Scottish Referendum / Independence - Vol 9

Scottish Referendum / Independence - Vol 9

TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED
Author
Discussion

biggbn

23,588 posts

221 months

Thursday 9th July 2020
quotequote all
hutchst said:
Tories are Conservative politicians or occasionally, in a wider context, party members, across the UK.

Toarees are mythical bogeymen that exist in tbe minds of some Scottish politians, traditionally believed to inhabit a mythical faraway land called Westminster.
Agreed. It is a misappropriation of language, but why play their game. Debate like adults and make them look like the immature ones

glazbagun

14,284 posts

198 months

Thursday 9th July 2020
quotequote all
biggbn said:
Perfectly valid point, I'm no fan of divisiveness either way and cannot deny that both accent and vocabulary is rich and diverse north of the border...as it is the world over. I'm no fan of SNP or Sturgeon and only raised the point for the reasons I give...and posted an apology for my tone. If you, or anyone else wish to still use this caricatured Scot's language, crack on. Your prerogative. For me it diminishes the impact of what you are saying and destroys credibility, but, each to their own. Freedom of speech and freedom of expression does not mean freedom from consequence, the consequence being excellent argumentative points are lost in the lazy caricaturing. Easy to hit an open goal.

I dont want to cause disharmony, I would not poke fun at another's accent, but, each to their own. To clarify, I agree with you about the bdisation of the word tory by some SNP to reconfigure it as a catch all for all that's wrong in their world. But to sink to that level of debate is only engaging on their terms. Sun Tzu would have something to say about that!!
I generally agree with all of that.

DuncsGTi

1,153 posts

180 months

Thursday 9th July 2020
quotequote all
ant1973 said:
She doesn't care. No evidence that anyone is moving to England. I am not remotely convinced she wants indy; why bother when she has power without responsibility. We need to pray for a split in the indy vote.
Anecdotal I know, when I moved back to the UK in June 2014 I discounted buying a house in Scotland solely because of the risk of a yes vote destroying the Scottish economy and housing market.

biggbn

23,588 posts

221 months

Thursday 9th July 2020
quotequote all
glazbagun said:
biggbn said:
Perfectly valid point, I'm no fan of divisiveness either way and cannot deny that both accent and vocabulary is rich and diverse north of the border...as it is the world over. I'm no fan of SNP or Sturgeon and only raised the point for the reasons I gave...and posted an apology for my tone. If you, or anyone else wish to still use this caricatured Scot's language, crack on. Your prerogative. For me it diminishes the impact of what you are saying and destroys credibility, but, each to their own. Freedom of speech and freedom of expression does not mean freedom from consequence, the consequence being excellent argumentative points are lost in the lazy caricaturing. Easy to hit an open goal.

I dont want to cause disharmony, I would not poke fun at another's accent, but, each to their own. To clarify, I agree with you about the bdisation of the word tory by some SNP to reconfigure it as a catch all for all that's wrong in their world. But to sink to that level of debate is only engaging on their terms. Sun Tzu would have something to say about that!!
I generally agree with all of that.
beer

Roderick Spode

3,134 posts

50 months

Thursday 9th July 2020
quotequote all
DuncsGTi said:
ant1973 said:
She doesn't care. No evidence that anyone is moving to England. I am not remotely convinced she wants indy; why bother when she has power without responsibility. We need to pray for a split in the indy vote.
Anecdotal I know, when I moved back to the UK in June 2014 I discounted buying a house in Scotland solely because of the risk of a yes vote destroying the Scottish economy and housing market.
We had our house valued in early 2014 and were actively seeking properties in Yorkshire and Wiltshire. Sometimes I wish we had followed up on that move, but in my misplaced trust, I thought their defeat in Sept 2014 would spell the end of the constitutional machinations, not fire the starting pistol for an increased campaign that is approaching six years old now, and shows no signs of stopping. I'm sure there are those within the SNP & wider independence movement who would celebrate two traitors / quislings / MI5 plants (delete as appropriate) moving south and purifying their beloved Scotland of non-Scots, but I know for a fact we would not be alone.

anonymous-user

55 months

Thursday 9th July 2020
quotequote all
About as useful as a 5 year weather forecast, but do you think the relative order probably is that far off?


ant1973

5,693 posts

206 months

Thursday 9th July 2020
quotequote all
biggbn said:
hutchst said:
Tories are Conservative politicians or occasionally, in a wider context, party members, across the UK.

