Wifes wants a Q7....but i'm leaning towards a Touareg...

Wifes wants a Q7....but i'm leaning towards a Touareg...

Author
Discussion

Tyson1980

Original Poster:

712 posts

157 months

Monday 6th February 2012
quotequote all
With our growing family i'm on the look out for a safe, reliable 4x4 which will be kept for a fair bit of time. It will be the workhorse and will most likely also be used for business purposes. We own a publishing/distribution company, so it will probably be used for ferrying distributors on our payroll and helping with the odd job here and there. Nothing to crazy....


For some reason, I just can't see myself in a Q7....The flipping thing is massive for a start...I have also heard it eats through front tyres...

Hence my inkling for a Touareg...it just looks great IMHO. I'm looking at 2008 3.0TDi V6 altitude's and they seem to be a lot of car for the money...


Any opinions? I dont like the X5's and RRS was high on the list until i realized how common they were..


PaperCut

640 posts

148 months

Monday 6th February 2012
quotequote all
From that choice, i'd have a Touareg. But for the money i'd want a Discovery 4

EDLT

15,421 posts

207 months

Monday 6th February 2012
quotequote all
Wifes you say?

Tyson1980

Original Poster:

712 posts

157 months

Monday 6th February 2012
quotequote all
EDLT said:
Wifes you say?
edit: I meant wife! One wife is enough for me!!!!!!!!!!

Stu R

21,410 posts

216 months

Monday 6th February 2012
quotequote all
Try a Q7 before you decide you don't like them. They're very good.

Disco 4 would be where my money went (if it had a nice long warranty), but the Q7 is great despite the image and love of munching tyres.

Blue62

8,879 posts

153 months

Monday 6th February 2012
quotequote all
Went through this a couple of months ago and decided against the Q7 because of the tyres, they really do get through them, plus I don't like the image/bulk. I really liked the Touareg, nice engine and it drives well, but it doesn't have 7 seats so I went for a Discovery in the end, very good car but a few reliability issues already and I've only just run it in!! If it was me I would go Touareg, but I was comparing the latest models, so probably worth checking out the performance and economy of the older cars, found a decent forum (mytreg or something)which was very helpful.

schmalex

13,616 posts

207 months

Monday 6th February 2012
quotequote all
We have a 56 plate 3.0V6 TDI Twig in the Altitude Spec with around 50k miles on it.

It is a lovely car. Returns 28 - 30mpg on a run. The Altitude spec has everything you could possibly want on it (privacy glass, nav, heated front & rear seats, bigger wheels, decent body kit etc, etc). Performance from the 3.0 is more than acceptable to hustle along the road at quite a pace.

Ours hasn't got air suspension, but to be honest it rides very well indeed on the standard coils & they are one less thing to go wrong!

The propshaft centre bearing is a common fault on the Twig, Q7 & Cayenne. If this fails, VW want c. £2,000 to repair with a new part. However, it is an easy job to get it refurbished & costs around £300.

We had a 4.4 V8 FFRR prior to the Twig & whilst the Rangie was a beautiful place to be on long journeys, the VW isn't too far behind it in comfort. This, combined with a tighter and more controlled chassis places the VW slightly ahead of the RR overall for me - granted, it's not quite as big, but frankly we never needed the space of the RR.

We take ours off-roading occasionally over the green lanes around our village & with H & L range & proper difflocks, it is supremely capable off road & will never leave you wanting. As a winter car, it's not quite as enjoyable as our Landy S3, but that's only because I really don't worry about sticking the Landy in a ditch!!! The Twig is very acceptable in the snow, but as always, it comes down to the tyres & how you drive it.

When we bought ours, we also looked at RRS's & Q7's. Personally, I prefer the look of the Touareg, as it isn't quite as shouty as its direct competitors.

Overall, a great piece of kit that does everything you ask of it in great comfort and reasonable economy.



Edited by schmalex on Monday 6th February 11:20

Tyson1980

Original Poster:

712 posts

157 months

Monday 6th February 2012
quotequote all
schmalex said:
We have a 56 plate 3.0V6 TDI Twig in the Altitude Spec with around 50k miles on it.

It is a lovely car. Returns 28 - 30mpg on a run. The Altitude spec has everything you could possibly want on it (privacy glass, nav, heated front & rear seats, bigger wheels, decent body kit etc, etc). Performance from the 3.0 is more than acceptable to hustle along the road at quite a pace.

Ours hasn't got air suspension, but to be honest it rides very well indeed on the standard coils & they are one less thing to go wrong!

The propshaft centre bearing is a common fault on the Twig, Q7 & Cayenne. If this fails, VW want c. £2,000 to repair with a new part. However, it is an easy job to get it refurbished & costs around £300.

