Commute or Move..

Author
Discussion

GreatGranny

9,128 posts

226 months

Tuesday 27th June 2017
quotequote all
OP, see if you can start early and leave early so you miss the worse of the traffic.

It will be a shock to begin with but you will soon get used to it.

I've done 120 miles a day for the last 6 1/2 years. 80-90 mins on average each way.

Yours will be well under 60 mins I would have thought.

As has been said maybe break up the week and B&B Wednesday night if it's particularly bad that week.

shotta287

Original Poster:

855 posts

94 months

Tuesday 27th June 2017
quotequote all
Thanks folks.

Certainly leaning to driving there and back and as some of you have pointed out, A38 seems best bet. B&B once a week maybe to break things up, I'll see!

Times like this I wish I could just buy an old barge like a 7 series or S Class and waft along but impossible (I'm 23!).

JB!

5,254 posts

180 months

Tuesday 27th June 2017
quotequote all
Derby conference centre does some cheap deals on long stay rooms, so you could do 4 nights a week and just drive back down to brum friday night.

Depends on what you actually do midweek as to if you'll notice.

Otherwise, cheap TD barge and cash in.

padhinbed

141 posts

150 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
I travelled from Birmingham (Moseley) to Derby (DE21) daily for 2 years. It isn't a bad run and you soon get accustomed to it. I found from mine that the best route was going through Solihull, on to the M42 at J5 and then go straight up and come off at the M1. I would avoid the A38 as, although it was 3 miles shorter, the general traffic speed meant it took longer.

As mentioned, time of departure is key. Leave at 6am and I could be there for just after 7. Leave at 6:30 and it would be gone 8am by the time I would arrive. Likewise on the reverse journey, avoid M42 J6-J4 between 5-6pm. I would often come off at J6 and then use the A45 to get to somewhere closer to home.

As it's only temp, just enjoy the drive. Get yourself Spotify and a decent playlist.

If you need any more advice, feel free to drop me a PM, I still do the commute couple of times a week although I now live further south.

HannsG

3,045 posts

134 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
I do Wolverhampton to Coventry on the train every day. Some people are shocked at the 'long commute'. It takes around 1.5hrs door to door


Boosted LS1

21,187 posts

260 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
The M42 is more of a dual carriageway then motorway and can be interesting to drive on. The M1 can be bland. As suggested elsewhere the A38 may be suitable, it's a fast bit of road if you want to hoof it along.

bmw320ci

595 posts

226 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
Boosted LS1 said:
The M42 is more of a dual carriageway then motorway and can be interesting to drive on. The M1 can be bland. As suggested elsewhere the A38 may be suitable, it's a fast bit of road if you want to hoof it along.
was going to mention that also, that M42 is a complete nightmare with trucks overtaking at the same speed.

I lived in Catshill near Bromsgrove and worked for East Midlands electricty in Notts. even though its only 42 miles its 42 miles too long with the M42 dual carrigaeway and then there is the crappy M1 that road has the butterfly affect, someone sneezes in leeds and the tail backs go back to the M25

Hoofy

76,358 posts

282 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
How long will the motorway drive actually be? I'd rather do 45 minutes of motorway driving than 45 minutes of city/town driving any day. It's far less tiresome than town driving. I often take a longer route on straight roads for one regular journey simply because it's easier.

bmw320ci

595 posts

226 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
Hoofy said:
How long will the motorway drive actually be? I'd rather do 45 minutes of motorway driving than 45 minutes of city/town driving any day. It's far less tiresome than town driving. I often take a longer route on straight roads for one regular journey simply because it's easier.
have you ever driven the M42? Drive it then make a comment lol its horrendous!!!!

2gins

2,839 posts

162 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
Over 6 months their offer is about £4700 based on the full 84 miles/day.

The extra fuel cost is about £1200 assuming 40 mpg and £1.20/L

So you're up £3.5k or £580 /month (before tax)

Maybe:

See if they'll give you a cost of living pay rise close to that instead, so you could take a short term let there (maybe let your place in BHam out as well)

See if they'll let you compress your hours to do a 4 day week, shaves 20% off the fuel bill (but also means you're guaranteed to hit the traffic in one direction). I do this, its a long day but in my case preferable to another £380 /month on childcare

See if you can switch your hours to 7-3 - the early start won't be fun in winter but you'll be driving home in daylight ahead of the rush.

