Fairy liquid + sugar - chemistry or physics?

Fairy liquid + sugar - chemistry or physics?

Author
Discussion

Rufus

Original Poster:

1,518 posts

208 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
So we all know after an afternoon in the engine bay of something or other, mechanics gloves or not, the best way of getting rid of the grease etc from our hands is a couple of teaspoons of sugar and some fairy liquid. Now is this because there is some sort of reaction between the two which helps cleaning, or is it purely that the sugar gives the soap something to bite on?

I'm suspecting the latter but would be interested if anybody knows....

PoleDriver

28,651 posts

195 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
The coarse sugar removes 1 or 2 layers of skin, complete with dirt! smile

Stu R

21,410 posts

216 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
You're combining a reasonably strong detergent designed to break down lipids, with something abrasive. Replace with any other abrasive which retains it's structure, and any other decent detergent and you'll find the results are very much the same.

GTIR

24,741 posts

267 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
Not good for your girly hands. nono
Or soap powder.

Forget Swarfega - they're (allegedly) only good at having a big marketing budget.

Best stuff is Manista, lemon or Orange.

On a related note, those disposable gloves that Halfords sell are utter tripe. Like paper. shoot
£8!

Stu R

21,410 posts

216 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
Same for Lava soap - used to be bloody amazing, now it's useless.

Laurel Green

30,785 posts

233 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
Same for all those new fangled oven cleaners. The glass door on my oven had a brown stain that none of the modern cleaners would touch - found some Vim in the back of the cleaning cupboard and it took the stain off with barely a rub.

Robb F

4,571 posts

172 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
GTIR said:
Not good for your girly hands. nono
Or soap powder.

Forget Swarfega - they're (allegedly) only good at having a big marketing budget.

Best stuff is Manista, lemon or Orange.

On a related note, those disposable gloves that Halfords sell are utter tripe. Like paper. shoot
£8!
Manista is the one!

and proper mechanics use the thick black tattooists gloves smile

Zwolf

25,867 posts

207 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
Petrol also works.

I use these for post oily-stuff clean up of tools and hands alike:

LeeMad

1,098 posts

154 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
GTIR said:
Best stuff is Manista, lemon or Orange.
another vote for this from me, orange. swarfega is ok if its just a bit of oil, thick grease and its useless.

what if you put sugar in swarfega? mind blown...

jackh707

2,126 posts

157 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
Real men wash their hands with acetone.

BliarOut

72,857 posts

240 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
GTIR said:
Not good for your girly hands. nono
Or soap powder.

Forget Swarfega - they're (allegedly) only good at having a big marketing budget.

Best stuff is Manista, lemon or Orange.

On a related note, those disposable gloves that Halfords sell are utter tripe. Like paper. shoot
£8!
VIM yes

Cock Womble 7

29,908 posts

231 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all

perdu

4,884 posts

200 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
I have used Swoop which is/was used by the AA as the standard hand cleaner for years and it wipes off with a paper towel if there's no water handy.

I buy it from Unipart/Partco

Sounds like birdseed, isnt!yes

Swarfega is smelly and a bit crap. I have used Manista, quite like that too smile

Simpo Two

85,618 posts

266 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
Molton Brown for me

getmecoat

Shaman

699 posts

201 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
WD-40 works a treat at removing oil from hands.

Mr Gear

9,416 posts

191 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
Try Fast Orange if you haven't tried it already. It really is superb. Infinitely better than Swarfega, and smells delicious too!

RizzoTheRat

25,217 posts

193 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
I find Wickes own brand version of the swarfega with grit in it works very well.

Rich1973

1,201 posts

178 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
Have non of you tried swarfega orange? granular bits and smells great. Good at getting most things off your hands.

mi1ne

307 posts

199 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
Normally gloves are a fail imo, but these are really good.

http://www.coleparmer.co.uk/Product/Microflex_smal...

Ray Luxury-Yacht

8,910 posts

217 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
As above, I spent years knackering the skin on my hands whilst spannering, and then tested lots of different hand cleaners. Despite this - even if I got my hands and nails clean, and then used a moisturiser, my skin and nail beds looked like crap and I often had dry skin cracking on knuckles etc.

Then one day I thought 'why not wear some gloves?'

I tried lots of different gloves. Eventually I found that you need to get a box of 'Nitrile' disposables. These seem to resist oil and petrol the best before disintegrating.

A box of 100 gloves is about £6 from Screwfix. If I'm spending a day spannering on the cars, the damage / melting ratio is about 3 pairs to an average day of mechanics.
But even once one of the fingers gets torn / damaged, generally the gloves are still protecting the rest very well. So all I do is wait until the gloves are looking a bit 'holey' and then go back into the garage for a new pair.

This is fine for light / general spannering, but if you get into some heavy work like removing axles / boxes / engines, you need to supplement them with something a bit more robust.

So for these tasks, I use another Screwfix supply - gloves from 'Caterpiller' or 'DeWalt'. These gloves are stretchy cotton based gloves, with a heavy rubber coating over the inside of the fingers and palms. These gloves are about a fiver a pair, and I reckon I get through maybe two pairs a year. I put them on over the top of a new pair of Nitriles. That way, even if you get a leakage of fluid onto the gloves - your hands still stay free of contamination below.

They grip and protect your hands well, on any jobs that are a bit more 'robust' on the car - but still give you enough tactility to feel what you're doing.


Trust me - since using gloves to work on cars, I've never had to use a hand cleaner of any sort - and my skin and nails always look as good as new. Give it a go!