Clio 172 Cup a big drop?

Clio 172 Cup a big drop?

Author
Discussion

billy939

Original Poster:

375 posts

145 months

Friday 27th April 2012
quotequote all
I currently have an EP3 Civic Type-R 2003. I bought it for a bargain price of £3000 in February with only 74k on the clock. Now due to my mum leaving my dad my mum is a bit short of money and I said I would offer to sell my EP3 for £3-4k and buy a Clio 172 Cup for £2k and lend my mum the change until she sold our house.
Now the boring stuff is out the way.....Would An EP3 to a 172 Cup Ph2 be a big drop or would I still be just as happy with my car?
I know they are close competitors, but have any EP3 owners gone to a Cliosport and never looked back?

papercup

2,490 posts

220 months

Friday 27th April 2012
quotequote all
I'd be happier with the Clio personally.

I was, in fact; after driving the Civic and the Integra I bought the 172 Cup. Both Hondas have a great engine/gearbox combo, but thats all; the steering and chassis on the Clio is better. More playful/responsive.

Anyway, best to try one.

Seems like a lot of hassle to go through for £1000 though.

RemyMartin

6,759 posts

206 months

Friday 27th April 2012
quotequote all
papercup said:
Seems like a lot of hassle to go through for £1000 though.
What I would have said.

Total ballache, appreciate the sentiment but probably easier to get a bank loan.

fizz47

2,695 posts

211 months

Friday 27th April 2012
quotequote all
Is it worth the hassle? - you will have to factor in costs of changing insurance mid-term -

Also if the new car has bits that need changing or doing you might find it eats into your £1000.

Stuff like new tyres, MOT, TAX etc.

Its very commendable you are helping your Mum but I would say there are better ways in attaining £1000. ( I do realise I dont know the ins and outs of your situation and this might be your only option)

Would it be possible for you to contribute little by litte rather than a 1K lump sum?



DanDC5

18,822 posts

168 months

Friday 27th April 2012
quotequote all
fizz47 said:
Is it worth the hassle? - you will have to factor in costs of changing insurance mid-term -

Also if the new car has bits that need changing or doing you might find it eats into your £1000.

Stuff like new tyres, MOT, TAX etc.

Its very commendable you are helping your Mum but I would say there are better ways in attaining £1000. ( I do realise I dont know the ins and outs of your situation and this might be your only option)

Would it be possible for you to contribute little by litte rather than a 1K lump sum?
This.

Better and easier option.

billy939

Original Poster:

375 posts

145 months

Friday 27th April 2012
quotequote all
Yeah more background information needed haha.....
My cars are insured through a works fleet policy so changing is pretty simple.
I'm already paying rent, but it's not how much money that is the issue, because if I preferred the Cliosport then I'd be tempted to keep it anyway. I'm more interested in whether I would miss my EP3. I love the Vtec raspy noise, the seats and driving position and the excellent gearbox. But as this is only going to be a weekend car and used for the occasional trackday then would I prefer the chuckability of the 172?

DanDC5

18,822 posts

168 months

Friday 27th April 2012
quotequote all
I drove both a while ago and bought the Civic for pretty much all the reasons you like it now, and imo it was more fun than the Clio to drive.