The 997 Appreciation Thread

The 997 Appreciation Thread

Author
Discussion

crisp packet

127 posts

159 months

Friday 8th March
quotequote all


Talk me out of it! Had this for years (green one. Wrap. Black under). Hartech engine rebuild. Ohlins set up by Centre Gravity. C2S. Such a great car. Maybe it’s because I haven’t driven it over the winter but thinking about selling.

Buttons to run. Even my then 21 year old daughter (now 26) got added to the insurance for just £40. I imagine totally depreciation proof. Maybe I just actually need to wait for the sun to properly come out and drive it.

Keep thinking selling is right as so little recent use but I also know I’ll regret it. Blinking wonderful little thing.

Louis Balfour

26,287 posts

222 months

Friday 8th March
quotequote all
crisp packet said:


Talk me out of it! Had this for years (green one. Wrap. Black under). Hartech engine rebuild. Ohlins set up by Centre Gravity. C2S. Such a great car. Maybe it’s because I haven’t driven it over the winter but thinking about selling.

Buttons to run. Even my then 21 year old daughter (now 26) got added to the insurance for just £40. I imagine totally depreciation proof. Maybe I just actually need to wait for the sun to properly come out and drive it.

Keep thinking selling is right as so little recent use but I also know I’ll regret it. Blinking wonderful little thing.
Sounds like why I sold my 997 GTS. I really liked the car, but it was not being used and was going to deteriorate, with ever bigger bills. I still miss it though.


ThunderSpook

3,612 posts

211 months

Saturday 9th March
quotequote all
crisp packet said:


Talk me out of it! Had this for years (green one. Wrap. Black under). Hartech engine rebuild. Ohlins set up by Centre Gravity. C2S. Such a great car. Maybe it’s because I haven’t driven it over the winter but thinking about selling.

Buttons to run. Even my then 21 year old daughter (now 26) got added to the insurance for just £40. I imagine totally depreciation proof. Maybe I just actually need to wait for the sun to properly come out and drive it.

Keep thinking selling is right as so little recent use but I also know I’ll regret it. Blinking wonderful little thing.
Why haven’t you driven it?

crisp packet

127 posts

159 months

Saturday 9th March
quotequote all
Not driven because of work route. Been deep~ish water in one section over the whole of the winter. Taken the Cayenne and raised it over that part. Weekends have been mostly grim plus when not at work been at the farm getting stuff done.

Just had it serviced though and getting a couple of other bits done at the mo so hoping I’ll get to reconnect soon.

Had lots of sports cars before this. Various 996s and 7s inc TT7.1, R35 GTR, integrales (3), 5 M3s inc supercharged e90 and I’ve liked this most. Really interactive. Couple of mods so makes a great noise, amazing handling, not so fast that you can’t enjoy singing through the rev range.

You’ve got me talking myself back into it now. Longest I’ve owned a car I think. Probs just need to get my bum in the seat more.

Interesting that there’s been quite a lot of talk on forums about preference of 997s over 991s and 2s. Makes 7s a bit of a bargain. Old enough yet young enough. Great cars.

Mr E

21,616 posts

259 months

Saturday 9th March
quotequote all
crisp packet said:


Talk me out of it! Had this for years (green one. Wrap. Black under). Hartech engine rebuild. Ohlins set up by Centre Gravity. C2S. Such a great car. Maybe it’s because I haven’t driven it over the winter but thinking about selling.
<ears prick up>

Harry Bosch

8 posts

1 month

Monday 11th March
quotequote all
All,

thanks very much for your feedback and advice.
It's a tough call, but on balance, my preference is still a 997.

Yes, the 991's probably a better car technically and there are more to choose from, but the 997 for me wins on smaller size, fewer electrics (hopefully less to to go wrong, most of the depreciation built into prices, prettier? (yes - subjective, I know).

We don't live in a city so stop/start driving with a manual transmission will be a rare event.
The funds I've earmarked for the purchase won't be available until around October time, so won't be searching in earnest for a few months yet.

However, if I see the right car advertised that ticks all of the boxes, I do have a plan B that enables me to purchase earlier.

I'll keep you all posted.

Cheers




AyBee

10,535 posts

202 months

Monday 11th March
quotequote all
GTRene said:
ATM said:
4.1 Hartech
Manual
C4S
Cab
2007

35 grand

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202311254...
thats cheap, such engine 4.1 alone cost a little fortune.
Now <£30k...

ATM

18,289 posts

219 months

Sunday 17th March
quotequote all
3.8 Hartech to only cylinders - 3 4 5 6
Manual
C4S
Cab
2005

16 grand currently - auction

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/176284361231


Nurburgsingh

5,119 posts

238 months

Sunday 17th March
quotequote all
ATM said:
3.8 Hartech to only cylinders - 3 4 5 6
Manual
C4S
Cab
2005

16 grand currently - auction
Genuine question - why wouldn't all of the cylinders be done?

