RE: Six Of The Best? Forgotten Hot Hatches

RE: Six Of The Best? Forgotten Hot Hatches

Author
Discussion

toon10

6,224 posts

158 months

Wednesday 19th October 2011
quotequote all
I'm biased as it was my first car but the Suzuki Swift Mk1 GTi gets my vote.

KingPoker

4 posts

196 months

Wednesday 19th October 2011
quotequote all
Some truly terrible cars here. (wait for backlash)

KingPoker

4 posts

196 months

Wednesday 19th October 2011
quotequote all
Perhaps I should go into slightly more detail. I just get annoyed when I see cars being touted as unsung hero's when if you show pretty much any of these one's here a corner, they will buckle at the knees.

To me, it's about more than point and shoot. And sadly that's where the SEAT also lets itself down. I have driven every model of Cupra FR since they came out (I learnt to drive in one) and they are rapid in a staright line but so unresponsive in the corners. They instill no confidence.

The Integra Type R I owned and current car 3.0 Z4 SE actually involve you in the drive. I'm not saying these cars in the article aren't good because of the thrills gained per £ but after you have driven a FWD car with a LSD and amazing race ready chassis and a RWD with perfect 50/50 balance you realise what a car should be like.

Therefore in my opinion it's obvious why the Civic Type R's, Golf GTI MK1's and Clio Cups have stolen the limelight. Because they offered something these cars never could/did.

snowmuncher

786 posts

164 months

Wednesday 19th October 2011
quotequote all
Roono said:
Don't worry Snowmuncher, the first was a chaved up wreak with snapped cambelt. Way past its best. The 4X4 kit went to New Zealand to keep others alive & the leather seats ended up in my 405 GLX!

Why did I sell my 205 Mi16. frown
I was only jesting !

I think maybe after a few years its easy to remember the goods times with cars, rather than hours spent in the small hours during a winter storm waiting for the AA man !

Mr Dave

3,233 posts

196 months

Wednesday 19th October 2011
quotequote all
KingPoker said:
Perhaps I should go into slightly more detail. I just get annoyed when I see cars being touted as unsung hero's when if you show pretty much any of these one's here a corner, they will buckle at the knees.

To me, it's about more than point and shoot. And sadly that's where the SEAT also lets itself down. I have driven every model of Cupra FR since they came out (I learnt to drive in one) and they are rapid in a staright line but so unresponsive in the corners. They instill no confidence.

The Integra Type R I owned and current car 3.0 Z4 SE actually involve you in the drive. I'm not saying these cars in the article aren't good because of the thrills gained per £ but after you have driven a FWD car with a LSD and amazing race ready chassis and a RWD with perfect 50/50 balance you realise what a car should be like.

Therefore in my opinion it's obvious why the Civic Type R's, Golf GTI MK1's and Clio Cups have stolen the limelight. Because they offered something these cars never could/did.
A good ZS is better than a lot of cars, not quite an Integra Type R, but not far off to be honest, if it had a Honda badge instead of a Rover one, there would be many more fan boys. No better FWD cars for the money than the ZR/ZS I reckon.



OllieC

3,816 posts

215 months

Wednesday 19th October 2011
quotequote all
KingPoker said:
perfect 50/50 balance
An excellent piece of marketing by BMW, but not the holy grail by any measure.

thehype

140 posts

222 months

Thursday 20th October 2011
quotequote all
Stew2000 said:
Gotta be a coupe. but also a future classic car. more rare than a DC2.
Good point, knew I'd missed something...

daveknott5

731 posts

220 months

Thursday 20th October 2011
quotequote all
One conspicuous absentee here - the BMW 130i M-Sport - puts these others to shame (though I may be a little biased!)

dudley71

122 posts

176 months

Thursday 20th October 2011
quotequote all
Missing: Nissan Sunny 2.0 GTi. Cracking hatch.

