Week 2 Cooking Competition - results

[jep]

zakelwe said:

jep said:

A pie has to win sorry, despite the other great, great efforts. However, the only way I can differentiate between the 2, is that unfortunately I can't tell if zakelwe's is a fully enclosed pie, or just a casserole with a lid.

So on that note... the Carmarthenshire vote goes to the Captain.

Didn't you see the attempts at my base? However the other pie was better. CaptainZep v Corporal Punishment considering what happened

Regards
Andy

Ah, ah, yes, true, but the finished pictures didn't show full enclosure.


I forgot that particular part of the thread. Very sorry.

[madbadger]

Any more for any more?

Looks like it will finish a bit closer than it was.

[Anna_S]

Well done CaptainZep, a well deserved win

[madbadger]

Well done.

[Cactussed]

Indeed, congratulations!

So, next random ingredients out of the hat are?

[zakelwe]

Aye Aye Captain! Well done, lovely meal.

Regards
Andy

[captainzep]

Thanks all.

Sorry for the delay, I'm currently 300 miles from home in Jep's neck of the woods. -Not that we colluded on the voting.

Hand on heart, it tasted good and went well, -maybe more luck than judgement. Not all of my cooking is a success.

Are we happy with the means of polling? It struck me that some very good dishes didn't get many votes because we use the single-vote forum poll.

Discuss.

Just don't want capable PH cooks getting downhearted, because this will die if people start dropping out.

Ingredients to follow in a new thread.

Edited by captainzep on Friday 16th October 10:32

[madbadger]

I agree.

Maybe allow multiple voting but trust people not to vote more than three times? Could potentially screw things up though.

[Anna_S]

I don't mind if I never win again, I just like taking part - I'm going nowhere me. But if there are better suggestions for voting lets hear them

[captainzep]

Anna_S said:

I don't mind if I never win again, I just like taking part - I'm going nowhere me. But if there are better suggestions for voting lets hear them

Me too. -And I actually prefer not to be the one naming the ingredients.

[madbadger]

thegavster said:

Anna_S said:

I don't mind if I never win again, I just like taking part

Exaclty, my initial reaction last week was to be disheartened after coming second from last, I said I was going to give it a miss this time round. However once the new ingredients were posted up my mind started wandering, if people enjoy cooking and the ingredients challenge/inspire them, then they'll enter regardless.

Quite agree.

But it would make voting easier.

[smack]

If you start the poll, can you see who voted for what? ie. Can you police people's voting to 2 for example if we use check boxes?

[Cactussed]

I vote we make the poll multiple votes, allow 3 votes and leave it to honesty. Its not as though it really matters, does it?

ETA: So long as I win

Edited by Cactussed on Friday 16th October 11:24

[Bullett]

I don't have any problem with the 1 man 1 vote system, anything else would be hard to police.

I missed week one becasue I was busy and the ingrediants didn't inspire me. Week 2 they did so I did. Winning is nice but I prefer the challenge and comments on what you did.

[zakelwe]

Yeah I agree, I don't think anyone will cheat. I'd guess most people haven't even been voting for their own dish even with one vote, well I haven't.

Regards
Andy

[grumbledoak]

Bullett said:

I don't have any problem with the 1 man 1 vote system, anything else would be hard to police.

Simple.

I think the main issue this time was that there was such a clear winner. That didn't leave many votes for the rest of us to share!

[V8mate]

Cap'n Zep by some margin. Looked good enough to eat!

[shirt]

well done zep! yay, i came joint last - the only way is up!

looking at that pie again i think the only reasonable way to judge is for you all to courier me a portion of your dishes and i will eat them. i mean decide on a winner.

[missdiane]

thegavster said:

Anna_S said:

I don't mind if I never win again, I just like taking part

Exaclty, my initial reaction last week was to be disheartened after coming second from last, I said I was going to give it a miss this time round. However once the new ingredients were posted up my mind started wandering, if people enjoy cooking and the ingredients challenge/inspire them, then they'll enter regardless.

I voted you gavster, different and probably what I would have opted to cook.
Well done CaptainZep