Maddie Goes Electric - A Beginner’s Guide - Fully Charged -

Maddie Goes Electric - A Beginner’s Guide - Fully Charged -

Author
Discussion

selym

9,544 posts

172 months

Tuesday 21st January 2020
quotequote all
robbieduncan said:
I don't currently have an EV. I admit I would like one. Next car will probably be a PHEV (mostly as second hand EV estates are non-existent). I thought it was a really good video. I think it probably represented a real-world viewpoint. Most people are not tracking which cars exist. Most people don't know much about EVs. A fair few people would like to be more environmentally friendly. This video was them
I've not watched the video(s) yet, but I have to get 5 more months of long distance commuting out of the way then I plan to do something with the Skoda estate (is it morally right to allow it to continue to pollute the planet by moving it on - I haven't been told yet). Replacing it will be a 4-5 year old hybrid, unless I can justify stretching to something purely electric.
I will watch the video because I am drowning in the sea of opinions about these things and what to get - however, to counter the comment about the drivers of EVs, it only seems to be the nutcases on here that sermonize, I've spoken to a few owners in the real world and it's just another car which saves them money.

robbieduncan

1,981 posts

237 months

Tuesday 21st January 2020
quotequote all
selym said:
I've not watched the video(s) yet, but I have to get 5 more months of long distance commuting out of the way then I plan to do something with the Skoda estate (is it morally right to allow it to continue to pollute the planet by moving it on - I haven't been told yet). Replacing it will be a 4-5 year old hybrid, unless I can justify stretching to something purely electric.
I will watch the video because I am drowning in the sea of opinions about these things and what to get - however, to counter the comment about the drivers of EVs, it only seems to be the nutcases on here that sermonize, I've spoken to a few owners in the real world and it's just another car which saves them money.
Unfortunately I don't think this video series will help with a hybrid: it's looking at brand-new EVs. Shame as the real world is more about second-hand than brand-new

selym

9,544 posts

172 months

Tuesday 21st January 2020
quotequote all
robbieduncan said:
selym said:
I've not watched the video(s) yet, but I have to get 5 more months of long distance commuting out of the way then I plan to do something with the Skoda estate (is it morally right to allow it to continue to pollute the planet by moving it on - I haven't been told yet). Replacing it will be a 4-5 year old hybrid, unless I can justify stretching to something purely electric.
I will watch the video because I am drowning in the sea of opinions about these things and what to get - however, to counter the comment about the drivers of EVs, it only seems to be the nutcases on here that sermonize, I've spoken to a few owners in the real world and it's just another car which saves them money.
Unfortunately I don't think this video series will help with a hybrid: it's looking at brand-new EVs. Shame as the real world is more about second-hand than brand-new
Yeah, I just couldn't afford a new EV - I've never owned a new car and won't be starting with electric. I have no qualms about asking randoms in the street about their experience; my boss has a Prius which I've driven a few times and we have had countless chats about it. It's no more boring than my Skoda.

CABC

5,588 posts

102 months

Tuesday 21st January 2020
quotequote all
this whole debate seems too charged for its own good.

how are real life experiences of hybrids? i see most of them as tax frauds and overly complex. are many getting anything like 75 miles without engine cutting in?

i see BEV for myself next as a daily but the evangelists should calm down, the network issue exists more for some users than others.

buggalugs

9,243 posts

238 months

Tuesday 21st January 2020
quotequote all
You mean plugin hybrids? A hybrid in its self is a good thing because they get such good MPG around town specifically because of regen braking etc. Plugins seem like a relatively minor advancement over a good normal hybrid like a Prius.

That said I’d still have say a C350e because to me it’s a fast petrol car with hybrid capability around town for the MPG and responsiveness. OK the plugin only gets you 10 miles but that’ll get me to work, and I’ll have a nice preheated cabin too.

Dave Hedgehog

14,568 posts

205 months

Tuesday 21st January 2020
quotequote all
buggalugs said:
You mean plugin hybrids? A hybrid in its self is a good thing because they get such good MPG around town specifically because of regen braking etc. Plugins seem like a relatively minor advancement over a good normal hybrid like a Prius.

That said I’d still have say a C350e because to me it’s a fast petrol car with hybrid capability around town for the MPG and responsiveness. OK the plugin only gets you 10 miles but that’ll get me to work, and I’ll have a nice preheated cabin too.
hybrids are a crutch pushed by a car industry desperate to hang on to its massive investment in complex engine plants and after sales model, they hate BEVs for having minimal maintenance




selym

9,544 posts

172 months

Tuesday 21st January 2020
quotequote all
Dave Hedgehog said:
buggalugs said:
You mean plugin hybrids? A hybrid in its self is a good thing because they get such good MPG around town specifically because of regen braking etc. Plugins seem like a relatively minor advancement over a good normal hybrid like a Prius.

