Would you fly on a 737 Max?

Author
Discussion

havoc

30,083 posts

236 months

Wednesday 8th September 2021
quotequote all
Saw that this morning.

...and in the context of corporate America, where suing someone is almost as common as saying 'hello', it makes perfect sense - the Board had become too arrogant, and it cost the shareholders. That Muilenberg still got to keep his $60 million (!) retirement package after what he'd done is literally adding insult to injury...

Super Sonic

4,871 posts

55 months

Wednesday 8th September 2021
quotequote all
'They don't all crash you know'

ch37

10,642 posts

222 months

Thursday 9th September 2021
quotequote all
Going back to the original question, I'd be shocked if it crossed the minds of more than 1% of people boarding the average Tui flight to Majorca or wherever.

We've just been away with Tui, the plane designation on our check-in app had an odd code, which I assumed meant it was a Max and they were trying to hide the fact. t turned out to be a 737-800 but I doubt anyone would have looked at the plane whilst stood on the tarmac at Bournemouth, realised it was a Max and then turned back.

craig1912

3,316 posts

113 months

Thursday 9th September 2021
quotequote all
ch37 said:
Going back to the original question, I'd be shocked if it crossed the minds of more than 1% of people boarding the average Tui flight to Majorca or wherever.

We've just been away with Tui, the plane designation on our check-in app had an odd code, which I assumed meant it was a Max and they were trying to hide the fact. t turned out to be a 737-800 but I doubt anyone would have looked at the plane whilst stood on the tarmac at Bournemouth, realised it was a Max and then turned back.
Assume you have phrased that incorrectly as an 800 isn’t a Max so there is nothing to realise!

anonymous-user

55 months

Thursday 9th September 2021
quotequote all
ch37 said:
Going back to the original question, I'd be shocked if it crossed the minds of more than 1% of people boarding the average Tui flight to Majorca or wherever.

We've just been away with Tui, the plane designation on our check-in app had an odd code, which I assumed meant it was a Max and they were trying to hide the fact. t turned out to be a 737-800 but I doubt anyone would have looked at the plane whilst stood on the tarmac at Bournemouth, realised it was a Max and then turned back.
How were they “trying to hide the fact”?

Tui website shows they have 737 800s and 737 max 8



I went on a TUI max 8 recently and there was absolutely no attempt to hide it at all.

It was staring me in the face on the safety card in the seatback pocket.




havoc

30,083 posts

236 months

Thursday 9th September 2021
quotequote all
ch37 said:
Going back to the original question, I'd be shocked if it crossed the minds of more than 1% of people boarding the average Tui flight to Majorca or wherever.

We've just been away with Tui, the plane designation on our check-in app had an odd code, which I assumed meant it was a Max and they were trying to hide the fact. t turned out to be a 737-800 but I doubt anyone would have looked at the plane whilst stood on the tarmac at Bournemouth, realised it was a Max and then turned back.
Most people don't actually care about stuff like this, or don't think, or both. "Yesterday's news is today's chip wrapper"

They just expect things to happen, and then get upset or angry when there's a problem. In the case of 2 737-MAX flights, that attitude wouldn't have worked.

Byker28i

60,056 posts

218 months

Friday 15th October 2021
quotequote all
A grand jury has indicted Boeing’s chief technical pilot on the 737 MAX launch for defrauding the FAA

https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/former-boeing-737-m...

havoc

30,083 posts

236 months

Friday 15th October 2021
quotequote all
Byker28i said:
A grand jury has indicted Boeing’s chief technical pilot on the 737 MAX launch for defrauding the FAA

https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/former-boeing-737-m...
Doesn't sound unreasonable.

...but I wonder who else was in on it? Unless you're a massively arrogant fk, surely you wouldn't do that without some sort of instructions or consent from on-high...

MB140

4,076 posts

104 months

Saturday 16th October 2021
quotequote all
havoc said:
Byker28i said:
A grand jury has indicted Boeing’s chief technical pilot on the 737 MAX launch for defrauding the FAA

https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/former-boeing-737-m...
Doesn't sound unreasonable.

...but I wonder who else was in on it? Unless you're a massively arrogant fk, surely you wouldn't do that without some sort of instructions or consent from on-high...
Let’s be brutally honest here. The law probably isn’t really that interested in some low level pilot. They will however threaten him with spending the rest of his life getting fked up in some stty American hellhole prison.

Or……..

Let’s do a deal, here’s an offer of immunity if you tell us who higher up actually knew about these issues.

havoc

30,083 posts

236 months

Saturday 16th October 2021
quotequote all
CTP most certainly isn't a low-level position, but yeah, I agree with the principle.

