Winter tyres vol 2

Author
Discussion

Mr E

21,629 posts

260 months

Saturday 23rd December 2017
quotequote all
During the deep freeze recently.

Fwd electrically powered hatchback on low rolling resistance tyres, somewhat unstable despite being driven very carefully. I would add that the traction control on the milk float is actually very good.

Massive tank of a RWD Mercedes with big gobs of V8 torque on conti winter contacts, genuinely no problem as long as you remember how heavy it is.

I drove the tank to work for a couple of days as it was on the right rubber.

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

256 months

Saturday 23rd December 2017
quotequote all
Nine-Eighty-Six said:
A DSG box is just a manual box with twin automated clutch packs. Use of gears is no different - if anything, the DSG clutches will operate much more smoothly than any person could operate one.
Well this is quite obviously wrong. The use of gears is very different since it's sequential, and if the clutches are operating more smoothly than you can control a manual clutch, it's time to brush up on those skills.

anonymous-user

55 months

Saturday 23rd December 2017
quotequote all
Mr2Mike said:
Nine-Eighty-Six said:
A DSG box is just a manual box with twin automated clutch packs. Use of gears is no different - if anything, the DSG clutches will operate much more smoothly than any person could operate one.
Well this is quite obviously wrong. The use of gears is very different since it's sequential, and if the clutches are operating more smoothly than you can control a manual clutch, it's time to brush up on those skills.
A DSG box will always change gear smoother than a traditional manual clutch/gearbox.

FiF

44,114 posts

252 months

Saturday 23rd December 2017
quotequote all
ruprechtmonkeyboy said:
Mr2Mike said:
Nine-Eighty-Six said:
A DSG box is just a manual box with twin automated clutch packs. Use of gears is no different - if anything, the DSG clutches will operate much more smoothly than any person could operate one.
Well this is quite obviously wrong. The use of gears is very different since it's sequential, and if the clutches are operating more smoothly than you can control a manual clutch, it's time to brush up on those skills.
A DSG box will always change gear smoother than a traditional manual clutch/gearbox.
And more quickly, and maintain power transmission through the change. Also although the changes are sequential, if you know what you're doing you can something close in approximation to a block change, eg 4 to 2, even if it flicks very very rapidly through 3.

Yes there's a definite skill in getting the best from a manual box, likewise understanding how to do the same with an automatic is a skill, a different one but nevertheless.


Glade

4,267 posts

224 months

Saturday 23rd December 2017
quotequote all
I have just put Goodyear Vector 4 seasons on my Octavia VRS to replace the standard Bridgestone potenzas which were worn out.

Maybe they need to scrub in, but they feel a bit vague. I would say worse than the worn out tyres they replaced.

I had nangkang all seasons on a Passat a few years back and didn't notice is so much... so I am surprised. Maybe the Passat just handled like st anyway so the difference was not as noticible.

matthias73

2,883 posts

151 months

Saturday 23rd December 2017
quotequote all
Just arrived in the alps in my e46 330i.

Cooper winter's, never even got the back end out. Must try harder.

cootuk

918 posts

124 months

Sunday 24th December 2017
quotequote all
My Nankang SV2 have just been tested..warm deg and slightly damp
...35mph through traffic lights when someone ran their red light. Full on stamp on brakes, antilock brakes activated, no sliding, threw steering to right at last second as was going to t-bone the passenger. Lots of tyre smoke. Stopped with a mm to spare.
Fairly impressed with the tyre grip.
No skid marks left.

fido

16,800 posts

256 months

Sunday 24th December 2017
quotequote all


Successfully navigated a set of steep inclines at 8C in damp conditions with minimum tyre squeal .. admittedly only a car park in Guildford.

NRS

22,188 posts

202 months

Sunday 24th December 2017
quotequote all
Glade said:
I have just put Goodyear Vector 4 seasons on my Octavia VRS to replace the standard Bridgestone potenzas which were worn out.

Maybe they need to scrub in, but they feel a bit vague. I would say worse than the worn out tyres they replaced.

I had nangkang all seasons on a Passat a few years back and didn't notice is so much... so I am surprised. Maybe the Passat just handled like st anyway so the difference was not as noticible.
Winters will feel worse due to softer rubber flexing more. Performance is the question though.