We had a 4.4 V8 FFRR prior to the Twig & whilst the Rangie was a beautiful place to be on long journeys, the VW isn't too far behind it in comfort. This, combined with a tighter and more controlled chassis places the VW slightly ahead of the RR overall for me - granted, it's not quite as big, but frankly we never needed the space of the RR.

We take ours off-roading occasionally over the green lanes around our village & with H & L range & proper difflocks, it is supremely capable off road & will never leave you wanting. As a winter car, it's not quite as enjoyable as our Landy S3, but that's only because I really don't worry about sticking the Landy in a ditch!!! The Twig is very acceptable in the snow, but as always, it comes down to the tyres & how you drive it.

When we bought ours, we also looked at RRS's & Q7's. Personally, I prefer the look of the Touareg, as it isn't quite as shouty as its direct competitors.

Overall, a great piece of kit that does everything you ask of it in great comfort and reasonable economy.



Edited by schmalex on Monday 6th February 11:20
Seems i am right about the T-reg then...cracking vehicle all things considered...

I do think the newer shape ones look good. 28-30mpg is acceptable. Regarding the air suspension, I am avoiding this as its one less thing to go wrong...

Your input is much appreciated...

turbospud

500 posts

239 months

Monday 6th February 2012
quotequote all
ive been looking at the newer 245 engined one and wonder it it does the mpg thats claimed,around 40,which is good for a big 4x4,anyone running one,some good deals on lease and prereg out there too

sjg

7,452 posts

266 months

Monday 6th February 2012
quotequote all
Toureg is barely a foot shorter, and two inches narrower, than a Q7. Most full-size estates are a similar length to the Q7 too.

Yes, it's big but it seems a little silly to be wanting a huge 4x4 and discount one because it's slightly bigger than another.

TwigtheWonderkid

43,394 posts

151 months

Monday 6th February 2012
quotequote all
If your wife wants a Q7, get a Q7. Why buy something she doesn't want for the same money as something she does want?

missing the VR6

2,323 posts

190 months

Monday 6th February 2012
quotequote all
Talking to a friend of the family who went from an old shape ML Merc to a Q7 she really hates it, as it's huge but she feels it's smaller inside than her old ML.
Took a 3.0TDI V6 Touareg Altitude in PX a few weeks ago and it seemend like a really lovely bit of kit.

I also kind of think Q7's are a bit chav.

CO2000

3,177 posts

210 months

Monday 6th February 2012
quotequote all
How about an XC90 ? R-Designs are nice & late one fall into the "low" tax rate (£260)

Willy Nilly

12,511 posts

168 months

Monday 6th February 2012
quotequote all
Tyson1980 said:
With our growing family i'm on the look out for a safe, reliable 4x4
All cars are safe, it's the driver that adds the danger.I'm putting a huge amount of effort in not making the usual 4X4 stereo types


Ranger 6

7,053 posts

250 months

Monday 6th February 2012
quotequote all
turbospud said:
ive been looking at the newer 245 engined one and wonder it it does the mpg thats claimed,around 40,which is good for a big 4x4,anyone running one,some good deals on lease and prereg out there too
The new shape one is a cracking car, much lighter and more agile than the first.

Tyson1980

Original Poster:

712 posts

157 months

Monday 6th February 2012
quotequote all
Ranger 6 said:
The new shape one is a cracking car, much lighter and more agile than the first.
The new shape came out in 2010? I cant quite stretch to that...

louiebaby

10,651 posts

192 months

Monday 6th February 2012
quotequote all
May I be the first to suggest the 5 litre V10 TDi?

No experience, but I really fancy one!

Cheib

23,267 posts

176 months

Monday 6th February 2012
quotequote all
I've driven a a mates T-Reg and I thought it was a nice car....good interior but a pretty poor drive to be honest. I've got an X5 which I know you don't want but in my mind it's a much nicer car to drive....admittedly I didn't drive them back to back but I just remember being underwhelmed when I drove the T-Reg. You can get a 2007 X5 for less than £25k.....a lot of car for the money.

Tyson1980

Original Poster:

712 posts

157 months

Monday 6th February 2012
quotequote all
Cheib said:
I've driven a a mates T-Reg and I thought it was a nice car....good interior but a pretty poor drive to be honest. I've got an X5 which I know you don't want but in my mind it's a much nicer car to drive....admittedly I didn't drive them back to back but I just remember being underwhelmed when I drove the T-Reg. You can get a 2007 X5 for less than £25k.....a lot of car for the money.
For some reason the design of the X5 grates on me. Dont know why...I'm probably 100% correct in assuming the X5 is the better all round car.

flatline84

1,060 posts

158 months

Monday 6th February 2012
quotequote all
For some reason the amount of hate directed at the Q7 gives me sympathetic feelings towards it.

a Q7 in 4.2 FSI spec for me please.