What is a drivers car to you?

What is a drivers car to you?

Author
Discussion

biggles330d

1,543 posts

151 months

Tuesday 17th December 2019
quotequote all
Steering feel, handling, good operator ergonomics, very organic feel to the brakes and powertrain and preferably a lack of mass.

I've had quick cars that are dull dull dull to drive and slow cars that are far more enjoyable. For me there's not a lot to do with speed and power and everything to do with how it puts its speed and power down.

blade7

11,311 posts

217 months

Tuesday 17th December 2019
quotequote all
SidewaysSi said:
Yep probably me...I am a big nobber especially to those who can't drive quickly enough. Don't tell me you have a Legacy as well?

But as I have a BMW, I like to heel and toe down the box, modulate the brakes to perfection then flick it into the roundabout, feeling the road through the great steering then play with the chassis balance to exit with some oversteer.

So yes, get out of the way..smile
I usually get out of the way about a mile after the roundabout, at that point I'm cruising at 60mph and the speeding nobber catches up with the old shopping car, and uses their straight line talent to put me in my place laugh

Edited by blade7 on Tuesday 17th December 23:09

Mr Tidy

22,408 posts

128 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
Well I've always owned RWD BMWs since 2005 - but obviously never owned any Subaru as I'm not a driving god, although a mate of a mate turned up with a Legacy at a Goodwood track day and it promptly broke. laugh

Mind you my mate's Sierra Cosworth broke at another track day at Silverstone when I was overtaking him in his XR4i. rolleyes (I'll never hear the last of that)! laugh

But while I'm not obsessive about weight, less than 1.5 tonnes works for me so long as it has some grunt and handles well - and petrol engine, manual box and RWD are essentials for me.

I've loved my BMW E86 3.0Sis for over 5 years, but yesterday I put a deposit on a Z4M Coupe and I just can't wait to pick it up.

My early Xmas present to myself! Because why not. laugh



Edited by Mr Tidy on Wednesday 18th December 01:30

Exige77

6,518 posts

192 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
A driver’s car should be a car you have to drive with the minimum of driver aids.

The driver does the driving and not the on-board computer. That’s a real driver’s car.

Early lotus Elise / Exige fits that bill.

They are a bit extreme for everyday driving so for a daily drive, I would suggest BMW M cars to be a good compromise. Yes, they have driver aids but you do feel more connected to the road than the “equivalent” Mercedes or Audi model.

The term Driver’s car has to relate to what’s available at the time. I know many would suggest none of today’s cars are true driver’s cars.


cerb4.5lee

Original Poster:

30,734 posts

181 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
Mr Tidy said:
I've loved my BMW E86 3.0Sis for over 5 years, but yesterday I put a deposit on a Z4M Coupe and I just can't wait to pick it up.

My early Xmas present to myself! Because why not. laugh
Great news! beer

At last! biggrin

Enjoy picking it up and I look forward to your views on it and seeing some pics of it. smile

Gary C

12,489 posts

180 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
Exige77 said:
A driver’s car should be a car you have to drive with the minimum of driver aids.

The driver does the driving and not the on-board computer. That’s a real driver’s car.

Early lotus Elise / Exige fits that bill.

They are a bit extreme for everyday driving so for a daily drive, I would suggest BMW M cars to be a good compromise. Yes, they have driver aids but you do feel more connected to the road than the “equivalent” Mercedes or Audi model.
Funny that people rate M cars as 'drivers' cars. I find them heavy and inert. Great cars, fast, easy to drive, cover ground well, but not to me a 'drivers' car (well, an E30 maybe).

Which means that the phrase 'drivers car' is about as meaningless as any other smile

MikeM6

5,008 posts

103 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
Mr Tidy said:
I've loved my BMW E86 3.0Sis for over 5 years, but yesterday I put a deposit on a Z4M Coupe and I just can't wait to pick it up.

My early Xmas present to myself! Because why not. laugh
Awesome, looking forward some pics when you get it! When do you pick it up?

MikeM6

5,008 posts

103 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
Gary C said:
Funny that people rate M cars as 'drivers' cars. I find them heavy and inert. Great cars, fast, easy to drive, cover ground well, but not to me a 'drivers' car (well, an E30 maybe).

Which means that the phrase 'drivers car' is about as meaningless as any other smile
rofl

ItalianHatch1990

7 posts

53 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
light, not to much power, fun whatever the speed

Gary C

12,489 posts

180 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
MikeM6 said:
Gary C said:
Funny that people rate M cars as 'drivers' cars. I find them heavy and inert. Great cars, fast, easy to drive, cover ground well, but not to me a 'drivers' car (well, an E30 maybe).

