New tyres, not tracked, won't replace them

New tyres, not tracked, won't replace them

Author
Discussion

pits

Original Poster:

6,429 posts

191 months

Friday 12th April
quotequote all
I don't think I'm being unreasonable here.
Bought tyres online from company A along with tracking.
Booked car in with company A who then used company B to do the work.
Old man dropped car off last week, tyres fitted, no print out for tracking.
I get home, drive car for weekend and it pulls to the left considerably, even steering wheel also off centre, having to drive whilst adding a bit of right hand to go straight.

Back in Monday morning, ask for tracking report, not available, sheepish looks, book it straight back in for today, I'm away again, old man drops it off, they have rung him said it's already, tracking was out, great.

So I have requested new front tyres, 500 miles of scrubbing, heavy car and expensive tyres, they won't fit new ones as their manager suggests there's nothing wrong with them, but having been a poor Teenager at one point, I know how quickly you can kill tyres with poor tracking.

Am I being unreasonable for asking for new tyres? They're not cheap (to me) and I don't want to get 6k miles down the road with tyres that are scrubbed out on the edges and need replacing due to them not tracking the car, which I paid for when I bought the tyres.

Watchthis

252 posts

63 months

Friday 12th April
quotequote all
Damage wouldn't be invisible. Check them and measure the tread depth over the full tyre. Then decide if you want to pursue or not

RSTurboPaul

10,406 posts

259 months

Friday 12th April
quotequote all
Pictures of tyres needed.

119

6,373 posts

37 months

Friday 12th April
quotequote all
Or just take it to another garage and have the tracking done whilst you wait for it.

500 miles is going to do fk all to your tyres so I’m not surprised they won’t replace them.

pits

Original Poster:

6,429 posts

191 months

Friday 12th April
quotequote all
If you look at the outside edge of the tyre, the wear "marks" are different, not by much but they are different, seems little but I have done 500 miles so for that little driving it's enough of an indicator for me.

Will provide photos when I go pick it up later

Zarco

17,891 posts

210 months

Friday 12th April
quotequote all
119 said:
Or just take it to another garage and have the tracking done whilst you wait for it.

500 miles is going to do fk all to your tyres so I’m not surprised they won’t replace them.
Yes, and get on with your life.

lord trumpton

7,406 posts

127 months

Friday 12th April
quotequote all
Op it's not worth stressing about

If the tyres look fine and the car drives fine then it's all good news

Just have a nice warm bath and forget all about it cool

OutInTheShed

7,671 posts

27 months

Friday 12th April
quotequote all
pits said:
I don't think I'm being unreasonable here.
Bought tyres online from company A along with tracking.
Booked car in with company A who then used company B to do the work.
Old man dropped car off last week, tyres fitted, no print out for tracking.
I get home, drive car for weekend and it pulls to the left considerably, even steering wheel also off centre, having to drive whilst adding a bit of right hand to go straight.

Back in Monday morning, ask for tracking report, not available, sheepish looks, book it straight back in for today, I'm away again, old man drops it off, they have rung him said it's already, tracking was out, great.

So I have requested new front tyres, 500 miles of scrubbing, heavy car and expensive tyres, they won't fit new ones as their manager suggests there's nothing wrong with them, but having been a poor Teenager at one point, I know how quickly you can kill tyres with poor tracking.

Am I being unreasonable for asking for new tyres? They're not cheap (to me) and I don't want to get 6k miles down the road with tyres that are scrubbed out on the edges and need replacing due to them not tracking the car, which I paid for when I bought the tyres.
You were being unreasonable driving it 500 miles in that state.

LightningBlue

523 posts

42 months

Friday 12th April
quotequote all
Baffled to be honest - did you ask them to check the tracking when you had the tyres replaced? Although a lot of places will advise/upsell for tracking they won’t do it unless you ask them to

Oceanrower

923 posts

113 months

Friday 12th April
quotequote all
LightningBlue said:
Baffled to be honest - did you ask them to check the tracking when you had the tyres replaced? Although a lot of places will advise/upsell for tracking they won’t do it unless you ask them to
Don’t be baffled. That is literally the second sentence!

JackJarvis

2,238 posts

135 months

Friday 12th April
quotequote all
pits said:
Am I being unreasonable
Very much so.

Hustle_

24,724 posts

161 months

Friday 12th April
quotequote all
If
  • the tracking was fine before you had the tyres fitted and the tracking done, and then it was noticeably out afterwards
or
  • the tracking was bad before you had the tyres fitted and the tracking done, and then it was noticeably bad in a different way afterwards
…then they did adjust the tracking and just made a hash of it as they usually do.

They in all probability will have only adjusted the front toe. Front toe being wrong will not cause the front tyres to wear differently from one another. It could cause uneven tyre wear on both tyres which would be similar on both sides (outside wear or inside wear). 500 miles though? To cause any appreciable wear it would’ve had to have been massively out. Think a degree total toe or something- and it wasn’t.

You’re being petty IMO. They gaffed up the toe. They rectified it second try.

Also, on most cars the toe being wrong can’t cause the steering to ‘pull’. What happens is, the toe is out in an uneven way one side to the other, you compensate for it at the steering wheel in order to go in a straight line. The toe across the front tyres is then equal in that condition. It’s still wrong, but that’s different from what a ‘pull’ is.

LightningBlue

523 posts

42 months

Saturday 13th April
quotequote all
Oceanrower said:
Don’t be baffled. That is literally the second sentence!
Oops! Can see why he’s upset then but it doesn’t seem to warrant replacing the tyres - they’d say he should’ve returned it immediately

dingg

3,997 posts

220 months

Saturday 13th April
quotequote all
OP is the pits

Sebring440

2,023 posts

97 months

Saturday 13th April
quotequote all
dingg said:
OP is the pits
Got no idea what that means, but I don't think the OP will be back as he's not hearing what he wants to hear.


lord trumpton

7,406 posts

127 months

Sunday 14th April
quotequote all
Sebring440 said:
dingg said:
OP is the pits
Got no idea what that means, but I don't think the OP will be back as he's not hearing what he wants to hear.
The thread had gone way off track

He's no doubt tyred of the negative responses

Simon_GH

236 posts

81 months

Sunday 14th April
quotequote all
How many miles did the old tyres do and were they scrubbed on one side indicating tracking was out?

stinkyspanner

721 posts

78 months

Sunday 14th April
quotequote all
How long would you expect to the tyres to last usually? 10k? So 500 miles is 5% of that, if I was managing that place I'd give you the 5% as goodwill and bid you good day

GasEngineer

953 posts

63 months

Sunday 14th April
quotequote all
pits said:
If you look at the outside edge of the tyre, the wear "marks" are different, not by much but they are different, seems little but I have done 500 miles so for that little driving it's enough of an indicator for me.

Will provide photos when I go pick it up later
Could you post the photos as promised OP?

The Gauge

1,925 posts

14 months

Sunday 14th April
quotequote all
OP needs to tread carefully