I may finally "get" crossovers...

I may finally "get" crossovers...

Author
Discussion

dmsims

6,538 posts

268 months

Monday 8th April 2019
quotequote all
Andy20vt said:
The current school mums favorite round here the RR Sport
Don't forget the Evoque complete with dyed blond hair, gold handbag, gaudy DG sunglasses and a bottle of water

1,156 L (up to 2018) and longer than a Yeti


Johnnytheboy

24,498 posts

187 months

Monday 8th April 2019
quotequote all
dmsims said:
Don't forget the Evoque complete with dyed blond hair, gold handbag, gaudy DG sunglasses and a bottle of water

1,156 L (up to 2018) and longer than a Yeti
On a tangential note, am I right in thinking the Evoque Convertible has been a bit of a flop? I've seen about three. It is silly money, mind.

hyphen

26,262 posts

91 months

Monday 8th April 2019
quotequote all
Johnnytheboy said:
dmsims said:
Don't forget the Evoque complete with dyed blond hair, gold handbag, gaudy DG sunglasses and a bottle of water

1,156 L (up to 2018) and longer than a Yeti
On a tangential note, am I right in thinking the Evoque Convertible has been a bit of a flop? I've seen about three. It is silly money, mind.
yes Seen only one, in orange. Not a single one currently on sale on Autotrader, so truly bombed!

Suprised to be honest, lmagined the fake tan types would have lapped them up.

Slow

6,973 posts

138 months

Monday 8th April 2019
quotequote all
hyphen said:
Johnnytheboy said:
dmsims said:
Don't forget the Evoque complete with dyed blond hair, gold handbag, gaudy DG sunglasses and a bottle of water

1,156 L (up to 2018) and longer than a Yeti
On a tangential note, am I right in thinking the Evoque Convertible has been a bit of a flop? I've seen about three. It is silly money, mind.
yes Seen only one, in orange. Not a single one currently on sale on Autotrader, so truly bombed!

Suprised to be honest, lmagined the fake tan types would have lapped them up.
There’s 82 on autotrader right now.

I would have one to be fair (once they go sub 5k) top down in the nice weather while not caring about the potholes while just going round town so not going to be fast either way.

petemurphy

10,130 posts

184 months

Monday 8th April 2019
quotequote all
dmsims said:
Don't forget the Evoque complete with dyed blond hair, gold handbag, gaudy DG sunglasses and a bottle of water

1,156 L (up to 2018) and longer than a Yeti
seeing as its the lowest depreciating car in the uk maybe theyre not as dumb as you think..

dmsims

6,538 posts

268 months

Monday 8th April 2019
quotequote all
petemurphy said:
dmsims said:
Don't forget the Evoque complete with dyed blond hair, gold handbag, gaudy DG sunglasses and a bottle of water

1,156 L (up to 2018) and longer than a Yeti
seeing as its the lowest depreciating car in the uk maybe theyre not as dumb as you think..
Custard time

petemurphy

10,130 posts

184 months

Monday 8th April 2019
quotequote all
dmsims said:
Custard time
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/money/cars/article-6898947/Cars-drop-value-quickest-three-years-revealed.html


nickfrog

21,189 posts

218 months

Monday 8th April 2019
quotequote all
Andy20vt said:
Indeed, remarkable that in a standard YETI you can get an amazing 1,760 litres of boot space in a car that is only 4.2 metres in length.
I couldn't agree more, we had the VW version (Tiguan MK1) and it was huge inside while still being short enough for us.

We now have the Yeti replacement (Karoq) and it's even bigger inside (1810l) as you can remove the rear seat altogether ; it's a little longer but still shorter than an Octavia Estate, so all good.

In terms of "image" and looking utilitarian etc.. we're not bothered what other people think, but I have no issues with anyone preferring a Yeti because it looks more functional tbf, each to their own.

It's good news to hear that you like Crossovers beer.




Edited by nickfrog on Monday 8th April 19:50

dmsims

6,538 posts

268 months

Monday 8th April 2019
quotequote all
petemurphy said:
dmsims said:
Custard time
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/money/cars/article-6898947/Cars-drop-value-quickest-three-years-revealed.html
How do they know the depreciation of the Range Rover Evoque P250 R-Dynamic ?

white_goodman

Original Poster:

4,042 posts

192 months

Monday 8th April 2019
quotequote all
Back to the OP, yeah, I quite like the Forester and it's more utilitarian and less "fashion"-led approach but it has gone more SUV and less "jacked-up" estate car than the first two generations. The problem with the Forester is that it's a class size up from most of the other vehicles under consideration and therefore spec-for-spec more expensive and you either have to go diesel (and a friend's wife got rid of hers fairly quickly because she hated the gearbox) or CVT if you want the XT (and generally I hate CVTs). Great AWD system though and had Subaru stuck with the Legacy Estate and Forester along the same lines as it used to be, they would have had a pretty captive customer in me, as I would have loved a Spec B or manual Forester XT to replace my WRX. Is the XV basically a "jacked-up" Impreza hatch i.e. no roomier. I could be wrong but I thought that I also read somewhere that it had a cheaper "Haldex"-type AWD setup?

