Golf R or 320d touring shadow

Golf R or 320d touring shadow

Author
Discussion

oop north

1,599 posts

129 months

Wednesday 19th June 2019
quotequote all
DoubleD said:
iphonedyou said:
doog442 said:
Sensible idea, no idea why that dullard was laughing at you.
Re-using teabags is sensible, and about as relevant to OP's thread.
The option of buying a car was offered as an alternative choice. Your childish comments are not relevant.
Your comments were only more relevant in your head - not to the OP. Why on earth do you answer C when the question is A or B? Apart from this being the internet of course smile

ianreeves

255 posts

205 months

Wednesday 19th June 2019
quotequote all
So I have a Golf R....

On one hand I should feel lucky, it's a performance car. Fast, good build quality, has lots of equipment.

Yet after a bit, I've just fallen out of love with it. Driving wise it's very bland. Doesn't ask you to do much just point and feed it pertol, it just lacks soul.

On the motorway you either doing ****mph with ease or getting annoyed at the constant 6-7 shifting, ending just locking it in gear.

In town the DSH just isn't great at starting either it's snappy and rips your head off or in the different modes feels very laggy.

Maybe it's just me and I just don't love it anymore frown


Chestrockwell

Original Poster:

2,630 posts

158 months

Wednesday 19th June 2019
quotequote all
ianreeves said:
So I have a Golf R....

On one hand I should feel lucky, it's a performance car. Fast, good build quality, has lots of equipment.

Yet after a bit, I've just fallen out of love with it. Driving wise it's very bland. Doesn't ask you to do much just point and feed it pertol, it just lacks soul.

On the motorway you either doing ****mph with ease or getting annoyed at the constant 6-7 shifting, ending just locking it in gear.

In town the DSH just isn't great at starting either it's snappy and rips your head off or in the different modes feels very laggy.

Maybe it's just me and I just don't love it anymore frown
I thought that, thats probably the reason why the 3 series and the E class was in the list, sure they’re not as fast or as fun as the Golf but will he still love it after 2 years? The A6 is the best option I think, comfortable cruiser with enough power if you want it!

andrewparker

8,014 posts

188 months

Wednesday 19th June 2019
quotequote all
ianreeves said:
So I have a Golf R....

On one hand I should feel lucky, it's a performance car. Fast, good build quality, has lots of equipment.

Yet after a bit, I've just fallen out of love with it. Driving wise it's very bland. Doesn't ask you to do much just point and feed it pertol, it just lacks soul.

On the motorway you either doing ****mph with ease or getting annoyed at the constant 6-7 shifting, ending just locking it in gear.

In town the DSH just isn't great at starting either it's snappy and rips your head off or in the different modes feels very laggy.

Maybe it's just me and I just don't love it anymore frown
It's biggest problem is that you have to drive the nuts of it for it to be entertaining. Do that and you're one of the 99% of people driving the car like an idiot, according to the PH masses. Drive it normally and it's just a super competent car that is comfortable and supremely easy to live with. I have an R estate as a family car and to be honest it barely gets used. I'm always in the Up GTI, which in comparison is as basic as it gets, but lots of fun!



Shiv_P

2,754 posts

106 months

Wednesday 19th June 2019
quotequote all
Chestrockwell said:
Thanks for the input gents, he found a very good deal on an A6 45 TFSI S Line , 366 3+23 10k per annum. Same engine as the Golf GTI so plenty of grunt. The new Audi’s come with a lot of kit standard too!
I would go for this. The interior is stunning and it is being reviewed as better than the E class & 5 series for a daily driver.

DoubleD

22,154 posts

109 months

Wednesday 19th June 2019
quotequote all
oop north said:
DoubleD said:
iphonedyou said:
doog442 said:
Sensible idea, no idea why that dullard was laughing at you.
Re-using teabags is sensible, and about as relevant to OP's thread.
The option of buying a car was offered as an alternative choice. Your childish comments are not relevant.
Your comments were only more relevant in your head - not to the OP. Why on earth do you answer C when the question is A or B? Apart from this being the internet of course smile
I was giving options, what help are you giving?

Chestrockwell

Original Poster:

2,630 posts

158 months

Wednesday 19th June 2019
quotequote all
Wooda80 said:
iphonedyou said:
doog442 said:
Sensible idea, no idea why that dullard was laughing at you.
Re-using teabags is sensible, and about as relevant to OP's thread.
You're both wrong. He should stay in his current shed, pay the extra £360 pm into his pension and hope he lives long enough to draw it down . smile
I suppose it is sensible and the pension thing is a good idea but as I said, been driving sub shed cars for the past 2 years, before that were 3-4K cars, there’s always been something needed, he’s tired of breaking down. It’s time to drive something new with zero headache, Bluetooth, music streaming without an aux, sounds silly when you have the ‘put it towards the pension’ mentality’ but we all deserve some self indulgence now n then

Zetec-S

5,907 posts

94 months

Wednesday 19th June 2019
quotequote all
oop north said:
DoubleD said:
iphonedyou said:
doog442 said:
Sensible idea, no idea why that dullard was laughing at you.
Re-using teabags is sensible, and about as relevant to OP's thread.
The option of buying a car was offered as an alternative choice. Your childish comments are not relevant.
Your comments were only more relevant in your head - not to the OP. Why on earth do you answer C when the question is A or B? Apart from this being the internet of course smile
Nothing wrong with an option C sometimes, you never know when it might help the OP.

