Nurburgring 2019

Author
Discussion

C70R

17,596 posts

105 months

Monday 16th December 2019
quotequote all
doogalman said:
Lost ranger said:
Kev_Mk3 said:
AMG driver & passenger is ok after rolling 7 times at SX.
Was it filmed or did someone manage to count?

If it was the driver or passenger counting
bow
I was told that the passenger had released the video. No idea if true or not as I don’t bother chasing crash videos.
Holy crap. I just came across this video, and recalled the discussion in this thread.

That's a monster crash.

https://www.hartvoorautos.nl/video-mercedes-amg-gt...

fridaypassion

8,575 posts

229 months

Tuesday 17th December 2019
quotequote all
Gary Woodland said:
Anyone booked for CD double header in April? smile
Can't wait!
Just booked for one day hoping a Spa day pops up for us too

Digga

40,339 posts

284 months

Tuesday 17th December 2019
quotequote all
C70R said:
doogalman said:
Lost ranger said:
Kev_Mk3 said:
AMG driver & passenger is ok after rolling 7 times at SX.
Was it filmed or did someone manage to count?

If it was the driver or passenger counting
bow
I was told that the passenger had released the video. No idea if true or not as I don’t bother chasing crash videos.
Holy crap. I just came across this video, and recalled the discussion in this thread.

That's a monster crash.

https://www.hartvoorautos.nl/video-mercedes-amg-gt...
No balancing throttle and even worse, if you look carefully, just a hint of brake on the way through the bend. Frightening crash though.

C70R

17,596 posts

105 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
Digga said:
C70R said:
doogalman said:
Lost ranger said:
Kev_Mk3 said:
AMG driver & passenger is ok after rolling 7 times at SX.
Was it filmed or did someone manage to count?

If it was the driver or passenger counting
bow
I was told that the passenger had released the video. No idea if true or not as I don’t bother chasing crash videos.
Holy crap. I just came across this video, and recalled the discussion in this thread.

That's a monster crash.

https://www.hartvoorautos.nl/video-mercedes-amg-gt...
No balancing throttle and even worse, if you look carefully, just a hint of brake on the way through the bend. Frightening crash though.
Watching it back, paying attention to the telemetry stuff (which I hadn't noticed previously), I can't see any braking in the bend... Am I missing something?

Digga

40,339 posts

284 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
C70R said:
Digga said:
C70R said:
doogalman said:
Lost ranger said:
Kev_Mk3 said:
AMG driver & passenger is ok after rolling 7 times at SX.
Was it filmed or did someone manage to count?

If it was the driver or passenger counting
bow
I was told that the passenger had released the video. No idea if true or not as I don’t bother chasing crash videos.
Holy crap. I just came across this video, and recalled the discussion in this thread.

That's a monster crash.

https://www.hartvoorautos.nl/video-mercedes-amg-gt...
No balancing throttle and even worse, if you look carefully, just a hint of brake on the way through the bend. Frightening crash though.
Watching it back, paying attention to the telemetry stuff (which I hadn't noticed previously), I can't see any braking in the bend... Am I missing something?
I keep looking and I think I can see a very, very slight 'brake'. There merest brush of the pedal. FWIW I am looking at this on a very large, brand new desktop monitor.

And also on YouTube, rather than the embedded link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=617&am...

Just as the tyres squeal and the car starts to rotate, I am sure there's a slight trace in the brake telemetry. (About 10:25)

xjay1337

15,966 posts

119 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
Digga said:
I keep looking and I think I can see a very, very slight 'brake'. There merest brush of the pedal. FWIW I am looking at this on a very large, brand new desktop monitor.

And also on YouTube, rather than the embedded link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=617&am...

Just as the tyres squeal and the car starts to rotate, I am sure there's a slight trace in the brake telemetry. (About 10:25)
There is.

I spot it too.

I think the issue was turning in with no throttle at that speed on the crest of the hill.

Digga

40,339 posts

284 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
xjay1337 said:
Digga said:
I keep looking and I think I can see a very, very slight 'brake'. There merest brush of the pedal. FWIW I am looking at this on a very large, brand new desktop monitor.

And also on YouTube, rather than the embedded link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=617&am...

Just as the tyres squeal and the car starts to rotate, I am sure there's a slight trace in the brake telemetry. (About 10:25)
There is.