MB140

4,076 posts

104 months

Saturday 16th October 2021
quotequote all
havoc said:
CTP most certainly isn't a low-level position, but yeah, I agree with the principle.
Sorry poorly worded. Whilst a chief test pilot is not low level in the terms of pilot, I’m terms of the Boeing management/board he’s a nobody.

anonymous-user

55 months

Saturday 16th October 2021
quotequote all
MB140 said:
havoc said:
CTP most certainly isn't a low-level position, but yeah, I agree with the principle.
Sorry poorly worded. Whilst a chief test pilot is not low level in the terms of pilot, I’m terms of the Boeing management/board he’s a nobody.
His role regarding the faa and being their designated representative is massively important here though.

Halmyre

11,210 posts

140 months

Sunday 17th October 2021
quotequote all
havoc said:
Byker28i said:
A grand jury has indicted Boeing’s chief technical pilot on the 737 MAX launch for defrauding the FAA

https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/former-boeing-737-m...
Doesn't sound unreasonable.

...but I wonder who else was in on it? Unless you're a massively arrogant fk, surely you wouldn't do that without some sort of instructions or consent from on-high...
Well, he IS a pilot...

Hill92

4,242 posts

191 months

Saturday 9th July 2022
quotequote all
Boeing threatens to cancel Boeing 737 MAX 10 aircraft unless given exemption from safety requirements

https://www.msn.com/en-gb/travel/news/boeing-threa...

Basically if they don't certify the new 737 MAX 10 before the end of the year, they'll have to incorporate new requirements that come into effect from 2023. This involves both more cost/engineering and extra training for pilots, defeating the point of it being "just another 737".

CEO talking about risks to the business like they haven't learned anything.

havoc

30,083 posts

236 months

Saturday 9th July 2022
quotequote all
"Too big to fail" syndrome?!?

Utterly disgusting...hope the FAA tell them where to go*.





* although almost certainly they won't as it's been proven time and again that the US Gov't is in the pocket of big business.

Richie Slow

7,499 posts

165 months

Saturday 9th July 2022
quotequote all
Hill92 said:
Boeing threatens to cancel Boeing 737 MAX 10 aircraft unless given exemption from safety requirements

https://www.msn.com/en-gb/travel/news/boeing-threa...

Basically if they don't certify the new 737 MAX 10 before the end of the year, they'll have to incorporate new requirements that come into effect from 2023. This involves both more cost/engineering and extra training for pilots, defeating the point of it being "just another 737".

CEO talking about risks to the business like they haven't learned anything.
They wouldn't have ever needed a full type certification process for the Max8 but they really did need to implement a program of pilot training on the new systems that included handling failures of MCAS. The mentality within Boeing to market the Max as an aircraft that needed no pilot familiarisation was the problem and that is where they were irresponsible, both corporately and morally.

The stain won't last long, stigmas only remain with those who have an interest. The DC10 had an awful reputation in the seventies but they went on to become statistically very safe and cost effective for many years. There is no reason why the Max cannot now do the same.

Teddy Lop

8,301 posts

68 months

Sunday 10th July 2022
quotequote all
Richie Slow said:
They wouldn't have ever needed a full type certification process for the Max8 but they really did need to implement a program of pilot training on the new systems that included handling failures of MCAS. The mentality within Boeing to market the Max as an aircraft that needed no pilot familiarisation was the problem and that is where they were irresponsible, both corporately and morally.

The stain won't last long, stigmas only remain with those who have an interest. The DC10 had an awful reputation in the seventies but they went on to become statistically very safe and cost effective for many years. There is no reason why the Max cannot now do the same.
People have short memories.

But with the Chinese wanting a slice of the market boeings position should have been to push the "prized safety and security" for all it's worth and for all it costs against the "they're a bit dodge y',know".

Ayahuasca

27,427 posts

280 months

Sunday 10th July 2022
quotequote all
I have flown a couple of times on a Max this year and didn’t crash once.

havoc

30,083 posts

236 months

Sunday 10th July 2022
quotequote all
Ayahuasca said:
I have flown a couple of times on a Max this year and didn’t crash once.
I know someone who took an old Renault on a road-trip and it didn't break down, contrary to their rep.

...doesn't mean an old Renault would be my first choice of car for a long journey.

Piginapoke

Original Poster:

4,768 posts

186 months

Sunday 17th July 2022
quotequote all
Flew on a Ryanair Max to Malta, and guess we’ll fly home on one too. Not a single reference to Max anywhere, the engines (so far forward!) and wingtips are a giveaway though,