Toarees are mythical bogeymen that exist in tbe minds of some Scottish politians, traditionally believed to inhabit a mythical faraway land called Westminster.
Agreed. It is a misappropriation of language, but why play their game. Debate like adults and make them look like the immature ones
Parody and satire can be a little cruel at times...

hidetheelephants

24,585 posts

194 months

Friday 10th July 2020
quotequote all
ant1973 said:
biggbn said:
hutchst said:
Tories are Conservative politicians or occasionally, in a wider context, party members, across the UK.

Toarees are mythical bogeymen that exist in tbe minds of some Scottish politians, traditionally believed to inhabit a mythical faraway land called Westminster.
Agreed. It is a misappropriation of language, but why play their game. Debate like adults and make them look like the immature ones
Parody and satire can be a little cruel at times...
I'm pretty sure tory was created as a derogatory term for conservative, subsequently adopted by them, not unlike Fred Hoyle's coining of Big Bang as a derogatory term for a particular theory about the origin of the universe was subverted by everyone adopting it and using it in scientific literature.

hutchst

3,706 posts

97 months

Friday 10th July 2020
quotequote all
ant1973 said:
Parody and satire can be a little cruel at times...
Indeed, although hardly in this case.

If one were to look for analogies, one might conclude that Nicola is far more post-2017 Theresa May than Boris Johnson. I suspect that a similar fate awaits, despite what the manufactured polls purport to tell us.

hutchst

3,706 posts

97 months

Friday 10th July 2020
quotequote all
hidetheelephants said:
I'm pretty sure tory was created as a derogatory term for conservative, subsequently adopted by them, not unlike Fred Hoyle's coining of Big Bang as a derogatory term for a particular theory about the origin of the universe was subverted by everyone adopting it and using it in scientific literature.
But Jo Swinson's Whigs does have a certain ring to it.

Edinburger

10,403 posts

169 months

Friday 10th July 2020
quotequote all
hutchst said:
ant1973 said:
Parody and satire can be a little cruel at times...
Indeed, although hardly in this case.

If one were to look for analogies, one might conclude that Nicola is far more post-2017 Theresa May than Boris Johnson. I suspect that a similar fate awaits, despite what the manufactured polls purport to tell us.
What makes you think polls are "manufactured"?

I don't rely on polls for anything and they've proven to be wrong several times, but your use of the word "manufactured" is interesting?

ant1973

5,693 posts

206 months

Friday 10th July 2020
quotequote all
For those that are interested, the face nappy regulations only apply to a retail setting i.e. sale or hire of goods or services which takes place in an indoor setting. It excludes:-

(a)restaurants, including restaurants and dining rooms in hotels or members’ clubs,

(b)cafes, including workplace canteens,

(c)bars, including bars in hotels or members’ clubs,

(d)public houses,

(e)banks, building societies, credit unions, short-term loan providers, savings clubs, cash points and undertakings which by way of business operate a currency exchange office, transmit money (or any representation of money) by any means or cash cheques which are made payable to customers.”.

You are permitted not to wear a face mask if you have a reasonable excuse which includes (but is not limited to):-

(5A) In relation to the wearing of a face covering, a reasonable excuse includes—

(a)to seek medical assistance,

(b)to provide care or assistance to a vulnerable person, including to provide emergency assistance,

(c)to avoid injury, illness or to escape a risk of harm,

(d)where the person cannot put on, wear or remove a face covering—

(i)because of any physical or mental illness or impairment or disability (within the meaning of section 6 of the Equality Act 2010),

(ii)without severe distress,

(e)to communicate with a person who has difficulties communicating (in relation to speech, language or otherwise),

(f)to eat or drink where reasonably necessary,

(g)to take medication,

(h)to remove a face covering temporarily to comply with a request by a relevant person or another person acting in the course of their duties, and for the purposes of this sub-paragraph “relevant person” has the meaning given by regulation 7(12).]

technodup

7,585 posts

131 months

Friday 10th July 2020
quotequote all
Absolutely mental. Why some people think more government is a good thing I'll never understand.

ant1973

5,693 posts

206 months

Friday 10th July 2020
quotequote all
hutchst said:
ant1973 said:
Parody and satire can be a little cruel at times...
Indeed, although hardly in this case.

