C4 GBBO

Author
Discussion

C5_Steve

3,181 posts

104 months

Thursday 2nd November 2023
quotequote all
Watched it last night, I'm not sure Dana deserved to go tbh but I think she's maybe been middle of the road for a few weeks now and never really stunned the judges with anything. I think Matty got lucky if I'm honest and don't think he'll last much longer. Saku has had two rough weeks now and needs to pull her socks up.

I also get unreasonably annoyed with the whole "See you in the morning" thing, especially obvious in this episode as it was DARK when they finished one of the tasks. Hadn't even thought about them wearing the same thing twice but makes sense.

I felt really bad for Tasha this week, she was clearly very stressed out which I assume prompted her to switch to sign for most of the last task. That said, I wasn't much impressed with her show-stopper and dare I say the judges went a bit over the top with their praise for it?


FiF

44,193 posts

252 months

Thursday 2nd November 2023
quotequote all
Well Extra Slice, Jo Brand got the usual cheap shot laugh for calling Matt Hancock a "tt".

Pity she didn't extend that to the person on the show who qualifies for that description the most, Tom "One Trick Pony" Allen.

greygoose

8,282 posts

196 months

Friday 3rd November 2023
quotequote all
FiF said:
Well Extra Slice, Jo Brand got the usual cheap shot laugh for calling Matt Hancock a "tt".
.
She’s not wrong though.

I enjoy Extra Slice, light hearted baking puns are a welcome diversion from the misery of the world at the moment.

HustleRussell

24,751 posts

161 months

Friday 3rd November 2023
quotequote all
FiF said:
Well Extra Slice, Jo Brand got the usual cheap shot laugh for calling Matt Hancock a "tt".

Pity she didn't extend that to the person on the show who qualifies for that description the most, Tom "One Trick Pony" Allen.
You think Tom Allen is more deserving of our distain than Matt Hancock?

FiF

44,193 posts

252 months

Friday 3rd November 2023
quotequote all
HustleRussell said:
FiF said:
Well Extra Slice, Jo Brand got the usual cheap shot laugh for calling Matt Hancock a "tt".

Pity she didn't extend that to the person on the show who qualifies for that description the most, Tom "One Trick Pony" Allen.
You think Tom Allen is more deserving of our distain than Matt Hancock?
Not going to divert thread further other to say whatever one thinks of Hancock, why should a baking show, a baking show ffs, throw in a totally off topic out of context barb like that.

What's next, mid sentence discussing a cake Brand suddenly shouts out " F***ing Brexit?" Sad, neither necessary nor appropriate, probably struggling to be relevant and edgy. She's another one trick pony.

TikTak

1,587 posts

20 months

Friday 3rd November 2023
quotequote all
C5_Steve said:
Watched it last night, I'm not sure Dana deserved to go tbh but I think she's maybe been middle of the road for a few weeks now and never really stunned the judges with anything.
Yeah same. Think there are a few behind the front runners and it'll take either something spectacular from one of them or disastrous from one of the guys at the front over the coming weeks to change it.

Also did not care for botanical week.

Red9zero

6,943 posts

58 months

Friday 3rd November 2023
quotequote all
FiF said:
Not going to divert thread further other to say whatever one thinks of Hancock, why should a baking show, a baking show ffs, throw in a totally off topic out of context barb like that.

What's next, mid sentence discussing a cake Brand suddenly shouts out " F***ing Brexit?" Sad, neither necessary nor appropriate, probably struggling to be relevant and edgy. She's another one trick pony.
I used to like JB, even saw her live show, but after her comment about throwing battery acid at politicians, I think she is vile.

smithyithy

7,261 posts

119 months

Friday 3rd November 2023
quotequote all
You'd hope the one place you could avoid toxic political prepossession would be a light-hearted family baking show, obviously she thinks otherwise rolleyes

HustleRussell

24,751 posts

161 months

Friday 3rd November 2023
quotequote all
FiF said:
HustleRussell said:
FiF said:
Well Extra Slice, Jo Brand got the usual cheap shot laugh for calling Matt Hancock a "tt".

