RE: Tesla Model S Revealed
Discussion
Tuna said:
I'm often stuck in Californian traffic jams. Really messes up my day. Especially when I'm trying to get to London.
Where's it being made, and where is its primary market?Hint: where have the majority of Tesla Roadsters been sold?
Edited by carl_w on Saturday 28th March 00:14
I think Tesla are on the right track and making decent if difficult headway into one possible future of the car. I have to agree with an early post stating that the change to electric cars will be a gradual one with more up take as the technology improves.
Personally something that looks as good as this should be given a chance. Heck if my OH used this to make the daily commute to work we'd be saving hundreds of dollars a month. Assuming the range is even only 1/2 or even just a 1/3 of the quoted figures that's still worth it to an awful lot of people.
Biggest problem I can see is the existing electric grid isn't capable of supplying enough juice to everyone to power these. A whole new way of delivering the leccy has to designed and implemented for this to work.
Personally something that looks as good as this should be given a chance. Heck if my OH used this to make the daily commute to work we'd be saving hundreds of dollars a month. Assuming the range is even only 1/2 or even just a 1/3 of the quoted figures that's still worth it to an awful lot of people.
Biggest problem I can see is the existing electric grid isn't capable of supplying enough juice to everyone to power these. A whole new way of delivering the leccy has to designed and implemented for this to work.
Tuna said:
There is going to be an energy crunch in the next decade, regardless of whether we stick with petrol, move to LPG or hydrogen or run our cars on electricity. Of all of those, moving to electricity gives us the greatest flexibility as to where the power for our cars ultimately comes from.
Actually, moving to electricity is just about the worst thing we could do. Some 40% of all the energy we use is transport related so the implication is that we will need to generate an awful lot more electricity to fill that 40% gap. Really, you're talking about nearly doubling the electricity we generate and that just isn't very practical. The government willl need to specify that all electricity used for transport must be renewable.
Someone else working on one here:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/mar/15/...
Someone else working on one here:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/mar/15/...
Edited by herewego on Saturday 28th March 15:58
herewego said:
Someone else working on one here:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/mar/15/...
"The batteries came from Korea, the brushless engines from America." http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/mar/15/...
Edited by herewego on Saturday 28th March 15:58
Oh joy... that'll help the balance of payments...
A Scotsman said:
Tuna said:
There is going to be an energy crunch in the next decade, regardless of whether we stick with petrol, move to LPG or hydrogen or run our cars on electricity. Of all of those, moving to electricity gives us the greatest flexibility as to where the power for our cars ultimately comes from.
Actually, moving to electricity is just about the worst thing we could do. Some 40% of all the energy we use is transport related so the implication is that we will need to generate an awful lot more electricity to fill that 40% gap. Really, you're talking about nearly doubling the electricity we generate and that just isn't very practical. Riyazc said:
it takes 4 hrs from a 220v socket, from an industrial socket it will take a lot less time to fully charge!
that's not a domestic socket for 4 Hours!think about it, 13A max at 220V for 4 hours is nothing like that much (actually ~11.4Kw/h)
(current Tesla stores some 53Kw/h in it's battery, to do this in 4 hours (assuming 100% efficent charge)would need 60A socket)
Scuffers said:
Riyazc said:
it takes 4 hrs from a 220v socket, from an industrial socket it will take a lot less time to fully charge!
that's not a domestic socket for 4 Hours!think about it, 13A max at 220V for 4 hours is nothing like that much (actually ~11.4Kw/h)
(current Tesla stores some 53Kw/h in it's battery, to do this in 4 hours (assuming 100% efficent charge)would need 60A socket)
A Scotsman said:
Tuna said:
There is going to be an energy crunch in the next decade, regardless of whether we stick with petrol, move to LPG or hydrogen or run our cars on electricity. Of all of those, moving to electricity gives us the greatest flexibility as to where the power for our cars ultimately comes from.
Actually, moving to electricity is just about the worst thing we could do. Some 40% of all the energy we use is transport related so the implication is that we will need to generate an awful lot more electricity to fill that 40% gap. Really, you're talking about nearly doubling the electricity we generate and that just isn't very practical. The energy crisis is likely to happen a long time before then. Any trend towards take up of electric vehicles would be likely to feed into our national energy policy (if we ever get round to having one).
carl_w said:
Tuna said:
I'm often stuck in Californian traffic jams. Really messes up my day. Especially when I'm trying to get to London.