I was in a similar situation to the OP a few years ago, finally got settled on the property ladder and was tempted by the wheel of finance and PCP'd a new Focus. Yes, it was a lot nicer than my sheddy old Mk1 Focus, and was slightly more economical, but I do sometimes look back and think of what else I could have used that £xxx per month payment on instead. Either keeping said shed on the road a couple more years (plus plenty of change), or financing an outright purchase of something like a Mk5/Mk6 Golf GTI for half the price of the new Focus.

MR94

141 posts

60 months

Wednesday 19th June 2019
quotequote all
I'd avoid the 320d Touring Shadow Edition, they released the new 3 series Touring last week making the one you'd order the old model, which isn't fantastic when spending what is still a fair bit of money.

The F30/F31 3 series interior aged rather quickly too, although they're fantastic to drive they're not that great a place to sit and spend time imo. Sit in one and then sit in a well specced VW/Audi/Merc and you'll wonder how BMW sold as many as they did.

Do you have a link to that A6 deal? Weirdly I'm in the exact same position with the exact same budget, i'm about to FTK on an A250 Prem Plus, but that A6 deal sounds definitely interesting. What kit does it include? From what I've read about the new Audi range, it's only really the tech pack that you need to tick, every other option is unnecessary.

Chestrockwell

Original Poster:

2,630 posts

158 months

Wednesday 19th June 2019
quotequote all
MR94 said:
I'd avoid the 320d Touring Shadow Edition, they released the new 3 series Touring last week making the one you'd order the old model, which isn't fantastic when spending what is still a fair bit of money.

The F30/F31 3 series interior aged rather quickly too, although they're fantastic to drive they're not that great a place to sit and spend time imo. Sit in one and then sit in a well specced VW/Audi/Merc and you'll wonder how BMW sold as many as they did.

Do you have a link to that A6 deal? Weirdly I'm in the exact same position with the exact same budget, i'm about to FTK on an A250 Prem Plus, but that A6 deal sounds definitely interesting. What kit does it include? From what I've read about the new Audi range, it's only really the tech pack that you need to tick, every other option is unnecessary.
The petrols have all gone unfortunately but the company has a few 40 TDI’s, S Line black editions for 369, I don’t have the link for it but it’s from fleetprices.com!


Shiv_P

2,754 posts

106 months

Wednesday 19th June 2019
quotequote all
MR94 said:
I'd avoid the 320d Touring Shadow Edition, they released the new 3 series Touring last week making the one you'd order the old model, which isn't fantastic when spending what is still a fair bit of money.

The F30/F31 3 series interior aged rather quickly too, although they're fantastic to drive they're not that great a place to sit and spend time imo. Sit in one and then sit in a well specced VW/Audi/Merc and you'll wonder how BMW sold as many as they did.

Do you have a link to that A6 deal? Weirdly I'm in the exact same position with the exact same budget, i'm about to FTK on an A250 Prem Plus, but that A6 deal sounds definitely interesting. What kit does it include? From what I've read about the new Audi range, it's only really the tech pack that you need to tick, every other option is unnecessary.
The standard kit is finally quite decent. You still have lots of upgrades available though eg B&O sound, adaptive cruise (tour pack), extended LED lighting inside, matrix LED headlights, air suspension etc etc... you get the point. However with just tech pack you're right you end up with a very nicely specced car already.

2 sMoKiN bArReLs

30,263 posts

236 months

Wednesday 19th June 2019
quotequote all
ianreeves said:
So I have a Golf R....

On one hand I should feel lucky, it's a performance car. Fast, good build quality, has lots of equipment.

Yet after a bit, I've just fallen out of love with it. Driving wise it's very bland. Doesn't ask you to do much just point and feed it pertol, it just lacks soul.

On the motorway you either doing ****mph with ease or getting annoyed at the constant 6-7 shifting, ending just locking it in gear.

In town the DSH just isn't great at starting either it's snappy and rips your head off or in the different modes feels very laggy.

Maybe it's just me and I just don't love it anymore frown
Aha...you've got one of them new fangled automatical things with just the two pedals?

I've an old skool manual & I just love it! Just returned from a 2,600 mile euro road trip & it was the mutts nuts.



iphonedyou

9,258 posts

158 months

Wednesday 19th June 2019
quotequote all
DoubleD said:
The option of buying a car was offered as an alternative choice. Your childish comments are not relevant.
Whatever you say.

rofl

DoubleD

22,154 posts

109 months

Wednesday 19th June 2019
quotequote all
iphonedyou said:
DoubleD said:
The option of buying a car was offered as an alternative choice. Your childish comments are not relevant.
Whatever you say.

rofl
Point proven so thanks.

anonymous-user

55 months

Wednesday 19th June 2019
quotequote all
I'm old school.