Pity she didn't extend that to the person on the show who qualifies for that description the most, Tom "One Trick Pony" Allen.
You think Tom Allen is more deserving of our distain than Matt Hancock?
Not going to divert thread further other to say whatever one thinks of Hancock, why should a baking show, a baking show ffs, throw in a totally off topic out of context barb like that.

What's next, mid sentence discussing a cake Brand suddenly shouts out " F***ing Brexit?" Sad, neither necessary nor appropriate, probably struggling to be relevant and edgy. She's another one trick pony.
Well I'm going to go on record as saying that Tom Allen is 'less bad' than Matt Hancock, and I don't think that's controversial.

former NHS England chief Sir Simon Stevens said:
The secretary of state for health and social care took the position that in this situation he - rather than, say, the medical profession or the public - should ultimately decide who should live and who should die.
What's Tom Allen done, been a bit too gay?

MesoForm

8,901 posts

276 months

Friday 3rd November 2023
quotequote all
TikTak said:
Also did not care for botanical week.
Quite liked it as a theme - they need to have new things for the show and at least it was a baking theme and not just cooking like the themes have been in recent series.

Randy Winkman

16,234 posts

190 months

Friday 3rd November 2023
quotequote all
MesoForm said:
TikTak said:
Also did not care for botanical week.
Quite liked it as a theme - they need to have new things for the show and at least it was a baking theme and not just cooking like the themes have been in recent series.
I liked the theme too. They could bake stuff and use different ingredients for flavour.

Swervin_Mervin

4,470 posts

239 months

Friday 3rd November 2023
quotequote all
No one else finding Noel Fielding increasingly irritating/cringe/unfunny? Two prime examples on this week's show with the lemon and then trying to crack a joke whilst being completely unaware of what Christy was trying to do. He does that a lot - making crap jokes when a baker's right int he middle of something tricky.

I didn't mind him at first, and love the Boosh etc, but he does my head in a bit on this now.

thegreenhell

15,482 posts

220 months

Tuesday 7th November 2023
quotequote all
Is this the worst technical ever?

illmonkey

18,231 posts

199 months

Tuesday 7th November 2023
quotequote all
Only 1 that is edible!

MXRod

2,754 posts

148 months

Tuesday 7th November 2023
quotequote all
Hilarious

nicanary

9,814 posts

147 months

Tuesday 7th November 2023
quotequote all
TBF to the bakers they were simply not given enough time for the challenge.

James6112

4,439 posts

29 months

Tuesday 7th November 2023
quotequote all
nicanary said:
TBF to the bakers they were simply not given enough time for the challenge.
Were they told that it takes 40 minutes to bake it?
Only a fool would think it’ll be fine in 20!

cherryowen

11,729 posts

205 months

Tuesday 7th November 2023
quotequote all
James6112 said:
Were they told that it takes 40 minutes to bake it?
No, it was mentioned by Hollywood when explaining the process to Pru.



ch37

10,642 posts

222 months

Tuesday 7th November 2023
quotequote all
One of the funniest episodes for a long time. If not a single baker is coming even remotely close to making an edible technical the instructions are probably too vague. Was the usual verbal hint even a mention of a lengthy bake time?

FiF

44,193 posts

252 months

Wednesday 8th November 2023
quotequote all
They had 90 mins, syrup needs to be sorted first, Hollywood said that would take 20 mins.

Realistically they've got to be getting the sponges in with *at minimum* 50 mins to go, to allow 10 mins for a bit of resting, plating up etc. That only leaves 20 mins for making sponge batter, greasing the basins, setting up the oven steaming environment, reading and understanding the instructions.

Clearly most of them had never made steamed puddings and didn't understand the basics of how steaming is a whole different process in timing. Even the contestant who said he loved steamed puddings didn't quite get there. Says to me, deliberately sparse instructions, not enough time allowed, and contestants lacking,

Right from series 1 always been the same, time allowed on technicals a problem. Exposed when Hollywood and Berry used to do the Masterclass episodes, which is maybe why they don't do them now.