Which means that the phrase 'drivers car' is about as meaningless as any other smile
rofl
Dont get me wrong, great cars but to me 'drivers car' would mean something like a Lotus Exige so I think it probably means very different things to different people.

Actually, just thinking about it, the think I really like in a drivers car is depth. A car that takes time to get to know it, that you have to master (if you ever do) but rewards when you get it right.

Many dislike the 911 because it can understeer and feel as if its fighting you, but when you learn how to shift the weight about and find that it responds better the more you learn, it rewards you and you want more, if it bites and if it doesn't scare you off, you want to learn what went wrong and become even more determined to drive it.



Edited by Gary C on Wednesday 18th December 20:42

cerb4.5lee

Original Poster:

30,734 posts

181 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
I really liked my Cerbera as a drivers car, it wasn't especially light but I loved the fact that it didn't have any driving aids. It was a car that you respected but the more you got to know it the better you got at driving it.

It was a car that I enjoyed driving slow or fast because it was noisy and you felt involved driving it.

I really enjoyed the drive I had of a Caterham for obvious reasons but it wasn't a long enough drive to really appreciate it. I'd also love a go in an Elise or Exige too for sure.

MikeM6

5,008 posts

103 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
Gary C said:
Dont get me wrong, great cars but to me 'drivers car' would mean something like a Lotus Exige so I think it probably means very different things to different people.

Actually, just thinking about it, the think I really like in a drivers car is depth. A car that takes time to get to know it, that you have to master (if you ever do) but rewards when you get it right.

Many dislike the 911 because it can understeer and feel as if its fighting you, but when you learn how to shift the weight about and find that it responds better the more you learn, it rewards you and you want more, if it bites and if it doesn't scare you off, you want to learn what went wrong and become even more determined to drive it.



Edited by Gary C on Wednesday 18th December 20:42
I can understand you limiting the definition of a sports car to "something like a Lotus Exige", but drivers cars are far more varied and come in all shapes and sizes. A car aimed at the driver rather then passengers, fun rather than comfort, dynamic rather than practical.

Gary C

12,489 posts

180 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
MikeM6 said:
I can understand you limiting the definition of a sports car to "something like a Lotus Exige", but drivers cars are far more varied and come in all shapes and sizes. A car aimed at the driver rather then passengers, fun rather than comfort, dynamic rather than practical.
Im only limiting the definition to me, to what I mean by 'drivers car;

If I could go and buy a car just for driving I would buy a S1 Exige probably. It so focused on driving. My actual 'drivers car' is a 31 year old 911.

I would not buy an M3 as my 'drivers car' as it is to me too compromised and to me less of a 'drivers' car.

So 'drivers car' isnt something that can be easily defined and is confused by peoples perception.

cerb4.5lee

Original Poster:

30,734 posts

181 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
Gary C said:
I would not buy an M3 as my 'drivers car' as it is to me too compromised and to me less of a 'drivers' car.

So 'drivers car' isnt something that can be easily defined and is confused by peoples perception.
Agree with this as well. The M3 is a lovely car to drive but because it tries very hard to be a "do it all car" it detracts it away from being a drivers car in many ways for me.

A drivers car is something more focused and less about practicality/comfort/NVH like the M3 is I reckon. It is all so subjective though for sure.

SidewaysSi

10,742 posts

235 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
M cars really are boring. I wouldn't call them driver's cars at all. Well not anything built after 2005 at any rate .

MikeM6

5,008 posts

103 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
SidewaysSi said:
M cars really are boring. I wouldn't call them driver's cars at all. Well not anything built after 2005 at any rate .
Mine isn't boring. Quite the opposite actually

mcelliott

8,676 posts

182 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
When I was younger I owned a mini 850cc, and a 205 1.9, both really fun cars to drive.

nipsips

1,163 posts

136 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
Judging by the hot hatch thread a 00> Renault Clio is all you need laugh

SidewaysSi

10,742 posts

235 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
MikeM6 said:
SidewaysSi said:
M cars really are boring. I wouldn't call them driver's cars at all. Well not anything built after 2005 at any rate .
Mine isn't boring. Quite the opposite actually
You obviously have a higher boredom threshold than me.

Burgerbob

485 posts

78 months

Wednesday 18th December 2019
quotequote all
To me, a true driver's car is one that puts the thrill of driving central to the design of the car.

This gives a very short list of cars