Deer collision

Author
Discussion

Alex

9,975 posts

285 months

Wednesday 20th November 2019
quotequote all
I hit one the DAY AFTER I picked up my brand new Civic Type R. Ran out of the verge and I had no time to take any avoiding action.




HTP99

22,576 posts

141 months

Wednesday 20th November 2019
quotequote all
My daughter hit one in her little 03 Micra, earlier on this year, fortunately there was hardly any damage; a cracked bumper and a slight dent on the bonnet, there was a fair amount of fur in the grille though.

Matt Cup

3,162 posts

105 months

Wednesday 20th November 2019
quotequote all
Krikkit said:


Edited by Krikkit on Wednesday 20th November 11:05
WTF happened here, did it drive through a band saw? It looks like something from a cartoon.

Any more pics of it or are they too gruesome for here?

Justin S

3,642 posts

262 months

Wednesday 20th November 2019
quotequote all
Mate hit one a week after buying an ex demo S3 . Not only did it take out the front bumper, grilles and anything plastic, also launched the bonnet hinge airbags . Insurance company were rubbish. Didn't believe him and he wished he took the name and number down of a guy walking his dog , who witnessed it. At the time, the guy said if he was alright and he said yes and thought he had no further need for info as it was a deer and his car. Impact was about 20 mph, as he slowed from 30 in a housing estate . Deer just got up and skipped into the woods opposite.

Dont like rolls

3,798 posts

55 months

Wednesday 20th November 2019
quotequote all
Ahhh, but will your car skid out and kill you if you try to avoid the deer, seems the Sweds have a test

https://teknikensvarld.se/algtest/

Arrrg, mine only get to 67kmph, that is it then, Rudolf is dead.

SturdyHSV

10,098 posts

168 months

Wednesday 20th November 2019
quotequote all
Matt Cup said:
Krikkit said:


Edited by Krikkit on Wednesday 20th November 11:05
WTF happened here, did it drive through a band saw? It looks like something from a cartoon.

Any more pics of it or are they too gruesome for here?
Seconded yikes

Krikkit

26,535 posts

182 months

Wednesday 20th November 2019
quotequote all
SturdyHSV said:
Matt Cup said:
Krikkit said:


Edited by Krikkit on Wednesday 20th November 11:05
WTF happened here, did it drive through a band saw? It looks like something from a cartoon.

Any more pics of it or are they too gruesome for here?
Seconded yikes
In the typical Australian way, they don't pull any punches: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2011-12-20/two-killed-...

RobM77

35,349 posts

235 months

Wednesday 20th November 2019
quotequote all
Krikkit said:
CanAm said:
Shakermaker said:
Yes, last month I had a deer jump out in front of me - at about 3pm on a clear afternoon - and I swerved to avoid it. Didn't hit it though, but I did hit a nice solid oak tree and cause enough damage to write off my car.
Go for the deer rather than a tree every time. Apologies to the animal lovers, but trees are VERY unforgiving if you hit them.
Indeed.

(edited to remove photos, as per request below)
Forgive me if you're not one of these people, but as a general comment (not aimed at you both) I find the "never swerve" message over simplistic and rather ridiculous. I was only thinking about this last night when driving home; as I drive 25k miles a year and live out in the countryside where there are loads of deer, badgers and foxes, plus I work in a reasonably rural area and commute mainly on unlit rural roads. If you're confident and capable in handling a car in a variety of situations, then nipping round an animal in the road or braking hard shouldn't really pose a problem; I did it with a fox last week in fact. Maybe it's my years of racing, but I'm assuming it's not and it's just common sense, but I don't find it particularly taxing differentiating between a dangerous swerve and a safe controlled manoeuvre. Sure, it's partly about sparing the life of the animal, but it's also about protecting your car from damage and potentially an accident (it can often be safer to avoid an animal than plough straight in it - imagine hitting a cow...). I've been driving 25 years, mostly in rural areas, much of it after dark, and have hit one bird in that whole time. Yes, I know a lot of that is probably luck, but much of it is just using main beam where possible and holding the steering wheel properly (not with one hand at the top like many people). I'm fairly sure my Dad's got a similar record of just the one or two birds and he's been driving for 53 years, again out in the countryside in an area known for wildlife and managed game such as pheasants and partridges.

soapbox

Edited by RobM77 on Wednesday 20th November 12:03

Hatchoo

211 posts

204 months

Wednesday 20th November 2019
quotequote all
SturdyHSV said:
Matt Cup said:
Krikkit said:
Edited by Krikkit on Wednesday 20th November 11:05
WTF happened here, did it drive through a band saw? It looks like something from a cartoon.

