Grand Designs

Author
Discussion

alock

4,228 posts

212 months

Thursday 24th November 2016
quotequote all
Too distracted by jeans with braces eek

anonymous-user

55 months

Friday 25th November 2016
quotequote all
alock said:
Too distracted by jeans with braces eek
Mrs G and I missed what he was saying as we were totally distracted by the braves and jeans.

I know it's not a fashion show, but what was he thinking. Especially as the braces were so tight the jeans were half way up his arse smile

loughran

2,752 posts

137 months

Friday 25th November 2016
quotequote all
I thought it was a great start to the series. I had doubts about the first house, the massive concrete bunker, but as the story unfolded it was pretty incredible how the architect had left courtyards where the original buildings had been. It was massive but in effect 2 houses.

Not sure why the 60s house with sloping roof was included, It was designed and built 50 years ago by David Levitt. The ladies did it up. Well done ladies.

The large green zinc agricultural house was the best of its type I've seen. The materials and craftsmanship looked first class and it really did seem to sit well in its surroundings. (a much overused phrase. wobble)

The fortress on Jersey was just ace, like something out of a James Bond movie, it sat there on the beach going 'fk off' to the weather. Definitely my favourite.

The villa in Cornwall was pants. If you're going to design a cantilever, have the courage of your convictions and do it properly. Don't have second thoughts later on and prop it up with a couple of crappy poles. It was completely outshone by Creek Veen, built 50 years earlier.


TimJMS

2,584 posts

252 months

Friday 25th November 2016
quotequote all
loughran said:
The villa in Cornwall was pants. If you're going to design a cantilever, have the courage of your convictions and do it properly. Don't have second thoughts later on and prop it up with a couple of crappy poles. It was completely outshone by Creek Veen, built 50 years earlier.
Couldn't agree more. Moreover The Balancing Barn shows how it can be done. I can only surmise they ruined the ship for a ha'porth of tar. You would expect that on GD, but not this.

Bonefish Blues

26,810 posts

224 months

Saturday 26th November 2016
quotequote all
Finally got to watch this. Mrs BFB was smitten by the pantsilever house. Am ashamed.

Whilst I get its significance I don't understand why the refurb made the list, perhaps delayed recognition from the profession?

First and last head and shoulders above the rest for me, especially the Jersey house, where you can see the context immediately as the camera pans out. The outside space looked slightly messily resolved though, something that the first did so beautifully by bringing it inside, as it were.

As said, some good stuff here.

Baron Greenback

6,999 posts

151 months

Saturday 26th November 2016
quotequote all
Liked all of them, the plywood house the least! Can't understand why the plywood house is for houses built in the 60's rebuilt now in 2016 competition. Jersey house my fav can't buy it due to no family ties to the island (presume it's still like it)!

greygoose

8,269 posts

196 months

Thursday 1st December 2016
quotequote all
Some very interesting features in the houses tonight, the Edinburgh house was particularly ingenious in its quirky uses of movable panels for light.

anonymous-user

55 months

Thursday 1st December 2016
quotequote all
greygoose said:
Some very interesting features in the houses tonight, the Edinburgh house was particularly ingenious in its quirky uses of movable panels for light.
Wasn't it just.

Love the Cumbria house externally - the stone and dark zinc (I assume) - not so sure about the inside.

greygoose

8,269 posts

196 months

Thursday 1st December 2016
quotequote all
garyhun said:
greygoose said:
Some very interesting features in the houses tonight, the Edinburgh house was particularly ingenious in its quirky uses of movable panels for light.
Wasn't it just.

Love the Cumbria house externally - the stone and dark zinc (I assume) - not so sure about the inside.
Inside was a bit bland, the lawn was immaculate though.

Sway

26,317 posts

195 months

Thursday 1st December 2016
quotequote all
Could happily live in any of the ones tonight - not typically the case.

I do tend to like 'clever' houses, think this comes from wanting to live in Caratacus Potts' house after I saw chitty chitty bang bang as a young child!

Evoluzione

Original Poster:

10,345 posts

244 months

Friday 2nd December 2016
quotequote all
loughran said:
I thought it was a great start to the series. I had doubts about the first house, the massive concrete bunker, but as the story unfolded it was pretty incredible how the architect had left courtyards where the original buildings had been. It was massive but in effect 2 houses.

Not sure why the 60s house with sloping roof was included, It was designed and built 50 years ago by David Levitt. The ladies did it up. Well done ladies.

The large green zinc agricultural house was the best of its type I've seen. The materials and craftsmanship looked first class and it really did seem to sit well in its surroundings. (a much overused phrase. wobble)

The fortress on Jersey was just ace, like something out of a James Bond movie, it sat there on the beach going 'fk off' to the weather. Definitely my favourite.

