How Solid Really is Your Marriage

How Solid Really is Your Marriage

Author
Discussion

Cold

15,247 posts

90 months

Thursday 18th January 2018
quotequote all
Sa Calobra said:
It's either way. Men can equally call the police too.
Unfortunately, in the real world, the police answering the call of a domestic incident will be looking to remove the male from the property. There's still a long, long way to go before men are ever considered to be potential victims of domestic abuse.

mjb1

2,556 posts

159 months

Thursday 18th January 2018
quotequote all
stargazer30 said:
I noticed there has been recent legislation that makes if illegal for one partner in the relationship to emotionally abuse and be controlling over the other. Things like stopping them seeing friends, abusive/demeaning behavior, taking there money etc.. I recon some of the WAGs in this thread would be on the wrong side of it. However its written for men abusing women, I don't think it can be applied when the woman is the abusive one.

Equal rights an all....
I think there was a thread about this new legislation in NPE a while ago. While most of the coverage has been from the angle of protecting women from emotional abuse, I actually think think women are the main perpetrators of it. I know so many men who have been or are still victims of it, but in most cases they brush it under the carpet for the sake of the kids or keeping the relationship alive. But you just know that most women wouldn't stand to be treated like that, and the one's that do try and put up with it are 'set straight' by their female friends.

There does seem to be a stigma towards men reporting themselves as victims, even when it's physical abuse, so it'll probably be even more challenging to report emotional abuse. There also seems to be a common perception that women are supposed to be a bit nuts, and it just gets blamed on hormones, time of the month, a previous bad experience (maybe real, maybe just in their head), having kids, menopause etc. That its normal, acceptable.

I've only had four serious relationships, and out of those - 2 women turned out to be completely bonkers, another one was ok most of the time but still a bit unpredictable. And one who was totally stable, but turned out to be very calculating and just used men as stepping stones to suit her current circumstances. Maybe it's all down to me, do I bring out the worst in them, or I'm just terrible at picking them out!

Frank7

6,619 posts

87 months

Thursday 18th January 2018
quotequote all
Olivera said:
jamesv81 said:
My mrs will say truly horrible things some days. Over Christmas she said she would not tell anyone if I died and get my body cremated and not have a service. I just laughed it off and said the funeral will be cheap then, but in reality it was a really hurtful comment that my last day would be on my own but she says stuff like that all the time.
No, that's not a 'hurtful comment', e.g. 'you are stupid idiot...". That is a seriously cruel and deranged comment. Don't convince yourself it's anywhere near normal.
Bit OTT that Olivera, IMO.
Light heartedly arguing with my wife about the non virtues of the perfectly adequate new Peugeot 2008 she’d gone for, after deep sixing the comfortable and semi luxurious Fiat Croma she’d had for just shy of 10 years, she retorted, “Should never have ditched that diesel SUV, if you’d died, I could have put you in a cardboard box in the Fiat, and dropped you at the Council Dump, just off the Old Kent Road.”
I took that as quite humorous, certainly not cruel and deranged.

GT03ROB

13,263 posts

221 months

Thursday 18th January 2018
quotequote all
Frank7 said:
Olivera said:
jamesv81 said:
My mrs will say truly horrible things some days. Over Christmas she said she would not tell anyone if I died and get my body cremated and not have a service. I just laughed it off and said the funeral will be cheap then, but in reality it was a really hurtful comment that my last day would be on my own but she says stuff like that all the time.
No, that's not a 'hurtful comment', e.g. 'you are stupid idiot...". That is a seriously cruel and deranged comment. Don't convince yourself it's anywhere near normal.
Bit OTT that Olivera, IMO.
Light heartedly arguing with my wife about the non virtues of the perfectly adequate new Peugeot 2008 she’d gone for, after deep sixing the comfortable and semi luxurious Fiat Croma she’d had for just shy of 10 years, she retorted, “Should never have ditched that diesel SUV, if you’d died, I could have put you in a cardboard box in the Fiat, and dropped you at the Council Dump, just off the Old Kent Road.”
I took that as quite humorous, certainly not cruel and deranged.
...but its all in the tone Mrs james could have said in a light hearted way & it could have been amusing as Mrs Frank did or it could have been said with menace through barred teeth which is the implication in what James says

Ari

19,347 posts

215 months

Thursday 18th January 2018
quotequote all
Frank7 said:
Olivera said:
jamesv81 said:
My mrs will say truly horrible things some days. Over Christmas she said she would not tell anyone if I died and get my body cremated and not have a service. I just laughed it off and said the funeral will be cheap then, but in reality it was a really hurtful comment that my last day would be on my own but she says stuff like that all the time.
No, that's not a 'hurtful comment', e.g. 'you are stupid idiot...". That is a seriously cruel and deranged comment. Don't convince yourself it's anywhere near normal.
Bit OTT that Olivera, IMO.
Light heartedly arguing with my wife about the non virtues of the perfectly adequate new Peugeot 2008 she’d gone for, after deep sixing the comfortable and semi luxurious Fiat Croma she’d had for just shy of 10 years, she retorted, “Should never have ditched that diesel SUV, if you’d died, I could have put you in a cardboard box in the Fiat, and dropped you at the Council Dump, just off the Old Kent Road.”
I took that as quite humorous, certainly not cruel and deranged.
The fact that the OP described it as My mrs will say truly horrible things some days surely must give you some clue that your example is not remotely comparable?

