Frameless windows - why?

Frameless windows - why?

Author
Discussion

dave87

525 posts

211 months

Wednesday 5th November 2008
quotequote all
Kinda essential on Convertibles, lol.

Murdock

406 posts

241 months

Wednesday 5th November 2008
quotequote all
neil_bolton said:
Murdock said:
neil_bolton said:
However, once you've poked yourself in the face a few times getting into the car on the edge of the glass, the novelty soon wears off hehe
Precisely how I smashed my last pair of glasses. hehe
Friggin hurts doesn't it; those pointy corners can do some damage!

Even worse when your passenger/missus wets herself laughing at you. Anger/fuming wasn't the word biggrin
Damn straight it does. What's worse is I had just spent the previous three hours washing, waxing and detailing the car, and was just hopping in to take it for a wee spin. There's gratitude for you! biggrin

h4muf

2,070 posts

215 months

Wednesday 5th November 2008
quotequote all
Audi coupe has `em aswell smile

sniff diesel

13,112 posts

220 months

Wednesday 5th November 2008
quotequote all
johnfelstead said:
It helps keep the centre of gravity low, which is a major design phylosophy to any Subaru with it's boxer engine layout.
I doubt the hefty rubber seal required weighs less than the metal frame for the door. On the E36 the saloon weighs less and has better torsional rigidity than the equivalent coupe.

sjwb

550 posts

216 months

Wednesday 5th November 2008
quotequote all
Simple reason? COST.
Door press tooling cheaper, door unit cost cheaper.
Not forgetting input from the felt tip fairies of course (stylists);)

Davi

17,153 posts

228 months

Wednesday 5th November 2008
quotequote all
neil_bolton said:
never mind the fact that the glass sticks to the seal in the winter and there's nothing that you can do!
THE single most annoying trait of them. In the past I've put a light smear of rubber lubricant on the seals - doesn't seem to freeze but you do of course then have a smeary glass irked Still, better than standing with a homer like expression when you can't get in your car.

Niiick

196 posts

203 months

Wednesday 5th November 2008
quotequote all
There is an aerodynamic advantage to either flush fit windows (think new Audi 100 1983 MY) or pillarless/frameless windows, so I imagine this coupled with styling is the reason for such things.

mat205125

17,790 posts

221 months

Thursday 6th November 2008
quotequote all
Looks better

Makes the pressing for the door and it's inner simpler

Reduces the waste materials scrapped from the apperture of the door when it is pressed


kambites

68,497 posts

229 months

Thursday 6th November 2008
quotequote all
dave87 said:
Kinda essential on Convertibles, lol.
There have been convertibles with window frames, although not many.

mat205125

17,790 posts

221 months

Thursday 6th November 2008
quotequote all
kambites said:
dave87 said:
Kinda essential on Convertibles, lol.
There have been convertibles with window frames, although not many.
Baur 3 series and Triumph Stags?

Not many because they look terrible.

kambites

68,497 posts

229 months

Thursday 6th November 2008
quotequote all
mat205125 said:
kambites said:
dave87 said:
Kinda essential on Convertibles, lol.
There have been convertibles with window frames, although not many.
Baur 3 series and Triumph Stags?

Not many because they look terrible.
Lotus Elan too.

Deluded

4,968 posts

199 months

Thursday 6th November 2008
quotequote all
I used to love them when I had my Rover 218vvc coupe. Makes you feel special when you open the doors with the windows down biggrin

One good thing about them though is that when you lock your keys in the car, the windows have enough give to bend them out slightly enough to pull the lock up inside. Not such a good thing when its not you pulling the lock up though...

edwardsje

29,538 posts

231 months

Thursday 6th November 2008
quotequote all
Mars said:
OK, so everyone is saying they are suitable for Cabrios, but who has heard of a Subaru Legacy Cabrio? Why does Subaru persist with frameless windows when they haven't EVER (as far as I can tell) made anything without a roof?
...although the late Mr McRae did his best on many occasions

Fer

7,736 posts

288 months

Thursday 6th November 2008
quotequote all
I have them on my 328 conv. Great for parking in tight spaces, but it has full closure alarms, which means that while you will get out OK, if you lock it, you will not be getting back in as easy!

(Not done it myself, but came very close before realising!)

RacingPete

8,976 posts

212 months

Thursday 6th November 2008
quotequote all
Have a Bugeye Impreza WRX and I like the look with them, also I had always thought that if I win the lottery I could make a convertible Impreza easier smile

The only problem I have with them is the first time I hit 120mph in the car there was a sudden loud buzzer noise and it made me thought that the car was fitted with some speed alarm. On the second time up to that speed I realised it was the wind vibration of the window against the seal and thus you have to drop the window and re-raise to remove the noise. Which does add a little extra twist to flying down Fuchsröhre driving

I did complain to my Subaru dealer but they said they had no way of testing it and thus couldn't fix it smile

davemac250

4,499 posts

213 months

Thursday 6th November 2008
quotequote all
Just checked, my arms are still there.

Must be the one touch windows.


edwardsje

29,538 posts

231 months

Thursday 6th November 2008
quotequote all
RacingPete said:
Have a Bugeye Impreza WRX and I like the look with them, also I had always thought that if I win the lottery I could make a convertible Impreza easier smile

The only problem I have with them is the first time I hit 120mph in the car there was a sudden loud buzzer noise and it made me thought that the car was fitted with some speed alarm. On the second time up to that speed I realised it was the wind vibration of the window against the seal and thus you have to drop the window and re-raise to remove the noise. Which does add a little extra twist to flying down Fuchsröhre driving

I did complain to my Subaru dealer but they said they had no way of testing it and thus couldn't fix it smile
They still do it!

TotalControl

8,229 posts

206 months

Thursday 6th November 2008
quotequote all
Frameless look good IMO. My celica had them and i really liked it. My mums 3 series has the frames and it just doesnt feel right. Dunno why?

Edited by TotalControl on Thursday 6th November 17:28

monthefish

20,456 posts

239 months

Thursday 6th November 2008
quotequote all
neil_bolton said:
Murdock said:
neil_bolton said:
However, once you've poked yourself in the face a few times getting into the car on the edge of the glass, the novelty soon wears off hehe
Precisely how I smashed my last pair of glasses. hehe
Friggin hurts doesn't it; those pointy corners can do some damage!

Even worse when your passenger/missus wets herself laughing at you. Anger/fuming wasn't the word biggrin
confused
Shirley a frameless door is easier to avoid that framed, as it is likely to be lower and less bulky?

sjwb said:
Simple reason? COST.
Door press tooling cheaper, door unit cost cheaper.
Not forgetting input from the felt tip fairies of course (stylists);)
Frameless doors are not cheaper to manufacture than an equivalent framed.

dino_jr

403 posts

184 months

Friday 22nd March
quotequote all
Hello / big bump

I may need to source a car with a "long" boot to get a wheelchair in, but as it will need to fit in a 2.5m wide garage, I think frameless doors will help too.
So, what +2020 reg 4-door cars have frameless windows... Are there any these days? I see Peugeot 508 and Audi A5 sportbacks, but not many / any others.

Edited by dino_jr on Friday 22 March 09:46


Edited by dino_jr on Friday 22 March 09:48