RE: Gordon Murray: 'Last flag-waver of a great V12'

RE: Gordon Murray: 'Last flag-waver of a great V12'

Author
Discussion

emss

82 posts

149 months

Sunday 28th February 2021
quotequote all
Hi,

leef44 said:
This concept is still for sale and in the interview he said they are not considering mass car production business.
<snip>
I get the point and completely understand his reluctance.
So the only solution to see T43 hit the road one day would rely on a major automotive group deciding to revive a glory of the past (Stellantis/Abarth, Stellantis/Lancia ?) or create a showcase for an existing brand (Ford, Stellantis/Alfa Romeo)...
I guess this probably won't happen, then.

Éric

CoffeePls

99 posts

39 months

Sunday 28th February 2021
quotequote all
Uncle John said:
I get it with Murray, but all the faux staged cheesiness does get tiring.
+1. So much hype, and it's seemingly like that with everything he does. It will be unpopular to criticise someone with a list of accomplishments as illustrious as his - but I'm finding so much drip feeding of his projects to be tedious now. I don't think I've seen any of his contributions actually on the road - it's not relevant enough to me for me to emotionally invest in the drip feed. Does he really need to do that to find buyers? The latest was a "virtual drive" of the T50 in Evo - that was a hype/BS tipping point for me. Might as well do a track review via Gran Turismo then.

I'm sure that the T50 will be amazing though. If/when it actually arrives.

redroadster

1,743 posts

233 months

Sunday 28th February 2021
quotequote all
BurtonLazars said:
How many Lithuanian models and carry-on luggage can you fit in an Ultima? How would the journey be from London to Le Mans?
Many owners take there cars over to le man's with luggage, there is a spare seat for a girl, if u need more hire one at other end, u have not replied actually about what I asked just made up some nonsense response.

BurtonLazars

579 posts

45 months

Sunday 28th February 2021
quotequote all
redroadster said:
Many owners take there cars over to le man's with luggage, there is a spare seat for a girl, if u need more hire one at other end, u have not replied actually about what I asked just made up some nonsense response.
It wasn’t a nonsense response - my point is that you can’t be serious that a T50 and an ultima are comparable cars to be bought by the same type of person? Totally rediculous comparison, whether or not they have the same power/ weight.

(I’m with you on the “if it flies, floats, or fks - hire it”, though wink)

rodericb

6,764 posts

127 months

Sunday 28th February 2021
quotequote all
hornbaek said:
BurtonLazars said:
hornbaek said:
Sad that all his talent is spent on something that is past its sell by date the day it roles out of the factory door. The F1 was ahead of its time and still today is pushing the envelope of what is possible with a naturally aspirated engine combining all the aero, lightness and drive ability into one design that is defying the passage of time.
Can you confirm you’re saying (?) that “the T50 is past its sell by date”, but the F1 is “still today pushing the envelope of what’s possible”? And that you think the F1 has better “aero, lightness and drive ability” than the T50.

hornbaek said:
Sadly with this new one he is at the dinosaur end of the V12 engine. Imagine if he had built something with the vision of the F1 that he had at the time.
Are you suggesting the T50 should have been an EV?
You are misunderstanding me. You need to add “at the time” into the equation. The F1 was leading in every department at the time of its launch. The T50 is not - and only has another 5-10 years to leave its mark before legislation takes it out of play. I see that as a missed opportunity to create something great which will live on into the future - such as the F1. That is also the reason why the F1 costs 3-4x more than the T50.
For the distances the entire fleet of this car will do in a year, the emissions would most likely be less than a plane load of weekenders off to the Costa del Sol because they can or a ship load of yet more consumer goods cum landfill from China, both of which are perfectly okay in witch hunt 2021 it seems. Nevermind, beyond 2030 I reckon you'll be able to get live updates of those dirty enthusiasts firing up their planet killers and you'll be able to flail about on the ground gasping for air or blockade the road.

Terminator X

15,103 posts

205 months

Sunday 28th February 2021
quotequote all
big_rob_sydney said:
Agree that current BEVs are too heavy. However, that will change. When we get solid state batteries, and then move on to capacitors, we may well see some pretty remarkable things...
Miraculous Battery Technology no doubt due in 2022.

TX.

Gareth9702

370 posts

133 months

Monday 1st March 2021
quotequote all
Does a working T50 or T50s exist yet?

redroadster

1,743 posts

233 months

Monday 1st March 2021
quotequote all
BurtonLazars said:
It wasn’t a nonsense response - my point is that you can’t be serious that a T50 and an ultima are comparable cars to be bought by the same type of person? Totally rediculous comparison, whether or not they have the same power/ weight.

(I’m with you on the “if it flies, floats, or fks - hire it”, though wink)
Just like all performance cars are tested against each other, I'm suggesting that the ultima would against the clock be as quick as multi million pound cars, so yes I think it's a relevant point, people buying these super cars are not using them to there potential they are investors just like buying art pieces, for more normal people or joint buyers an ultima is use able and affordable with prob same exhilaration just not the high tech or snob value.

anonymous-user

55 months

Monday 1st March 2021
quotequote all
redroadster said:
BurtonLazars said:
It wasn’t a nonsense response - my point is that you can’t be serious that a T50 and an ultima are comparable cars to be bought by the same type of person? Totally rediculous comparison, whether or not they have the same power/ weight.

(I’m with you on the “if it flies, floats, or fks - hire it”, though wink)
Just like all performance cars are tested against each other, I'm suggesting that the ultima would against the clock be as quick as multi million pound cars, so yes I think it's a relevant point, people buying these super cars are not using them to there potential they are investors just like buying art pieces, for more normal people or joint buyers an ultima is use able and affordable with prob same exhilaration just not the high tech or snob value.
I'm hoping that Gordons cars go better than his Hawaiian shirt collection..