I spot it too.

I think the issue was turning in with no throttle at that speed on the crest of the hill.
And even the merest hint of brake will fk things right up.

TBF, I think the rate they were catching the slower car ahead may have weighed on the driver's mind too.

C70R

17,596 posts

105 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
Digga said:
xjay1337 said:
Digga said:
I keep looking and I think I can see a very, very slight 'brake'. There merest brush of the pedal. FWIW I am looking at this on a very large, brand new desktop monitor.

And also on YouTube, rather than the embedded link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=617&am...

Just as the tyres squeal and the car starts to rotate, I am sure there's a slight trace in the brake telemetry. (About 10:25)
There is.

I spot it too.

I think the issue was turning in with no throttle at that speed on the crest of the hill.
And even the merest hint of brake will fk things right up.

TBF, I think the rate they were catching the slower car ahead may have weighed on the driver's mind too.
It's an absolutely fearsome corner, and needs either 100% or 0% commitment in my experience.

RacerMike

4,209 posts

212 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
Digga said:
xjay1337 said:
Digga said:
I keep looking and I think I can see a very, very slight 'brake'. There merest brush of the pedal. FWIW I am looking at this on a very large, brand new desktop monitor.

And also on YouTube, rather than the embedded link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=617&am...

Just as the tyres squeal and the car starts to rotate, I am sure there's a slight trace in the brake telemetry. (About 10:25)
There is.

I spot it too.

I think the issue was turning in with no throttle at that speed on the crest of the hill.
And even the merest hint of brake will fk things right up.

TBF, I think the rate they were catching the slower car ahead may have weighed on the driver's mind too.
The driver posted it on YouTube himself, and completely holds his hands up to the fact he massively screwed up:

Peter De La Mare said:
I get it a bit wrong.
So I messed up a bit, but I think the car should have stuck instead of the rear making no attempt to go round the corner.

I turned in a bit earlier than usual, I steer out if it slightly and catch a bump which is bigger than it used to be, I would normally be back on the gas at this point to load up the car for the long sweeping off-camber turn over the crest, but the rear starts going before I collect myself and there’s no catching it. A tiny error with huge consequences.

My M3 goes around this bend at the same speed and feels planted each time. It’s possible my tyres weren’t completely up to temp as this was the first lap out of the car park, and Cup2s due take a while to get to temp.
I asked what stability control mode he was in, and it sounds like it was in one of the reduced Traction Settings that the GT R has. I believe that then turns off DSC, so he wouldn't have had much support for oversteer.

Digga

40,339 posts

284 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
C70R said:
It's an absolutely fearsome corner, and needs either 100% or 0% commitment in my experience.
I use "Medium", like all the rest of the corners. hehe

C70R

17,596 posts

105 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
Digga said:
C70R said:
It's an absolutely fearsome corner, and needs either 100% or 0% commitment in my experience.
I use "Medium", like all the rest of the corners. hehe
I've had my indicator on for the previous half a mile, so I'm a bit closer to zero...

Perks of tracking a car with only 200bhp.

Digga

40,339 posts

284 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
C70R said:
Digga said:
C70R said:
It's an absolutely fearsome corner, and needs either 100% or 0% commitment in my experience.
I use "Medium", like all the rest of the corners. hehe
I've had my indicator on for the previous half a mile, so I'm a bit closer to zero...

Perks of tracking a car with only 200bhp.
It's definitely a Brown Alert! corner.

RSbandit

2,612 posts

133 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
Wow horrible crash glad everyone was OK. SX is the one corner I fear above all others can go so badly wrong there even for a small error as above.

Pdelamare

659 posts

129 months

Saturday 21st December 2019
quotequote all
That’s me destroying my lovely GTR. I wasn’t entirely happy with how it was handling on the two first laps, as my passengers will attest, maybe it’s because it’s such a different car to my usual highly-modified E92 M3. It was a small driving error by turning in too early that on any other corner would be an easy save, but this corner’s reputation as a car killer isn’t undeserved, at all.

I’ve previously tracked this car at Donington and Brands GP without issue, it’s fast and handles well, but it just felt a bit weird at the ring. It did have rear wheel steering errors in the morning which seemed to clear ok, wether this had an affect I have no idea. Probably not.