If one were to look for analogies, one might conclude that Nicola is far more post-2017 Theresa May than Boris Johnson. I suspect that a similar fate awaits, despite what the manufactured polls purport to tell us.
I think given the nationalists grip of Scottish life and their apparent insensitivity towards those of a different disposition, we are entitled to be no less cruel in rejoinder. It's good that they are not about to criminalise satire... Oh wait....

ant1973

5,693 posts

206 months

Friday 10th July 2020
quotequote all
technodup said:
Absolutely mental. Why some people think more government is a good thing I'll never understand.
We now have 7 iterations of these regulations micro managing every aspect of life. On one level it is actually very funny. I have visited my last shop for a while and I doubt I will be alone. Still nearly at the end of July and the onset of the real misery will not be far off as furlough ends. No one will be talking about this ridiculous virus by the end of August. Staying safe will likely mean keeping a roof over your head and food on the table. The politicians deserve all that is coming to them.

Clearly she is also intent on leaving some sectors of the economy closed while furlough ends. Can't see that having a happy ending...

wobert

5,059 posts

223 months

Friday 10th July 2020
quotequote all
Nipolean on the BBC comparing covering use to that of wearing seatbelts in cars.... laugh


biggbn

23,588 posts

221 months

Friday 10th July 2020
quotequote all
ant1973 said:
hutchst said:
ant1973 said:
Parody and satire can be a little cruel at times...
Indeed, although hardly in this case.

If one were to look for analogies, one might conclude that Nicola is far more post-2017 Theresa May than Boris Johnson. I suspect that a similar fate awaits, despite what the manufactured polls purport to tell us.
I think given the nationalists grip of Scottish life and their apparent insensitivity towards those of a different disposition, we are entitled to be no less cruel in rejoinder. It's good that they are not about to criminalise satire... Oh wait....
I find that an interesting point. Does poor, immature, divisive behaviour by another group validate the same kind of behaviour by yourself? He/they started it? Sounds like the kind of excuse given at primary schools all over the world, behaviour that engenders whataboutery and is doomed to stifle debate and maintain said division going forward.

Humour, satire, caricature are wonderful and can prove more incisive than supposed high brow debate. The poor mimicking others hardly counts in that regard for me im afraid.

ant1973

5,693 posts

206 months

Friday 10th July 2020
quotequote all
biggbn said:
ant1973 said:
hutchst said:
ant1973 said:
Parody and satire can be a little cruel at times...
Indeed, although hardly in this case.

If one were to look for analogies, one might conclude that Nicola is far more post-2017 Theresa May than Boris Johnson. I suspect that a similar fate awaits, despite what the manufactured polls purport to tell us.
I think given the nationalists grip of Scottish life and their apparent insensitivity towards those of a different disposition, we are entitled to be no less cruel in rejoinder. It's good that they are not about to criminalise satire... Oh wait....
I find that an interesting point. Does poor, immature, divisive behaviour by another group validate the same kind of behaviour by yourself? He/they started it? Sounds like the kind of excuse given at primary schools all over the world, behaviour that engenders whataboutery and is doomed to stifle debate and maintain said division going forward.

Humour, satire, caricature are wonderful and can prove more incisive than supposed high brow debate. The poor mimicking others hardly counts in that regard for me im afraid.
When the phrase in question is used to demonstrate utter contempt for a legitimate but different point of view, I think it is worthy of being parodied. Her pronunciation of it is artificially exaggerated to give it a guttural vibe. And it is basically a euphemism for a mythical bogeyman to distract the mentally enfeebled from their own failings.

ant1973

5,693 posts

206 months

Friday 10th July 2020
quotequote all
Because masks are so worth it according to Swinney:-

"We are now in a situation where people have much more freedom but coronavirus is still in our community.

"There are still, we believe, about 1,000 people who are carrying the infection in Scottish society."

Pretty slim odds of meeting someone with the virus... What's that? Use them when the virus was more prevalent? That would be mental. What are you thinking...

anonymous-user

55 months

Friday 10th July 2020
quotequote all

Countries all over the world (including England) are initiating local lock downs to suppress the virus, due to the massive economic and social consequences of going into winter with covid not under control

And in here, we are whining about face nappies and high taxes and basically calling it the little flu.

Just out of interest, who here supports Trump?

Edited by anonymous-user on Friday 10th July 09:08

TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED