Chris Evans

Author
Discussion

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

199 months

Monday 17th September 2018
quotequote all
RJG46 said:
BBC are supposedly denying rumours it will be Ball. She does currently have her own show on ITV.
She also has a role on strictly too.

rdjohn

6,189 posts

196 months

Monday 17th September 2018
quotequote all
Unlike Chris, I think Zoe is good on TV. I think she could have been good on a revised Top Gear format.

But I don’t know what she uses as “mother’s little helper” in the morning, but she is just way too hyper. Sara Cox on the other hand is always genuinely funny , putting herself as the butt of any jokes, with good rappot with listers on the line.

I don’t want Radio 2 to return to the TOG format of auld Tell, but there has to be a middle ground.

And please do not try to replicate the Friday morning format, which worked well for the first couple of interviews, but by the time it got to 9:00 was a total shambles with people interrupting and generally being crap.

Steve Wright and Graham Norton are old hands at this, if it’s live radio, one guest at a time, for a short period, is probably sufficient.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

199 months

Monday 17th September 2018
quotequote all
rdjohn said:
Unlike Chris, I think Zoe is good on TV. I think she could have been good on a revised Top Gear format.

But I don’t know what she uses as “mother’s little helper” in the morning, but she is just way too hyper. Sara Cox on the other hand is always genuinely funny , putting herself as the butt of any jokes, with good rappot with listers on the line.

I don’t want Radio 2 to return to the TOG format of auld Tell, but there has to be a middle ground.

And please do not try to replicate the Friday morning format, which worked well for the first couple of interviews, but by the time it got to 9:00 was a total shambles with people interrupting and generally being crap.

Steve Wright and Graham Norton are old hands at this, if it’s live radio, one guest at a time, for a short period, is probably sufficient.
If I catch the Friday show I personally enjoy the bants between guests and host. Live music too from great bands with some celebs joining in singing/arsing about is good harmless fun.



How do you like your eggs in the morning? I like mine with a double yoke (kiss) kiss

Hilts

4,393 posts

283 months

Monday 17th September 2018
quotequote all
Not my first choice but an improvement on Evans, will give her a shake.

RJG46

980 posts

69 months

Monday 17th September 2018
quotequote all
Coxy's Radio 1 Breakfast show was crap. Lauren Laverne over her or Ball any day of the week.

Sparky137

869 posts

182 months

Monday 17th September 2018
quotequote all
RJG46 said:
Coxy's Radio 1 Breakfast show was crap. Lauren Laverne over her or Ball any day of the week.
Its a good job that she's changed a lot since her Radio 1 days then.

Europa1

10,923 posts

189 months

Tuesday 18th September 2018
quotequote all
Welshbeef said:
enjoy the bants
Go and stand in the corner and think about what you've done.

droopsnoot

11,975 posts

243 months

Tuesday 18th September 2018
quotequote all
I'll see how it goes - if it's someone rubbish, at least I can go back to Radio 1 now it's Greg James instead of Grimshaw.

That said, I have the radio on in the afternoon so I am now hearing Grimshaw from 4pm, and I was surprised to find he's nowhere near as annoying. I don't know whether it's because he speaks less, or because I'm working so not paying quite so much attention, or maybe he's just settled down a bit. But I haven't found the need to re-tune.

Front bottom

5,648 posts

191 months

Tuesday 18th September 2018
quotequote all
A bit off topic, but I usually give them all swerve and listen to 6music.

That was until the DAB stopped working in the car. I'm now at the mercy of FM, and pretty much everything is gash, except for maybe Absolute, but there's only so much I can take of that.

Radio 1 is aimed at 18year olds, and Radio 2 at 60 year olds. There's nothing for my age group (late 40s, and admittedly have an eclectic music taste), and don't get me started on commercial radio.

Thank gawd for DAB, when it's working.

Edited by Front bottom on Tuesday 18th September 12:56

Kitchski

6,516 posts

232 months

Tuesday 18th September 2018
quotequote all
Front bottom said:
A bit off topic, but I usually give them all swerve and listen to 6music.

That was until the DAB stopped working in the car. I'm now at the mercy of FM, and pretty much everything is gash, except for maybe Absolute, but there's only so much I can take of that.

