Is this the last tory government

Is this the last tory government

Author
Discussion

Halb

53,012 posts

184 months

Thursday 14th February 2019
quotequote all
Anna SOurbry on NN now, mentioned a colleague of hers has been threatened wit de-selection because they voted for the PMs deal. Talking about a 'purple' wave in the Tory party.

JagLover

42,524 posts

236 months

Friday 15th February 2019
quotequote all
Halb said:
Anna SOurbry on NN now, mentioned a colleague of hers has been threatened wit de-selection because they voted for the PMs deal. Talking about a 'purple' wave in the Tory party.
Or rather a "blue" wave as the membership is far more Eurosceptic than MPs.

Add on to that that many MPs, like Boles, have their main home in London and occasional, and reluctantly, visit the "provinces" and you often have a chasm between the views of MPs and members.

FiF

44,233 posts

252 months

Friday 15th February 2019
quotequote all
This pretty much articulates my views on where the opportunity for any new party lies.

Sorry it's a Twitter video but go with it.

The YouGov report which provides a background is here

Personally suspect that it would be economically extremely difficult to meet all the aspirations contained within the views expressed, which partly explains the never ending battles between the main parties, thus it ever was. However it's a decent starting point.

JagLover

42,524 posts

236 months

Friday 15th February 2019
quotequote all
FiF said:
This pretty much articulates my views on where the opportunity for any new party lies.

Sorry it's a Twitter video but go with it.

The YouGov report which provides a background is here

Personally suspect that it would be economically extremely difficult to meet all the aspirations contained within the views expressed, which partly explains the never ending battles between the main parties, thus it ever was. However it's a decent starting point.
All parties under FPTP represent coalitions of different interests. If they are smart pro-business politicians will realise that they are currently alienating their natural supporters through presenting them with a choice between business and the preservation of their way of life. There needs to be a grand bargain, capitalism with constraints, that can unite enough centrist and right wing voters to produce a governing coalition.

The only way I can see this happening at present is if the Tories split, but perhaps I will be proved wrong.

FiF

44,233 posts

252 months

Saturday 16th February 2019
quotequote all
Btw does anyone have any sympathy for Soubry complaining about new members joining constituency associations and the risk of deselection?

It's hard to watch this cluster feck which has been made so difficult by the extreme elements at both ends of the spectrum. The 80% sensible people in the middle (made up statistic) just want to do what is best in line with a democratic decision and prepared to make the compromises to allow that to happen.

Frankly I agree with her, shock horror, that the Conservative party is utterly broken. So is Labour. In fact predicting what Parliament is going to do next would be easier if the HoC were occupied by 600 plus orangutans.

bitchstewie

51,643 posts

211 months

Saturday 16th February 2019
quotequote all
Maybe sympathy is too strong a word but I think you have to question the idea that 80 people of any political persuasion can simply rock up at a constituency party meeting and pay their membership fees and work to get an MP deselected where the constituency may be entirely supportive of that MP's work.

But I guess at that point you also question the party rules that allow that to happen.

Fittster

20,120 posts

214 months

Saturday 16th February 2019
quotequote all
Has anyone found the rules about deselection? I thought the conclusion that you can join the party for £25 and then vote to deselect the MP has rather optimistic.

amusingduck

9,398 posts

137 months

Saturday 16th February 2019
quotequote all
Fittster said:
Has anyone found the rules about deselection? I thought the conclusion that you can join the party for £25 and then vote to deselect the MP has rather optimistic.
Seems like this

Guardian said:
A Conservative MP who wants to be readopted as their party’s official candidate has to make a formal application well before an election. If he or she then fails to secure the backing of the executive council of the local party, which holds a vote, the sitting MP has the right to call a full postal ballot of all members of the local party. If the candidate does not secure the support of a majority of those members, he or she is deselected. Deselections are rare because Conservative MPs are normally assiduous at cultivating local support, though divisions over Brexit have created new tensions in some constituencies.
I hope Soubry gets deselected, she's ripe for it. Same for anyone who stood under the Conservative manifesto and subsequently tried to overturn the referendum - especially those in Leave constituencies.

turbobloke

104,154 posts

261 months

Saturday 16th February 2019
quotequote all
Possibly a pearoast as this is from 12 feb but based on those beloved/cursed polls, there would be another Conservative government if a general election was held. Not a minority gov't either..

iNews said:
General election poll says Tories would win with an incredibly slim majority The poll of more than 40,000 people was based on the only model to accurately predict the 2017 election result.
https://inews.co.uk/news/politics/general-election-poll-uk-next-prediction-results-tories-majority-labour/

The last Conservative government? Not likely, and not just because of the above cursed/blessed poll.

