The Murtaya - TVR Alternative?

The Murtaya - TVR Alternative?

Author
Discussion

grahamw48

9,944 posts

238 months

Friday 5th June 2009
quotequote all
I find the Murtaya rather ugly to be honest, having seen the frontal view.

Far too upright and brick-like. Similar to those other bricks with big gaping black gobs...as is the latest trend....Audis.

Soon all cars will look like tranny vans, and probably weigh as much too.

Someone put a stop to it ! irked


Pooh

3,692 posts

253 months

Friday 5th June 2009
quotequote all
JonRB said:
Was the Murtaya originally the Delfino Feroce ("ferocious dolphin", FFS) or was that another roadster based on Impreza running gear?
It was originally called the Minari and was based on the Alfa boxer engined 33 or Sud.

RichB

51,572 posts

284 months

Friday 5th June 2009
quotequote all
grahamw48 said:
I find the Murtaya rather ugly to be honest...
I agree in my opinion it lacks any of the subtlety or beauty of Wheeler and Ravenscroft's classic TVRs; the Griffith, Chimaera and Cerbera. It may be fast but visually it cannot be mentioned in the same breath as these design classics.

scotty_d

6,795 posts

194 months

Saturday 6th June 2009
quotequote all
I have seen these in the flesh at knockhill motor fair a few weeks ago and i thought they looked ok in photo's ect but now i have been up close i have changed my mind i dont think much of its looks now It does not have the presence of TVR’S and it looks to kit car at least TVR hide it a bit more not for me but i bet it is real fun to drive.

RichB

51,572 posts

284 months

Saturday 6th June 2009
quotequote all
scotty_d said:
it looks to kit car at least TVR hide it a bit
Maybe that's because since the late 60's TVRs have not been kit cars? confused

Always amuses and irritates me this - when talking about Morgans people go all gooey eyed and say how wonderful it is to see English craftsmanship making hand built cars, yet with TVRs, because they used GRP instead of wood they call them kit cars. Odd... hehe

grahamw48

9,944 posts

238 months

Saturday 6th June 2009
quotequote all
Agree.

Lotus Sevens started life as 'kit cars' too, but you need at least 15 grand to buy a decent one now, and look what a plethora of look-a-likes they gave rise to.

I'll be interested to see what McClaren come up with, now they're talking of going into serious production....probably out of my price range though. frown


Allandwf

1,755 posts

195 months

Saturday 6th June 2009
quotequote all
grahamw48 said:
Agree.

Lotus Sevens started life as 'kit cars' too, but you need at least 15 grand to buy a decent one now, and look what a plethora of look-a-likes they gave rise to.

I'll be interested to see what McClaren come up with, now they're talking of going into serious production....probably out of my price range though. frown
Europas and Elans, ( original ones, ) could also be purchased in component form.

grahamw48

9,944 posts

238 months

Saturday 6th June 2009
quotequote all
Yes, and it was only to avoid 'purchase tax' anyway, from what I remember.

If the modern day equivalent of Colin Chapman...say, Ross Brawn was to come up with a component form road-racer there wouldn't be too many sneery 'kit-car' comments. wink

Edited by grahamw48 on Saturday 6th June 11:23

Podie

46,630 posts

275 months

Saturday 6th June 2009
quotequote all
blitzracing said:
I love the G50, although I think I'd prefer a petrol variant than the elctric one wink

Hiryu

161 posts

212 months

Sunday 7th June 2009
quotequote all
Pooh said:
JonRB said:
Was the Murtaya originally the Delfino Feroce ("ferocious dolphin", FFS) or was that another roadster based on Impreza running gear?
It was originally called the Minari and was based on the Alfa boxer engined 33 or Sud.
In the beginning, Adrenaline Motorsport got the rights to the Delfino and wanted to start building those...However, they started realizing that there were a lot of changes that they wanted to make on the original Delfino design, and they eventually started over. Using both the Minari and Feroce as inspiration, they came up with the Murtaya. I think AMS is also planning to re-release the Minari with an updated powertrain (AMS also has the rights to the Minari).

