Dyson job losses

Author
Discussion

So

26,295 posts

223 months

Thursday 24th January 2019
quotequote all
PorkInsider said:
Troubleatmill said:
SeeFive said:
Park life.
That deserves a clap
I think that pretty well sums up many Brexiteers’ response to any questioning around the sanity of what we’re heading into.

It’s treated as if it were a football match: all that matters is who won.
That also deserves a clap

esxste

3,684 posts

107 months

Thursday 24th January 2019
quotequote all
PorkInsider said:
I think that pretty well sums up many Brexiteers’ response to any questioning around the sanity of what we’re heading into.

It’s treated as if it were a football match: all that matters is who won.
Or they're not quite ready to grasp that all the things that were promised won't be delivered.




NormalWisdom

2,139 posts

160 months

Thursday 24th January 2019
quotequote all
SeeFive said:
cardigankid said:
A lot of very well reasoned argument
Epitomised the mess this country is in

Piha

7,150 posts

93 months

Thursday 24th January 2019
quotequote all
cardigankid said:
Tuna - the hypocrisy is hilarious but not the way you portray it, as was stated earlier.

The problem I have with James Dyson is not that he is taking his company to Singapore, it is that he took a public position supporting Brexit which is in effect saying Britain should go it alone internationally, and now it appears he thinks that we should go it alone without him.

I can’t say that I like Dyson much. I don’t buy the genius inventor shtick. I think that he is the latest in a long line of people who have ‘invented a fantastic new vacuum cleaner’ that everyone has to have. It’s not the first time and it won’t be the last, and in the end there are more important things in the world than vacuum cleaners. The difference with Dyson is that he has spun a brand round himself while hiring bright young people to do the actual work. What is the result? A vacuum cleaner, a hand drier and yet another person who is going to develop a wonderful electric car. Let me make a prediction. The new car will never happen unless some major industrial is prepared to do it for him and stick Dyson's name on the front. Maybe that is why he is going to Singapore, and in any case Singapore is welcome to him. He is just going to let people down, like all snake oil salesmen, and the sooner it happens and we deal with it the better.

So far as Brexit is concerned, he is just one of a number of prominent people who have political friends among the Brexiteers who was persuaded to throw his weight behind the bandwagon, in return for some payback we will find out about in due course. Neither he nor they offered any rational argument for it nor stuck around to deal with the problems but they managed to get a majority.

It will not surprise anyone that I voted remain. I did so because while the EU is far from perfect it is a relatively efficient trading group centred on the most efficient industrial machine in the world, I.e. Germany. It will succeed provided and to the extent that the other members move towards the German way of doing things. Because of our EU membership we have had inward investment which would never have happened otherwise, not least in the car industry which would not exist otherwise and is now heading back in that direction. We have got access to young people from Eastern Europe who are prepared to do the jobs which our young people won’t because we have proudly sent them all to University to study graphic design or stand-up comedy and they now think manual work is beneath them. I wish some Brexiteer would stand up and offer some rational explanation of how this shambles is going to work out in our favour, without raving on about the death of democracy, a concept which is not going to mean a hell of a lot when the day comes when we have nothing to eat. How for example the Irish border is going to be sorted. Who is going to staff our hotels. Who is going to drive our car industry forward often at a loss, when the Germans have given us up as a bad job and gone home.

Who voted for this? I see no reason to blame other than a class of obtuse short sighted isolationists suffering from their remaining delusions of grandeur. The UK is now an international joke. We have a government which with its supporters, for obscure reasons probably related to personal greed has led us into utter chaos with no solutions, strategic or tactical concept of how to deal with the situation. We have a Prime Minister who is unable to achieve consensus on anything, or even govern the country. Despite having a large number of talented and creative individuals Britain is utterly lacking in the financial muscle, depth of experience, drive and discipline to succeed in world markets. We are a country with an ageing population, an aversion to hard work, a culture of selling out rather than building up, governed by an Oxbridge led class of bureaucrats who still think that they are (and are capable of) running an empire, and would stamp out any spark of inconvenient entrepreneurship which threatened their ivory tower. James Dyson is just another rat leaving the ship and the least of your concerns.
What a very good post and accurately reflects my own opinion!

bow

samsock

234 posts

67 months

Thursday 24th January 2019
quotequote all
The real news for me, is not the move of the HQ alone, but the timing of the move, and the direction of travel.

