In gear or neutral

Author
Discussion

Syd knee

Original Poster:

2,924 posts

206 months

Thursday 15th March 2007
quotequote all
When parking on level ground should a car be parked in gear or in neutral?

SamHH

5,050 posts

217 months

Thursday 15th March 2007
quotequote all
I always park in gear. I don't see any advantage to leaving it in neutral.

Vaux

1,557 posts

217 months

Thursday 15th March 2007
quotequote all
level or not level, I leave it in gear.

R_U_LOCAL

2,681 posts

209 months

Thursday 15th March 2007
quotequote all
In gear, as everyone else has said. If on the flat or facing uphill, leave it in 1st, and if facing downhill, leave it in reverse.

bertbert

19,072 posts

212 months

Thursday 15th March 2007
quotequote all
R_U_LOCAL said:
In gear, as everyone else has said. If on the flat or facing uphill, leave it in 1st, and if facing downhill, leave it in reverse.

Why's that?
Bert

R_U_LOCAL

2,681 posts

209 months

Thursday 15th March 2007
quotequote all
bertbert said:
R_U_LOCAL said:
In gear, as everyone else has said. If on the flat or facing uphill, leave it in 1st, and if facing downhill, leave it in reverse.

Why's that?
Bert


Should the car's handbrake fail, or should you (god forbid) fail to set it properly, and gravity tries to do it's worst, those gears will, in effect, attempt to turn the engine the "wrong" way.

Or in other words, it'd be less likely that the engine would turn over.

TripleS

4,294 posts

243 months

Friday 16th March 2007
quotequote all
R_U_LOCAL said:
bertbert said:
R_U_LOCAL said:
In gear, as everyone else has said. If on the flat or facing uphill, leave it in 1st, and if facing downhill, leave it in reverse.

Why's that?
Bert


Should the car's handbrake fail, or should you (god forbid) fail to set it properly, and gravity tries to do it's worst, those gears will, in effect, attempt to turn the engine the "wrong" way.

Or in other words, it'd be less likely that the engine would turn over.


Just a couple of thoughts:

Is it true that an engine is less likely to turn over the wrong way? I don't see why it should be.

If it does turn over the wrong way, I have heard that some engines can suffer mechanical damage as a result. This may depend on the arrangement of the camshaft drive chain/belt and its tensioner system, but I'm just speculating.

Best wishes all,
Dave.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

206 months

Friday 16th March 2007
quotequote all
I always leave it in reverse. As far as I'm aware reverse is shorter geared than first, hence providing the best braking effect

tigger1

8,402 posts

222 months

Friday 16th March 2007
quotequote all
I always park with the car in gear, and don't pull too hard on the handbrake, ever since I snapped a cable doing exactly that a few years ago.

henrycrun

2,449 posts

241 months

Friday 16th March 2007
quotequote all
If you park on a hill, arrange the front wheels so that the car would roll and stop against the kerb

rsvmilly

11,288 posts

242 months

Friday 16th March 2007
quotequote all
henrycrun said:
If you park on a hill, arrange the front wheels so that the car would roll and stop against the kerb
A legal requirement in San Francisco, isn't it?

GravelBen

15,696 posts

231 months

Friday 16th March 2007
quotequote all
yes I leave it in gear, 1st if flat or facing downhill, R if facing uphill, (so that if it does move and turns engine over it will be turning the right way) wheels turned if I happen to remember.


People with turbo-timers have to leave their cars in neutral though...

SamHH

5,050 posts

217 months

Friday 16th March 2007
quotequote all
GravelBen said:
People with turbo-timers have to leave their cars in neutral though...


What's a turbo-timer?

Major Bloodnok

1,561 posts

216 months

Friday 16th March 2007
quotequote all
rsvmilly said:
henrycrun said:
If you park on a hill, arrange the front wheels so that the car would roll and stop against the kerb
A legal requirement in San Francisco, isn't it?

Yep, if the road passes the "pencil test". If pencil laid on the pavement will start rolling on its own, then you have to turn your wheels to the kerb.

tigger1

8,402 posts

222 months

Friday 16th March 2007
quotequote all
SamHH said:
GravelBen said:
People with turbo-timers have to leave their cars in neutral though...


What's a turbo-timer?


Let's you leave the engine running so that turbo can coll down after you've stopped, without you having to sit and watch it - then it kills the engine.

Helps to cool down the turbo properly before you park. (I could be wrong!)

trevorh

1,359 posts

285 months

Friday 16th March 2007
quotequote all
SamHH said:
GravelBen said:
People with turbo-timers have to leave their cars in neutral though...


What's a turbo-timer?


It's a timer that allows the engine to run on while the turbo cools down. You can park and lock the car and walk away, the engine will switch itself off. I have a colleague who has one on his 911 turbo in California; not sure about their legality here, though.

Edited to add: a little slow off the mark.

Edited by trevorh on Friday 16th March 14:48

Philbes

4,361 posts

235 months

Friday 16th March 2007
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


And if her foot slips off the clutch?

leosayer

7,308 posts

245 months

Friday 16th March 2007
quotequote all
henrycrun said:
If you park on a hill, arrange the front wheels so that the car would roll and stop against the kerb


I do this, but never leave the car in gear for fear of forgetting when I next start it up...even though I usually press the clutch in when starting.

TripleS

4,294 posts

243 months

Friday 16th March 2007
quotequote all
Philbes said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]


And if her foot slips off the clutch?


Yes, that is a potential problem, but in general I'm more mindful of avoiding undue wear of the clutch release mechanism, so I aim to have my foot on the clutch pedal for as little time as possible, within reason.

Best wishes all,
Dave.

SamHH

5,050 posts

217 months

Friday 16th March 2007
quotequote all
tigger1 and trevorh - thanks for the explanation.