Its great this kid has got on the housing ladder after two years of trying but buying new metal on £360 a month or whatever...madness. I really hope Big bro didn't encourage it.

Trust me after seven months or so there will be a few niggling doubts creeping as to why he will never actually own said motor and where that money could go instead. Saving up for the next house, pension contributions ?. I guess there's a reason I retired last 40's having paid the mortgage off and 3 kids through Uni....did I deserve a new car at any stage of that process? Of course not but still had plenty of car fun in the process hence the £8K option really shouldn't be balked at.

There are fully fledged professional people on very decent salaries, in big houses on BMW / Audi /Merc and Lexus forums who actively dissect the ins and outs of paying that sort of money for cars. Many are dropping off the PCP bandwagon and giving their head a shake.

cerb4.5lee

30,786 posts

181 months

Thursday 20th June 2019
quotequote all
2 sMoKiN bArReLs said:
ianreeves said:
So I have a Golf R....

On one hand I should feel lucky, it's a performance car. Fast, good build quality, has lots of equipment.

Yet after a bit, I've just fallen out of love with it. Driving wise it's very bland. Doesn't ask you to do much just point and feed it pertol, it just lacks soul.

On the motorway you either doing ****mph with ease or getting annoyed at the constant 6-7 shifting, ending just locking it in gear.

In town the DSH just isn't great at starting either it's snappy and rips your head off or in the different modes feels very laggy.

Maybe it's just me and I just don't love it anymore frown
Aha...you've got one of them new fangled automatical things with just the two pedals?

I've an old skool manual & I just love it! Just returned from a 2,600 mile euro road trip & it was the mutts nuts.


I'm also in the camp that two pedals spoil a car rather than improve it. Two pedals gives a car a completely different feel to one with three pedals. Even if a car is relatively boring to drive if it has three pedals you have an extra layer of involvement/interaction for me.

SWoll

18,477 posts

259 months

Thursday 20th June 2019
quotequote all
DoubleD said:
iphonedyou said:
DoubleD said:
The option of buying a car was offered as an alternative choice. Your childish comments are not relevant.
Whatever you say.

rofl
Point proven so thanks.
You don't think that it was fair to assume from the OP that the option of buying a used car had been considered and discarded as not what he is looking for?

What did you think his response was going to be? "What, you can buy older cars for cash? Thanks for letting me know as hadn't realised"

DoubleD

22,154 posts

109 months

Thursday 20th June 2019
quotequote all
SWoll said:
DoubleD said:
iphonedyou said:
DoubleD said:
The option of buying a car was offered as an alternative choice. Your childish comments are not relevant.
Whatever you say.

rofl
Point proven so thanks.
You don't think that it was fair to assume from the OP that the option of buying a used car had been considered and discarded as not what he is looking for?

What did you think his response was going to be? "What, you can buy older cars for cash? Thanks for letting me know as hadn't realised"
I was offering a different option, after that it is up to him.

Pica-Pica

13,852 posts

85 months

Thursday 20th June 2019
quotequote all
cerb4.5lee said:
2 sMoKiN bArReLs said:
ianreeves said:
So I have a Golf R....

On one hand I should feel lucky, it's a performance car. Fast, good build quality, has lots of equipment.

Yet after a bit, I've just fallen out of love with it. Driving wise it's very bland. Doesn't ask you to do much just point and feed it pertol, it just lacks soul.

On the motorway you either doing ****mph with ease or getting annoyed at the constant 6-7 shifting, ending just locking it in gear.

In town the DSH just isn't great at starting either it's snappy and rips your head off or in the different modes feels very laggy.

Maybe it's just me and I just don't love it anymore frown
Aha...you've got one of them new fangled automatical things with just the two pedals?

I've an old skool manual & I just love it! Just returned from a 2,600 mile euro road trip & it was the mutts nuts.


I'm also in the camp that two pedals spoil a car rather than improve it. Two pedals gives a car a completely different feel to one with three pedals. Even if a car is relatively boring to drive if it has three pedals you have an extra layer of involvement/interaction for me.
If an automatic is constantly shifting between top and next down gear, I suspect
a) inadequate torque
and/or
b) over-sized rolling circumference on tyres.

andrewparker

8,014 posts

188 months

Thursday 20th June 2019
quotequote all
doog442 said:
I'm old school.

Its great this kid has got on the housing ladder after two years of trying but buying new metal on £360 a month or whatever...madness. I really hope Big bro didn't encourage it.

Trust me after seven months or so there will be a few niggling doubts creeping as to why he will never actually own said motor and where that money could go instead. Saving up for the next house, pension contributions ?. I guess there's a reason I retired last 40's having paid the mortgage off and 3 kids through Uni....did I deserve a new car at any stage of that process? Of course not but still had plenty of car fun in the process hence the £8K option really shouldn't be balked at.

There are fully fledged professional people on very decent salaries, in big houses on BMW / Audi /Merc and Lexus forums who actively dissect the ins and outs of paying that sort of money for cars. Many are dropping off the PCP bandwagon and giving their head a shake.
Great.