Removing render yourself?

Author
Discussion

cringle

Original Poster:

398 posts

187 months

Wednesday 16th January 2013
quotequote all
Hi All,
Had a new kitchen started today, also having chimney breast enlarged and a stud wall removed. As the builder started removing the old kitchen down to brick, he rang and told me the render on the outside wall was trapping moisture, not allowing the bricks to "breathe" and led to the moisture affecting the inner wall. Only spoke to him on the fone and he said they were crumbling as he tapped them with his hammer.

He said i need to have the render removed, the exterior walls sandblasted and then all repointed...for 15 grand...

Now its a 1920s semi, slightly larger than average, the render is only on the side and back of the house, but is this price even in the ballpark?? Is any of it a DIY job?

The kitchens bloody expensive enough frown any advice greatly appreciated

spikeyhead

17,383 posts

198 months

Wednesday 16th January 2013
quotequote all
It's easy enough to do yourself, but unless it's already falling off will take a long time and probably some scaffold.

VxDuncan

2,850 posts

235 months

Wednesday 16th January 2013
quotequote all
Get a second opinion...

Little Lofty

3,298 posts

152 months

Wednesday 16th January 2013
quotequote all
VxDuncan said:
Get a second opinion...
+1

cringle

Original Poster:

398 posts

187 months

Wednesday 16th January 2013
quotequote all
Just been home to see the ripped out kitchen, the plaster was soaking wet, galvanised wiring covers rusted through...hmmm moral of the story get the highest survey level prior to buying! What a beeatch. I'll get a 2nd opinion though thanks guys. Hope the gable wall doesnt crumble overnight

Busa mav

2,563 posts

155 months

Wednesday 16th January 2013
quotequote all
Be careful that you understand the implications of possibly removing a large area of render.

After a certain % of the render is removed , you may find yourself having to ( according to building regs ) upgrade the U value of the existing walls of the house .

surveyor

17,876 posts

185 months

Wednesday 16th January 2013
quotequote all
How is the water getting behind the render?

I'd like to make sure that it is getting behind, and is not a rising damp thing myself.

If the wall was hidden behind cupboards and tiles, it's quite likely that even the highest level of survey would not have spotted it. Defective render and danp walls really should be spotted in a valuation for mortgage purposes, providing that access was available.

russ_a

4,589 posts

212 months

Wednesday 16th January 2013
quotequote all
We have been quoted 2k per side \ wall for a largish detached house. That is to take off the existing render, apply new render and then paint.

roofer

5,136 posts

212 months

Wednesday 16th January 2013
quotequote all
Hammer test existing render to ascertain problem.

psychoR1

1,070 posts

188 months

Wednesday 16th January 2013
quotequote all
Busa mav said:
Be careful that you understand the implications of possibly removing a large area of render.

After a certain % of the render is removed , you may find yourself having to ( according to building regs ) upgrade the U value of the existing walls of the house .
p
Correct - there should be some grants for insulation as part o
f the green deal this year - don't hold yer breath tho'!

mgtony

4,022 posts

191 months

Wednesday 16th January 2013
quotequote all
How large an area is damp? Could there be a water pipe running up the wall which has been leaking?
Removing the old render to re-render it is one thing but removing it to end up with decent finished clean bricks to repoint for the final look is a bit more tricky!

cringle

Original Poster:

398 posts

187 months

Wednesday 16th January 2013
quotequote all
The builder seems quite knowledgeable to be fair, he doesn't think its a rising damp problem but apparently there is quite a high water table in this area and an impromptu discussion with a neighbour who doesnt have render revealed they had had a similar issue albeit higher up in the house. The damp in question is confined to the ground floor level mainly the back of the chimney and the corners of the kitchen all of which are outside walls. There weren't any leaking pipes. I did a bit of research and i think the insulation issue in removing render wouldnt really apply due to the cavity walls, a previous damp course and the age of the property. And i would say only 23% was removed. Just thinking if i remove most of the render myself it may save quite a bit in labour charges, then a sandblast/pointing and no more bloody render. The builder reckons this will be enough to sort it as the bricks will be able to "breathe". His mate who does these jobs is coming out tomorrow to see for sure if this is the solution so shall report back!