Stew2000

2,776 posts

179 months

Thursday 20th October 2011
quotequote all
dudley71 said:
Missing: Nissan Sunny 2.0 GTi. Cracking hatch.
Depends on the driver laugh

tali1

5,267 posts

202 months

Thursday 20th October 2011
quotequote all
Stew2000 said:
dudley71 said:
Missing: Nissan Sunny 2.0 GTi. Cracking hatch.
Depends on the driver laugh
How so ???? -as Sunny GTi was one of the best handling and fastest hot hatches in its class

swifthobo

869 posts

171 months

Thursday 20th October 2011
quotequote all
toon10 said:
I'm biased as it was my first car but the Suzuki Swift Mk1 GTi gets my vote.
funny you should say that there's one just come up for sale i've never seen one for sale and i only know of 3 left

Matt_N

8,905 posts

203 months

Friday 21st October 2011
quotequote all
Stew2000 said:
j_s14a said:
thewheelman said:
Stew2000 said:
thewheelman said:
Hellbound said:
What about this GTi?



Come on now, we all remember the advert.... smile
They were kind of a let down after the mighty GtiR....
Lotus engineering wins all! laugh

Were they any good to drive? They look so similar to the old Mitsubishi Colt....
That's because they are the old Mitsubishi Colt biggrin
This ^ laugh
Might have a go with one sometime see if it any good.
I sometimes see one when driving past the local Proton/Daihatsu dealership.

Yep, same car, bar a few minor differences.

Here is my track prepped Colt:



Was asked to participate in this feature but due to the car not being road legal wasn't able to.

aqualung666

50 posts

195 months

Friday 21st October 2011
quotequote all
s m said:
aqualung666 said:
I always had a thing for the astra 16v Gte

ok not very good on the corners and if you wanted to stop you had plan a week in advance but that red top engine was grate and pulled like a train all the way
Brakes were actually excellent on these - praised as 'Superb' even in road tests alongside the 309Gti and Gti 16v.

The handling was not for novice drivers, agreed, though as it could bite you back like a 205

must have just been the couple i had as they were defiantly not in the superb stopper category, but i never had a drive in a 309 so i can't compare between the two.

YesItsARover

2,721 posts

166 months

Friday 21st October 2011
quotequote all
Mr Dave said:
A good ZS is better than a lot of cars, not quite an Integra Type R, but not far off to be honest, if it had a Honda badge instead of a Rover one, there would be many more fan boys. No better FWD cars for the money than the ZR/ZS I reckon.
yes

Shed money.
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3256039.htm

Kitchski

6,516 posts

232 months

Friday 21st October 2011
quotequote all
swerni said:
YesItsARover said:
Mr Dave said:
A good ZS is better than a lot of cars, not quite an Integra Type R, but not far off to be honest, if it had a Honda badge instead of a Rover one, there would be many more fan boys. No better FWD cars for the money than the ZR/ZS I reckon.
yes

Shed money.
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3256039.htm
over priced shed
Go on, I'll bite. How is that over priced then? Because from where I'm sitting that's about right.

IrrElephant

30,398 posts

161 months

Friday 21st October 2011
quotequote all
minimatt1967 said:
It's a coupe though.
How is it?



Looks like a hatchback to me.

Jamz3k

35 posts

167 months

Friday 21st October 2011
quotequote all
A Beetle RSi...seriously?

Stew2000

2,776 posts

179 months

Friday 21st October 2011
quotequote all
IrrElephant said:
minimatt1967 said:
It's a coupe though.
How is it?



Looks like a hatchback to me.
wiki (if you believe it) says Compact/Luxury. It's kinda technically both. hatchback with coupe styling.

Kitchski

6,516 posts

232 months

Friday 21st October 2011
quotequote all
But Integras aren't really unusual, because every man and his dog raves on about them, much like the 205 GTi or RS Turbo.

I think the idea here was to get together a crop of cars that are usually at the back of most people's minds when they think hot hatch (although an Integra is to me too as I'd also class it as a coupe, same as an Alfa GT or a Calibra).

Cars like the Proton GTi/Colt GTi, Charade GTti, Xsara VTS, Focus ST170 even perhaps? No one gives them a second thought, except for those that are 'in the know'. I also think that you could apply that rule to most of the cars in that article too. And I'm not just sticking up for it because my car was in there! laugh