Would you buy a Cat C.

Author
Discussion

NUEZ

254 posts

247 months

Sunday 24th October 2010
quotequote all
I've had a cat C previously. Elise S1 111s paid 8k for it when going rate was 11-12k.

I think there is no problem with it as long as you kn ow the history of the car. I had pictures of the damage to car pre repair and could see what had actually been damaged in the accident.

I ended up spinning it in the wet and going sideways into a post. It was written off again and put back on the road (not by me). So now it will be a Cat C+C

Fire99

9,844 posts

230 months

Sunday 24th October 2010
quotequote all
NUEZ said:
I've had a cat C previously. Elise S1 111s paid 8k for it when going rate was 11-12k.

I think there is no problem with it as long as you kn ow the history of the car. I had pictures of the damage to car pre repair and could see what had actually been damaged in the accident.

I ended up spinning it in the wet and going sideways into a post. It was written off again and put back on the road (not by me). So now it will be a Cat C+C
Not the luckiest Elise in the world biggrin

As you say, it's all about going into such things with your eyes open (that's buying cars, not hitting posts!! biggrin ) If you know what's been repaired, you're happy with it and it's appropriately cheaply priced, then why not.

But, and it's a big but, I don't doubt there are alot of badly repaired, over-priced examples for sale out there.

Ursicles

1,068 posts

243 months

Thursday 29th June 2017
quotequote all
Thread resurrection!!

Ive been looking for a cheap runabout which is a bit of fun, and found an MX5 - 1.8, mk1, honest looking car (and seller seems genuine) so ticks my boxes.

Did a quick car check on it and its come back as Cat C.

Car is only £1k - worth the purchase, or walk away and find something else?

lucido grigio

44,044 posts

164 months

Thursday 29th June 2017
quotequote all
Does the current seller know or have pics of the damage ?

Are you planning on keeping this car a long time or forever ?

Plenty of other cars out there not Cat c.

kiethton

13,896 posts

181 months

Thursday 29th June 2017
quotequote all
At that value it makes no odds i reckon.

My 540i was cat C'ed a few months ago after somebody pulled out on me. Headlight repair, new bumper and wing and it's not 100% but back on the road. Bodyshop wanted £5.9k to repair, value appraised at £5.5k. It cost me £900 to fix and £500 to buy back....


DUMBO100

1,878 posts

185 months

Thursday 29th June 2017
quotequote all
I've heard of a VX220 being written off because no carbon wings could be found to fix it. I guess if it has minor panel damage it shouldn't be a cause for concern

Ursicles

1,068 posts

243 months

Thursday 29th June 2017
quotequote all
To be fair the cat c happened in 2004, so its an old car and my thinking is that its so old now that any faults etc with the repair will have come to light by now?

Dont think the owner has any pics - prob not even aware of it as he only had it since Jan himself.

Prob plan to use it for 6 months and sell it after that - even as a Cat C prob be worth 800?

meb90

359 posts

94 months

Thursday 29th June 2017
quotequote all
I think it depends what the damage is, and whether proof of damage and repair can be shown.

I bought a cat C, but it was written off due to the windows being smashed, and having paint stripper applied to the roof, bonnet and bumpers (I'm thinking pissed of ex). No structural damage, and as its a project it was no bother to me.