That said I’d still have say a C350e because to me it’s a fast petrol car with hybrid capability around town for the MPG and responsiveness. OK the plugin only gets you 10 miles but that’ll get me to work, and I’ll have a nice preheated cabin too.
hybrids are a crutch pushed by a car industry desperate to hang on to its massive investment in complex engine plants and after sales model, they hate BEVs for having minimal maintenance
Does this enlightenment come overnight or do you have to attend classes?

buggalugs

9,243 posts

238 months

Tuesday 21st January 2020
quotequote all
Dave Hedgehog said:
buggalugs said:
You mean plugin hybrids? A hybrid in its self is a good thing because they get such good MPG around town specifically because of regen braking etc. Plugins seem like a relatively minor advancement over a good normal hybrid like a Prius.

That said I’d still have say a C350e because to me it’s a fast petrol car with hybrid capability around town for the MPG and responsiveness. OK the plugin only gets you 10 miles but that’ll get me to work, and I’ll have a nice preheated cabin too.
hybrids are a crutch pushed by a car industry desperate to hang on to its massive investment in complex engine plants and after sales model, they hate BEVs for having minimal maintenance
Spoken like a fanboy. Do you have any actual evidence that BEV's need less maintainance?

Hybrids are something people can afford and will buy, that removes pollution from cities.

PistonBroker

2,419 posts

227 months

Tuesday 21st January 2020
quotequote all
Thanks for the heads-up OP, I shall give this a watch.

I'm convinced by all of this, it's Mrs PB who remains unconvinced. I may try to watch it when she's in the room. ;-)

robbieduncan

1,981 posts

237 months

Tuesday 21st January 2020
quotequote all
Dave Hedgehog said:
hybrids are a crutch pushed by a car industry desperate to hang on to its massive investment in complex engine plants and after sales model, they hate BEVs for having minimal maintenance
Perhaps. But as of now something like the 350e (which I also have my eye on) is a good option for those wanting a family-sized, estate car. There are no BEV versions of these that I can find available now (especially second hand). Sure there will be shortly but not now. And no, I don't want a SUV.

A lot of my families journeys are very local so the range will be fine on electric mode and whilst the charging infrastructure is built-out and improved we still have petrol for longer journeys. Seems a good solution for the next few years to me

Beefmeister

16,482 posts

231 months

Thursday 23rd January 2020
quotequote all
It's a stroke of genius by Fully Charged. A huge number of the core demographic for buying a new EV are early 30's, male.

A lot of them will know Maddie from CBeebies and will probably fancy her a little bit. That gets their foot in the door so to speak, then the fact that it's just a bloody good mini-series keeps them on board.

Clever stuff.

Fastlane

1,153 posts

218 months

Thursday 23rd January 2020
quotequote all

robbieduncan

1,981 posts

237 months

Friday 24th January 2020
quotequote all
Fastlane said:
Another good episode I think. As a non-EV user who's never used or even sat in an EV it was interesting to see the charging systems, times etc. Sure I could have found all this out easily with a quick search but to your average person this was good info

DMC2

1,834 posts

212 months

Friday 24th January 2020
quotequote all
Terminator X said:
I appreciate you guys may hate on me here but I still don't know a single person who wants an electric car. Where is all the demand?

TX.
Loads of demand from company owners who can buy a Taycan put it through their business and be better off. So please count me as a single person who wants one.

NugentS

686 posts

248 months

Friday 24th January 2020
quotequote all
Terminator X said:
I appreciate you guys may hate on me here but I still don't know a single person who wants an electric car. Where is all the demand?

TX.
I have one

I still want one - just a different one. I am just using the first as a "dip my toe in the water" mechanism

MaxSo

Original Poster:

1,910 posts

96 months

Friday 24th January 2020
quotequote all
I also have one and now I want a better one. I don’t really want another ICE car as a daily car ever again.

SWoll

18,426 posts

259 months

Friday 24th January 2020
quotequote all
I don't want one.

So I got two instead. smile

BBYeah

331 posts

184 months

Sunday 2nd February 2020
quotequote all
Sold my big diesel estate. Bought e-golf. Next stop is to swap small hybrid for bigger longer-range electric car, hopefuly a polestar 2.

chunkytfg

134 posts

182 months

Monday 3rd February 2020
quotequote all
I'm finding the Series pretty good tbh. Nothing on it so far I didn't already know though.

I want a EV but can't afford one yet and for the odd occasion we do longer journeys into the middle of nowhere the infrastructure to refuel and ICE wins.

My missus is the perfect candidate for one with her 50 mile a day commute, driveway and home and almost no need for a longer range. She will probably end up in something Zoe sized in the next 12-18 months assuming we can make the numbers work against a Fiat 500 900cc with zero tax, minimal insurance costs and home servicing.