Maybe at one point Dyson beleived in some form of Brexit, but now we have a clearer picture, it is very obvious he doesn't like what he sees.

And obviously, only 2 staff are moving now, but I doubt he is going to invest another penny in the UK and headcount will inevitably drop in Wiltshire over the years, slowly, then quickly.

So all in all a massive blow to the leavers cause. Really hard to spin this into a neutral, but bravo to those who are trying.

bitchstewie

51,311 posts

211 months

Thursday 24th January 2019
quotequote all
samsock said:
The real news for me, is not the move of the HQ alone, but the timing of the move, and the direction of travel.

Maybe at one point Dyson beleived in some form of Brexit, but now we have a clearer picture, it is very obvious he doesn't like what he sees.

And obviously, only 2 staff are moving now, but I doubt he is going to invest another penny in the UK and headcount will inevitably drop in Wiltshire over the years, slowly, then quickly.

So all in all a massive blow to the leavers cause. Really hard to spin this into a neutral, but bravo to those who are trying.
Kind of how I see it too.

I wouldn't necessarily paint it as doom and gloom but it's most odd reading pages of people trying to say it doesn't matter and it's fine etc.

otis criblecoblis

1,078 posts

67 months

Thursday 24th January 2019
quotequote all
zygalski said:
otis criblecoblis said:
I was more wonder what the hell it meant , hence asking the significance of any of them.
No, not required to post here, but I do enjoy asking the dolt end of Remain here some questions and to see if they have the slightest clue on what they are on about. This being a classic gibberish post that only appeals to the shallow.
Since you are keen to add your 2p worth, why don't you have ago and explain what you took from it ?
Meh.
You probably think Brexit's going really well.
Good for you. Perhaps you'll follow Dyson's lead & leave the country now the damage is done?
Nice ! Remainer loon wants me to leave the country because I wonder what the hell is meant if Mogg opens a fund, and the children of an MEP have a passport of the birth country of their mother.
Scratch the surface, and the Corbyn/Momentum type hate exposes itself.



Dindoit

1,645 posts

95 months

Thursday 24th January 2019
quotequote all
otis criblecoblis said:
I wonder what the hell is meant if Mogg opens a fund, and the children of an MEP have a passport of the birth country of their mother.
I’ll spell it out for you. The loudest Brexit voices told you how great the country is, how strong the country is and how being here is the best thing in the whole world. We’ve got our country back!

Then it transpires they’re going to move to Monaco (Ratcliffe) and France (Lawson) or locate their business interests in Ireland (Mogg) and Singapore (Dyson) or get their children passports in Germany (Farage). Do as I say, not as I do.

Mogg’s Icav for example is set up in Dublin so that it can service clients in the EU. Feel free to shout dolt and non-story all you like but if you can’t or won’t see how this is a conflict of interests then I’m afraid I can’t help you.

Tuna

19,930 posts

285 months

Thursday 24th January 2019
quotequote all
cardigankid said:
Tuna - the hypocrisy is hilarious but not the way you portray it, as was stated earlier.

The problem I have with James Dyson is not that he is taking his company to Singapore, it is that he took a public position supporting Brexit which is in effect saying Britain should go it alone internationally, and now it appears he thinks that we should go it alone without him.

I can’t say that I like Dyson much. I don’t buy the genius inventor shtick. I think that he is the latest in a long line of people who have ‘invented a fantastic new vacuum cleaner’ that everyone has to have. It’s not the first time and it won’t be the last, and in the end there are more important things in the world than vacuum cleaners. The difference with Dyson is that he has spun a brand round himself while hiring bright young people to do the actual work. What is the result? A vacuum cleaner, a hand drier and yet another person who is going to develop a wonderful electric car. Let me make a prediction. The new car will never happen unless some major industrial is prepared to do it for him and stick Dyson's name on the front. Maybe that is why he is going to Singapore, and in any case Singapore is welcome to him. He is just going to let people down, like all snake oil salesmen, and the sooner it happens and we deal with it the better.

