When is a 911 not a 911?

When is a 911 not a 911?

Author
Discussion

Steve Rance

5,448 posts

232 months

Saturday 6th January 2018
quotequote all
When you have to drive it like a mid engined car, it’s not a 911

Tony 1234

3,465 posts

228 months

Sunday 7th January 2018
quotequote all
RATATTAK said:
and that's why the 997.2 will be regarded as the last true 911
I'd guess you have such a car? smile

Gary C

12,489 posts

180 months

Sunday 7th January 2018
quotequote all
Steve Rance said:
When you have to drive it like a mid engined car, it’s not a 911
That's actually a really good point.

Driving a 911 has always been an experience.

For example, I drove a 997 gt3 on the track and while it was more 'comfortable' and faster than my 3.2 carrera, it definatley had the same genes, you had to transfer weight to kill understeer, or to get rear traction to really fire out of a corner. drivie it wrong and they become a poor handling, understeery donkey.

I like that it took some time to really learn the car and that to me is a 911.


But I also like that my cars model number is 911.

Edited by Gary C on Sunday 7th January 10:38

Yellow491

2,925 posts

120 months

Sunday 7th January 2018
quotequote all
The response was predicatable!smile
Carrera was used in the mid 1950,s for race cars,shame marketing did not keep the name for special,lightweight race cars only.
The 911badge today is just a marketing tool,look at the r,most fall for it,great cars they are and hopefully i will get to know what the next gt3rs will be like,but the dilema for me will still be do i take the 1973 car out or a more modern version porsche on a nice early road run.

Gary C

12,489 posts

180 months

Sunday 7th January 2018
quotequote all
Yellow491 said:
The response was predicatable!smile
Carrera was used in the mid 1950,s for race cars,shame marketing did not keep the name for special,lightweight race cars only.
The 911badge today is just a marketing tool,look at the r,most fall for it,great cars they are and hopefully i will get to know what the next gt3rs will be like,but the dilema for me will still be do i take the 1973 car out or a more modern version porsche on a nice early road run.
Oh I'm so sorry your lordship.

I will immediately remove the carrera name from any of my cars documentation smile

EGTE

996 posts

183 months

Sunday 7th January 2018
quotequote all
browngt3 said:
EGTE said:
craigjm said:
My god this is like stepping into the Jaguar forum and hearing the old fossils say the the XJ isn’t an XJ for various rediculous reasons. The most hilarious I heard was that the series 2 was the last XJ as it’s the last one to have the eye of William Lyons cast over it. Lets apply that logic.... which 911 was the last one to have Ferdinand involvement? rolleyes The simple answer is, if the manufacturer calls it a 911 it’s a 911. Any talk of “the last one was the 964” or whatever just makes you sound like the last person people would want to stand next to at a drinks party.
So true. This is just the Illuminati out in force and it's very, very tedious.
Well you're here, are you not? smile
I'm Tom Hanks' better-looking stand-in :-)

EGTE

996 posts

183 months

Sunday 7th January 2018
quotequote all
Yellow491 said:
The response was predicatable!smile
Carrera was used in the mid 1950,s for race cars,shame marketing did not keep the name for special,lightweight race cars only.
The 911badge today is just a marketing tool,look at the r,most fall for it,great cars they are and hopefully i will get to know what the next gt3rs will be like,but the dilema for me will still be do i take the 1973 car out or a more modern version porsche on a nice early road run.
Just for you: https://www.illuminatiofficial.org

RDMcG

19,188 posts

208 months

Sunday 7th January 2018
quotequote all
I have never worried about this discussion. The 911 has evolved hugely since the first cars and of course my current car has little resemblance to the old 911S of my youth.

So what? Most Porsches are still around and if you want a 911S compared to a new 991GT3, go for it. For me, the continual change has been fascinating. Personally they are still all 911s. Not interested in being frozen in time. Respect that others prefer old cars

Hung onto a 7.1RS from new as it’s nice to keep a manual. I suppose that’s not a real 911 either for many. Fair enough.



RSVP911

8,192 posts

134 months

Sunday 7th January 2018
quotequote all
RDMcG said:
I have never worried about this discussion. The 911 has evolved hugely since the first cars and of course my current car has little resemblance to the old 911S of my youth.

So what? Most Porsches are still around and if you want a 911S compared to a new 991GT3, go for it. For me, the continual change has been fascinating. Personally they are still all 911s. Not interested in being frozen in time. Respect that others prefer old cars

Hung onto a 7.1RS from new as it’s nice to keep a manual. I suppose that’s not a real 911 either for many. Fair enough.
+1

Fast Bug

11,719 posts

162 months

Sunday 7th January 2018
quotequote all
Mine isn't a real 911, nor are the ones I met up with this morning as we had them out and driven hard on the slippery cold (and salted!) roads and not once did I hear anyone mention values laugh


RDMcG

19,188 posts

208 months

Sunday 7th January 2018
quotequote all
Fast Bug said:
Mine isn't a real 911, nor are the ones I met up with this morning as we had them out and driven hard on the slippery cold (and salted!) roads and not once did I hear anyone mention values laugh

Agree! For me the value of the car is the time I spend enjoying it.smile

Yellow491

2,925 posts

120 months

Sunday 7th January 2018
quotequote all
EGTE said:
Nice one smile

frozen-in-wiltshire

152 posts

85 months

Sunday 7th January 2018
quotequote all
+2