Patrick Stewart to return as Picard

Patrick Stewart to return as Picard

Author
Discussion

Flip Martian

19,723 posts

191 months

Monday 10th February 2020
quotequote all
geeks said:
Guvernator said:
I'm actually enjoying the slow burn build up, think it's setting the tone nicely.

My wife and I both commented the episodes seem too short which is a sign we are enjoying it as we are thirsty for more.

I do have a couple of questions though, how can Rios the pilot afford a warp capable ship which looks pretty advanced? Surely they don't just build\give ships to just anyone, especially someone with a sketchy Starfleet history. Did he buy it? If so how, they don't have money and even if they did, how did Rios get enough to buy a ship.

Secondly how is Picard paying for his services? Again no money in 24th Century? They mention a few times about him not being cheap? How does Picard have money?

That whole find a pilot who just so happens to own a very slick, warp capable ship and is willing to boldly go off into a dangerous adventure at the drop of a hat is a bit "convenient"
I think of it more like this...

They say the goal of man is no longer the accumulation of wealth and while they mention that no one needs money its clear some form of currency is required, Trading with the Ferengi for example requires Latinum. I would imagine there would be a credits based system still required but I can also imagine it not really relating to what we would know as money.

We know little from outside the Federation/races we know in the Trek verse, I can very much imagine there being places one could be less reputable and earn a "living"

Of course, I could be completely wrong but as an example look at Into Darkness with the smuggler ship they seized.
The writers may well use that one day to explain it - in 1 episode "no money is required anymore" but then in another it can be conveniently ignored - it's one of the inconsistencies that gets mentioned quite a lot with the other series

slipstream 1985

12,275 posts

180 months

Monday 10th February 2020
quotequote all
You are all forgetting TNG episodes were about the same length just they would start at 17:03 then 3 breaks of 4 mins and a break to the next program at the end.

They have built a decent base of stories to be explained.

The synthetics
The borg
The romulan connection
B4 also what happened to Lore Datas brother is he involved with this?

Plenty of other stories to develop as well how are the Klingon empire getting on

"Engage" was a nice cheesey practically looking at the camera line but it works.

Flip Martian

19,723 posts

191 months

Monday 10th February 2020
quotequote all
Lore was deactivated and dismantled in TNG though. Unless they invent something suitably convoluted, that would have been that.

Civpilot

6,235 posts

241 months

Monday 10th February 2020
quotequote all
Flip Martian said:
geeks said:
Guvernator said:
I'm actually enjoying the slow burn build up, think it's setting the tone nicely.

My wife and I both commented the episodes seem too short which is a sign we are enjoying it as we are thirsty for more.

I do have a couple of questions though, how can Rios the pilot afford a warp capable ship which looks pretty advanced? Surely they don't just build\give ships to just anyone, especially someone with a sketchy Starfleet history. Did he buy it? If so how, they don't have money and even if they did, how did Rios get enough to buy a ship.

Secondly how is Picard paying for his services? Again no money in 24th Century? They mention a few times about him not being cheap? How does Picard have money?

That whole find a pilot who just so happens to own a very slick, warp capable ship and is willing to boldly go off into a dangerous adventure at the drop of a hat is a bit "convenient"
I think of it more like this...

They say the goal of man is no longer the accumulation of wealth and while they mention that no one needs money its clear some form of currency is required, Trading with the Ferengi for example requires Latinum. I would imagine there would be a credits based system still required but I can also imagine it not really relating to what we would know as money.

We know little from outside the Federation/races we know in the Trek verse, I can very much imagine there being places one could be less reputable and earn a "living"

Of course, I could be completely wrong but as an example look at Into Darkness with the smuggler ship they seized.
The writers may well use that one day to explain it - in 1 episode "no money is required anymore" but then in another it can be conveniently ignored - it's one of the inconsistencies that gets mentioned quite a lot with the other series
I always thought the whole 'no money' thing only really applied to Star Fleet and crew members (almost like a Future Army/Navy thing, yes they get paid, but they are not really in it for the money).

Obviously money exists and is still used otherwise how would Picard afford to run the vineyards? How would people pay for his wine? Or Sisko's Dad be able to afford to run the Earth based restaurant in DS9? not like he gives free meals away to everyone.

FourWheelDrift

88,615 posts

285 months

Monday 10th February 2020
quotequote all
No money, all transactions are done by sexual favours.

vxr8mate

1,655 posts

190 months

Monday 10th February 2020
quotequote all
I seem to recall the Ferrengi traded with pressed latinum ...or sexual favours.

Civpilot

6,235 posts

241 months

Monday 10th February 2020
quotequote all
FourWheelDrift said:
No money, all transactions are done by sexual favours.
No wonder Ben Sisko's Dad is so upbeat all the time... his restaurant always seems busy laugh

Guvernator

13,170 posts

166 months

Monday 10th February 2020
quotequote all
DS9 is sort of a special case as it's basically a border frontier trading post so they use money for some things. In fact I think they mention this a few times in DS9. I'm pretty sure Sisko gets into a few arguments
with the Ferengi over the use of money initially but comes round to the idea.

