Quantity Surveyors

Author
Discussion

ATTAK Z

11,141 posts

190 months

Monday 25th August 2008
quotequote all
jollygreen said:
ATTAK Z said:
Please be aware that most quantity surveyors know the cost of everything but the value of nothing ;-P
hehe

I actually do project economics too so value IS my bag baby
You are the exception that proves the rule. Are you old enough to remember the Allegro - designed by accountants; as were most of the cars around that time!!!

jollygreen

Original Poster:

16,169 posts

203 months

Monday 25th August 2008
quotequote all
No mate, I'm 28... laugh

In fairness, few QS's these days match the old stereotypes of mail-reading dinner-party typres with st-brown allegros. hehe

dxg

8,221 posts

261 months

Monday 25th August 2008
quotequote all
jollygreen said:
ATTAK Z said:
Please be aware that most quantity surveyors know the cost of everything but the value of nothing ;-P
hehe

I actually do project economics too so value IS my bag baby
I "do" stakeholder engagement and judgement, so evaluation (grounded in cognition) is my bag baby!

ATTAK Z

11,141 posts

190 months

Monday 25th August 2008
quotequote all
dxg said:
jollygreen said:
ATTAK Z said:
Please be aware that most quantity surveyors know the cost of everything but the value of nothing ;-P
hehe

I actually do project economics too so value IS my bag baby
I "do" stakeholder engagement and judgement, so evaluation (grounded in cognition) is my bag baby!
Not my scene - I'm out

jollygreen

Original Poster:

16,169 posts

203 months

Friday 29th August 2008
quotequote all
Jobs advertised in the P&J today for QS's and Estimators for a contractor in Dubai. Bound to be nice money I would say...

sleep envy

62,260 posts

250 months

Friday 29th August 2008
quotequote all
had a chat with a headhunter this week looking to place a few people, he said that there's a mass exodus for the arab states at the moment which is leaving slim pickings in the UK

better have a chat and a beer with my boss before I head off on holiday next week biggrin

3sixty

2,963 posts

200 months

Saturday 10th January 2009
quotequote all
Ah, found this thread thanks to a helpeful pointer on the Salary Perceptions thread.

I'm currently in my 5th year of my Uni course. I chose to do it part time so I could gain some experience in industry while I study (And money.... :P )

I'm studying at Salford University as I was told this was one of the better universities for Built Environment studies in the North West. Have to say, having now been working as for a PQS in Manchester for the last 3 years, what they teach you in Uni is nothing like being in the industry. I've had one measurement module in 5 years and even then it was 1 semester of a mix of SMM and CESMM. I would be truely worried if I was a graduate coming into QS from full time, I wouldn't have a clue. Most of what they teach at Uni is not applicable/useful in a normal working day.

I currently work for a PQS in Manchester and do a mixture of mainly resi, commercial and retail. As with the current conditions, these areas have slowed slightly so I'm now doing a little work in health and education.

Would ideally like to move on to work for a Developer though. Anyone here work for some major developers? Just wanted a few questions answering on what they do day to day etc.

dxg

8,221 posts

261 months

Sunday 11th January 2009
quotequote all
3sixty said:
I'm studying at Salford University as I was told this was one of the better universities for Built Environment studies in the North West. Have to say, having now been working as for a PQS in Manchester for the last 3 years, what they teach you in Uni is nothing like being in the industry. I've had one measurement module in 5 years and even then it was 1 semester of a mix of SMM and CESMM. I would be truely worried if I was a graduate coming into QS from full time, I wouldn't have a clue. Most of what they teach at Uni is not applicable/useful in a normal working day.
As someone who teaches measurement (and other things) at one of Salford's direct competitors, I think you'll find that's a feature of Salford's degree, rather than Unis as a whole.

Anyway, if you're still measuring a few years down the path then something's gone wrong. Although you still need to be able to measure to get through those first few years...

Mattt

16,661 posts

219 months

Sunday 11th January 2009
quotequote all
DXG, are you at Manchester?