Any more pics of it or are they too gruesome for here?
Seconded yikes
Some very cursory googling suggests that 2 people were killed in this crash. I vote no more pictures.

s m

23,236 posts

204 months

Wednesday 20th November 2019
quotequote all
Justin S said:
Mate hit one a week after buying an ex demo S3 . Not only did it take out the front bumper, grilles and anything plastic, also launched the bonnet hinge airbags . Insurance company were rubbish. Didn't believe him and he wished he took the name and number down of a guy walking his dog , who witnessed it. At the time, the guy said if he was alright and he said yes and thought he had no further need for info as it was a deer and his car. Impact was about 20 mph, as he slowed from 30 in a housing estate . Deer just got up and skipped into the woods opposite.
That does sound like a dear collision

Explorer1959

154 posts

59 months

Wednesday 20th November 2019
quotequote all
A friend hit a badger a week or two ago in a Merc. Required new bumper, lights, grille, and no. plate.

Tough wee thing a badger.

When I worked in north Sweden a moose was the worst thing to hit. It wasn’t just the damage to the car’s metalwork but the unfortunate tendency for the moose’s stomach to burst...

The stench can never be removed.

J4CKO

41,608 posts

201 months

Wednesday 20th November 2019
quotequote all
I got a bit caught in Tatton park as someones dog spooked a herd of deer, not great when you are on a bicycle !

LimaDelta

6,530 posts

219 months

Wednesday 20th November 2019
quotequote all
andyxxx said:
LimaDelta said:
Estimated at around 70,000 hit by cars per year in the UK,.
I'm sure there are loads - but I can't believe that estimate.
That is towards the higher end of the scale but official estimates are between 42,000 and 74,000. Which data are you basing your estimate on?

s m

23,236 posts

204 months

Wednesday 20th November 2019
quotequote all
J4CKO said:
I got a bit caught in Tatton park as someones dog spooked a herd of deer, not great when you are on a bicycle !
Fenton?

Explorer1959

154 posts

59 months

Wednesday 20th November 2019
quotequote all
I got a bit caught in Tatton park as someones dog spooked a herd of deer, not great when you are on a bicycle !


Same but with a herd of cattle on one of the Cambridge commons.

It felt like a John Wayne movie.

Peanut Gallery

2,428 posts

111 months

Wednesday 20th November 2019
quotequote all
I do a fair mileage in un-lit, rural roads, and have had to brake mighty sharply just last week as Bambi ran across the road. I do hope that when the time comes I do not try and swerve, and just keep going straight, sorry animal lovers, but I know one grave where the recently married young lady lies who presumably swerved for a rabbit.

anonymous-user

55 months

Wednesday 20th November 2019
quotequote all
I've hit, and killed, two Muntjac in my 18 or so years of living in a rural Herts village, both on the same road (Winding Hill from Bishops Stortford to Much Hadham), albeit in different places.

Muntjac aren't big by deer standards (think large Lab size typically), but first time I had significant damage to brake lines as it went under the car - and I could smell cooking meat every time I drove for a week or two after it was fixed, even though the technicians told me they'd removed what they could. That was a 350Z. Second time was mostly superficial bumper damage on my 6 series Gran Coupe.

I've had a couple of very close shaves with Red deer, which are a whole lot bigger, but no damage to car or beast both times thankfully.

Many years ago, when we lived in very rural Northumberland (Bingfield) a 'neighbour' (relative term, they lived 2 or 3 miles away, but that can be close in Northumbrian terms) was killed when a Red deer jumped a hedge and landed through the windscreen.


mikeswagon

702 posts

142 months

Wednesday 20th November 2019
quotequote all
I drive almost 20k a year on rural roads, have done for 30 years now. I've hit one Roe deer, scuffed it's rear off the bumper of my 16v XR2i back in the early 90s, minor crack on the 2i, and possibly skid marks from the deer.

These wild animals do have a habit of crossing in front of you without warning, but if we're talking about rounding a corner to find one in the road, what if that was a person, or a broken down vehicle? You'd brake/swerve then, so why not for Bambi?

The last thing I hut was an Owl, which despite their eyesight, didn't spot a Volcanic Orange MINI. It came out of the woods, and bounced off my windscreen, at which point I made some weird involuntary noise before going back.


Greshamst

2,069 posts

121 months

Wednesday 20th November 2019
quotequote all
Dont like rolls said:
Ahhh, but will your car skid out and kill you if you try to avoid the deer, seems the Sweds have a test

https://teknikensvarld.se/algtest/

Arrrg, mine only get to 67kmph, that is it then, Rudolf is dead.
The highest speed appears achievable by a Citroen Xantia Activa, then second is a Nissan Quashqai...

Both beating Audi R8, Mclaren 675LT, Mercedes AMG GT S, Porsche Carrera 4s...

Bizarre

TeaNoSugar

1,241 posts

166 months

Wednesday 20th November 2019
quotequote all
LimaDelta said:
andyxxx said:
LimaDelta said:
Estimated at around 70,000 hit by cars per year in the UK,.
I'm sure there are loads - but I can't believe that estimate.
That is towards the higher end of the scale but official estimates are between 42,000 and 74,000. Which data are you basing your estimate on?
That seems ridiculously high. An average of 110-202 per day?

Having said that, I just googled how many miles are driven in the Uk each year... 328 billion in 2018!!!! That’s 898,600,000 per day, so at 200 deer strikes a day, that’s one strike for every 4.5 million miles driven in the UK. Seems more reasonable when you look at the massive amount of car use!