RE: Driven: Wiesmann MF5 Roadster

RE: Driven: Wiesmann MF5 Roadster

Author
Discussion

jellison

12,803 posts

278 months

Wednesday 15th September 2010
quotequote all
Jimbo Deany said:
Comparable to TVR?!?! It's about 3 times their (former) prices for god's sake. Hardly comparable to the affordable British roadsters. I'm sure TVR could have upped their affordability given another £80k per unit. Me? I'd take a Morgan Aero 8. Heritage, racing pedigree, half the price and built in Blighty.
An Aero Eight with a 5.0 V8 tuned to 500 would be best, rather than the V10. I presume you could pull the 4.4 they have and drop a 5.0 in and tweek it pretty easy.

GTRene

16,610 posts

225 months

Wednesday 15th September 2010
quotequote all
jellison said:
Jimbo Deany said:
Comparable to TVR?!?! It's about 3 times their (former) prices for god's sake. Hardly comparable to the affordable British roadsters. I'm sure TVR could have upped their affordability given another £80k per unit. Me? I'd take a Morgan Aero 8. Heritage, racing pedigree, half the price and built in Blighty.
An Aero Eight with a 5.0 V8 tuned to 500 would be best, rather than the V10. I presume you could pull the 4.4 they have and drop a 5.0 in and tweek it pretty easy.
@Jimbo...the price for a standard TVR Sagaris back in 2006 or 2007 was 134.500,-euro! in the Netherlands, a Wiesmann MF4 GT was the same price in 2006<>2007 as that Sagaris and tha Wiesmann was much better quality so for us Dutch or even the Germans thats not truth what you say, maybe in the UK? I don't know...

@Jellison, I believe the latest Aero already uses the 4.8 V8 from BMW the same as the Wiesmann MF4 GT uses biggrin
also a while ago I came across a engine tuner that could get more then 500hp out the bigger and faster made BMW V8 and still NA...I see if I can find that link, then I Post it here.



Edited by GTRene on Wednesday 15th September 19:29

jellison

12,803 posts

278 months

Thursday 16th September 2010
quotequote all
GTRene said:
jellison said:
Jimbo Deany said:
Comparable to TVR?!?! It's about 3 times their (former) prices for god's sake. Hardly comparable to the affordable British roadsters. I'm sure TVR could have upped their affordability given another £80k per unit. Me? I'd take a Morgan Aero 8. Heritage, racing pedigree, half the price and built in Blighty.
An Aero Eight with a 5.0 V8 tuned to 500 would be best, rather than the V10. I presume you could pull the 4.4 they have and drop a 5.0 in and tweek it pretty easy.
@Jimbo...the price for a standard TVR Sagaris back in 2006 or 2007 was 134.500,-euro! in the Netherlands, a Wiesmann MF4 GT was the same price in 2006<>2007 as that Sagaris and tha Wiesmann was much better quality so for us Dutch or even the Germans thats not truth what you say, maybe in the UK? I don't know...

@Jellison, I believe the latest Aero already uses the 4.8 V8 from BMW the same as the Wiesmann MF4 GT uses biggrin
also a while ago I came across a engine tuner that could get more then 500hp out the bigger and faster made BMW V8 and still NA...I see if I can find that link, then I Post it here.

Edited by GTRene on Wednesday 15th September 19:29
A Sag is a much better looking car - and way better with an LS7 wink

When I win the Lotto (have to do it though - it does seem to just be the chav underclass that ever win!), I'll have a Hardtop Aero (can't remember the name) with a 500bhp V8 Beemer.

dinkel

26,965 posts

259 months

Thursday 16th September 2010
quotequote all
Transmitter Man said:
So I should be able to stay with it Al?

http://www.classicandperformancecar.com/front_webs...

Phil
Keep it Phil, it's gold and you know it!

jellison said:
1395kg - Christ.