I used to do 40 miles each way when I was about 23, it took an hour on a mix of different roads and was OK. Gave me a chance to unwind a bit on the way home, switch off from thinking about work.


Dog Star

16,132 posts

168 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
Andy-IM said:
I1.Get yourself an automatic.

2. Don't give in to the temptation to come off the motorway when things pile up. It's still quicker than fighting your way through backroads when everyone else is doing the same.
Good advice there; I'd never have a manual again, even if I lived somewhere where I never had to queue; a decent automatic these days is just as good (that's a debate for another thread).

And point 2 - I do Rossendale - Leeds daily on the M62 and have done for many, many years. It's only in the last year or so thought that I've realised that you're just as well sat in the queue on the motorway. Even what looks like a mahoosive queue usually only adds about 15-20 minutes to the journey.

Also - if commuting in busy periods - stick to lane 1 with the trucks; it's certainly no slower and usually a bit faster.

We could probably do with a motorway driving/congestion "tips and tricks" thread in GG.


Hoofy

76,358 posts

282 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
bmw320ci said:
Hoofy said:
How long will the motorway drive actually be? I'd rather do 45 minutes of motorway driving than 45 minutes of city/town driving any day. It's far less tiresome than town driving. I often take a longer route on straight roads for one regular journey simply because it's easier.
have you ever driven the M42? Drive it then make a comment lol its horrendous!!!!
I live in SW London and not very far (time-wise, down the A3) from the M25 car park.

bmw320ci

595 posts

226 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
yep lived in Carshalton beeches for some years too, I used to commute bu noe just get a £40 travelodge get in early leave late from work commute on Mondays and Fridays

CivBrum

125 posts

83 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
2gins said:
Over 6 months their offer is about £4700 based on the full 84 miles/day.

The extra fuel cost is about £1200 assuming 40 mpg and £1.20/L

So you're up £3.5k or £580 /month (before tax)

Maybe:

See if they'll give you a cost of living pay rise close to that instead, so you could take a short term let there (maybe let your place in BHam out as well)

See if they'll let you compress your hours to do a 4 day week, shaves 20% off the fuel bill (but also means you're guaranteed to hit the traffic in one direction). I do this, its a long day but in my case preferable to another £380 /month on childcare

See if you can switch your hours to 7-3 - the early start won't be fun in winter but you'll be driving home in daylight ahead of the rush.

I used to do 40 miles each way when I was about 23, it took an hour on a mix of different roads and was OK. Gave me a chance to unwind a bit on the way home, switch off from thinking about work.
The £580pcm better off doesn't count the depreciation and servicing costs on your vehicle though.

JZZ30

1,076 posts

115 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
shotta287 said:
Times like this I wish I could just buy an old barge like a 7 series or S Class and waft along but impossible (I'm 23!).
Have you actually had a quote?

2gins said:
So you're up £3.5k or £580 /month (before tax)
Tax free, is it not?

romeogolf

2,056 posts

119 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
I had a 60-mile each-way commute for a year up the M40 from Hertfordshire to Oxford and it wasn't terrible, you just get used to it.

I currently do 35 miles each way and again, it's just part of my working day and I don't think twice about it.

If you're getting paid 43p/mile then you're laughing.

Willy Nilly

12,511 posts

167 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
It's only for a few months, so just drive it. Commuting can be a ball ache, but moving is a bigger one.

anonymous-user

54 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
Move, why waste 2 odd hours a day of your life in a car if you do not have too, for the sake of £500 a month before servicing / wear+tear, no thanks.

I seriously can't fathom why anyone would commute, as above, 100+ miles e/w or 3 hours per day in a car, what a waste of life!

I currently do 25KM on the autobahn, that is the furthest commute I have had, hate it, wouldn't do it again.

herewego

8,814 posts

213 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
Renting a place for 5 months is not moving. Always stay as close as possible to work, preferably a 20 minute walk. Commuting time is lost time. Unless you need to be back home at night or weekends just relax in a rented flat and enjoy the change of scenery. You never know who you will meet.

bmw320ci

595 posts

226 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
herewego said:
Renting a place for 5 months is not moving. Always stay as close as possible to work, preferably a 20 minute walk. Commuting time is lost time. Unless you need to be back home at night or weekends just relax in a rented flat and enjoy the change of scenery. You never know who you will meet.
Currently in Brussels and go home once a month to annoyance of my wife!!!