So far as Brexit is concerned, he is just one of a number of prominent people who have political friends among the Brexiteers who was persuaded to throw his weight behind the bandwagon, in return for some payback we will find out about in due course. Neither he nor they offered any rational argument for it nor stuck around to deal with the problems but they managed to get a majority.

It will not surprise anyone that I voted remain. I did so because while the EU is far from perfect it is a relatively efficient trading group centred on the most efficient industrial machine in the world, I.e. Germany. It will succeed provided and to the extent that the other members move towards the German way of doing things. Because of our EU membership we have had inward investment which would never have happened otherwise, not least in the car industry which would not exist otherwise and is now heading back in that direction. We have got access to young people from Eastern Europe who are prepared to do the jobs which our young people won’t because we have proudly sent them all to University to study graphic design or stand-up comedy and they now think manual work is beneath them. I wish some Brexiteer would stand up and offer some rational explanation of how this shambles is going to work out in our favour, without raving on about the death of democracy, a concept which is not going to mean a hell of a lot when the day comes when we have nothing to eat. How for example the Irish border is going to be sorted. Who is going to staff our hotels. Who is going to drive our car industry forward often at a loss, when the Germans have given us up as a bad job and gone home.

Who voted for this? I see no reason to blame other than a class of obtuse short sighted isolationists suffering from their remaining delusions of grandeur. The UK is now an international joke. We have a government which with its supporters, for obscure reasons probably related to personal greed has led us into utter chaos with no solutions, strategic or tactical concept of how to deal with the situation. We have a Prime Minister who is unable to achieve consensus on anything, or even govern the country. Despite having a large number of talented and creative individuals Britain is utterly lacking in the financial muscle, depth of experience, drive and discipline to succeed in world markets. We are a country with an ageing population, an aversion to hard work, a culture of selling out rather than building up, governed by an Oxbridge led class of bureaucrats who still think that they are (and are capable of) running an empire, and would stamp out any spark of inconvenient entrepreneurship which threatened their ivory tower. James Dyson is just another rat leaving the ship and the least of your concerns.
Not sure where to start on that one. Hope you feel better having let it all out though.

The list of points where I fundamentally disagree with you is so long it's hardly worth even starting. I don't know if you're involved in tech innovation in any way, but your comments suggest you really don't understand the UK environment at all. I think you have next to no knowledge of what Dyson actually does, or how he got to a billion pounds a year earnings. I think you don't understand how we work in world markets. I think you dismiss anyone or anything you don't understand.

But I've quoted your post to see how accurate some of your beliefs turn out to be.

(Should've just gone with 'Parklife' - that made me laugh - sorry).

loughran

2,749 posts

137 months

Thursday 24th January 2019
quotequote all
Could you tell me what Dyson does to generate a billion pound income if it’s not from vacuum cleaners, hand and hair dryers ?

toppstuff

13,698 posts

248 months

Thursday 24th January 2019
quotequote all
Piha said:
cardigankid said:
Tuna - the hypocrisy is hilarious but not the way you portray it, as was stated earlier.

The problem I have with James Dyson is not that he is taking his company to Singapore, it is that he took a public position supporting Brexit which is in effect saying Britain should go it alone internationally, and now it appears he thinks that we should go it alone without him.

I can’t say that I like Dyson much. I don’t buy the genius inventor shtick. I think that he is the latest in a long line of people who have ‘invented a fantastic new vacuum cleaner’ that everyone has to have. It’s not the first time and it won’t be the last, and in the end there are more important things in the world than vacuum cleaners. The difference with Dyson is that he has spun a brand round himself while hiring bright young people to do the actual work. What is the result? A vacuum cleaner, a hand drier and yet another person who is going to develop a wonderful electric car. Let me make a prediction. The new car will never happen unless some major industrial is prepared to do it for him and stick Dyson's name on the front. Maybe that is why he is going to Singapore, and in any case Singapore is welcome to him. He is just going to let people down, like all snake oil salesmen, and the sooner it happens and we deal with it the better.