For the replacement I think I’ll go back to an M car, M2 probably (with suitable mods of course).

C70R

17,596 posts

105 months

Saturday 21st December 2019
quotequote all
Pdelamare said:
That’s me destroying my lovely GTR. I wasn’t entirely happy with how it was handling on the two first laps, as my passengers will attest, maybe it’s because it’s such a different car to my usual highly-modified E92 M3. It was a small driving error by turning in too early that on any other corner would be an easy save, but this corner’s reputation as a car killer isn’t undeserved, at all.

I’ve previously tracked this car at Donington and Brands GP without issue, it’s fast and handles well, but it just felt a bit weird at the ring. It did have rear wheel steering errors in the morning which seemed to clear ok, wether this had an affect I have no idea. Probably not.

For the replacement I think I’ll go back to an M car, M2 probably (with suitable mods of course).
Glad you managed to get out relatively unscathed.

That was a whopper.

Pdelamare

659 posts

129 months

Saturday 21st December 2019
quotequote all
Thanks, that’s the biggest crash I’ve been involved in. I’m a bit surprised I didn’t break my neck on the first landing upside down, my helmet touches the roof liner when the car is on its wheels let alone landing upside down from a great height. My right arm has lacerations all the way up when it exited the car during one of the rolls, luckily I felt the cold breeze on it and yanked it back into the car.

Photos of the car in the pound show it took a very severe beating, the chassis roof rail was broken on my side.

Digga

40,339 posts

284 months

Sunday 22nd December 2019
quotequote all
Pdelamare said:
Thanks, that’s the biggest crash I’ve been involved in. I’m a bit surprised I didn’t break my neck on the first landing upside down, my helmet touches the roof liner when the car is on its wheels let alone landing upside down from a great height. My right arm has lacerations all the way up when it exited the car during one of the rolls, luckily I felt the cold breeze on it and yanked it back into the car.

Photos of the car in the pound show it took a very severe beating, the chassis roof rail was broken on my side.
Thanks for posting. Very glad that both you and the ballast were okay. Cars can be replaced.

Do you think you may have braked, or may the trace be an ABS glitch? Whatever, rear wheel steering issues are disconcerting. It's a weird track and there are places, like SX, where it's not like anywhere else - savage bumps, even after resurfacing last winter.

Pdelamare

659 posts

129 months

Sunday 22nd December 2019
quotequote all
I don’t recall braking tbh as I know this would have been the wrong thing to do. I think I was a bit shocked it got out of shape so early in the turn and was in denial about it all lol.

RacerMike

4,209 posts

212 months

Sunday 22nd December 2019
quotequote all
Pdelamare said:
I don’t recall braking tbh as I know this would have been the wrong thing to do. I think I was a bit shocked it got out of shape so early in the turn and was in denial about it all lol.
When I did my training for Industry Pool, it was drilled into us that we should go over SX [u]on[/u] throttle. So that means, brake after the first crest, then get back on the power. The reason being, in more powerful and faster cars, the apex crest unsettles the rear end and causes fairly massive oversteer.

Saying that, it can easily be that you end up in a situation where you can’t be on power. Good example being earlier this year when there was a Fiesta doing half my speed on the exit. I had to lift and brake, otherwise I’d have ended up in the back of his car. It’s for reasons like this that I always leave some form of stability control on....not just Traction. There are times round there that I’ve definitely been saved by it due to having to lift or slow for stuff that wasn’t in an ideal place.

Key thing was you were both ok in the long run. Just shows how strong modern cars are!

C70R

17,596 posts

105 months

Monday 23rd December 2019
quotequote all
Pdelamare said:
Thanks, that’s the biggest crash I’ve been involved in. I’m a bit surprised I didn’t break my neck on the first landing upside down, my helmet touches the roof liner when the car is on its wheels let alone landing upside down from a great height. My right arm has lacerations all the way up when it exited the car during one of the rolls, luckily I felt the cold breeze on it and yanked it back into the car.

Photos of the car in the pound show it took a very severe beating, the chassis roof rail was broken on my side.
This is the worry for me.

You're basically driving something with racecar performance on a racetrack, but with none of the safety features you'd expect from a racecar (plumbed extinguisher, full rollcage, non-opening windows).
The potential for doing serious damage to yourself by driving at 10/10ths is huge.