M140 Shadow Edition - just gone and ordered one

M140 Shadow Edition - just gone and ordered one

Author
Discussion

anonymous-user

55 months

Sunday 24th March 2019
quotequote all
I guess the massive discounts are there simply because the car doesn’t sell enough. It’s a 1 Series which always struggles for popularity against more mainstream alternatives like the Golf and Focus, and it has a bloody great six cylinder engine in it which isn’t exactly a mainstream proposition either.

Add to that, some rather luke warm reviews from the motoring world with regards its handling and whether it’s actually fun to drive or a bit of a detached experience, and you end up needing to make it very attractive price-wise in order to sell it.

This is all coming from a 1 Series owner so I have no axe to grind with BMW, the 1 Series or the M135i/140i.

Driver101

14,376 posts

122 months

Sunday 24th March 2019
quotequote all
sotonjoe said:
I guess the massive discounts are there simply because the car doesn’t sell enough. It’s a 1 Series which always struggles for popularity against more mainstream alternatives like the Golf and Focus, and it has a bloody great six cylinder engine in it which isn’t exactly a mainstream proposition either.

Add to that, some rather luke warm reviews from the motoring world with regards its handling and whether it’s actually fun to drive or a bit of a detached experience, and you end up needing to make it very attractive price-wise in order to sell it.

This is all coming from a 1 Series owner so I have no axe to grind with BMW, the 1 Series or the M135i/140i.
They've sold over 10,000 M140i. That's a lot in this class of car and easily outselling rivals.


The 6 cylinder engine returns better fuel economy than the similarly powered 4 cylinder cars and has cheaper road tax too. £140 for the M140i auto.

Required service intervals are longer than rivals and BMW servicing prices is on par with other manufacturers. Keep the car for 3 years and most people will need one service and a brake fluid change. That should be no more than £350 total. The second service is a bit more costly at around £550 at a main dealer.

The automatic assumption the bigger engine will be more expensive to run and it's normally not the case in this instance.



Court_S

13,001 posts

178 months

Sunday 24th March 2019
quotequote all
sotonjoe said:
I guess the massive discounts are there simply because the car doesn’t sell enough. It’s a 1 Series which always struggles for popularity against more mainstream alternatives like the Golf and Focus, and it has a bloody great six cylinder engine in it which isn’t exactly a mainstream proposition either.

Add to that, some rather luke warm reviews from the motoring world with regards its handling and whether it’s actually fun to drive or a bit of a detached experience, and you end up needing to make it very attractive price-wise in order to sell it.

This is all coming from a 1 Series owner so I have no axe to grind with BMW, the 1 Series or the M135i/140i.
Not sure I agree there bud. The one series in all forms seems pretty popular and the M135 got an awful lot of good if not brilliant press. The six pot is it’s USP (well for now) in a segment dominated by turbo charged four pots.

My local Sytner seem to do a roaring trade in them. And the stock cars went pretty sharpish.

With regards to discounts, I was offered a pretty good chunk of money off a GTI TCR and the first ones haven’t even been delivered yet.

BMW seem to do pretty big discounts across the range these days. They seem to have adopted the Ford model whereby the list price is fiction that no one pays.

Deep Thought

35,848 posts

198 months

Monday 25th March 2019
quotequote all
No Sunset Orange cars in UK stock with the spec we want so we are running with an estoril blue one.

Could have it by the weekend. woohoo

Court_S

13,001 posts

178 months

Monday 25th March 2019
quotequote all
Deep Thought said:
No Sunset Orange cars in UK stock with the spec we want so we are running with an estoril blue one.

Could have it by the weekend. woohoo
Good stuff. What spec were you after?

The sunset cars that I was offered were either poverty spec or crazy spec, taking it past the number for the higher VED.

SmudgerByName

62 posts

101 months

Wednesday 27th March 2019
quotequote all
Does anyone have a link or a contact for these offers? Looking for something to replace the Velar in a few months time and I need something quick again

Court_S

13,001 posts

178 months

Wednesday 27th March 2019
quotequote all
SmudgerByName said:
Does anyone have a link or a contact for these offers? Looking for something to replace the Velar in a few months time and I need something quick again
I'm not sure if linking to other sites is allowed on here, but if you go to Baby BMW, under their sponsors section TRL (Tony Lewis) has a section which sets out the base deal plus the cost impact of options etc with his contact details.

Deep Thought

35,848 posts

198 months

Wednesday 27th March 2019
quotequote all
Court_S said:
SmudgerByName said:
Does anyone have a link or a contact for these offers? Looking for something to replace the Velar in a few months time and I need something quick again
I'm not sure if linking to other sites is allowed on here, but if you go to Baby BMW, under their sponsors section TRL (Tony Lewis) has a section which sets out the base deal plus the cost impact of options etc with his contact details.
+1

That's how I found it. I went armed to my local dealer but didn't need it though

Deep Thought

35,848 posts

198 months

Friday 29th March 2019
quotequote all
And thats it home! woohoo



The alloys are anthracite but that was taken first thing this morn when it wasnt fully light yet.

cerb4.5lee

30,738 posts

181 months

Friday 29th March 2019
quotequote all
Congratulations! thumbup

Love the colour, enjoy it. driving

Deep Thought

35,848 posts

198 months

Saturday 30th March 2019
quotequote all
cerb4.5lee said:
Congratulations! thumbup

Love the colour, enjoy it. driving
Thank you!

Yes, well pleased. Just need to find a new home for the MINI at some point..