So far as Brexit is concerned, he is just one of a number of prominent people who have political friends among the Brexiteers who was persuaded to throw his weight behind the bandwagon, in return for some payback we will find out about in due course. Neither he nor they offered any rational argument for it nor stuck around to deal with the problems but they managed to get a majority.

It will not surprise anyone that I voted remain. I did so because while the EU is far from perfect it is a relatively efficient trading group centred on the most efficient industrial machine in the world, I.e. Germany. It will succeed provided and to the extent that the other members move towards the German way of doing things. Because of our EU membership we have had inward investment which would never have happened otherwise, not least in the car industry which would not exist otherwise and is now heading back in that direction. We have got access to young people from Eastern Europe who are prepared to do the jobs which our young people won’t because we have proudly sent them all to University to study graphic design or stand-up comedy and they now think manual work is beneath them. I wish some Brexiteer would stand up and offer some rational explanation of how this shambles is going to work out in our favour, without raving on about the death of democracy, a concept which is not going to mean a hell of a lot when the day comes when we have nothing to eat. How for example the Irish border is going to be sorted. Who is going to staff our hotels. Who is going to drive our car industry forward often at a loss, when the Germans have given us up as a bad job and gone home.

Who voted for this? I see no reason to blame other than a class of obtuse short sighted isolationists suffering from their remaining delusions of grandeur. The UK is now an international joke. We have a government which with its supporters, for obscure reasons probably related to personal greed has led us into utter chaos with no solutions, strategic or tactical concept of how to deal with the situation. We have a Prime Minister who is unable to achieve consensus on anything, or even govern the country. Despite having a large number of talented and creative individuals Britain is utterly lacking in the financial muscle, depth of experience, drive and discipline to succeed in world markets. We are a country with an ageing population, an aversion to hard work, a culture of selling out rather than building up, governed by an Oxbridge led class of bureaucrats who still think that they are (and are capable of) running an empire, and would stamp out any spark of inconvenient entrepreneurship which threatened their ivory tower. James Dyson is just another rat leaving the ship and the least of your concerns.
What a very good post and accurately reflects my own opinion!

bow
Plus 1.

Good stuff.

chunder27

2,309 posts

209 months

Thursday 24th January 2019
quotequote all
All Dyson has done is what most manufacturers did years ago.

Moved the so called unskilled aspect of his company to a cheap labour site as he feels it is unnecessary to pay 10ph for production when in his mind you can get the same for 3.

He was late doing it.

Most industry did it years ago and some are bringing it back because it is not made as well as it could be, note Merc quality when they moved decades ago, PCB manufacture in some countries and various other ways in which people abroad.

I can give you a perfect example. I worked for a relatively small manufacturer of sound equipment, we bought a similar size company abroad who made very high quality similar equipment on a similar scale. Things went well, quality remained the same, output increased slightly due to more staff as production was moved from there to here.

American multinational buys us, output is put from a few a month to tens, parts are bought cheaper raw material quality is lowered for increased profit, stuff is bundled out the door, quality suffers, plant is closed down and moved to Romania, quality suffers yet more, R&D stays here. We all get laid off.

This is how it works, accountant and money savers run companies, not real men. So this is why this happens.

Germany are not the biggest industrial nation in Europe because they are better, they simply invested in their industry and allowed it to flourish after the war, just like Japan.

We allowed ours to be broken up by unions and government.

andymadmak

14,596 posts

271 months

Thursday 24th January 2019
quotequote all
Piha said:
cardigankid said:
T James Dyson is just another rat leaving the ship
What a very good post and accurately reflects my own opinion!
Well, the post is an interpretation of events. You agree with it. That's fine. I'm less inclined to believe it. Who knows, maybe none/some/all of the assertions are correct.
But the underlying assertion that Dyson is leaving (all two people) because Brexit surely does not stand up to any reasonable scrutiny...
For a start, if Brexit was the cause why not move those two people to somewhere in the EU?
Secondly, is it not also possible that one factor might be that with Remainers having so comprehensively screwed up Brexit Dyson might be thinking that the advantages of a full Brexit are no longer available to the UK, and thus relocating to Singapore makes more sense?

