quick one a friend opened her car door on a passing car

quick one a friend opened her car door on a passing car

Author
Discussion

Buggerlugz

Original Poster:

120 posts

149 months

Saturday 17th March 2012
quotequote all

said car hit it

havent got all the details but it was probably opened 6 to 12 inches

how will the insurance sort it out

whos fault knock for knock, excess etc etc...



sday12

5,053 posts

212 months

Saturday 17th March 2012
quotequote all
Fault.
Driver to pay excess on his policy.
Sorry.

R300will

3,799 posts

152 months

Saturday 17th March 2012
quotequote all
sday12 said:
Fault.
Driver to pay excess on his policy.
Sorry.
yep, your friend's an idiot sorry

saaby93

32,038 posts

179 months

Saturday 17th March 2012
quotequote all
Her policy shirley?

It's worse when youre on your bike and this happens

Steffan

10,362 posts

229 months

Saturday 17th March 2012
quotequote all
That is the approach of the insurance companies.

Your friend opened the door into traffic. Their fault.

I hope they were not injured

carmonk

7,910 posts

188 months

Saturday 17th March 2012
quotequote all
Six to 12 inches? Yeah, right. Six inches would mean the wing mirrors would have collided had the door not been opened. Basically she just didn't look and swung the door open.

Buggerlugz

Original Poster:

120 posts

149 months

Saturday 17th March 2012
quotequote all

thanks as i thought there goes her excess

thanks

Tonberry

2,091 posts

193 months

Saturday 17th March 2012
quotequote all
I see this practically everyday. Morons opening their doors wide open on narrow streets with little room, and then jumping out like it's normal behavior.


Buggerlugz

Original Poster:

120 posts

149 months

Saturday 17th March 2012
quotequote all

it wasnt swung wide open

SV8Predator

2,102 posts

166 months

Saturday 17th March 2012
quotequote all
Buggerlugz said:
it wasnt swung wide open
So it didn't cause an accident then? Whay did you post then?

Steffan

10,362 posts

229 months

Saturday 17th March 2012
quotequote all
Buggerlugz said:
it wasnt swung wide open
Wide enough to strike the other car.

It could easily have been a motorcycle of cyclist. There could have been serious injuries.

Your friend needs to wise up on safe driving and parking. They were lucky.

anonymous-user

55 months

Saturday 17th March 2012
quotequote all
Steffan said:
Wide enough to strike the other car.

It could easily have been a motorcycle of cyclist. There could have been serious injuries.

Your friend needs to wise up on safe driving and parking. They were lucky.
I did this to a cyclist once except we had pulled up to the kerb and he was passing us up the inside, he went straight into the door silly prick

anonymous-user

55 months

Saturday 17th March 2012
quotequote all
This might not be as you all expect.

A few years ago my friend was cleaning her 306 GTI-6 on the side of the street where she lives and she was lying inside it cleaning the carpets with the door open about 1-2 foot into the road with her feet sticking out.

The door shut back onto her feet and she pushed it back open with her foot a couple of feet. At that moment a car passed by and smashed right into the open door making a right mess of both cars.

The police got involved and it was decided between the police and insurance etc that the driver of the passing car was at fault for not leaving sufficient space when passing parked cars, in case of things exactly like this happening.

TwigtheWonderkid

43,599 posts

151 months

Saturday 17th March 2012
quotequote all
Buggerlugz said:
thanks as i thought there goes her excess

thanks
If she doesn't claim for her own damage she won't have to pay the excess. Her insurance company will pay the third party's claim in full and she won't have to pay anything towards it.

wst

3,494 posts

162 months

Saturday 17th March 2012
quotequote all
NinjaPower said:
This might not be as you all expect.

A few years ago my friend was cleaning her 306 GTI-6 on the side of the street where she lives and she was lying inside it cleaning the carpets with the door open about 1-2 foot into the road with her feet sticking out.

The door shut back onto her feet and she pushed it back open with her foot a couple of feet. At that moment a car passed by and smashed right into the open door making a right mess of both cars.

The police got involved and it was decided between the police and insurance etc that the driver of the passing car was at fault for not leaving sufficient space when passing parked cars, in case of things exactly like this happening.
To be honest though, said friend was a bit daft in your example anyway, she could have cleaned the carpets from the other side from the sounds of how she was positioned in the car, unless she's about 4 feet tall (letting her 'lie inside it' while having her feet sticking out while cleaning drivers-side carpet tongue out)

anonymous-user

55 months

Sunday 18th March 2012
quotequote all
wst said:
o be honest though, said friend was a bit daft in your example anyway, she could have cleaned the carpets from the other side from the sounds of how she was positioned in the car, unless she's about 4 feet tall (letting her 'lie inside it' while having her feet sticking out while cleaning drivers-side carpet tongue out)
Well yes she is very short! 5 foot max perhaps.

And yes it was a bit stupid of her but hey, don't shoot the messenger! I'm just saying what happened! smile

J a k e

1,195 posts

236 months

Sunday 18th March 2012
quotequote all
NinjaPower said:
This might not be as you all expect.

A few years ago my friend was cleaning her 306 GTI-6 on the side of the street where she lives and she was lying inside it cleaning the carpets with the door open about 1-2 foot into the road with her feet sticking out.

The door shut back onto her feet and she pushed it back open with her foot a couple of feet. At that moment a car passed by and smashed right into the open door making a right mess of both cars.

The police got involved and it was decided between the police and insurance etc that the driver of the passing car was at fault for not leaving sufficient space when passing parked cars, in case of things exactly like this happening.
Similar experience:
I was passenger in a recovery truck which collided with a parked car's door that was flung open just as we were passing. The car's driver and the truck driver had a heated exchange of opinions as to whose fault it was, and the police were called.
To our surprise, the police (who really weren't interested) declared it was the truck driver's fault for not leaving enough room when passing the parked car.
It honestly wouldn't have been possible for our truck to pass the car without being in striking distance of the car's door.
Doesn't seem right to me, but that's what happened.

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

159 months

Sunday 18th March 2012
quotequote all
IIRC 1985 Road Traffic Act paragraph 125 suggests that the parked driver is responsible.

RH

V40TC

2,014 posts

185 months

Sunday 18th March 2012
quotequote all
Our Old union rep did this in works van to a cyclist
day in court 3 points
fine and compensation for said cyclist.

Driver at fault.

Tunku

7,703 posts

229 months

Sunday 18th March 2012
quotequote all
My hazy memory says it is the passing vehicle at fault. SP&L should know the answer.
No hang on, you should check when opening a door that nothing is coming, or it's your fault for opening the door as something passes and hits it. If you door is already open and someone comes along and hits it, it's their fault.
I said my memory is hazy.


Edited by Tunku on Sunday 18th March 23:39