It's like someone saying 'I'm going to fking kill you' to you. There is a HUGE difference to a mate saying it whilst laughing to a drunk stranger snarling it in your face.

Harry Flashman

19,357 posts

242 months

Thursday 18th January 2018
quotequote all
mjb1 said:
stargazer30 said:
I noticed there has been recent legislation that makes if illegal for one partner in the relationship to emotionally abuse and be controlling over the other. Things like stopping them seeing friends, abusive/demeaning behavior, taking there money etc.. I recon some of the WAGs in this thread would be on the wrong side of it. However its written for men abusing women, I don't think it can be applied when the woman is the abusive one.

Equal rights an all....
I think there was a thread about this new legislation in NPE a while ago. While most of the coverage has been from the angle of protecting women from emotional abuse, I actually think think women are the main perpetrators of it. I know so many men who have been or are still victims of it, but in most cases they brush it under the carpet for the sake of the kids or keeping the relationship alive. But you just know that most women wouldn't stand to be treated like that, and the one's that do try and put up with it are 'set straight' by their female friends.

There does seem to be a stigma towards men reporting themselves as victims, even when it's physical abuse, so it'll probably be even more challenging to report emotional abuse. There also seems to be a common perception that women are supposed to be a bit nuts, and it just gets blamed on hormones, time of the month, a previous bad experience (maybe real, maybe just in their head), having kids, menopause etc. That its normal, acceptable.
I did a special assignment for the criminology module of my law degree on female on male domestic abuse, and reporting statistics.

Domestic abuse is one of the most underreported crimes of any kind. And in the case of male victims, the factor that we were able to ascertain was even smaller - frankly only a tiny minority of victims reported, and only ever for violent, rather than emotional, abuse (in those days, no-one reported emotional abuse, to be fair – the police at that time, the late 90's, would have told you to GTFO).

Rather sadly, one of the men I interviewed ended up being stabbed to death by his partner some years later. Never even made the papers – no one cared.


Taaaaang

6,599 posts

186 months

Thursday 18th January 2018
quotequote all
dirty boy said:
Taaaaang said:
Rather incongruous; criticising a "look at me, look at me, my life is amazing" post in the middle of people talking about how their lives are falling apart makes me a "hard man" or any of the other insults flung my way.

Sad.
Yeah, nobody should be allowed to have fun when everyone else is miserable.

Let's all be miserable together.
I didn't say that.

If I was standing listening to my friend tell me about his car woes, for instance, the last thing I would do is pipe up and tell him how I've never had a problem with mine/best car ever/yaddayadda.

Taaaaang

6,599 posts

186 months

Thursday 18th January 2018
quotequote all
Robertj21a said:
Robatr0n said:
What a venomous little troll!
Quite ! - a good summary.

smile
I didn't realise that having a differing opinion to others makes one a "troll".

Taaaaang

6,599 posts

186 months

Thursday 18th January 2018
quotequote all
tighnamara said:
Taaaaang said:
Rather incongruous; criticising a "look at me, look at me, my life is amazing" post in the middle of people talking about how their lives are falling apart makes me a "hard man" or any of the other insults flung my way.

Sad.
So previously known as Haggleburyfinius

Wow just wow, you must have some serious issues. Hope it all works out for you.
When your on the right wave length have a read back your posts.


Edited by tighnamara on Tuesday 16th January 21:05
My old username is not a secret....

Sorry to break it to you but I feel the same way today.

People who decide to eulogise about their own lives on a topic that those around them are struggling with are as annoying as elvenerife types.

Anyway, despite not being able to resist defending myself, I wish those of you with troublesome marriages the best and those of you, like myself, with great ones, the same.

WestyCarl

3,256 posts

125 months

Thursday 18th January 2018
quotequote all
Taaaaang said:
People who decide to eulogise about their own lives on a topic that those around them are struggling with are as annoying as elvenerife types.
.
I thought the title was "How solid really is your marriage", seems fair to say very.