bitchstewie

51,311 posts

211 months

Thursday 24th January 2019
quotequote all
andymadmak said:
Well, the post is an interpretation of events. You agree with it. That's fine. I'm less inclined to believe it. Who knows, maybe none/some/all of the assertions are correct.
But the underlying assertion that Dyson is leaving (all two people) because Brexit surely does not stand up to any reasonable scrutiny...
For a start, if Brexit was the cause why not move those two people to somewhere in the EU?
Secondly, is it not also possible that one factor might be that with Remainers having so comprehensively screwed up Brexit Dyson might be thinking that the advantages of a full Brexit are no longer available to the UK, and thus relocating to Singapore makes more sense?
Panasonic and Sony relocated to the EU and we were told it wasn't due to Brexit even though both said it was.

And now Dyson has moved because of remainers.

Brilliant.

andymadmak

14,596 posts

271 months

Thursday 24th January 2019
quotequote all
bhstewie said:
Panasonic and Sony relocated to the EU and we were told it wasn't due to Brexit even though both said it was.

And now Dyson has moved because of remainers.

Brilliant.
Thank you for confirming my point

Vaud

50,572 posts

156 months

Thursday 24th January 2019
quotequote all
chunder27 said:
All Dyson has done is what most manufacturers did years ago.

Moved the so called unskilled aspect of his company to a cheap labour site as he feels it is unnecessary to pay 10ph for production when in his mind you can get the same for 3.
Singapore is not cheap manufacturing... look at the costs of living and now they have minimum wage rolling out... It is high in productivity, has good infrastructure, education and is good for attracting talent from the APAC region as it's a pretty nice place to be (with families, etc)

It is decreasingly competitive on raw cost (source: Deloitte) but increasingly competitive on higher value skills, like design, systems engineering and integration, coding, etc.

Piha

7,150 posts

93 months

Thursday 24th January 2019
quotequote all
andymadmak said:
Well, the post is an interpretation of events. You agree with it. That's fine. I'm less inclined to believe it. Who knows, maybe none/some/all of the assertions are correct.
But the underlying assertion that Dyson is leaving (all two people) because Brexit surely does not stand up to any reasonable scrutiny...
For a start, if Brexit was the cause why not move those two people to somewhere in the EU?
Secondly, is it not also possible that one factor might be that with Remainers having so comprehensively screwed up Brexit Dyson might be thinking that the advantages of a full Brexit are no longer available to the UK, and thus relocating to Singapore makes more sense?
Maybe Jimmy D is moving because he demanded the UK join the Euro and he didn't get what he wanted?

Davos123

5,966 posts

213 months

Thursday 24th January 2019
quotequote all
chunder27 said:
This is how it works, accountant and money savers run companies, not real men
Maybe we should let some women have a go?

andymadmak

14,596 posts

271 months

Thursday 24th January 2019
quotequote all
Piha said:
Maybe Jimmy D is moving because he demanded the UK join the Euro and he didn't get what he wanted?
So why not move to a Eurozone country?

anonymous-user

55 months

Thursday 24th January 2019
quotequote all
otis criblecoblis said:
zygalski said:
otis criblecoblis said:
I was more wonder what the hell it meant , hence asking the significance of any of them.
No, not required to post here, but I do enjoy asking the dolt end of Remain here some questions and to see if they have the slightest clue on what they are on about. This being a classic gibberish post that only appeals to the shallow.
Since you are keen to add your 2p worth, why don't you have ago and explain what you took from it ?
Meh.
You probably think Brexit's going really well.
Good for you. Perhaps you'll follow Dyson's lead & leave the country now the damage is done?
Nice ! Remainer loon wants me to leave the country because I wonder what the hell is meant if Mogg opens a fund, and the children of an MEP have a passport of the birth country of their mother.
Scratch the surface, and the Corbyn/Momentum type hate exposes itself.
You forgot to call him a dolt.