20% off a new car? Really?

20% off a new car? Really?

Author
Discussion

Fast Bug

11,719 posts

162 months

Tuesday 11th November 2014
quotequote all
Sheepshanks said:
Fast Bug said:
Can you show me a new, unregistered car with 50% off please?
Still clutching at straws?
Nope, waiting for people to back up claims smile

Roo

11,503 posts

208 months

Tuesday 11th November 2014
quotequote all
Orangewheels said:
It hasn't happened for years - the only time I can remember is back in 2008 when the credit crunch turned up, one or two American brands getting rid of their fairly dreadful stuff like the Dodge Avenger:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1082181/Bu...


There really has to be something horribly wrong for a discount like that to happen.
I was at a CJD dealer at that time.

Buy one, get one free.

Support money on Crossfire meant it was cheaper to lease one as a demo than the monthly write down on owning it.

TA14

12,722 posts

259 months

Tuesday 11th November 2014
quotequote all
Fast Bug said:
Sheepshanks said:
Fast Bug said:
Can you show me a new, unregistered car with 50% off please?
Still clutching at straws?
Nope, waiting for people to back up claims smile
The thing is I think that you could make useful contributions if you wanted to. Only you have suggested the 50% off claim and only you have suggested that others have suggested that 25% off is common/normal. Read the thread, it really is only you.

The generalgist seems to be the following as percentages of list price: 45 manufacturing, 20 R and D and other overheads, and 35 various commissions. Obviously this will vary between manufacturer and model and also how you classify it so using the same figures you could say: manufacturing, R & D and other overheads and manufacturer's profit 73%, dealers and others commission 27%; or yet another way would be to say manufacturing cost 45%, gross margin over 50%. From what I've heard over the years I was under the impression that the 45/20 cost for the manufacturer was more like 30/45. An informed view on guidance of the real figures would be a nice post smile

CarlT

3,423 posts

248 months

Tuesday 11th November 2014
quotequote all
Let me try and clarify some stuff on this:

- The factory design and then put together the basic spec of the car.
- This gives a price for the std car - the price will be different for different engines.
- the UK importer / NSC will then decide on the relative specs that they want for the UK - so the UK SE model will be different to the French, to the German etc. Each piece of equipment that is added has a cost and this is added to the original std price.

- Each trim level and engine variant will then have a cost price that will the price the UK importer pays (this will include a factory levy - development costs. This reduces as the vehicle gets older in its life cycle).

- The UK NSC will then agree with the parent company the RRP that they want to charge in the UK. This will be based upon the competitor prices, equipment values + the amount of Profit that needs to be returned. This price will have the std dealer margin built into it.

- the UK will then have to forecast the mix of engines / versions etc they are going to sell.. Every single variant will have a different profit in it for the NSC. The more of the higher specs they sell, the greater the overall contribution... There will clearly be a greater contribution the more they sell...

- All pricing is done around the basic price (excluding VAT, delivery and RFL etc)

- the invoice price to the UK is done in Euros, so if the exchange rate falls - the profit is hit massively. A small decrease can have Millions of £s worth of impact...

- The std dealer margin is fixed and can vary by model and trim level. This is known as the guaranteed margin - regardless of the volume of cars the dealer sells, they will have this on every car.

- The dealer can also earn money based on volume, sales satisfaction, dealer stds etc - this margin is not guaranteed and cannot be relied upon to come in.

- there may also be additional support on cars - Deposit contributions or even additional %tage support. This be on a by model or by version basis and generally will increase as demand drops or the car gets further into its life cycle.

- the NSC will also have fixed expenses per model - advertising and marketing costs normally! The margins and support are variable expenses.


Apologies if this is going on a bit, but hopefully might add some clarity to it...

john banks

275 posts

191 months

Tuesday 11th November 2014
quotequote all
Flibble said:
If you're missing it, so am I. Getting £35k off a secondhand car, even a nearly new, isn't that exceptional I'd think.

BMW seem to on a big discount drive on new cars recently though, 15-20% discounts all over the place.
Sorry should have explained more. Being able to get £20k off new meant I was demanding more off used. There were many used deals I ignored. Depreciation figures seem to quote from list too, misrepresenting many cars.

Roo

11,503 posts

208 months

Tuesday 11th November 2014
quotequote all
Sheepshanks said:
Fast Bug said:
Can you show me a new, unregistered car with 50% off please?
Still clutching at straws?
You seem to be getting confused.

This thread is about the margin available to the customer from the retailer.

What you said was:

Sheepshanks said:
There's typically slightly more than 50% gross margin in a car.
Which has been shown as nowhere near the amount of margin a retailer can offer the customer.

northandy

3,496 posts

222 months

Tuesday 11th November 2014
quotequote all
I ordered a new x3 in July, despite the 6 month wait due to demand I used a broker and got 10% off.

Bmw do massive discounts off the 6 series, we're doing 20k plus

CarlT

3,423 posts

248 months

Wednesday 12th November 2014
quotequote all
john banks said:
. Depreciation figures seem to quote from list too, misrepresenting many cars.
Of course it does, it is the only thing that is constant...

regprentice

59 posts

118 months

Wednesday 12th November 2014
quotequote all
Worth noting that drive the deal dont show consistent pricing across all makes.(mentioning as they have been referred to a few times.) For Ford in particular they show 'business' prices net of vat not available to the man in the street. BMW pricing assumes a 'BMW loyalty bonus' of 1k which you will not get if your current motor isnt a BMW.


Sheepshanks

32,805 posts

120 months

Wednesday 12th November 2014
quotequote all
regprentice said:
Worth noting that drive the deal dont show consistent pricing across all makes.(mentioning as they have been referred to a few times.) For Ford in particular they show 'business' prices net of vat not available to the man in the street. BMW pricing assumes a 'BMW loyalty bonus' of 1k which you will not get if your current motor isnt a BMW.
I can't be bothered to register to check the Ford prices but I think that's most unlikely to be correct. It might even be illegal under price marking regulations.

And DtD haven't listed BMW at all for some time.

Sheepshanks

32,805 posts

120 months

Thursday 13th November 2014
quotequote all
Roo said:
You seem to be getting confused.

This thread is about the margin available to the customer from the retailer.
You seem to be confused - have a read of the thread title and the OP.

I suspect most customers don't care how the discount is arrived at.

thelawnet

1,539 posts

156 months

Thursday 13th November 2014
quotequote all
regprentice said:
Worth noting that drive the deal dont show consistent pricing across all makes.(mentioning as they have been referred to a few times.) For Ford in particular they show 'business' prices net of vat not available to the man in the street. BMW pricing assumes a 'BMW loyalty bonus' of 1k which you will not get if your current motor isnt a BMW.
It clearly says the terms. for Ford, for example, it says that the prices will be £250 higher if you can't complete before the end of November, and there's a £1100 incentive based on taking at least 2k on HP.

Ari

Original Poster:

19,348 posts

216 months

Wednesday 19th November 2014
quotequote all
Orangewheels said:
Interesting stuff
Sorry, just come back to this thread. Thanks for positing this, it's helpful.