Which "modern" cars rust badly?

Which "modern" cars rust badly?

Author
Discussion

redstu

Original Poster:

2,287 posts

240 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
I'm talking about cars from about the mid 90s onwards , a time when I thought rust was meant to be a bad memory from the 70s/80s.

How many owners have been suprised when there car failed its MOT on structural (or other) rust?
Year or date range would be appreciated.

So personal experience or trade/ MOT station experience welcome.

My 71 viva , 79 Dolomite sprint both suffered very badly, my 87 528i was much better but still not great.

Why do I ask ? Its because I only run old cars as I never see the point of paying the huge running costs of modern cars as my annual mileage is only about 5000 so depreciation and annual dealer servicing makes it too costly.



Edited by redstu on Sunday 18th October 20:15

Flanders.

6,371 posts

209 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
My Fiesta has some rust on the rear arches. Bloody thing.

finlo

3,763 posts

204 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
[quote=redstu]I'm talking about cars from about the mid 90s onwards , a time when I thought rust was meant to be a bad memory from the 70s/80s.

How many owners have been suprised when there car failed its MOT on structural (or other) rust?

So personal experience or trade/ MOT station experience welcome.

My 71 viva , 79 Dolomite sprint both suffered very badly, my 87 528i was much better but still not great.

Why do I ask ? Its because I only run old cars as I never see the point of paying the huge running costs of modern cars as my annual mileage is only about 5000 so depreciation and annual dealer servicing makes it too costly.


Mercedes, although they claim to have got the rot licked we are still seeing rust on examples as little as a year old!
eek

snuffle

1,587 posts

183 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
Jaguar XK8s are failing on front floor pans and inner sills.
X types should be failing too, but thats just personal opinion.

Matthew_Eames

1,052 posts

205 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
Fords, never seem to have solved it.

supersingle

3,205 posts

220 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
As previously mentioned, Mercedes!

They seem to be taking their brand image and deliberately tearing it to pieces and flushing it down the bog.

5 wh

1,502 posts

216 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
Mercedes and Ford are the worst rusters from that era

POORCARDEALER

8,525 posts

242 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all


Ford, Mercedes...........

Disco_Biscuit

837 posts

195 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
Dodge Caliber, 2 years old and rusting

gamefreaks

1,965 posts

188 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
Mid 90's Renaults. Particually 19's and Clios. The body panels would stay nice and shiney but the structure underneath would be rusting away!

pad58

12,545 posts

182 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
Missus polo rust on the wheelarch and on the sill 99reg

Not sure but i though vw had a ten year warranty on their cars.

deevlash

10,442 posts

238 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
Ford Puma frown

cptsideways

13,550 posts

253 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
C Class Mercs also known as the Corrosion Class - Like Silver 70's Datsun's

Ford Ka even 3 year old ones are failing on structural rust, they are truly shocking


ctid

202 posts

184 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
Mk4 (1995-1999) VW Polos. Mine needs new sills and rear arches on both sides. Needed plated welded into the sills just to pass the MOT.

Everything else on the car was fine, just the shell seems to be rotting away frown

pits

6,429 posts

191 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
What about Land Rover Discos, the 90s ones were awfull, the inners rot out before the exteriors

muckymotor

2,288 posts

222 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
MX5s seem to suffer from rusty rear arches and sills.

PimpmyHotwheels

361 posts

181 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
B6 A4's

greggy50

6,170 posts

192 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
Vauxhall Tigra's seem to me pretty bad seen a few quite recently with rusted to fk rear arches :/

Technonotice

4,250 posts

192 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
greggy50 said:
Vauxhall Tigra's seem to me pretty bad seen a few quite recently with rusted to fk rear arches :/
same as astras, fking rusty st boxes

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

210 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
C,E,S and V Class Mercs