Countdown

39,954 posts

197 months

Sunday 24th December 2017
quotequote all
cootuk said:
My Nankang SV2 have just been tested..warm deg and slightly damp
...35mph through traffic lights when someone ran their red light. Full on stamp on brakes, antilock brakes activated, no sliding, threw steering to right at last second as was going to t-bone the passenger. Lots of tyre smoke. Stopped with a mm to spare.
Fairly impressed with the tyre grip.
No skid marks left.
Sorry if stupid question but if you had ABS kicking in and there were no skid marks where did the tyre smoke come from?

wevster

765 posts

158 months

Sunday 24th December 2017
quotequote all
Dont know if it's been posted yet but this video is interesting

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=qrlLirtHh10


7mike

3,010 posts

194 months

Sunday 24th December 2017
quotequote all


Managed the last cold snap on the standard summers; fitted these just in time for what will no doubt be the mildest winter on record tongue out

cootuk

918 posts

124 months

Sunday 24th December 2017
quotequote all
Countdown said:
Sorry if stupid question but if you had ABS kicking in and there were no skid marks where did the tyre smoke come from?
From the very last bit when I threw the steering hard right so the tyres were 90degree to the direction of travel

Countdown

39,954 posts

197 months

Sunday 24th December 2017
quotequote all
cootuk said:
Countdown said:
Sorry if stupid question but if you had ABS kicking in and there were no skid marks where did the tyre smoke come from?
From the very last bit when I threw the steering hard right so the tyres were 90degree to the direction of travel
I’m really sorry to be so pedantic but

(a) that’s not actually possible. (Your tyres would be fouling your steering and suspension)

(b) even if it WAS possible you would need skid marks in order to generate tyre smoke (it’s the loss of grip between the tyre and the road surface that creates both)

getmecoat

Glade

4,267 posts

224 months

Sunday 24th December 2017
quotequote all
NRS said:
Winters will feel worse due to softer rubber flexing more. Performance is the question though.
Upon investigation the tyre place put <30 psi in each tyre, the recommendation under the fuel flap is 2.4 bar or 2.7 bar for economy... So I stuck 2.5 bar, which I think is about 35psi in and it's much better now!

mad4amanda

2,410 posts

165 months

Tuesday 9th January 2018
quotequote all
Looking for some all season tyres to go on new wheels for my wife's Audi A4 18" wheels so 235 40 18 but I cant find Michelin Cross climates or Goodyears equivalent in that size ?
Unless I have the sline sizes wrong?
Its a 2007 aA4 sline convertible TDI 140 that came with a set of 20" Bentley rims with horrid stretched tyres on them
I have no Handbook so used online site for reference
There must be something available for it?

8bit

4,868 posts

156 months

Tuesday 9th January 2018
quotequote all
mad4amanda said:
Looking for some all season tyres to go on new wheels for my wife's Audi A4 18" wheels so 235 40 18 but I cant find Michelin Cross climates or Goodyears equivalent in that size ?
Unless I have the sline sizes wrong?
Its a 2007 aA4 sline convertible TDI 140 that came with a set of 20" Bentley rims with horrid stretched tyres on them
I have no Handbook so used online site for reference
There must be something available for it?
There are Audi OE tyres in 245/40/R18 so you may well have the size slightly incorrect. However Vredestein Quatrac 5 all-seasons are available in 235/40/R18 and 245/40/R18 - we just put a set on our 2008 Merc ML320 (20") and have managed to use them in dry, wet and snow/ice conditions and they've been great so far. You're looking at about £106/corner in either of those sizes.

smarty156

372 posts

87 months

Tuesday 9th January 2018
quotequote all
Somebody mentioned further back that we didn't used to have winter tyres because the regular tyres weren't summer and had more aggressive tread.
Went to the design museum in London before Christmas (they have a Ferrari exhibition on) and here's a picture of the rear tyre of a Ferrari F40 from the 1990s (I think). If these were the standard tyres then it illustrates the point beautifully.

Edited by smarty156 on Tuesday 9th January 14:10

Glade

4,267 posts

224 months

Tuesday 9th January 2018
quotequote all
8bit said:
mad4amanda said:
Looking for some all season tyres to go on new wheels for my wife's Audi A4 18" wheels so 235 40 18 but I cant find Michelin Cross climates or Goodyears equivalent in that size ?
Unless I have the sline sizes wrong?
Its a 2007 aA4 sline convertible TDI 140 that came with a set of 20" Bentley rims with horrid stretched tyres on them
I have no Handbook so used online site for reference
There must be something available for it?
There are Audi OE tyres in 245/40/R18 so you may well have the size slightly incorrect. However Vredestein Quatrac 5 all-seasons are available in 235/40/R18 and 245/40/R18 - we just put a set on our 2008 Merc ML320 (20") and have managed to use them in dry, wet and snow/ice conditions and they've been great so far. You're looking at about £106/corner in either of those sizes.

8bit

4,868 posts

156 months

Wednesday 10th January 2018
quotequote all
Glade said:
That's them, not sure why you posted the screenshot though?