I'm also a fan of the Yeti (very "Matro Rancho") and disappointed that Skoda didn't persevere with it. The newest would be 2 years old now though, so it would have to be lowish miles and I would prefer to seek out a 4x4 version. My wife's grandfather is in his 80s and generally buys a new car every 3 years but he's holding onto his 2014 Yeti, as it's the "best car he has ever had" and he doesn't like what they have replaced it with as much.

anonymous-user

55 months

Monday 8th April 2019
quotequote all
nickfrog said:
It's good news to hear that you like Crossovers beer.

Edited by anonymous-user on Monday 8th April 19:50
I like one particular crossover, not all crossovers wink

DoubleD

22,154 posts

109 months

Monday 8th April 2019
quotequote all
Andy20vt said:
nickfrog said:
It's good news to hear that you like Crossovers beer.

Edited by nickfrog on Monday 8th April 19:50
I like one particular crossover, not all crossovers wink
Do you like the 2 wheel drive yeti?

nickfrog

21,189 posts

218 months

Monday 8th April 2019
quotequote all
Andy20vt said:
nickfrog said:
It's good news to hear that you like Crossovers beer.

Edited by nickfrog on Monday 8th April 19:50
I like one particular crossover, not all crossovers wink
Fair enough. Considering how very similar they all are (if not near identical in VAG's case), the main distinction is image, but surely you're not too bothered about that, unlike the typical SUV buyer (apparently).

cailean

917 posts

174 months

Monday 8th April 2019
quotequote all
white_goodman said:
Back to the OP, yeah, I quite like the Forester and it's more utilitarian and less "fashion"-led approach but it has gone more SUV and less "jacked-up" estate car than the first two generations. The problem with the Forester is that it's a class size up from most of the other vehicles under consideration and therefore spec-for-spec more expensive and you either have to go diesel (and a friend's wife got rid of hers fairly quickly because she hated the gearbox) or CVT if you want the XT (and generally I hate CVTs). Great AWD system though and had Subaru stuck with the Legacy Estate and Forester along the same lines as it used to be, they would have had a pretty captive customer in me, as I would have loved a Spec B or manual Forester XT to replace my WRX. Is the XV basically a "jacked-up" Impreza hatch i.e. no roomier. I could be wrong but I thought that I also read somewhere that it had a cheaper "Haldex"-type AWD setup?
The XV is almost the same size as the original Forester that was so loved. It is the same AWD system as the Forester (not haldex) and now has X-mode as well. It does however have a CVT, but improved from the original ones.

warch

2,941 posts

155 months

Tuesday 9th April 2019
quotequote all
One bind with AWD cars, like 4x4 crossovers and all Foresters is the transmission and the need to keep the tyre diameters similar. You tend to have to change tyres in sets of four, not in pairs. Petrol Foresters seem to be quite thirsty too, although that is not unreasonable with the turbo models.

I don't mind Yetis but I haven't recovered from the sheer awfulness of my last car (Golf) to consider buying another VAG built vehicle just yet. Yetis are much more like a 4x4 version of these cars (we use one at work) which would probably make super family cars.



Frankthered

1,624 posts

181 months

Tuesday 9th April 2019
quotequote all
warch said:
One bind with AWD cars, like 4x4 crossovers and all Foresters is the transmission and the need to keep the tyre diameters similar. You tend to have to change tyres in sets of four, not in pairs. Petrol Foresters seem to be quite thirsty too, although that is not unreasonable with the turbo models.

I don't mind Yetis but I haven't recovered from the sheer awfulness of my last car (Golf) to consider buying another VAG built vehicle just yet. Yetis are much more like a 4x4 version of these cars (we use one at work) which would probably make super family cars.


I tend to agree, but they're boxy again.

These also tend to be slow and not the most entertaining things to drive. I'm occasionally tempted to find an older version because they'd be great for lugging stuff around, but a lot of the ones that come up used have been converted to accommodate a wheelchair.

tonyb1968

1,156 posts

147 months

Tuesday 9th April 2019
quotequote all
Johnnytheboy said:
Andy20vt said:
Do you work for Peugeot by any chance?
rofl

He should, if not!
Nope, but I do get very good discounts from my dealer biggrin

Edited by tonyb1968 on Tuesday 9th April 16:24

jwilliamsm3

286 posts

130 months

Sunday 14th April 2019
quotequote all
I'm not a fan of crossovers at all, although some I admit can look alright but I couldn't ever see myself having one.
Im not a lover of SUVs either, only ones I like are the silly fast and silly expensive v8 petrol ones like the x5m, Cayenne turbo etc.

My old girl had an F54 mini clubman JCW which she wanted to change as it was a manual, and she went looking for a replacement and spotted this Volvo XC90 T5. I could tell the dealer needed to get rid of it as it was a cancelled order, gave her all the waffle of the T5 engine has a very long waiting list etc, but when I checked the spec on it it was missing about 6 things I deemed as vital, so I managed to put her off.
In the end I convinced her to get an almost new GLA45 AMG for the same money as the Volvo but with an outstanding spec.
That's a crossover I can live with haha