Can Sir Keir Starmer revive the Labour Party? (Vol. 2)

Can Sir Keir Starmer revive the Labour Party? (Vol. 2)

Author
Discussion

Lester H

2,735 posts

105 months

Friday 29th March
quotequote all
S600BSB said:
He has.
Correct. Since I posted on here about 3 months ago, all he has to do is avoid major errors.

Wombat3

12,164 posts

206 months

Friday 29th March
quotequote all
Lester H said:
S600BSB said:
He has.
Correct. Since I posted on here about 3 months ago, all he has to do is avoid major errors.
I think you underestimate the size of the task he has (in terms of the swing needed & the majority he has to overturn)

When you couple that with the lack of quality people on his team, the general apathy towards politics and politicians in general he is going to need to inspire people more than just a bit.

I listened to part of his local election launch speech, the delivery alone was mind numbing and enough to put you to sleep. The content was the same old vacuous rhetoric and contentless word salad with a healthy dose of "because I'm not the Tories" thrown in.

If that's all he's got I could easily see a hung parliament and further descent into petty bickering.

That will mean another wasted 5 years, at least.

S600BSB

4,632 posts

106 months

Friday 29th March
quotequote all
Wombat3 said:
Lester H said:
S600BSB said:
He has.
Correct. Since I posted on here about 3 months ago, all he has to do is avoid major errors.
I think you underestimate the size of the task he has (in terms of the swing needed & the majority he has to overturn)

When you couple that with the lack of quality people on his team, the general apathy towards politics and politicians in general he is going to need to inspire people more than just a bit.

I listened to part of his local election launch speech, the delivery alone was mind numbing and enough to put you to sleep. The content was the same old vacuous rhetoric and contentless word salad with a healthy dose of "because I'm not the Tories" thrown in.

If that's all he's got I could easily see a hung parliament and further descent into petty bickering.

That will mean another wasted 5 years, at least.
Wombat is right in that to overturn a 80 seat majority in a single parliament would be an astonishing achievement - particularly given the state of Labour when SKS took over a leader.

SKS will also need a decent majority himself to allow some very difficult decisions to be enacted; the desperate state of our public services and 14 years of virtually no economic growth means prioritising resources etc will be challenging. But I absolutely believe he is going to do it. Broken Britain certainly needs him to!

Rufus Stone

6,228 posts

56 months

Friday 29th March
quotequote all
S600BSB said:
Wombat is right in that to overturn a 80 seat majority in a single parliament would be an astonishing achievement - particularly given the state of Labour when SKS took over a leader.

SKS will also need a decent majority himself to allow some very difficult decisions to be enacted; the desperate state of our public services and 14 years of virtually no economic growth means prioritising resources etc will be challenging. But I absolutely believe he is going to do it. Broken Britain certainly needs him to!
2019 wasn't a normal GE though, it was a 'whoever would get brexit done' GE. As a result the Tories got far more than they would otherwise have done.

Wombat3

12,164 posts

206 months

Friday 29th March
quotequote all
Rufus Stone said:
S600BSB said:
Wombat is right in that to overturn a 80 seat majority in a single parliament would be an astonishing achievement - particularly given the state of Labour when SKS took over a leader.

SKS will also need a decent majority himself to allow some very difficult decisions to be enacted; the desperate state of our public services and 14 years of virtually no economic growth means prioritising resources etc will be challenging. But I absolutely believe he is going to do it. Broken Britain certainly needs him to!
2019 wasn't a normal GE though, it was a 'whoever would get brexit done' GE. As a result the Tories got far more than they would otherwise have done.
You are probably right about that, it was also the "not Corbyn" GE.

However, you also have to throw boundary changes into the mix as well which make the task harder. I.m also not convinced that the red wall will turn red again. That doesn't mean it will stay blue either.


crankedup5

9,644 posts

35 months

Friday 29th March
quotequote all
Never have the lyrics from The Beatles been so appropriate in describing SKS :

He’s a real nowhere man
sitting in his nowhere land
making all his nowhere plans for nobody

Doesn’t have a point of view
Knows not where he’s going to

(passed on from Little Miss Brexit)


Rufus Stone

6,228 posts

56 months

Friday 29th March
quotequote all
crankedup5 said:
Never have the lyrics from The Beatles been so appropriate in describing SKS :

He’s a real nowhere man
sitting in his nowhere land
making all his nowhere plans for nobody

Doesn’t have a point of view
Knows not where he’s going to

(passed on from Little Miss Brexit)
Still better than the Racist party though (oops Reform).

valiant

10,234 posts

160 months

Friday 29th March
quotequote all
crankedup5 said:
Never have the lyrics from The Beatles been so appropriate in describing SKS :

He’s a real nowhere man
sitting in his nowhere land
making all his nowhere plans for nobody

Doesn’t have a point of view
Knows not where he’s going to

(passed on from Little Miss Brexit)
And yet he'll win the next GE. Not bad for a 'nowhere' man.

