Advice for a noob soon to be commuting 120ish miles a day...

Advice for a noob soon to be commuting 120ish miles a day...

Author
Discussion

Mikey2312

Original Poster:

141 posts

79 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
culpz said:
Yeah, sorry, only just re-read the budget. C-Class? Saab? Golf TDI?
Have to admit the Audi A6 seems to be good value for money.. I don't know a lot about the engines i.e. which to avoid, which to focus on, etc if anyone can shed some experience?

Sycamore

1,787 posts

118 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
PH won't agree because it's British, but an MG ZT 2.0 CDTI?
Same engine as 320D,
Reliable (My dads is on 185k and never any major issues other than routine consumables).
Comfy
Can easily fit an aftermarket head unit if required - I paid £200 for a touchscreen with TV, Bluetooth, DAB, phone mirror.

You could buy one with low miles and in great condition for £2.5k max.

I'm biased as I have the 1.8t, but it's where my money would go.

anonymous-user

54 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
E46 320d?

Mikey2312

Original Poster:

141 posts

79 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
AlrightYouns said:
E46 320d?
My kryptonite.. the E46 BMW laugh

I'm going to keep it in mind if I can't find anything else... Do the E46 320D's suffer swirl flap issues, etc?

Mikey2312

Original Poster:

141 posts

79 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
Would anyone throw out any objections??...

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2017...

greysquirrel

332 posts

169 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
that looks cheap... i would probably buy a cat D but not sure about C, i would really want to know what had been fixed/quality of any repair. your insurance will be more as well.

culpz

4,884 posts

112 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
Didn't realise E90's were that cheap. Seems pretty decent. Might be worth getting it on one of those online HPI checks.

Mikey2312

Original Poster:

141 posts

79 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
There are a few early E90s floating around the £3,500 - £4,000 mark on autotrader to be fair which seems surprising

Mikey2312

Original Poster:

141 posts

79 months

Wednesday 27th September 2017
quotequote all
Further to this, would anyone recommend a Honda Civic 2.2 I-CTDi? They seem to be going for good money at the moment

Plate spinner

17,707 posts

200 months

Wednesday 27th September 2017
quotequote all
I use a Mercedes C220cdi for a similar commute.

underphil

1,246 posts

210 months

Wednesday 27th September 2017
quotequote all
Mikey2312 said:
Cheers for the quick replies guys!

I've across this but have no experience of Volvo's, they are one of the only cars I haven't owned and I have had many laugh

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2017...

The Skoda is a good shout, I haven't looked at those yet
C30 boot is tiny! - The S40 / V50 are the same car in saloon & estate form

S80s are also surprisingly cheap, and you're not going to get much better comfort and refinement than one of them!

AmosMoses

4,042 posts

165 months

Wednesday 27th September 2017
quotequote all
Something VAG with a 1.9

MR2 Steve

280 posts

107 months

Wednesday 27th September 2017
quotequote all
I would look for a big volvo. I went in one as a passenger and it offers comfort for not a lot of money.

Mikey2312

Original Poster:

141 posts

79 months

Wednesday 27th September 2017
quotequote all
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2017...

Something like this? albeit without the horrendous alloys laugh

northwest monkey

6,370 posts

189 months

Wednesday 27th September 2017
quotequote all
Quite nice that. Looks more than £3k worth of car.

I'd still consider an automatic and a decent radio is a must. It gets very boring changing gear a lot and you can spend a long time doing 120 miles...

Don't bother reading old reviews for these sorts of cars - a journalist will get to drive one when its brand new on specially selected roads. They aren't driving a 10-year old one with mismatched tyres, a knackered shock absorber and a sagging seat. What might have been comfy 10 years ago could now be a spine jarring lump.

Bigger cars tend to be more comfy than smaller cars and doing lots of miles I'd forget about "fun". Getting to work / home is far more important. I've done a big commute in the past and found a Jeep Cherokee far more relaxing than a 330i.




Mikey2312

Original Poster:

141 posts

79 months

Wednesday 27th September 2017
quotequote all
northwest monkey said:
Quite nice that. Looks more than £3k worth of car.

I'd still consider an automatic and a decent radio is a must. It gets very boring changing gear a lot and you can spend a long time doing 120 miles...

Don't bother reading old reviews for these sorts of cars - a journalist will get to drive one when its brand new on specially selected roads. They aren't driving a 10-year old one with mismatched tyres, a knackered shock absorber and a sagging seat. What might have been comfy 10 years ago could now be a spine jarring lump.

Bigger cars tend to be more comfy than smaller cars and doing lots of miles I'd forget about "fun". Getting to work / home is far more important. I've done a big commute in the past and found a Jeep Cherokee far more relaxing than a 330i.
I don't know if I'm narrowing it down or adding to the list.. The S40 is a nice motor but forums report poor fuel consumption so I'm back to the C30... as long as the boot isn't any smaller than the fiesta then I can cope with it.. I'm on the wavelength of... lighter car + same engine as S40 = better mpg... someone please correct me if I'm wrong?

My list stands now at..

Volvo C30 2.0 D R-Design
Volvo S40 2.0 D SE Sport (If I can get some facts on mpg)
Honda Civic 2.2 I-CDTi (either EX or Type S)
Audi A4 2.0 TDI
Audi A6 2.0 TDI

I figure I can always add a parrot kit to the car I buy if it doesn't come with many gadgets like the C30

SVX

2,182 posts

211 months

Wednesday 27th September 2017
quotequote all
If I was commuting that distance, and I'm glad I don't anymore - my money would be all over the best Volvo S60 D5 auto I could find.

exelero

1,890 posts

89 months

Wednesday 27th September 2017
quotequote all
Did you consider S60 D5? For 4k you can get a lovely one and it can do moon miles with routine maintenance.

Mikey2312

Original Poster:

141 posts

79 months

Wednesday 27th September 2017
quotequote all
disregarding the boot space, are the C30 seats different to that in the bigger variants like S40/S60?

I'm quite liking the S40 at the moment

culpz

4,884 posts

112 months

Wednesday 27th September 2017
quotequote all
Mikey2312 said:
My list stands now at..

Volvo C30 2.0 D R-Design
Volvo S40 2.0 D SE Sport (If I can get some facts on mpg)
Honda Civic 2.2 I-CDTi (either EX or Type S)
Audi A4 2.0 TDI
Audi A6 2.0 TDI
The Volvo's look like a decent bet but i don't know that much about them and I've heard that certain engines are a no go and suffer various issues. I'm not sure if the C30 and S40 with those particular engines are specifically troublesome though.

I'd never personally touch a Honda with a diesel engine. Similar to Lexus really, it's not their forte and they tend to be uneconomical and unreliable compared to their petrol variants.

The A6 looks like a good shout. It will be a huge step up from the Fiesta and very comfortable, wafty and at-home chewing up the motorway miles nicely. It's quite a big barge though and could be pretty expensive to repair.

So, i'd probably go for the A4 out of that lot. It's just like the A6 but a bit smaller, lighter and probably a bit cheaper to run and maintain.