Robertj21a

16,485 posts

106 months

Saturday 16th February 2019
quotequote all
amusingduck said:
I hope Soubry gets deselected, she's ripe for it. Same for anyone who stood under the Conservative manifesto and subsequently tried to overturn the referendum - especially those in Leave constituencies.
Yes, Soubry needs to go. She could be a right pain before Brexit so she's now way overdue.

.

bitchstewie

51,643 posts

211 months

Saturday 16th February 2019
quotequote all
How about letting her constituency decide? "Will of the people" and all that? scratchchin

Robertj21a

16,485 posts

106 months

Saturday 16th February 2019
quotequote all
bhstewie said:
How about letting her constituency decide? "Will of the people" and all that? scratchchin
She could always stand as an Independent if she honestly believes that her electorate want her to continue. Nothing like some voting results to give her a good kicking.

.

bitchstewie

51,643 posts

211 months

Saturday 16th February 2019
quotequote all
Of course she can, and if she did and got trounced I'd have absolutely zero issue with that.

Fittster

20,120 posts

214 months

Saturday 16th February 2019
quotequote all
The trouble with party members deselecting MPs is that its easy to see it being manipulated. How long before lots of new members join North East Somerset to remove JRM, purely for the fun of it.

You'd end up with a situation where no MP gets to stand twice and the candidates are jokes to annoy the parties natural supporters.

eccles

13,745 posts

223 months

Saturday 16th February 2019
quotequote all
Fittster said:
The trouble with party members deselecting MPs is that its easy to see it being manipulated. How long before lots of new members join North East Somerset to remove JRM, purely for the fun of it.
It's been much the same in the Labour party. All those new Momentum supporting members voting off the old guard who don't fit the bill.

Halb

53,012 posts

184 months

Saturday 16th February 2019
quotequote all
Fittster said:
The trouble with party members deselecting MPs is that its easy to see it being manipulated. How long before lots of new members join North East Somerset to remove JRM, purely for the fun of it.

You'd end up with a situation where no MP gets to stand twice and the candidates are jokes to annoy the parties natural supporters.
A few safeguards could be put in place.
I'm not a an of gangparty [olitics as it is though.
Power to the people! biggrin

JagLover

42,524 posts

236 months

Sunday 17th February 2019
quotequote all
Fittster said:
The trouble with party members deselecting MPs is that its easy to see it being manipulated. How long before lots of new members join North East Somerset to remove JRM, purely for the fun of it.

You'd end up with a situation where no MP gets to stand twice and the candidates are jokes to annoy the parties natural supporters.
But in practice it rarely happens.

Boles is in trouble but he is both a leading figure in trying to derail Brexit, in a leave constituency, and was poorly regarded locally before that. He has such poor local roots that members of his constituency association were complaining they had never met his partner.

When we do have MPs being deselected for frivolous reasons that is the time to worry.

Talksteer

4,915 posts

234 months

Monday 18th February 2019
quotequote all
eccles said:
Fittster said:
The trouble with party members deselecting MPs is that its easy to see it being manipulated. How long before lots of new members join North East Somerset to remove JRM, purely for the fun of it.
It's been much the same in the Labour party. All those new Momentum supporting members voting off the old guard who don't fit the bill.
The result is polarisation and and even greater difficulties in getting anything done.

Current system is broken as representative government, FPTP and no written constitution are fundamentally incompatible with referendums.



FiF

44,233 posts

252 months

Tuesday 19th February 2019
quotequote all
Snap poll, usual caveats apply about polls, especially a snap poll like this but....

So the Lib Dems would lose an election to a party that doesn't actually exist. rofl


powerstroke

Original Poster:

10,283 posts

161 months

Tuesday 26th February 2019
quotequote all
So stupid woman is being bullied into taking the chance of a deal off the table by her own side ....