Terry Winks

1,183 posts

13 months

Sunday 17th March
quotequote all
Cost mainly, odd that Cylinder 3 would be done too. Essentially with these engines when the bore scoring does occur it’s 99% of the time 4,5 and 6 with issues, 6 being the worst.

Rebuilding half the engine will see you pretty future proof.

ATM

18,289 posts

219 months

Sunday 17th March
quotequote all
Nurburgsingh said:
ATM said:
3.8 Hartech to only cylinders - 3 4 5 6
Manual
C4S
Cab
2005

16 grand currently - auction
Genuine question - why wouldn't all of the cylinders be done?
I'm guessing it was an IMS failure repair which damaged 3 and they found bore score in 4 5 and 6.

Nurburgsingh

5,119 posts

238 months

Sunday 17th March
quotequote all
ATM said:
Nurburgsingh said:
ATM said:
3.8 Hartech to only cylinders - 3 4 5 6
Manual
C4S
Cab
2005

16 grand currently - auction
Genuine question - why wouldn't all of the cylinders be done?
I'm guessing it was an IMS failure repair which damaged 3 and they found bore score in 4 5 and 6.
But even the worst Man Maths tells you that its not going to be £5K to do the other 2 whilst everything is apart and that way you have a "fully rebuilt engine" rather than 2/3's of a rebuilt engine?

Terry Winks

1,183 posts

13 months

Sunday 17th March
quotequote all
I think it’s important to remember it’s not 2/3’ds a fully rebuilt engine. Whatever work you have to done it’s a full engine rebuild, just without the additional works involved that a full Hartech upgrade would give.

ATM

18,289 posts

219 months

Monday 18th March
quotequote all
Lets see what it sells for. I'd say its still worth a punt if you're in the market for a soft top. I'm guessing 22 grand. Anything less and I'll be kicking myself although I really REALLY dont need any more cars.

AyBee

10,535 posts

202 months

Monday 18th March
quotequote all
I'd say the investment in doing 1 and 2 would have repaid itself several times over in the view that the owner cuts every corner with maintenance! Bizarre decision when the engine's out the car and apart to only do 4/6 cylinders IMO.

Slippydiff

14,832 posts

223 months

Monday 18th March
quotequote all
Man maths doesn’t come into it, if you’ve bought cheap, had a loan to buy it, you aren’t using the car, it’s already proven to be a money pit, the wife hates it (the money you bought it with was going to be the new kitchen you promised her) and you just want shot of it to avert an imminent divorce …

“That” phonecall would have gone along the lines of “Well do the others need replacing, I’m going to have to sell the car now, so just do what is needed to get it running and make it saleable”.

I imagine Hartech and others must have had that conversation many times over the past ?? years.

RiccardoG

1,588 posts

272 months

Friday 22nd March
quotequote all

I think common sense and being realistic also comes to play here. I mean, if half the engine is not susceptible to bore score why spend the money on future proofing something that has a very small chance of actually occuring?

Anyone know what the incremental cost of lining 1 extra cylinder is?

If/when mine is scored I will think very carefully about whether to do all 6 or onlly the weak 3. Suppose it will depend on other circumstances at the time as well, as highlighted above.

ATM

18,289 posts

219 months

Friday 22nd March
quotequote all
RiccardoG said:
Anyone know what the incremental cost of lining 1 extra cylinder is?
Good question. I think their menu pricing talked about machining the block with all 6 for 2950 from memory. You can check their website. What confused me was their 'performance' pistons are sold as a set of 6. I still dont know if you can reuse the old pistons. If a piston has been scraping on the bore and scoring then I'd assume not.

Filibuster

Original Poster:

3,157 posts

215 months

Friday 22nd March
quotequote all
ATM said:
RiccardoG said:
Anyone know what the incremental cost of lining 1 extra cylinder is?
Good question. I think their menu pricing talked about machining the block with all 6 for 2950 from memory. You can check their website. What confused me was their 'performance' pistons are sold as a set of 6. I still dont know if you can reuse the old pistons. If a piston has been scraping on the bore and scoring then I'd assume not.


From their website as of March 2024 (with disclaimer regarding fluctuating parts prices).

So potentially only £550 saved yikes

RiccardoG

1,588 posts

272 months

Saturday 23rd March
quotequote all
Filibuster said:


From their website as of March 2024 (with disclaimer regarding fluctuating parts prices).

So potentially only £550 saved yikes
Good data, thanks for taking the trouble!

I see one bank vs two banks difference £1200+VAT (£1440). I suppose you always need to do the one bank as a logical minimum, then add 1, 2 or 3 on the other side depending on risk apetite / budget.

But yes, even the whole extra bank adds just 10~20%, so you probably would.