More cars belching black smoke than ever?

More cars belching black smoke than ever?

Author
Discussion

FiF

44,121 posts

252 months

Friday 19th August 2022
quotequote all
njw1 said:
FiF said:
mat205125 said:
Rozzers said:
Remapped VAG stuff in poor condition especially bad for this.
It's a scene thing dude!

You wouldn't understand, grandad.
Not doing yourself or 'the scene thing' rolleyes any favours with that response.

In reality across the automotive world there are many areas of specialist interest which others just don't appreciate to the same degree as someone into a particular scene. I'd argue that the majority of enthusiasts across the spectrum see something out of the ordinary and have the view that it's 'not my thing but whatever floats your particular boat then on you go and good luck.'

When that particular 'scene' results in a situation where something becomes dangerous, anti social or just plain illegal then those vehicles should IMHO not be on the road.
Parrot in aisle one please... smile
Realise he was trying to be a comedian but in reality failed. The point made still stands. Parrot needs some lead shot up its arse.

georgeyboy12345

3,523 posts

36 months

Friday 19th August 2022
quotequote all
FiF said:
njw1 said:
FiF said:
mat205125 said:
Rozzers said:
Remapped VAG stuff in poor condition especially bad for this.
It's a scene thing dude!

You wouldn't understand, grandad.
Not doing yourself or 'the scene thing' rolleyes any favours with that response.

In reality across the automotive world there are many areas of specialist interest which others just don't appreciate to the same degree as someone into a particular scene. I'd argue that the majority of enthusiasts across the spectrum see something out of the ordinary and have the view that it's 'not my thing but whatever floats your particular boat then on you go and good luck.'

When that particular 'scene' results in a situation where something becomes dangerous, anti social or just plain illegal then those vehicles should IMHO not be on the road.
Parrot in aisle one please... smile
Realise he was trying to be a comedian but in reality failed. The point made still stands. Parrot needs some lead shot up its arse.
I’m not sure you did, grandad.

Networkgeek

402 posts

34 months

Friday 19th August 2022
quotequote all
My 1.9 TDI T5 camper can be smoky at times. I tend to drive it like Miss Daisy, so when I do accelerate hard a big puff of black ste comes out the back.

It's not intentional at all, it's just the 1.9TDI (pre dpf) way of life. They're a bit sooty

FiF

44,121 posts

252 months

Friday 19th August 2022
quotequote all
georgeyboy12345 said:
FiF said:
njw1 said:
FiF said:
mat205125 said:
Rozzers said:
Remapped VAG stuff in poor condition especially bad for this.
It's a scene thing dude!

You wouldn't understand, grandad.
Not doing yourself or 'the scene thing' rolleyes any favours with that response.

In reality across the automotive world there are many areas of specialist interest which others just don't appreciate to the same degree as someone into a particular scene. I'd argue that the majority of enthusiasts across the spectrum see something out of the ordinary and have the view that it's 'not my thing but whatever floats your particular boat then on you go and good luck.'

When that particular 'scene' results in a situation where something becomes dangerous, anti social or just plain illegal then those vehicles should IMHO not be on the road.
Parrot in aisle one please... smile
Realise he was trying to be a comedian but in reality failed. The point made still stands. Parrot needs some lead shot up its arse.
I’m not sure you did, grandad.
The highlighting of the incorrect use of the term 'poor condition' made things very clear about the general aim point of the post. But the rest of it?

But no doubt you'll just carry on with the obvious baiting which as always is obvious. Otherwise, two word answer, second word "Off!"

Countdown

39,963 posts

197 months

Friday 19th August 2022
quotequote all
Zarco said:
bmwmike said:
Removing dpf's is a proper council thing.
Proper dick move yes
Is it any different to decatting?

mko9

2,375 posts

213 months

Friday 19th August 2022
quotequote all
Early 2000s diesels were putting out a fair amount of black smoke even when they were new. I can only imagine what a 15-20 year old car is putting out now. Just take a look back at the EU diesel particulate standards from that era.

