Best //M car of all time?

Best //M car of all time?

Author
Discussion

Manand38

Original Poster:

1,683 posts

207 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
What do you lot consider to be the best "standard" //M car of all time time when considering handling and driver feedback?

I've only driven the Z3 M Coupe and E46 CSL in anger. IMHO The M coupe gives better driver feedback, but the CSL is better handling.

belleair302

6,853 posts

208 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
Old School E 30 M3 Evo Sport, pure racing thoroughbred or original CSL batmobile!


Edited by belleair302 on Friday 6th April 19:38

gavm5

186 posts

207 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
I am on my second e34 M5,
The first one was an early 3.6 model and I have recently acquired a last of the line 3.8 LE which has the fully functioning edc suspension, bigger 'floating' disc brakes and a 6 speed box.
I thought the 3.6 to be more raw, but put the edc into S mode on the 3.8 and it is truly awesome, niether car has any silly traction control device - its purely driver responsibilty !
Practical real world performance M5's at there best, plus I insure them on a classic policy, have a child seat fitted in the rear and have enough room for a trip away.
The 3.6's produce 315 bhp and the 3.8's 340 bhp but with more usable torque.
The last of the truly handbuilt ///M's

M5Dave

829 posts

210 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
Only driven the E36 M3 and the E39 M5.

Unfortunately, the more modern the car, the more weight they inevitably carry, which is the enemy when it comes to handling and driver feedback.

So I think one of the early cars would have to be best, E30 M3, E28 M5 or possibly even the E12 M535i which was really the car that started it all.

steil

1,113 posts

240 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
Probably a tough call between an E28 M5 or an E30 M3, however I've yet to drive an M1...

belleair302

6,853 posts

208 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
E28 M5 is a pretty wild ride, the brakes are rubbish and the 'on the limit wet ride' is challenging. M1's are there any in the UK actually being driven today? I have an E34 M5, a great car, not so impressed with the steering but a beautiful piece of engineering to own and savage engine noise above 5,000 RPM.

jezzaaa

1,872 posts

260 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
Z4MC obviously....but then I am a tad biased at present.... ;-)

GTRene

16,678 posts

225 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
Most famous M car is ofcorse the E30 M3

Best is the Z3 M coupeyes I've driven a few M cars and the Z3 M coupe is really a masterpiece for the money and good feeling factor, its rare too and will be a sort of collectable as the E30 M3..wait and see...

Cause the very very best is the Hartge Z3 coupe 5.0 V8 6-speed, but then I'm biasedhehe
GTRene

ButtMonkey Racer

453 posts

224 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
Another vote for the E34 3.8 M5. Mine's fantastic, really howls and no saloon car of that era should handle as well as it does.

bob1179

14,107 posts

210 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
E30 M3.



Or E28 M5 (the greatest M5!)



I want one of each. They are both proper M cars, hand built and absolutley stunning.

I also love the original E12 M535i, although I suppose not a proper M car in the sense, it was the first one that was widely available to the public in 1980/81 and at the time was about as powerful as the Ferrari 308, 218 bhp in a saloon car in 1980 was pretty awesome.

M5Dave

829 posts

210 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
bob1179 said:
E30 M3.



Or E28 M5 (the greatest M5!)



I want one of each. They are both proper M cars, hand built and absolutley stunning.

I also love the original E12 M535i, although I suppose not a proper M car in the sense, it was the first one that was widely available to the public in 1980/81 and at the time was about as powerful as the Ferrari 308, 218 bhp in a saloon car in 1980 was pretty awesome.



Excellent choices, however I must disagree with your comments on the E12 M535i. Although not fitted with a motorsport engine, it is IMO a proper M car in every way, handbuilt by BMW Motorsport at the Garching factory.

bob1179

14,107 posts

210 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
M5Dave said:


Excellent choices, however I must disagree with your comments on the E12 M535i. Although not fitted with a motorsport engine, it is IMO a proper M car in every way, handbuilt by BMW Motorsport at the Garching factory.



I didn't know that the original M535i was built on a seperate production line to the rest of the range. Either way, if you gave me anyone of those cars I'd be a happy bunny.

I always wanted to see one of those legendary handbuilt 530i's that were handbuilt for a few special customers in the 70's.

belleair302

6,853 posts

208 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
The E12 M535i was built from April 1980 until May 1981. Only 1410 cars were built, by hand in Garching, Germany. 450 were RHD with 408 coming to the UK from Sept 1980. An additional 240 cars were produced in South Africa and none were sold in the USA. 218 bhp @5200 rpm and 224lb ft torque at 4000 rpm. They must have been amazing cars in their day!

loach

3,357 posts

217 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
I'll throw the M1 into the mix, having driven a couple. On a hoon last year through the Eifel mountains, I can confirm that the car is pretty astounding for something of its age. Lovely noise, tractable, flexible, well built, comfy, excellent ride, grippy, feelsome. Put next to similar vintage Ferrari, for example, it really does underscore how the Italian cars were massively over-rated at the time. I loved it, and I want one.


Edited by loach on Friday 6th April 16:16

olf

11,974 posts

219 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
Defo the E28 M5. No question. It defined the whole Q car thang and nothing has been quite so discreet since.

On a slighly related but separate subject, I was thinking today how the M badge has proved an ageless brand. Looks as good today as it did on the earliest cars.

kiko

269 posts

227 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
There's no other possible answer to that question... M3 E30! Its simply the most sucessful race car EVER! No other car had so many victories on official events, how can you beat that?

olf

11,974 posts

219 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
Note the original post ask for the best STANDARD M of all time. Race cars all all very nice but...

belleair302

6,853 posts

208 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
I wonder if in ten years time the ultimate M car will still be a car approaching 30 years old? My guess is yes. Modern cars will be safer, heavier and less connected to driving ability and feel and more controlled by electronics. Live dangerously, buy an M BMW!

housemaster

2,076 posts

228 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
Here endeth the discussion...



Interesting to see the second drivers name, as that looks like the GP support race at Silverstone in 1979...

housemaster

2,076 posts

228 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
Mind you......then again, though not strictly and M...