Or at least that's how I've gathered the history over the last few years...

Mike

Gnits

919 posts

201 months

Friday 19th June 2009
quotequote all
As a thought (cos I dont' actually know!) for those with TVR's is there any kind of modification that gets done or do most of you stick with std?
Having had a nose inside a T350 I would probably keep it as standard - did love the inside I have to say! But what does everyone else do?

I was just thinking that the Scoobs seem to be modified here there and everywhere by the owners and many of those mods in terms of brakes, engine etc coud also be done to the Murtaya.

TUS64N

92 posts

241 months

Friday 19th June 2009
quotequote all
i couldnt buy it for the name alone, my indian dentists wife is called murtaya and she aint pretty either.

Chris71

21,536 posts

242 months

Saturday 20th June 2009
quotequote all
RichB said:
scotty_d said:
it looks to kit car at least TVR hide it a bit
Maybe that's because since the late 60's TVRs have not been kit cars? confused
[pedant]
The last kit TVR was made in 1972. I know because I grew up being driven around in it.
[/pedant]

I don't understand the objection to kits anyway. You don't hear people going: Caterham Superlights? Nah, they're crap... kits you see. In fact there's a slight irony to any TVR owner sniping at the kit industry (not saying you were, but it happens) and that lies in the fact that kit cars are always bundled in with two other types of car in people's narrow minded stereotypes. The first is Italian cars. The second is TVRs.

If all kits are tacky as per the stereotype then it fits that all TVRs break down periodically and spend the rest of the time being driven in a point and squirt fashion by overweight middle aged accountants wearing too much Brute. I don't see why you'd subscribe to one myth and not the other. smile

RichB

51,572 posts

284 months

Saturday 20th June 2009
quotequote all
Chris71 said:
RichB said:
scotty_d said:
it looks to kit car at least TVR hide it a bit
Maybe that's because since the late 60's TVRs have not been kit cars? confused
there's a slight irony to any TVR owner sniping at the kit industry (not saying you were, but it happens)...
No, you're right I wasn't. When I ordered my Griff I was genuinely exhilarated to be able to visit the factory to meet the craftsmen and women who built my car. I still have an album of photos from the day and occasionally look at them as a reminder of the hay-day of TVR producing wonderful hand-built Blackpool bombers biggrin

s5tuart

593 posts

203 months

Sunday 21st June 2009
quotequote all
Perhaps the Melling Wildcat is a more suitable TVR equivalent?

grahamw48

9,944 posts

238 months

Sunday 21st June 2009
quotequote all
I'm backing Ginetta.

A drop top version of the G50 would be nice. smile

Chris71

21,536 posts

242 months

Monday 22nd June 2009
quotequote all
s5tuart said:
Perhaps the Melling Wildcat is a TVR replica?
EFA hehe

It's not a bad car, but I'd rather have a real Griff second hand.

JR

12,722 posts

258 months

Monday 22nd June 2009
quotequote all
RichB said:
scotty_d said:
it looks to kit car at least TVR hide it a bit
Maybe that's because since the late 60's TVRs have not been kit cars? confused

Always amuses and irritates me this - when talking about Morgans people go all gooey eyed and say how wonderful it is to see English craftsmanship making hand built cars, yet with TVRs, because they used GRP instead of wood they call them kit cars. Odd... hehe
Just a footnote but the last TVR kit was in the 70s ('74?) and TVRs do use wood...

RichB

51,572 posts

284 months

Monday 22nd June 2009
quotequote all
JR said:
TVRs do use wood...
OK, the dashboard...

pkitchen

1,747 posts

209 months

Monday 22nd June 2009
quotequote all
grahamw48 said:
I'm backing Ginetta.

A drop top version of the G50 would be nice. smile
yes