HannsG

Original Poster:

3,045 posts

135 months

Sunday 31st March 2019
quotequote all
Deep Thought said:
And thats it home! woohoo



The alloys are anthracite but that was taken first thing this morn when it wasnt fully light yet.
Exactly what ours will look like. Nice! I'm glad I started this thread now!!

The alloys those are the orbit ones in the grey? Not matt black?


Deep Thought

35,848 posts

198 months

Sunday 31st March 2019
quotequote all
HannsG said:
Deep Thought said:
And thats it home! woohoo



The alloys are anthracite but that was taken first thing this morn when it wasnt fully light yet.
Exactly what ours will look like. Nice! I'm glad I started this thread now!!

The alloys those are the orbit ones in the grey? Not matt black?
Indeed, yes it inspired us to go look while the deals were still on smile

Yes, they're Orbit Grey, though darker looking than i was expecting.

Leicester Loyal

4,553 posts

123 months

Sunday 31st March 2019
quotequote all
That is absolutely stunning. Enjoy it!

What are the running costs on these? I've read a few reviews of people saying it's cost them around 5-6k for a year, is this normal or were these people just unlucky?

brickwall

5,250 posts

211 months

Sunday 31st March 2019
quotequote all
Leicester Loyal said:
That is absolutely stunning. Enjoy it!

What are the running costs on these? I've read a few reviews of people saying it's cost them around 5-6k for a year, is this normal or were these people just unlucky?
Total cost of ownership (incl. depreciation and capital cost) might be around that, perhaps a bit higher. Running costs alone should be nowhere near.

For what it's worth, my costs are:

Road tax: £140 (make sure the new price with options is under £40k)
Insurance: I pay £650
3 year service pack from BMW is £399, so £135 per year. If it's under warranty there should be no repairs.

That makes ~£950 before fuel and depreciation.

Fuel: I get 26mpg in mixed driving. At 8,000 miles per year that's £1,650

So that's £2,600.

Depreciation: Say £4k per year for the first 3 years (value from £29k new to £17k after 3 years). Maybe this is aggressive - but I can't see 3 year old ones being worth more than £20k.
Capital cost: Say average value £18k over the ownership period, at 1.5% - that's £270 per year.

So total £6.5-£7k. Perhaps take £1k off that if you're feeling bold about residuals.

Deep Thought

35,848 posts

198 months

Sunday 31st March 2019
quotequote all
Leicester Loyal said:
That is absolutely stunning. Enjoy it!

What are the running costs on these? I've read a few reviews of people saying it's cost them around 5-6k for a year, is this normal or were these people just unlucky?
Based on what we've seen so far, i'm expecting to see low to mid 30's in terms of MPG, but we do mostly longish runs. Our Cooper S did around 38MPG over the same runs. We're running it on Super Unleaded which adds a bit to the fuelling costs compared to the Cooper S which ran 95RON.

Depreciation? If we were getting £6,000 a year depreciation, then it would be worth £10,000 at year 3 which sounds overly harsh.

Checking the figures from TRL over on Baby BMW they're showing a residual of £13.3K at 4 years which would make depreciation closer to £4K per year, assuming you kept it 4 years. Changing at 1 or 2 years, and, like any car the depreciation curve will be steeper.

I think most if not all 5 door performance hatchbacks of that ilk will show more depreciation than that.

Edited by Deep Thought on Sunday 31st March 17:00

Deep Thought

35,848 posts

198 months

Sunday 31st March 2019
quotequote all
brickwall said:
Total cost of ownership (incl. depreciation and capital cost) might be around that, perhaps a bit higher. Running costs alone should be nowhere near.

For what it's worth, my costs are:

Road tax: £140 (make sure the new price with options is under £40k)
Insurance: I pay £650
3 year service pack from BMW is £399, so £135 per year. If it's under warranty there should be no repairs.

That makes ~£950 before fuel and depreciation.

Fuel: I get 26mpg in mixed driving. At 8,000 miles per year that's £1,650

So that's £2,600.

Depreciation: Say £4k per year for the first 3 years (value from £29k new to £17k after 3 years). Maybe this is aggressive - but I can't see 3 year old ones being worth more than £20k.
Capital cost: Say average value £18k over the ownership period, at 1.5% - that's £270 per year.

So total £6.5-£7k. Perhaps take £1k off that if you're feeling bold about residuals.
BMW have quoted us £299 for three years.

Leicester Loyal

4,553 posts

123 months

Monday 1st April 2019
quotequote all
The 5/6k figure seems reasonable I guess then and fairly standard when all costs are included, the models I was looking at were a couple of years old and not a Shadow Edition. Thanks for the replies.

This really is a stunning car, I can't help but keep looking at them online. I have to keep reminding myself I'm meant to be buying a house in a few months.

Court_S

13,001 posts

178 months

Monday 1st April 2019
quotequote all
Deep Thought said:
And thats it home! woohoo



The alloys are anthracite but that was taken first thing this morn when it wasnt fully light yet.
That looks lovely. EB really suits these. Now just the first boring 1200 miles to get through before you can really enjoy it.

For anyone else looking, Soper BMW have been advertising 0% on the outgoing 1 series. I have no idea what the discounts are like, I’d imagine it’s not the £10 plus thousands that were offered last quarter.

HannsG

Original Poster:

3,045 posts

135 months

Monday 1st April 2019
quotequote all
Deep Thought said:
BMW have quoted us £299 for three years.
Hi,

OP here. I have secured a service pack for £299 over the first three years of the car. I'll be doing 8,000 miles per year.

Is it worth it? God these cars are cheap to service compared to my E46 M3!!!!!