Radio 1 is aimed at 18year olds, and Radio 2 at 60 year olds. There's nothing for my age group (late 40s, and admittedly have an eclectic music taste), and don't get me started on commercial radio.

Thank gawd for DAB, when it's working.

Edited by Front bottom on Tuesday 18th September 12:56
I enjoy Radio X at 4pm, because you get Johnny Vaughan and his merry gaggle. Gav Woods is brilliant! A very likeable guy, and the show falls apart without him.
For your age range, it's worth a go, despite the adverts and repeated music. The humour is great, as long as you don't hate JV (as some do - he's a bit marmite).

Up to 4pm, Radio X is a bit vanilla really. I don't mind Chris Moyles, but I'm not mad on him. Toby Tarrant is a safe pair of hands, but has a fairly harmless 10am slot. Likewise the guy in the afternoons. Ellis James and John Robbins are the jewel in Radio X's crown, but they're only on during Saturdays.

kev1974

4,029 posts

130 months

Tuesday 18th September 2018
quotequote all
What I don't understand is, the vast talent pool that organisations like the BBC have to draw on, and yet they keep going back time and time again to the same people like Sara Cox and Zoe Ball.

Of all the local stations they have in their stable (or even the independent locals they could easily poach from), is there really nobody new that they can "promote" up to national level? Or even look to places like the Netherlands where many of their DJs speak perfect English. Either way, give us someone fresh (and presumably far more affordable to the licence fee payers).

Why does the BBC's talent searches only ever seem to have the same six or so people as contenders?

Front bottom

5,648 posts

191 months

Tuesday 18th September 2018
quotequote all
Kitchski said:
Front bottom said:
A bit off topic, but I usually give them all swerve and listen to 6music.

That was until the DAB stopped working in the car. I'm now at the mercy of FM, and pretty much everything is gash, except for maybe Absolute, but there's only so much I can take of that.

Radio 1 is aimed at 18year olds, and Radio 2 at 60 year olds. There's nothing for my age group (late 40s, and admittedly have an eclectic music taste), and don't get me started on commercial radio.

Thank gawd for DAB, when it's working.

Edited by Front bottom on Tuesday 18th September 12:56
I enjoy Radio X at 4pm, because you get Johnny Vaughan and his merry gaggle. Gav Woods is brilliant! A very likeable guy, and the show falls apart without him.
For your age range, it's worth a go, despite the adverts and repeated music. The humour is great, as long as you don't hate JV (as some do - he's a bit marmite).

Up to 4pm, Radio X is a bit vanilla really. I don't mind Chris Moyles, but I'm not mad on him. Toby Tarrant is a safe pair of hands, but has a fairly harmless 10am slot. Likewise the guy in the afternoons. Ellis James and John Robbins are the jewel in Radio X's crown, but they're only on during Saturdays.
Cheers. I don't mind JV, but could never stand Moyles. The others I've never heard of. Mind you, my receiver has never picked up on Radio X for some reason.

I think the simple answer is to get the DAB fixed as soon as possible!

SpeckledJim

31,608 posts

254 months

Tuesday 18th September 2018
quotequote all
kev1974 said:
What I don't understand is, the vast talent pool that organisations like the BBC have to draw on, and yet they keep going back time and time again to the same people like Sara Cox and Zoe Ball.

Of all the local stations they have in their stable (or even the independent locals they could easily poach from), is there really nobody new that they can "promote" up to national level? Or even look to places like the Netherlands where many of their DJs speak perfect English. Either way, give us someone fresh (and presumably far more affordable to the licence fee payers).

Why does the BBC's talent searches only ever seem to have the same six or so people as contenders?
Exactly this. I listen to a BBC local radio station and half of the daytime/drivetime presenters could hold their own on Radio 2, no problem at all. Give them a chance.

Shakermaker

11,317 posts

101 months

Tuesday 18th September 2018
quotequote all
SpeckledJim said:
kev1974 said:
What I don't understand is, the vast talent pool that organisations like the BBC have to draw on, and yet they keep going back time and time again to the same people like Sara Cox and Zoe Ball.