Meanwhile your messiahs Farage and Tice will win feck all.

bitchstewie

51,264 posts

210 months

Friday 29th March
quotequote all
crankedup5 said:
Never have the lyrics from The Beatles been so appropriate in describing SKS :

He’s a real nowhere man
sitting in his nowhere land
making all his nowhere plans for nobody

Doesn’t have a point of view
Knows not where he’s going to

(passed on from Little Miss Brexit)
Maybe he can hum it as he walks into Number 10 hehe

S600BSB

4,632 posts

106 months

Friday 29th March
quotequote all
crankedup5 said:
Never have the lyrics from The Beatles been so appropriate in describing SKS :

He’s a real nowhere man
sitting in his nowhere land
making all his nowhere plans for nobody

Doesn’t have a point of view
Knows not where he’s going to

(passed on from Little Miss Brexit)
Everything was better in the 1950s wasn’t it Crank. Haha

biggbn

23,383 posts

220 months

Friday 29th March
quotequote all
crankedup5 said:
Never have the lyrics from The Beatles been so appropriate in describing SKS :

He’s a real nowhere man
sitting in his nowhere land
making all his nowhere plans for nobody

Doesn’t have a point of view
Knows not where he’s going to

(passed on from Little Miss Brexit)
Man, I used this one months, maybe years ago....

carlo996

5,669 posts

21 months

Friday 29th March
quotequote all
S600BSB said:
Everything was better in the 1950s wasn’t it Crank. Haha
Broken Britain (copyright socialist worker 1973) rofl

W124

1,535 posts

138 months

Friday 29th March
quotequote all
Wombat3 said:
Rufus Stone said:
S600BSB said:
Wombat is right in that to overturn a 80 seat majority in a single parliament would be an astonishing achievement - particularly given the state of Labour when SKS took over a leader.

SKS will also need a decent majority himself to allow some very difficult decisions to be enacted; the desperate state of our public services and 14 years of virtually no economic growth means prioritising resources etc will be challenging. But I absolutely believe he is going to do it. Broken Britain certainly needs him to!
2019 wasn't a normal GE though, it was a 'whoever would get brexit done' GE. As a result the Tories got far more than they would otherwise have done.
You are probably right about that, it was also the "not Corbyn" GE.

However, you also have to throw boundary changes into the mix as well which make the task harder. I.m also not convinced that the red wall will turn red again. That doesn't mean it will stay blue either.
I really was ‘not Corbyn’ - as much as, maybe more than Brexit. And the Tories misread it. Cummings misread it.


crankedup5

9,644 posts

35 months

Friday 29th March
quotequote all
biggbn said:
crankedup5 said:
Never have the lyrics from The Beatles been so appropriate in describing SKS :

He’s a real nowhere man
sitting in his nowhere land
making all his nowhere plans for nobody

Doesn’t have a point of view
Knows not where he’s going to

(passed on from Little Miss Brexit)
Man, I used this one months, maybe years ago....
Indeed, but always worth repeating and judging by the SKS devotees it’s still hurting them biggrin

crankedup5

9,644 posts

35 months

Friday 29th March
quotequote all
S600BSB said:
crankedup5 said:
Never have the lyrics from The Beatles been so appropriate in describing SKS :

He’s a real nowhere man
sitting in his nowhere land
making all his nowhere plans for nobody

Doesn’t have a point of view
Knows not where he’s going to

(passed on from Little Miss Brexit)
Everything was better in the 1950s wasn’t it Crank. Haha
hehe
I dunno, tell me about it wink


biggbn

23,383 posts

220 months

Friday 29th March
quotequote all
crankedup5 said:
biggbn said:
crankedup5 said:
Never have the lyrics from The Beatles been so appropriate in describing SKS :

He’s a real nowhere man
sitting in his nowhere land
making all his nowhere plans for nobody

Doesn’t have a point of view
Knows not where he’s going to

(passed on from Little Miss Brexit)
Man, I used this one months, maybe years ago....
Indeed, but always worth repeating and judging by the SKS devotees it’s still hurting them biggrin
For Boris it was 'Dedicated follower of fashion', and for Rishi its Queen's 'The Invisible Man'

crankedup5

9,644 posts

35 months

Friday 29th March
quotequote all
biggbn said:
crankedup5 said:
biggbn said:
crankedup5 said:
Never have the lyrics from The Beatles been so appropriate in describing SKS :

He’s a real nowhere manjeri
sitting in his nowhere land
making all his nowhere plans for nobody

Doesn’t have a point of view
Knows not where he’s going to

(passed on from Little Miss Brexit)
Man, I used this one months, maybe years ago....
Indeed, but always worth repeating and judging by the SKS devotees it’s still hurting them biggrin
For Boris it was 'Dedicated follower of fashion', and for Rishi its Queen's 'The Invisible Man'
laugh
Guess that Truss wasn’t around long enough for her to be labelled with a music track?

crankedup5

9,644 posts

35 months

Friday 29th March
quotequote all
bhstewie said:
crankedup5 said:
Never have the lyrics from The Beatles been so appropriate in describing SKS :

He’s a real nowhere man
sitting in his nowhere land
making all his nowhere plans for nobody

Doesn’t have a point of view
Knows not where he’s going to

(passed on from Little Miss Brexit)
Maybe he can hum it as he walks into Number 10 hehe
Indeed, I can’t recall what Cameron hummed as walked into No 10 after his resignation speech.
Very funny and strange at same time.

biggbn

23,383 posts

220 months

Friday 29th March
quotequote all
crankedup5 said:
bhstewie said:
crankedup5 said:
Never have the lyrics from The Beatles been so appropriate in describing SKS :

He’s a real nowhere man
sitting in his nowhere land
making all his nowhere plans for nobody

Doesn’t have a point of view
Knows not where he’s going to

(passed on from Little Miss Brexit)
Maybe he can hum it as he walks into Number 10 hehe
Indeed, I can’t recall what Cameron hummed as walked into No 10 after his resignation speech.
Very funny and strange at same time.
' it wasn't me' ?....

S600BSB

4,632 posts

106 months

Friday 29th March
quotequote all
crankedup5 said:
S600BSB said:
crankedup5 said:
Never have the lyrics from The Beatles been so appropriate in describing SKS :

He’s a real nowhere man
sitting in his nowhere land
making all his nowhere plans for nobody

Doesn’t have a point of view
Knows not where he’s going to

(passed on from Little Miss Brexit)
Everything was better in the 1950s wasn’t it Crank. Haha
hehe
I dunno, tell me about it wink
Haha - very good.