Al - Nice 420SEAC (it would not be close to the Wiseman though (if the lump is as it came from the factory).
You cannot compare the two. The TVR is a raceing car fro the road and it is not made to be comfy in any way: I like it! But then, comfy for me is another world.

The W'mann is so much more a quality product and surely that's where the money went in.

Jon really: a Sagaris is a nice car but absolutely no match for any W'mann.

jellison

12,803 posts

278 months

Thursday 16th September 2010
quotequote all
Dink - Imagine a 1100kg(ish) Sag with LS7 or ZR1 power - Perfect. You would of course need balls like Spacehoppers to drive it properly!

pSyCoSiS

3,602 posts

206 months

Thursday 16th September 2010
quotequote all
I love this car.

Something insanely different, and I think it looks good.

Wouldn't compared it to a British roadster though!

An E-Type still has bag loads of more charm than one of these.

Jimbo Deany

17 posts

182 months

Friday 17th September 2010
quotequote all
I was meaning the old school Griffiths and Chimeras which were being knocked out for circa £40k+ until (comparatively) recently. The Sagaris is a different kettle of fish but still seems very expensive compared to UK prices.

GTRene

16,610 posts

225 months

Friday 17th September 2010
quotequote all
Jimbo Deany said:
I was meaning the old school Griffiths and Chimeras which were being knocked out for circa £40k+ until (comparatively) recently. The Sagaris is a different kettle of fish but still seems very expensive compared to UK prices.
the pound was very high then...and even such car in NL incl taxes costed about 100.000,-euro in Nl I believe...also the to come TVR Typhoon..2006 see here the Dutch to expect price...180.000,-euro but that car never came sadly.

17 nov 2006 ... TVR woordvoerder Jason Oxley geeft aan dat de prijs nog moet komen, maar denk aan een bedrag rond 120.000 Britse pond (zo'n 180.000 euro).

anyway the Wiesmann is so much more car quality not to compare in that way with a TVR, also the chassis is way different, maybe compare that with a Aston Martin special version also alu mono etc...and then the Wiesmann is very rare too.

but I know what you want to say...wish they were cheaper biggrin I wished that too...biggrin

Edited by GTRene on Friday 17th September 17:22

vintageracer01

873 posts

176 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
shouldbworking said:
BILL PAYER said:
Is this colour scheme an attempt at making a normally lovely looking machine appear like it belongs to Noddy ?
Well im sure Stephen Ireland will be thrilled that there was at least one person in the world who looked at his Bentleys colour scheme and thought 'wow, that looks great, I should do that'

I am absolutely speechless what some people do to their cars.

vintageracer01

873 posts

176 months

Sunday 19th September 2010
quotequote all
ewenm said:
At £100k or so for a V8 coupe, it would be a tough choice between the MF4:


and the Shelby Daytona Coupe:
That is a rather easy one, I think: Shelby Daytona Coupe anytime

dinkel

26,965 posts

259 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all
If it's raw power performnace you're after, yes the Daytona Coupe is your car.

Podie

46,630 posts

276 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all
Love the car, hate the colour scheme.

ewenm

28,506 posts

246 months

Monday 20th September 2010
quotequote all
vintageracer01 said:
ewenm said:
At £100k or so for a V8 coupe, it would be a tough choice between the MF4:


and the Shelby Daytona Coupe:
That is a rather easy one, I think: Shelby Daytona Coupe anytime
Or you could stick with the British offering from Morgan.

ablittle

11 posts

214 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
I have seen 20+ of these cars in a hotel in Monte Carlo.

They were some sight, in all colours you could imagine.

It was the Fairmount Hotel & they took up the whole front of the hotel.....mind you there was still room for 1 Black 458.

Needless to say I have some nice photos, the other thing that struck me was the strong smell of new leather, since most of the roofs were off , even @ night.....not much crime springs to mind

magic_marker

146 posts

206 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
pistonlager said:
JumpinJack said:
Just about sums up footballers! That bird isn't going to look too great either if she has a bump sitting that close to the wheel!
Nah, she has nothing to worry about, her fake tits will absorb most of the impact.
hahahahaha!!!

Re the colour scheme I can't understand why people get worked up. it's not like this is the ONLY combination. Besides, it's in England colours hehe Weismann cars appeal to me greatly, as does any car that holds some unique value in this day of cookie-cutter mass production while having very positive attributes.

Harry Flashman

19,385 posts

243 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
£130k also buys you a Morgan Aero Supersports - but Morgan are missing a trick: despite their its aluminium construction, sublime looks and rarity, the Aero has to make do with BMW's 367bhp V8.

I'd have the Wiesmann, in a decent colour scheme. I prefer the looks and style of the Morgan, but in the drivetrain stakes, it's completely outclassed.

DonkeyApple

55,458 posts

170 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
Harry Flashman said:
£130k also buys you a Morgan Aero Supersports - but Morgan are missing a trick: despite their its aluminium construction, sublime looks and rarity, the Aero has to make do with BMW's 367bhp V8.

I'd have the Wiesmann, in a decent colour scheme. I prefer the looks and style of the Morgan, but in the drivetrain stakes, it's completely outclassed.
I suspect that Morgan don't need the extra power in the same way. wink

Comparing the two cars together does give a good example of my one single problem with the Wiesmann, that it is fibreglass. The clarity and crispness of the lines on the Morgan by using aluminium instead of a mould just stand out a mile and IMHO make it look a far more expensive and classy car.

The Wiesmann would move itself into a different visual league by using a metal shell. I just think it would work so much better given the classical look of the car.

GTRene

16,610 posts

225 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
that 4.8 V8 367hp BMW engine sits also in the Wiesmann MF4 GT

nice to see both Aero 8 and GT (mf4) together, same engine and both nice classic looks.


they make the roads more colorfull...sadly both expensive biggrin

900T-R

20,404 posts

258 months

Friday 8th October 2010
quotequote all
I like them - although this one misses the point IMO even disregarding the gross colour combo - but I'm not sure I get the 'it's German so its design and build quality must be fantastic' ethos. In terms of basic exterior and interior design it's about at the level TVR was with their 'S' models - look at that dash, or the integration of external elements like lights, door handles and other adornmemnts for instance - which is fair enough as the basic design is about that old; it just got a load of chintz added over time that to me detracts from its appeal.

As for quality of finish - Sonax uses a 2003 MF3 as a demonstator for their detailing products and has for a good few years now - and looking closely, the paint finish isn't nearly as good as that of my 1993 Chimaera, with clearly visible ripples and sanding marks underneath.

Technically, what sets them apart is the Morganesque aluminium tub construction adopted recently, but OTOH their application of mass production technology is far more wholesale than it was with recentish TVRs, including BMW front struts. Basically, what you get is a re-shelled Beemer. Which is good in many ways, don't get me wrong, but there are limitations to that approach.

Harry Flashman

19,385 posts

243 months

Friday 8th October 2010
quotequote all
jellison said:
Jimbo Deany said:
Comparable to TVR?!?! It's about 3 times their (former) prices for god's sake. Hardly comparable to the affordable British roadsters. I'm sure TVR could have upped their affordability given another £80k per unit. Me? I'd take a Morgan Aero 8. Heritage, racing pedigree, half the price and built in Blighty.
An Aero Eight with a 5.0 V8 tuned to 500 would be best, rather than the V10. I presume you could pull the 4.4 they have and drop a 5.0 in and tweek it pretty easy.
No, you can't. Cooling issues. I wanted the 5.0 from the M5 put into mine, just for giggles - impossible. Not enough room, cooling issues, and the VANOS units won't fit. Later Aeros use the 4.8 engine which puts out 367bhp - and even with increased room etc, no dice.

Best option is some sort of Alpina tuned lump of the 4.4. or 4.8 - but rather rare, and pricey if you can find one. And you'll still have the cooling issues.