Limpet

6,320 posts

162 months

Friday 19th August 2022
quotequote all
Zarco said:
Spotted an E46 diesel of some description in my neighborhood over the weekend. The thing sounded like a truck. Very odd.
Saw an E90 yesterday that was the same. Big cloud of black smoke as it pulled away, but it had a very odd, deep sound to it. Much as I hate to admit it, not an entirely unpleasant one either.

Had a massive Darkside Developments graphic across the back window.

Edited by Limpet on Friday 19th August 12:05

LankyFreak

670 posts

29 months

Friday 19th August 2022
quotequote all
FiF said:
The highlighting of the incorrect use of the term 'poor condition' made things very clear about the general aim point of the post. But the rest of it?

But no doubt you'll just carry on with the obvious baiting which as always is obvious. Otherwise, two word answer, second word "Off!"
Big bite from yourself there


FiF

44,121 posts

252 months

Friday 19th August 2022
quotequote all
LankyFreak said:
FiF said:
The highlighting of the incorrect use of the term 'poor condition' made things very clear about the general aim point of the post. But the rest of it?

But no doubt you'll just carry on with the obvious baiting which as always is obvious. Otherwise, two word answer, second word "Off!"
Big bite from yourself there
No denial there, sometimes you bite, say something and go on to stand your corner, and sometimes you just mutter under your breath something like "Oh feck right off you pillock" and then just ignore it and don't post

Maybe should have ignored it. That's three of you now, any more silly boy specimens for the PH pile on? This is becoming amusing.

By the way not one of you has commented on the part which suggested when a vehicle or its use is dangerous, anti social or illegal then that is not acceptable. Lack of engagement on that specific in itself possibly suggests something not very complimentary about attitudes.

LankyFreak

670 posts

29 months

Friday 19th August 2022
quotequote all
FiF said:
No denial there, sometimes you bite, say something and go on to stand your corner, and sometimes you just mutter under your breath something like "Oh feck right off you pillock" and then just ignore it and don't post

Maybe should have ignored it. That's three of you now, any more silly boy specimens for the PH pile on? This is becoming amusing.

By the way not one of you has commented on the part which suggested when a vehicle or its use is dangerous, anti social or illegal then that is not acceptable. Lack of engagement on that specific in itself possibly suggests something not very complimentary about attitudes.
I don't like "reeky" diesels, they sound ste, it looks ste, and they tend to be owned by throbbers. I'd never own one personally.

I do enjoy other antisocial automotive shenanigans, so you're correct in assuming I'm an arse.

bmwmike

6,954 posts

109 months

Friday 19th August 2022
quotequote all
Countdown said:
Zarco said:
bmwmike said:
Removing dpf's is a proper council thing.
Proper dick move yes
Is it any different to decatting?
Not much different, no. DPF removal would result in more local pollutants and irritants / particulates and smoke potentially, but decat results in more harmful gases too.

oldagepensioner

362 posts

29 months

Friday 19th August 2022
quotequote all
Wheel Turned Out said:
Has anyone else noticed an increase in the number of cars leaving a ferocious trail of billowing filth behind them?

Slightly knackered vans and 3.5t tippers doing it are to be somewhat expected. But I can't remember ever seeing, or being stuck behind, as many cars doing it as I have in the last six months or so. Primarily seems to be mid-late 00's German fare, usually in a bit of a state.

Just seems strange to me how even with clean air at a higher priority than ever, and rightly so, there's still so many people around unintentionally rolling coal.
Saw one a couple of days ago as it happens think it was an old Disco.

wombleh

1,796 posts

123 months

Friday 19th August 2022
quotequote all
Evanivitch said:
wombleh said:
The mk1 fabia doesn’t have a DPF so will kick out smoke regardless of maintenance/mods. Don’t imagine tuning it and removing EGR/etc will help much, but they’re quite smoky anyway.
That's not true, a Fabia would still have to pass a smoke test.

The issue was all too often cheap genetic remaps that are available on such cars. With diesel tunes it's very easy to get more power just by over fueling and getting loads of exhaust soot.
What bit is it you think isn’t true? Because I own one , or rather the wife does. Unmodified and regularly maintained, still smokes on hard acceleration and passes the MOT every year.