Of all the local stations they have in their stable (or even the independent locals they could easily poach from), is there really nobody new that they can "promote" up to national level? Or even look to places like the Netherlands where many of their DJs speak perfect English. Either way, give us someone fresh (and presumably far more affordable to the licence fee payers).

Why does the BBC's talent searches only ever seem to have the same six or so people as contenders?
Exactly this. I listen to a BBC local radio station and half of the daytime/drivetime presenters could hold their own on Radio 2, no problem at all. Give them a chance.
I'd suggest this does happen, to a degree. Just it takes longer. Despite being public funded, the people within the organisation themselves will still want to be part of a structure where they can progress upwards. Getting the R2 Breakfast Show is not something that you can just step into from "nowhere" - you'll need to be established within the BBC national network already, which means you may well have worked up the roster from a local station. There has to be incentive for those already at R2 that doing a good enough job might get them on to a full time show weekday daytime - so anytime from 6am-7pm, those are the slots that are wanted by many.

Granted, not everyone will want that, but I expect that somewhere, there's a few people waiting for Ken Bruce and Steve Wright to retire so that they can have their time in the main roster of presenters.


ReaperCushions

6,039 posts

185 months

Tuesday 18th September 2018
quotequote all
I doubt it will happen, but I think a Radio 2 breakfast show with Moyles and his gang from the late 2000s (Comedy Dave, Dom, Rachel, Tina etc...) would be brilliant. That was a fantastic show back in its heyday.


RJG46

980 posts

69 months

Tuesday 18th September 2018
quotequote all
Shakermaker said:
SpeckledJim said:
kev1974 said:
What I don't understand is, the vast talent pool that organisations like the BBC have to draw on, and yet they keep going back time and time again to the same people like Sara Cox and Zoe Ball.

Of all the local stations they have in their stable (or even the independent locals they could easily poach from), is there really nobody new that they can "promote" up to national level? Or even look to places like the Netherlands where many of their DJs speak perfect English. Either way, give us someone fresh (and presumably far more affordable to the licence fee payers).

Why does the BBC's talent searches only ever seem to have the same six or so people as contenders?
Exactly this. I listen to a BBC local radio station and half of the daytime/drivetime presenters could hold their own on Radio 2, no problem at all. Give them a chance.
I'd suggest this does happen, to a degree. Just it takes longer. Despite being public funded, the people within the organisation themselves will still want to be part of a structure where they can progress upwards. Getting the R2 Breakfast Show is not something that you can just step into from "nowhere" - you'll need to be established within the BBC national network already, which means you may well have worked up the roster from a local station. There has to be incentive for those already at R2 that doing a good enough job might get them on to a full time show weekday daytime - so anytime from 6am-7pm, those are the slots that are wanted by many.

Granted, not everyone will want that, but I expect that somewhere, there's a few people waiting for Ken Bruce and Steve Wright to retire so that they can have their time in the main roster of presenters.
Hardly, Evans got the Radio 1 Breakfast Show following the success of The Big Breakfast on C4. Evans started out in Commercial Radio in Manchester, a fairly short-lived and unsuccessful stint at GLR was his only time at BBC Local Radio.

RJG46

980 posts

69 months

Tuesday 18th September 2018
quotequote all
What happened to the days of Comedians presenting stuff on the radio.

Ricky Gervais/Jimmy Carr at XFM. Adam and Joe/Jon Holmes at 6 Music.



AdeTuono

7,259 posts

228 months

Tuesday 18th September 2018
quotequote all
Shakermaker said:
I expect that somewhere, there's a few people waiting for Ken Bruce and Steve Wright to retire
There are literally millions waiting for Wright to retire. I suspect he's like Her Majesty, and will go on forever. We should be allowed to vote.

Kitchski

6,516 posts

232 months

Tuesday 18th September 2018
quotequote all
RJG46 said:
What happened to the days of Comedians presenting stuff on the radio.

Ricky Gervais/Jimmy Carr at XFM. Adam and Joe/Jon Holmes at 6 Music.
Ellis James and John Robbins, on Radio X as mentioned above. Genuinely funny show!

The Shamewell is brilliant!

RJG46

980 posts

69 months

Tuesday 18th September 2018
quotequote all
Had no idea Jon Holmes had his own Saturday AM show on BBC Radio Kent until a couple of days ago. Supposed to be rather good.