The villa in Cornwall was pants. If you're going to design a cantilever, have the courage of your convictions and do it properly. Don't have second thoughts later on and prop it up with a couple of crappy poles. It was completely outshone by Creek Veen, built 50 years earlier.
I'm just catching up tonight, what was the orange cladding on the fortress? I must have missed it.

loughran

2,752 posts

137 months

Friday 2nd December 2016
quotequote all
Evoluzione said:
loughran said:
I thought it was a great start to the series. I had doubts about the first house, the massive concrete bunker, but as the story unfolded it was pretty incredible how the architect had left courtyards where the original buildings had been. It was massive but in effect 2 houses.

Not sure why the 60s house with sloping roof was included, It was designed and built 50 years ago by David Levitt. The ladies did it up. Well done ladies.

The large green zinc agricultural house was the best of its type I've seen. The materials and craftsmanship looked first class and it really did seem to sit well in its surroundings. (a much overused phrase. wobble)

The fortress on Jersey was just ace, like something out of a James Bond movie, it sat there on the beach going 'fk off' to the weather. Definitely my favourite.

The villa in Cornwall was pants. If you're going to design a cantilever, have the courage of your convictions and do it properly. Don't have second thoughts later on and prop it up with a couple of crappy poles. It was completely outshone by Creek Veen, built 50 years earlier.
I'm just catching up tonight, what was the orange cladding on the fortress? I must have missed it.
Corten steel I think.

Sway

26,317 posts

195 months

Friday 2nd December 2016
quotequote all
You'll be able to date certain houses to within a 5 year period in a few decades I reckon - purely on whether there's any coreten...

Shakermaker

11,317 posts

101 months

Friday 2nd December 2016
quotequote all
A bedroom, with a bath in it? Never seen that before, what a bizarre idea.

Could definitely do with getting the motors replaced on his shutters though.

I didn't care much for the first house they featured, the one in London, and I didn't care much for the Japanese extension house either.

But the other three, I liked them. With the large house in Amersham, I now have a desire to have that inbuilt balcony they have in the master bedroom, and also the little triangular overhang with a window on the upper floor.

Evoluzione

Original Poster:

10,345 posts

244 months

Friday 2nd December 2016
quotequote all
loughran said:
Evoluzione said:
loughran said:
I thought it was a great start to the series. I had doubts about the first house, the massive concrete bunker, but as the story unfolded it was pretty incredible how the architect had left courtyards where the original buildings had been. It was massive but in effect 2 houses.

Not sure why the 60s house with sloping roof was included, It was designed and built 50 years ago by David Levitt. The ladies did it up. Well done ladies.

The large green zinc agricultural house was the best of its type I've seen. The materials and craftsmanship looked first class and it really did seem to sit well in its surroundings. (a much overused phrase. wobble)

The fortress on Jersey was just ace, like something out of a James Bond movie, it sat there on the beach going 'fk off' to the weather. Definitely my favourite.

The villa in Cornwall was pants. If you're going to design a cantilever, have the courage of your convictions and do it properly. Don't have second thoughts later on and prop it up with a couple of crappy poles. It was completely outshone by Creek Veen, built 50 years earlier.
I'm just catching up tonight, what was the orange cladding on the fortress? I must have missed it.
Corten steel I think.
That's interesting I never knew that. There is a flyover in Leeds, built 2006 - 2008, I always wondered why they never painted the steel it's made from, now I know. idea

Baron Greenback

6,999 posts

151 months

Friday 2nd December 2016
quotequote all
I quite like corten steel cladding in its place! Not quite caught up with latest episode!

anonymous-user

55 months

Friday 2nd December 2016
quotequote all
Well, two episodes in and my favourite so far is the fortress on Jersey, makes a change to see a 'masculine'design.

loughran

2,752 posts

137 months

Friday 2nd December 2016
quotequote all
Not keen on the house in Edinburgh. This is what happens when you let a man who can't get a girlfriend build a house.



What a fking eyesore.

And the detail/ motorised shutters/window through the wall/bath to conceal a body.... just no !

I did like the Covert House despite the bedrooms being underground... it's just... it would have looked so much better if that raw concrete was plastered. They seemed genuinely excited that you could discern the very point where the second concrete lorry was late but just in time. I'm all for honest construction techniques but reveling in a change of concrete density in your wall is perhaps taking things a little toooo far.

The details were beautiful but plaster the damn walls, it'll look so much better.

I missed the second half. who got put through to the final ?

Sway

26,317 posts

195 months

Friday 2nd December 2016
quotequote all
Covert and the Edinburgh one!

Bonefish Blues

26,810 posts

224 months

Friday 2nd December 2016
quotequote all
I agree with the poster one from above TBH - lots of cleverness for the sake of it I thought.