I don't think it's representative of what the rest of the Federation do which is pretty much no money. However like with a lot of things in ST, while the basic premise sounds good, it's very wishy washy when you get into the nuts and bolts of it. How do you convince Stan the toilet cleaner that he's not going to get paid anything but he is "bettering himself" when he's unblocking Worf's toilet for the third time in a week.

sparks_190e

Original Poster:

12,738 posts

214 months

Monday 10th February 2020
quotequote all
Civpilot said:
FourWheelDrift said:
No money, all transactions are done by sexual favours.
No wonder Ben Sisko's Dad is so upbeat all the time... his restaurant always seems busy laugh
I loved the restaurant episodes, basically anything showing civilians.. the height of 90's fashion in the late 23rd century! Ben's son Jake was especially guilty


slipstream 1985

12,275 posts

180 months

Monday 10th February 2020
quotequote all
Guvernator said:
DS9 is sort of a special case as it's basically a border frontier trading post so they use money for some things. In fact I think they mention this a few times in DS9. I'm pretty sure Sisko gets into a few arguments
with the Ferengi over the use of money initially but comes round to the idea.

I don't think it's representative of what the rest of the Federation do which is pretty much no money. However like with a lot of things in ST, while the basic premise sounds good, it's very wishy washy when you get into the nuts and bolts of it. How do you convince Stan the toilet cleaner that he's not going to get paid anything but he is "bettering himself" when he's unblocking Worf's toilet for the third time in a week.
The idea is that humanity has bettred themselves and no longer chase monetary things. everyone has clean living quarters replicators to provide anything you need.

I imagine most undesirable jobs have been automated or just engineered out of society.
The federation maybe is Socialism in it's truest form?

carl_w

9,202 posts

259 months

Monday 10th February 2020
quotequote all
slipstream 1985 said:
The idea is that humanity has bettred themselves and no longer chase monetary things. everyone has clean living quarters replicators to provide anything you need.

I imagine most undesirable jobs have been automated or just engineered out of society.
The federation maybe is Socialism in it's truest form?
So anyone who fancies some of JL's wine can just teleport over and help themselves?

slipstream 1985

12,275 posts

180 months

Monday 10th February 2020
quotequote all
carl_w said:
slipstream 1985 said:
The idea is that humanity has bettred themselves and no longer chase monetary things. everyone has clean living quarters replicators to provide anything you need.

I imagine most undesirable jobs have been automated or just engineered out of society.
The federation maybe is Socialism in it's truest form?
So anyone who fancies some of JL's wine can just teleport over and help themselves?
I'm also assuming there are no "have nots" in society and zero theft.

I imagine the federation future is one when the annual purge of the poor has has the effect of wiping out the poor biggrin

kowalski655

14,681 posts

144 months

Monday 10th February 2020
quotequote all
Guvernator said:
I was shocked to learn Jeri Ryan who plays 7 of 9 is 51 now! From the trailers she still looks good but that was a bit of a blow tbh.
Hoping you hd a chance?smile
slipstream 1985 said:
..
The federation maybe is Socialism in it's truest form?
Started by President Sanders in 2021 biggrin

carl_w

9,202 posts

259 months

Monday 10th February 2020
quotequote all
slipstream 1985 said:
I'm also assuming there are no "have nots" in society and zero theft.

I imagine the federation future is one when the annual purge of the poor has has the effect of wiping out the poor biggrin
I'm not saying that.

JL's vineyard has a fixed output. If the whole of the Federation wants a bottle most of them are going to be disappointed.

Normally that would be solved by setting a price where supply meets demand.

slipstream 1985

12,275 posts

180 months

Monday 10th February 2020
quotequote all
carl_w said:
slipstream 1985 said:
I'm also assuming there are no "have nots" in society and zero theft.

I imagine the federation future is one when the annual purge of the poor has has the effect of wiping out the poor biggrin
I'm not saying that.

JL's vineyard has a fixed output. If the whole of the Federation wants a bottle most of them are going to be disappointed.

Normally that would be solved by setting a price where supply meets demand.
I know what you meant. I'm guessing everyone is so honest they dont beam in and steal a bottle just accept that if they get a bottle as a gift good otherwise no worries about having a repliated substitute not quite as good but good enough.

carl_w

9,202 posts

259 months

Monday 10th February 2020
quotequote all
slipstream 1985 said:
I know what you meant. I'm guessing everyone is so honest they dont beam in and steal a bottle just accept that if they get a bottle as a gift good otherwise no worries about having a repliated substitute not quite as good but good enough.
That raises the opposite problem. There are only so many bottles he can gift and he has to get rid of the output or store it.

cologne2792

2,128 posts

127 months

Monday 10th February 2020
quotequote all
Although at the mention of impending retirement, Montgomery Scott said,
" Suits me. I've just bought a boat "

Guvernator

13,170 posts

166 months

Monday 10th February 2020
quotequote all
I think it was one of those cool ideas that Rodenberry had which is theoretically possible in a post scarcity, utopian society but the practical aspects of it don't really work.

AlexC1981

4,932 posts

218 months

Monday 10th February 2020
quotequote all
It's one of those things us Star Trek fans have to not think too closely about. Like how the universal translator manages to perfectly sync up with the lip movements of the person speaking, even though they are speaking in a different language.

james_TW

16,287 posts

198 months

Tuesday 11th February 2020
quotequote all
I'm caught up... I enjoyed that, I figured that was Hugh before the name drop, but I'm enjoying the story development so far smile

Oh and I got goosebumps over the TNG music biggrin