Taaaaang

6,599 posts

186 months

Thursday 18th January 2018
quotequote all
WestyCarl said:
Taaaaang said:
People who decide to eulogise about their own lives on a topic that those around them are struggling with are as annoying as elvenerife types.
.
I thought the title was "How solid really is your marriage", seems fair to say very.
Conversations ebb and flow though don't they.

For years here, people have said "See the lounge/P&P as like a pub and converse as you would with people in person".

Sa Calobra

37,129 posts

211 months

Thursday 18th January 2018
quotequote all
Taaaaang said:
Conversations ebb and flow though don't they.

For years here, people have said "See the lounge/P&P as like a pub and converse as you would with people in person".
You wouldn't speak to people like that in the pub though. The internet makes it safe for you to speak your mind.

Taaaaang

6,599 posts

186 months

Thursday 18th January 2018
quotequote all
Sa Calobra said:
Taaaaang said:
Conversations ebb and flow though don't they.

For years here, people have said "See the lounge/P&P as like a pub and converse as you would with people in person".
You wouldn't speak to people like that in the pub though. The internet makes it safe for you to speak your mind.
Me? I'm quite forthright in person; perhaps even more so than on the internet as people are always spoiling for a fight online and most of the time it's not worth the effort.

There is nothing I have ever written on the internet that I wouldn't be comfortable saying to someone in person.

Robertj21a

16,477 posts

105 months

Thursday 18th January 2018
quotequote all
Taaaaang said:
Me? I'm quite forthright in person; perhaps even more so than on the internet as people are always spoiling for a fight online and most of the time it's not worth the effort.

There is nothing I have ever written on the internet that I wouldn't be comfortable saying to someone in person.
Remind me to not be in the same place as you. There's plenty of very annoying people out there already, I don't need another.

Sa Calobra

37,129 posts

211 months

Thursday 18th January 2018
quotequote all
Taaaaang said:
Me? I'm quite forthright in person; perhaps even more so than on the internet as people are always spoiling for a fight online and most of the time it's not worth the effort.

There is nothing I have ever written on the internet that I wouldn't be comfortable saying to someone in person.
Ah yes, one of those.

https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=boorish+definiti...



singlecoil

33,610 posts

246 months

Thursday 18th January 2018
quotequote all
Taaaaang said:
dirty boy said:
Taaaaang said:
Rather incongruous; criticising a "look at me, look at me, my life is amazing" post in the middle of people talking about how their lives are falling apart makes me a "hard man" or any of the other insults flung my way.

Sad.
Yeah, nobody should be allowed to have fun when everyone else is miserable.

Let's all be miserable together.
I didn't say that.

If I was standing listening to my friend tell me about his car woes, for instance, the last thing I would do is pipe up and tell him how I've never had a problem with mine/best car ever/yaddayadda.
Your analogy doesn't fit. It does however possibly explain why you don't understand why so many people disagree with you.

FocusRS3

Original Poster:

3,411 posts

91 months

Thursday 18th January 2018
quotequote all
Symptomless Coma said:
It’s nice to hear that marriage can work for some, i for one am quite envious.
Hi mate , any update ?

PS Taaaaaaang , can we pls stop the arguing so this thread can return to the original subject matter . Tks chap

FocusRS3

Original Poster:

3,411 posts

91 months

Saturday 20th January 2018
quotequote all
Bump -

Sleeplesscoma , any update matey ?

Symptomless Coma

188 posts

182 months

Saturday 20th January 2018
quotequote all
FocusRS3 said:
Bump -

Sleeplesscoma , any update matey ?
She wants me out of the house. Her friends think she’s being a dick.
I broke down at work on Tuesday, that was fun. Been to docs for something to help me sleep.
Oh and her car broke down Wednesday was friendly that day so she borrowed mine for a couple of days, returned it yesterday and at least she spoke to the kids for a few mins. I’m trying to hold normality for the kids. Also the solicitor has said I have grounds for divorce but basically I’m fked.
She might turn up today to see the kids, but hasn’t actually said anything.


FocusRS3

Original Poster:

3,411 posts

91 months

Saturday 20th January 2018
quotequote all
Symptomless Coma said:
She wants me out of the house. Her friends think she’s being a dick.
I broke down at work on Tuesday, that was fun. Been to docs for something to help me sleep.
Oh and her car broke down Wednesday was friendly that day so she borrowed mine for a couple of days, returned it yesterday and at least she spoke to the kids for a few mins. I’m trying to hold normality for the kids. Also the solicitor has said I have grounds for divorce but basically I’m fked.
She might turn up today to see the kids, but hasn’t actually said anything.
Ok doesn’t sound like there is any chance of a reconciliation then.

So is she suggesting you leave the house and she takes full responsibility of the kids again ?

Going to the docs is a smart move . It also (if there is a big court showdown ) shows how’s it’s affected you .

Sorry to hear this , I’d be reluctant to leave the house