Thanks for everyones help!

nails1979

597 posts

142 months

Thursday 17th January 2013
quotequote all
Smells like bs. The render shouldn't be really getting that wet. Also as you have cavity walls and not single brick aslong as the cavitys arent blocked up then the bricks can dry out. Albeit from the inside.
Id say he waters running down the wall from poorly fitted guttering or a problem with the roof.

psychoR1

1,070 posts

188 months

Thursday 17th January 2013
quotequote all
Something doesn't sound right here. In any wall there is a condensation point (Look up interstitial condensation) that needs to be designed out. If your wall really was that 'wet' the damage would be from soaked brick cracking at sub zero temps - one of the reasons why we have DPC's, cavity and gutters. Has the cavity been bridged at some point? Has the chimney been used for gas but not lined? Is it damp in the kitchen? Bear in mind you are seeing the symptom not the cause and get a pro in (arch or engineer) to diagnose before spending upto £15k on forum advice.

don'tbesilly

13,940 posts

164 months

Thursday 17th January 2013
quotequote all
cringle said:
The builder seems quite knowledgeable to be fair, he doesn't think its a rising damp problem but apparently there is quite a high water table in this area and an impromptu discussion with a neighbour who doesnt have render revealed they had had a similar issue albeit higher up in the house. The damp in question is confined to the ground floor level mainly the back of the chimney and the corners of the kitchen all of which are outside walls. There weren't any leaking pipes. I did a bit of research and i think the insulation issue in removing render wouldnt really apply due to the cavity walls, a previous damp course and the age of the property. And i would say only 23% was removed. Just thinking if i remove most of the render myself it may save quite a bit in labour charges, then a sandblast/pointing and no more bloody render. The builder reckons this will be enough to sort it as the bricks will be able to "breathe". His mate who does these jobs is coming out tomorrow to see for sure if this is the solution so shall report back!

Thanks for everyones help!
So your builder doesn't think it's rising damp,but apparently the area has a high water table.
Is there any relevance between those two assumptions?

If the building is a cavity wall construction,how is the damp travelling from the outer skin,to the inner skin of brickwork?

Sorry,but from what you've written,and been told by the builder,I'd suggest the problem lies elsewhere,and has little to do with the render.

Unless of course,the house has had cavity wall insulation,has it?

Monty Zoomer

1,459 posts

158 months

Thursday 17th January 2013
quotequote all
It sounds to me as if the builder is trying to sell you a service that you might not need.

Like a lot of others have said, get a second opinion. His mate will offer to do it and he might even come up with a sudden price reduction, but you need an independent opinion.

dazwalsh

6,095 posts

142 months

Thursday 17th January 2013
quotequote all
whatever is wrong with it, 15 grand is absurd!


essayer

9,096 posts

195 months

Thursday 17th January 2013
quotequote all
I assume you have cavity walls and not solid given the age of the house?

Where exactly is the dampness on the wall ?

Is the outside render visibly cracked in places, or can water run against it, perhaps from a gutter, leaking pipe, roof etc?

If you are getting damp in an area that used to be a chimney this could be related to the plaster used , hygroscopic salts I think it is.

Damp in the high corners could just be condensation from normal cooking, washing up etc, do you use an extractor, open a window, dry laundry in the kitchen?





fulham911club

2,046 posts

243 months

Thursday 17th January 2013
quotequote all
russ_a said:
We have been quoted 2k per side \ wall for a largish detached house. That is to take off the existing render, apply new render and then paint.
That seems v good value - do you guys travel to SE? If so please PM their details...

TA14

12,722 posts

259 months

Thursday 17th January 2013
quotequote all
psychoR1 said:
Something doesn't sound right here.
Quite a lot makes no sense. Builder tapping inner leaf bricks and they crumble, cavity wall bricks needing to breath.

As PR1 said get professional advice, find the root of the problem and get a new builder.