Where's it being made, and where is its primary market?Hint: where have the majority of Tesla Roadsters been sold?
Here's a hint for you. This car isn't aimed solely at wealthy American celebrities.
Tuna said:
A Scotsman said:
Tuna said:
There is going to be an energy crunch in the next decade, regardless of whether we stick with petrol, move to LPG or hydrogen or run our cars on electricity. Of all of those, moving to electricity gives us the greatest flexibility as to where the power for our cars ultimately comes from.
Actually, moving to electricity is just about the worst thing we could do. Some 40% of all the energy we use is transport related so the implication is that we will need to generate an awful lot more electricity to fill that 40% gap. Really, you're talking about nearly doubling the electricity we generate and that just isn't very practical. The energy crisis is likely to happen a long time before then. Any trend towards take up of electric vehicles would be likely to feed into our national energy policy (if we ever get round to having one).
Oil comes from minute fossillised sea creatures. This implies minute sea creatures probably contains energy. If you could efficiently gather them up it would avoid all this waiting around for it to turn into oil.
Actually don't whales perform this collection duty for us? How much oil can we get out of a whale?
Actually don't whales perform this collection duty for us? How much oil can we get out of a whale?
EliseNick said:
Lucozade said "Wonder why they didn't try to use some solar panel arrangements on the roof to trickle charge the batteries when the car is parked outside and to keep the batteries topped up. Too costly, too heavy, etc."
My calculations suggest that, assuming you could fit 2sqm of solar panel on there somewhere, with an efficiency of 10%, if you left it outside during an eight hour working day in summer in England, you would accumulate 16.8 miles worth of charge - not to be sniffed at.
The mass would be a few kg at most. I don't know why they didn't do this. (See also the Eco Elise.) I suppose it would be an easy thing to integrate into the design, although it would mean your car had to be essentially black.
It's worst than that - rather than having solar panels it's got a bloody glass roof! I mean, can you imagine the solar loading in the californian sun with that roof? Get into it after leaving it parked up all day on rodeo drive or whatever and the battry'd be flat before the aircon had managed to get the cabin down to comfortable temps.My calculations suggest that, assuming you could fit 2sqm of solar panel on there somewhere, with an efficiency of 10%, if you left it outside during an eight hour working day in summer in England, you would accumulate 16.8 miles worth of charge - not to be sniffed at.
The mass would be a few kg at most. I don't know why they didn't do this. (See also the Eco Elise.) I suppose it would be an easy thing to integrate into the design, although it would mean your car had to be essentially black.
Even with the latest heat-reflective glass that roof is putting lots of extra load on the aircon and adding significant additional mass.
It all suggests to me that this design is a REALLY EARLY concept (more than the PR suggests) and should probably be taken with a significant block of rock salt.
Mr Fenix said:
I think Tesla are on the right track and making decent if difficult headway into one possible future of the car. I have to agree with an early post stating that the change to electric cars will be a gradual one with more up take as the technology improves.
Personally something that looks as good as this should be given a chance. Heck if my OH used this to make the daily commute to work we'd be saving hundreds of dollars a month. Assuming the range is even only 1/2 or even just a 1/3 of the quoted figures that's still worth it to an awful lot of people.
Biggest problem I can see is the existing electric grid isn't capable of supplying enough juice to everyone to power these. A whole new way of delivering the leccy has to designed and implemented for this to work.
The charging circuit can ask the leccy company via the internet to request permission to charge. If the demand gets too high, then the leccy company can ask some fully charged cars to back-generate for a bit to hold up the grid in that area until the demand drops.Personally something that looks as good as this should be given a chance. Heck if my OH used this to make the daily commute to work we'd be saving hundreds of dollars a month. Assuming the range is even only 1/2 or even just a 1/3 of the quoted figures that's still worth it to an awful lot of people.
Biggest problem I can see is the existing electric grid isn't capable of supplying enough juice to everyone to power these. A whole new way of delivering the leccy has to designed and implemented for this to work.
I get the impression that Tesla is concentrating on the motor and drivetrain side though, slapping a load of batteries on there is kind of an afterthought. That makes sense to me, the whole energy storage problem is still in flux but they can solve the technicalities of the drivetrain now and that will always be useful tech.
Hydrogen Fuel cell, Methanol fuel cell, petrol generator with small battery pack, Mr Fusion, whatever wins I'm sure they can adapt pretty fast.
Personally I want my charging alternator to run off a small rear mounted jet engine so my car can look like the batmobile
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff