Best burgers and burger buns?

Author
Discussion

dapprman

2,322 posts

267 months

Monday 28th August 2023
quotequote all
Personally I found the Lidl brioche buns to the best of that ilk this year.

richhead

877 posts

11 months

Monday 28th August 2023
quotequote all
dapprman said:
Personally I found the Lidl brioche buns to the best of that ilk this year.
Brioche buns have no place with a burger, a nice crusty white roll from your baker of choice is the way, none of that poncy stuff

Cockaigne

2,797 posts

19 months

Monday 28th August 2023
quotequote all
richhead said:
Brioche buns have no place with a burger, a nice crusty white roll from your baker of choice is the way, none of that poncy stuff
yes way too sweet. I like Tesco fresh white baps or even oven muffins.

Just decent burger, cheese, maybe bacon, and bit of sauce. I think people mess about you end up with too many flavours.

ambuletz

Original Poster:

10,739 posts

181 months

Tuesday 29th August 2023
quotequote all
cant stand brioche buns.
- too sweet
- burn very easily
- they will disintegrate into nothing. In no time you end up eating a burger covered with a thin layer of wet slop on the bottom


I want a normal, seeded burger bun. trouble is many of the ones designed as such tend to be quite crap. They're heavily processed for a very very long shelf life. Yes you can get the supermarket bakery 'seeded rolls'. But these go off too fast and cant be frozen. Kind of wish someone would do a KFC bun style.. only 'cos i'm fed up of trying everything else.

Luke.

10,996 posts

250 months

Tuesday 29th August 2023
quotequote all
ambuletz said:
cant stand brioche buns.
- too sweet
- burn very easily
- they will disintegrate into nothing. In no time you end up eating a burger covered with a thin layer of wet slop on the bottom


I want a normal, seeded burger bun. trouble is many of the ones designed as such tend to be quite crap. They're heavily processed for a very very long shelf life. Yes you can get the supermarket bakery 'seeded rolls'. But these go off too fast and cant be frozen. Kind of wish someone would do a KFC bun style.. only 'cos i'm fed up of trying everything else.
M&S do a very good seeded burger bun. And likewise, can't stand the brioche crap.

dudleybloke

19,834 posts

186 months

Tuesday 29th August 2023
quotequote all
Tesco cheese rolls are great with burgers, they toast up without going dry and don't fall apart, plus the added bonus of cheese.

Mobile Chicane

20,832 posts

212 months

Tuesday 29th August 2023
quotequote all
richhead said:
dapprman said:
Personally I found the Lidl brioche buns to the best of that ilk this year.
Brioche buns have no place with a burger, a nice crusty white roll from your baker of choice is the way, none of that poncy stuff
Exactly.



The Gauge

1,878 posts

13 months

Tuesday 29th August 2023
quotequote all
A saw a comment somewhere saying something like 'We want wider burgers, not taller' which I think is true. If they have to be served with a cocktail stick through them to stop them toppling then what's the point, just make them wider, much wider.

Blown2CV

28,819 posts

203 months

Tuesday 29th August 2023
quotequote all
whatever roll you put a burger into, it cannot make the burger more about bread than meat, and it cannot be so crusty or substantial that in biting through it you slice your lips to bits and shoot the burger contents over your dinner guest. Some rolls just don't work on burgers such as ciabatta, sourdough etc. I don't think crusty bread works at all really. If there is any dryness being brought to the party, then that too can fk off. Bun should be steamed/foiled/wettened in some way.

Cockaigne

2,797 posts

19 months

Tuesday 29th August 2023
quotequote all
The Gauge said:
A saw a comment somewhere saying something like 'We want wider burgers, not taller' which I think is true. If they have to be served with a cocktail stick through them to stop them toppling then what's the point, just make them wider, much wider.
i just smash them down, both sides, works well. i think thicker burgers take up less shelf space.

Acorn1

649 posts

20 months

Tuesday 29th August 2023
quotequote all
ambuletz said:
cant stand brioche buns.
- too sweet
- burn very easily
- they will disintegrate into nothing. In no time you end up eating a burger covered with a thin layer of wet slop on the bottom


I want a normal, seeded burger bun. trouble is many of the ones designed as such tend to be quite crap. They're heavily processed for a very very long shelf life. Yes you can get the supermarket bakery 'seeded rolls'. But these go off too fast and cant be frozen. Kind of wish someone would do a KFC bun style.. only 'cos i'm fed up of trying everything else.
This!

I can't stand them with burgers, may as well slice a doughnut in half

ambuletz

Original Poster:

10,739 posts

181 months

Tuesday 29th August 2023
quotequote all
Cockaigne said:
The Gauge said:
A saw a comment somewhere saying something like 'We want wider burgers, not taller' which I think is true. If they have to be served with a cocktail stick through them to stop them toppling then what's the point, just make them wider, much wider.
i just smash them down, both sides, works well. i think thicker burgers take up less shelf space.
this is what i do with all the pre-formed burgers you get in the chilled meat section. cling film over the burger and flatten down using a large flat bottomed pot.

matrignano

4,370 posts

210 months

Tuesday 29th August 2023
quotequote all
Any recommendation for a burger that can be cooked in the pan (no oil) and doesn't start swimming in its own fat straight away?
But also doesn't dry out to a Maccy D's cardboard like consitency?

I like M&S's Ultimate Burger but there must be something better out there?


Luke.

10,996 posts

250 months

Tuesday 29th August 2023
quotequote all
matrignano said:
Any recommendation for a burger that can be cooked in the pan (no oil) and doesn't start swimming in its own fat straight away?
But also doesn't dry out to a Maccy D's cardboard like consitency?

I like M&S's Ultimate Burger but there must be something better out there?
Buy some mince with 20% fat. Roll a bit into a ball, chuck it on a pan, flatten and add salt and pepper to both sides. Can't beat it.

BIRMA

3,808 posts

194 months

Tuesday 29th August 2023
quotequote all
matrignano said:
Any recommendation for a burger that can be cooked in the pan (no oil) and doesn't start swimming in its own fat straight away?
But also doesn't dry out to a Maccy D's cardboard like consitency?

I like M&S's Ultimate Burger but there must be something better out there?
If you have a mincer available making your own is so simple, I've been making my own for years I buy fresh meat from the Butchers counter at Morrisons, some chuck steak and then buy any cheap rump steak that's on offer, just add salt and pepper and you'll never buy another from a shop. I use 70% chuck and 30% rump.
I always buy fresh meat so I can freeze the extra ones I don't cook on the day.
Having said that the other day Igot caught out by unexpected guests and didn't have any in the freezer so I bought some ultimate burgers from Asda at about £3.75 and they weren't bad.
Just popped into Iceland and these are on offer for £5. I've always thought that Wagyu was too subtle a flavour for burgers but at this price why not. I usually buy Wagyu rump which is exquisite.



Edited by BIRMA on Tuesday 29th August 15:46


Edited by BIRMA on Tuesday 29th August 15:46


Edited by BIRMA on Tuesday 29th August 15:47


Edited by BIRMA on Tuesday 29th August 15:49

Cockaigne

2,797 posts

19 months

Tuesday 29th August 2023
quotequote all
it is weird how wagyu is seen as best burger mince, i think it is too fatty. There are better British breeds, like black Angus (Iceland did these but disappeared) or Dexter, but not mainstream enough. I think the cross breeds of Wagyu have saturated the market.

i notice Waitrose is doing British heritage, two burgers for 3 quid, seems good value.

ambuletz

Original Poster:

10,739 posts

181 months

Tuesday 29th August 2023
quotequote all
plenty of videos and articles out there comparing fat content, if you want good maillard reaction you need the fat 20-30%. fat is flavour. depending on how much flavour you want mince your own from various bits.... but aint nobody got time for that.

TheLurker

1,371 posts

196 months

Tuesday 29th August 2023
quotequote all
ambuletz said:
plenty of videos and articles out there comparing fat content, if you want good maillard reaction you need the fat 20-30%. fat is flavour. depending on how much flavour you want mince your own from various bits.... but aint nobody got time for that.
Agreed. Especially if grilling on the BBQ the fat makes some good flames for that flame grilled effect as well.

Try a turkey burger if you want to see what a lack of fat does.

matrignano

4,370 posts

210 months

Tuesday 29th August 2023
quotequote all
Yes agreed, but sometimes I just fancy a burger and can’t be arsed to faff with the bbq, so pan it is.
The fattier burgers don’t work on a pan IMHO

CharlesdeGaulle

26,267 posts

180 months

Tuesday 29th August 2023
quotequote all
My Lidl burgers are Belgian. The trick is to mash 3 and roll them and divide into 2. Add extra seasoning, a finely chopped chilli and some shallot, and then stick on a ridged grill pan or the barbie. I like them squeezed thin and wide. Fantastic.