BurtonLazars

579 posts

45 months

Monday 1st March 2021
quotequote all
redroadster said:
Just like all performance cars are tested against each other, I'm suggesting that the ultima would against the clock be as quick as multi million pound cars, so yes I think it's a relevant point, people buying these super cars are not using them to there potential they are investors just like buying art pieces, for more normal people or joint buyers an ultima is use able and affordable with prob same exhilaration just not the high tech or snob value.
What would you learn from a road test of ultima vs T50? (Let’s assume the outcome is that the ultima is slightly faster around a track, at 0-60, and 0-100-0)?

I disagree that an ultima is as useable as a T50. ...but I agree with your point that an ultima gives access to a t50 “like” track driving experience.

Edited by BurtonLazars on Monday 1st March 13:29

SpeckledJim

31,608 posts

254 months

Monday 1st March 2021
quotequote all
_Neal_ said:
robsco said:
GM is a master of self promotion; full of his own importance (and rightfully so!), a few poetically judged statements and namedropping the F1 and he has keyboard warriors globally squeezing their tinkles. This car is an astonishing achievement, but it is a trinket. The majority will be kept stored, never to see the light of day. Removing the emotion, it is nowhere near as great an achievement as a manufacturer that can build a high quality family car that can sustain years and years of abuse, over hundreds of thousands of miles in radically changing conditions, whilst doing so profitably and on a huge scale.

That's not to take away from the fact that this is the most exciting project probably since the F1, I sincerely hope GM is around to see the first customer cars delivered.
Good post, agree with all that. I've struggled to read anything GM comes out with for a little while now to be honest. Since an Article in (I think Evo) back in the mid 2000s where he said (I'm paraphrasing) "Horacio Pagani is incredible, he reminds me of me" it's all been much of the same.
He's the Brian Clough of auto engineers.


Dr Interceptor

7,796 posts

197 months

Monday 1st March 2021
quotequote all
I'd trust everything he does, he's been making 'specials' for years.


CoffeePls

99 posts

39 months

Monday 1st March 2021
quotequote all
SpeckledJim said:
_Neal_ said:
robsco said:
GM is a master of self promotion; full of his own importance (and rightfully so!), a few poetically judged statements and namedropping the F1 and he has keyboard warriors globally squeezing their tinkles. This car is an astonishing achievement, but it is a trinket. The majority will be kept stored, never to see the light of day. Removing the emotion, it is nowhere near as great an achievement as a manufacturer that can build a high quality family car that can sustain years and years of abuse, over hundreds of thousands of miles in radically changing conditions, whilst doing so profitably and on a huge scale.

That's not to take away from the fact that this is the most exciting project probably since the F1, I sincerely hope GM is around to see the first customer cars delivered.
Good post, agree with all that. I've struggled to read anything GM comes out with for a little while now to be honest. Since an Article in (I think Evo) back in the mid 2000s where he said (I'm paraphrasing) "Horacio Pagani is incredible, he reminds me of me" it's all been much of the same.
He's the Brian Clough of auto engineers.
The F1 was ground breaking. Phenomenal. Everyone thought that it could never be beaten, not just because of its numbers but also its purity, sound, styling, innovation etc. etc. That followed the multitude of F1 racers, and was followed by the Rocket, all of which can be described in the same way.

The T50 just puts me in mind of a Greatest Hits album. You know you're going to love it, it will have all the old favourites, maybe a token new track here and there to promote sales - but nothing really new that moves things forward. The tracks have gone from cutting edge to "classic", and others have stepped forward to move the game on.

DrJNA

62 posts

71 months

Monday 1st March 2021
quotequote all
Always bugs me when people expect to be called by their Honorary titles... Gordon, you're not a proper Professor!

anonymous-user

55 months

Monday 1st March 2021
quotequote all
BurtonLazars said:
redroadster said:
Just like all performance cars are tested against each other, I'm suggesting that the ultima would against the clock be as quick as multi million pound cars, so yes I think it's a relevant point, people buying these super cars are not using them to there potential they are investors just like buying art pieces, for more normal people or joint buyers an ultima is use able and affordable with prob same exhilaration just not the high tech or snob value.
What would you learn from a road test of ultima vs T50? (Let’s assume the outcome is that the ultima is slightly faster around a track, at 0-60, and 0-100-0)?

I disagree that an ultima is as useable as a T50. ...but I agree with your point that an ultima gives access to a t50 “like” track driving experience.

Edited by BurtonLazars on Monday 1st March 13:29
How can you say that when a T50 hasn't even turned a wheel?

BurtonLazars

579 posts

45 months

Monday 1st March 2021
quotequote all
ThePackMan said:
How can you say that when a T50 hasn't even turned a wheel?
Power to weight ratio and “like” being a fuzzy term. I was trying to show understood the point of view of the person to whom I was replying. I don’t agree with it, of course.

anonymous-user

55 months

Monday 1st March 2021
quotequote all
BurtonLazars said:
ThePackMan said:
How can you say that when a T50 hasn't even turned a wheel?
Power to weight ratio and “like” being a fuzzy term. I was trying to show understood the point of view of the person to whom I was replying. I don’t agree with it, of course.
That makes “like” zero sense..

BurtonLazars

579 posts

45 months

Monday 1st March 2021
quotequote all
ThePackMan said:
That makes “like” zero sense..
Well, I’m sorry - I can explain it to you but I can’t understand it for you.

PH User

22,154 posts

109 months

Monday 1st March 2021
quotequote all
Could you explain it to me as well please?

Ian-b468s

2 posts

88 months

Monday 1st March 2021
quotequote all
Why were we not allowed to see the Gordon Murray exhibition a couple of years ago!