3sixty

2,963 posts

200 months

Sunday 11th January 2009
quotequote all
dxg said:
3sixty said:
I'm studying at Salford University as I was told this was one of the better universities for Built Environment studies in the North West. Have to say, having now been working as for a PQS in Manchester for the last 3 years, what they teach you in Uni is nothing like being in the industry. I've had one measurement module in 5 years and even then it was 1 semester of a mix of SMM and CESMM. I would be truely worried if I was a graduate coming into QS from full time, I wouldn't have a clue. Most of what they teach at Uni is not applicable/useful in a normal working day.
As someone who teaches measurement (and other things) at one of Salford's direct competitors, I think you'll find that's a feature of Salford's degree, rather than Unis as a whole.

Anyway, if you're still measuring a few years down the path then something's gone wrong. Although you still need to be able to measure to get through those first few years...
Oh no, I agree. In the 3 years of working as a PQS there are few times when I've actually done some 'real' measurement for a BQ. But there should be a foundation there, similarly they don't teach you a lot on construction tech.

The main topics seem to be 'professional skills', such as report writing, presentation skills, working as a team, Latham/Egan approach etc. This is fine and good to know, but its not the core of what being a QS is about... and not that useful for somebody such as myself on part-time who attends meetings, presents, writes reports on a daily basis.

jollygreen

Original Poster:

16,169 posts

203 months

Sunday 11th January 2009
quotequote all
When I was at uni (96-01) the course was 99% tailored towards the builidng insustry which I thought was pretty misguided, given that QS's turn up pretty much everywhere!


3sixty

2,963 posts

200 months

Monday 12th January 2009
quotequote all
Its gone completely the other way now though and are teaching 'general' topics which makes the title of 'Quantity surveying degree' seem stupid. There needs to be a balance.

sleep envy

62,260 posts

250 months

Monday 12th January 2009
quotequote all
dxg said:
Anyway, if you're still measuring a few years down the path then something's gone wrong.
depends what sector of the industry you're in

jollygreen

Original Poster:

16,169 posts

203 months

Monday 12th January 2009
quotequote all
The partner in the office of the large PQS firm I did my work placement with retired a few years back. He's now back in a PQS office (aged 68 or so!) doing measurement for 40 hours a week and throughly enjoying himself!

Not sure I fancy it now but one of these days (when money doesn't motivate me anymore) I may go back to it hehe

Jamm

2,087 posts

193 months

Saturday 24th January 2009
quotequote all
Just managed to land an apprenticeship with bham city council within construction.

Bloody over the moon as Im 20 now and was beginning to think I would never got on the career ladder, especially in our current climate.

Best thing is once Ive finished Im almost guaranteed a job with the council working as part of Urban Design.

Lefty Guns

Original Poster:

16,169 posts

203 months

Sunday 25th January 2009
quotequote all
Jamm said:
Just managed to land an apprenticeship with bham city council within construction.

Bloody over the moon as Im 20 now and was beginning to think I would never got on the career ladder, especially in our current climate.

Best thing is once Ive finished Im almost guaranteed a job with the council working as part of Urban Design.
Council is maybe a good start but make sure you don't get pigeonholed bud - stay there for a coupl,e of years and move into the private sector... just my tuppenceworth...

3sixty

2,963 posts

200 months

Monday 26th January 2009
quotequote all
jollygreen said:
The partner in the office of the large PQS firm I did my work placement with retired a few years back. He's now back in a PQS office (aged 68 or so!) doing measurement for 40 hours a week and throughly enjoying himself!

Not sure I fancy it now but one of these days (when money doesn't motivate me anymore) I may go back to it hehe
I dont think I could ever enjoy or be motivated to doing some BQ measurement. The odd bit of measures for W:F ratios etc. isnt so bad, but find it so mundane of doing all those tedious measures for BQs.

Just as a topping of my previous question, does anyone work on the client/developer side as a QS? Development Manager? etc. etc.

DoubleYellow

1,288 posts

190 months

Monday 2nd February 2009
quotequote all
BQ work bores me to tears. Much prefer commercial / contract side of things.

Got to take the rough with the smooth though I guess.

sleep envy

62,260 posts

250 months

Monday 2nd February 2009
quotequote all
BQ - do clients still pay extra for them?

3sixty

2,963 posts

200 months

Monday 2nd February 2009
quotequote all
sleep envy said:
BQ - do clients still pay extra for them?
Ours do, but most don't realise and pay a fixed fee. Usually make a huge margin on them.

I suppose is slightly better than those clients who pay for a cost plan/feasibility, and then spend the next 600 days asking you to do 'small' amendments for no extra fee. Most of the BQs I've done seem to be final and require no further work.