufacturing/engineering now, so they no longer need automotive tech help from someone like Ford (or Toyota), they just need money. That's where Tata and M&M come in.

Aston knows HOW to do it, they just don't have the money to do it...

Jon39

12,905 posts

145 months

Wednesday 28th November 2012
quotequote all
DB9VolanteDriver said:
···· Aston knows HOW to do it, they just don't have the money to do it...
What a perfect quotation. Possibly applicable at every change of owner since 1913.

The UK figures for the Vantage, show how difficult the car manufacturing business is.

With initial model excitement .............. 1504 new registrations in 2006.

When the model is 5 years old ............. 358 new registrations in 2011.

Demand for some items remains fairly constant, but with motor vehicles, consumers always seem to demand the latest.

Unless the profits from one model can fund development of a successor, then your quotation will be applicable again.


Zod

35,295 posts

260 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
cardigankid said:
OK but what did Tata bring to JLR?
Money, lots of money.

FatFrank

133 posts

146 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
cardigankid said:
FatFrank said:
DB9VolanteDriver said:
A car (or other automotive related company) buying AM as a trophy is just what AM needs. People should remember that Ford bought AM for the very same reason. Once bought, they injected massive amounts of money into AM, which is still bearing fruit at AM today.
It wasn't just the money that Ford poured into Aston that made it what it is today, it was the parts bin. Without the equivalent wealth of resource to draw from it wouldn't be long before whoever invests in Aston either, severly compromises the future product, or chokes on the cost of making new vehicles. Ford brought everything from engines to instrument clusters into our cars. Ultimately we need a company with similar resources to that which Ford had if we want to see the next generation of cars that we all desire. BMW, MB, VAG, JLR or even Toyota with its demonstrated LF-A mindset would be better than M&M.

FF
OK but what did Tata bring to JLR?
Unfortunately the comparison with Tata and Jaguar Land-Rover is not valid. JLR has a critical mass from its sales volume that creates economies of scale enabling autonomous, non-automotive related, investment to succeed. JLR sold over 300,000 cars last year, Aston only 4000. That means that for a given investment level JLR can afford to develop unique, new, state of the art components that will be shared across tens of thousands of cars. whereas with the same investment Aston could not.

You can already see many examples of these JLR successes through economies of scale such as the new digital instrument cluster and pop up shift selector being deployed across both car and SUV significant volume. Unique product component propositions as these are those that Aston will only be able to dream of without an OEM partner, no matter how deep the investors pockets.

Additionally, do not forget that the genesis of much of JLRs product and engine range is still from Ford. Even the Evoque has its routes in a Ford platform.

FF



Edited by FatFrank on Thursday 29th November 03:46

Neil1300R

5,487 posts

180 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
Updated article by Reuters on M&M:-

http://uk.reuters.com/article/2012/11/28/business-...

And its now being officially admitted that AM / Investment DAR are looking for new investors

http://www.efinancialnews.com/story/2012-11-28/ast...




Edited by Neil1300R on Thursday 29th November 08:38

George29

14,708 posts

166 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
Neil - does it say anything about if AMG take over if they will drop the Cygnet? They will no longer need to lower the emmissions average then will they? wink

mikey k

13,012 posts

218 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
Mahindra Spokesman said:
Even as the company vies for Aston Martin, it is eyeing a couple of smaller European auto component makers that are on the block due to mounting losses, said another source.

"They don't go after deals proactively and end up overpaying, and would rather wait for the stressed assets to come to the market," the banker said.

"They are focused on building a little empire of prized assets instead of shock-and-awe kind of deals."

"They are very portfolio-centric, opportunistic, in their M&A strategy. They believe in zeroing into a stressed situation and cleaning the mess quickly so that you can capture the value,"
Seems to contradict any attempt to buy in to AML confused

XXXAngelXXX

1,711 posts

230 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
some insider news - MB is bidding through an italian investment company wink and the Indians also - DAR will sell to the highest offer - the deal will be done this week.

don't ask. wink

mikey k

13,012 posts

218 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
XXXAngelXXX said:
some insider news - MB is bidding through an italian investment company wink and the Indians also - DAR will sell to the highest offer - the deal will be done this week.

don't ask. wink
IF MB are that keen why the hell don't they go direct and save time and money?

XXXAngelXXX

1,711 posts

230 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
they can retire from bidding without loosing their face wink

Neil1300R

5,487 posts

180 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
XXXAngelXXX said:
some insider news - MB is bidding through an italian investment company wink and the Indians also - DAR will sell to the highest offer - the deal will be done this week.

don't ask. wink
Not exactly insider news - its been reported for the past week by Bloomberg / Reuters etc!

mikey k

13,012 posts

218 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
It did occur that they could stand back and prevent and of the st sticking to them wink
I guess they are willing to pay the premium for doing that and the cost of bidding against themselves smile

XXXAngelXXX

1,711 posts

230 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
they are wealthy wink you cant imagine how many people here in Stuttgart gets money from them for doing strictly NOTHING wink

Neil1300R

5,487 posts

180 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
XXXAngelXXX said:
they are wealthy wink you cant imagine how many people here in Stuttgart gets money from them for doing strictly NOTHING wink
You need to be doing extra Nothings for them, then you can get an Aston again! laugh

jonby

5,357 posts

159 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
Autocar report today

Aston Martin has confirmed that it is in advanced talks with investors for an equity injection.

A document sent to bond holders in the firm today reported: "Aston Martin, with the support of its shareholders, confirms that discussions are at an advanced stage to secure a capital increase which will ensure it can deliver its medium and long-term growth plans."

Both Indian conglomerate Mahindra & Mahindra and Italian buyout firm Invest Industrial are reported to be vying to invest in Aston, with the former offering a significantly greater cash injection and the latter offering less financial support but a technical partnership with Mercedes and AMG.

Initial reports suggested that Invest Industrial were favourites to secure the £250m deal, but sources now suggest that Mahindra & Mahindra has moved ahead in negotiations and is the favoured partner. The winning bidder is expect to own 40% of the company and have 50% of the voting rights.

Financial analysts are reporting that the admission to bond holders that talks are underway signals that a deal is likely to be imminent, and could be concluded within a week.

XXXAngelXXX

1,711 posts

230 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
Neil1300R said:
You need to be doing extra Nothings for them, then you can get an Aston again! laugh
laughlaughlaugh Sadly i don't work for MB frown

brakedwell

1,229 posts

201 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
VAG - Bentley
BMW - Rolls Royce, Mini
MB - Aston Martin

Family silver all gone, done and dusted. clap

yeti

10,523 posts

277 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
Still got Morgan and Noble smile

That's pretty much all we're good for; very small and very niche. Aston got too big.

You forgot TVR - Russian halfwit
MG Rover - Nanjing Automotive
Lotus - Proton or whoever it is today

However, with regard to your examples; all those companies have made roaring successes of car makers tht would probably otherwise be defunct. And they are still mostly made here with Brit workers. In this day and age of globalisation, who really cares who owns who...

FatFrank

133 posts

146 months

Thursday 29th November 2012
quotequote all
brakedwell said:
VAG - Bentley
BMW - Rolls Royce, Mini
MB - Aston Martin

Family silver all gone, done and dusted. clap
But look at he product resurgence at Rolls and Bentley. Bring on MB and look forward to a new generation of Aston classics smile