best large reliable SUV for towing what fuel?

best large reliable SUV for towing what fuel?

Author
Discussion

Jumpingjackflash

Original Poster:

589 posts

179 months

Saturday 13th May 2023
quotequote all
I have started looking at a Large SUV for towing but the choices are not very easy. Firstly I wanted a Range Rover of Defender but I have been put off by stories of them getting stolen and expensive insurance. I also Heard the engines can be unreliable due to blocked DBF filters. What fuel? first choice would be diesel but as we know diesel is being phased out and I can see city centres banning them in the not so distance future. Are hybrids powerful enough to tow and would towing anything reduce battery life and make batteries pointless. A big petrol would be lovely but even though petrol is cheaper to buy economy would be terrifying. Any thoughts on a good SUV that would not break down, would be allowed into cities and not get stolen in a city?

Temo_Wil

161 posts

192 months

Saturday 13th May 2023
quotequote all
Recently purchased a 2014 Touareg R-Line to replace a V6S F-Pace. Inexpensive, reliable and goes under the radar. Has a great towing capacity as well….

DonkeyApple

55,342 posts

169 months

Saturday 13th May 2023
quotequote all
I would have thought a diesel Tuareg would be up there. Nothing fancy about them but they're good solid cars, built by the hundreds or thousands. And they're bad spec Lamborghinis at the end of the daybiggrin. Probably the only way to try and future proof a big ICE SUV would be a hybrid but I'm not sure you still won't risk getting clobbered for having the wrong sort of hybrid.

Nothing really beats a Range Rover at this game but the risk of getting one of the Friday editions is very unappealing if you just want an easy life.

paul arm1967

20 posts

143 months

Saturday 13th May 2023
quotequote all
If you want to go to the north pole get a land rover , if you want to go to the north pole and back get a land cruiser

Jumpingjackflash

Original Poster:

589 posts

179 months

Saturday 13th May 2023
quotequote all
Temo_Wil said:
Recently purchased a 2014 Touareg R-Line to replace a V6S F-Pace. Inexpensive, reliable and goes under the radar. Has a great towing capacity as well….
What was the F-Pace like? I like the new ones and to my eyes like mini Range Rovers inside. However they do share the JLR engines and presumably the remote control software for the keys.

biggbn

23,391 posts

220 months

Saturday 13th May 2023
quotequote all
Can you tow with a Lexus? If so, no brainer if reliability is your main criteria. Beautifully put together too, rx450 se-l 7 seater for me.

Temo_Wil

161 posts

192 months

Saturday 13th May 2023
quotequote all
Jumpingjackflash said:
Temo_Wil said:
Recently purchased a 2014 Touareg R-Line to replace a V6S F-Pace. Inexpensive, reliable and goes under the radar. Has a great towing capacity as well….
What was the F-Pace like? I like the new ones and to my eyes like mini Range Rovers inside. However they do share the JLR engines and presumably the remote control software for the keys.
It looked and sounded lovely. Sadly the quality was not as expected though with various electrical gremlins and things like cheap leather, surface corrosion in the rear arches, poor dealer service etc etc and all on a 3 year old car with 18k miles. In short I’d probably never have another JLR vehicle which is a shame as I have a soft sport for the new Defender 130

Jumpingjackflash

Original Poster:

589 posts

179 months

Saturday 13th May 2023
quotequote all
Temo_Wil said:
It looked and sounded lovely. Sadly the quality was not as expected though with various electrical gremlins and things like cheap leather, surface corrosion in the rear arches, poor dealer service etc etc and all on a 3 year old car with 18k miles. In short I’d probably never have another JLR vehicle which is a shame as I have a soft sport for the new Defender 130
I looked at a Defender 130 but they have a large hump in the boot which would stop easy and smooth loading.

Donkey44

74 posts

12 months

Saturday 13th May 2023
quotequote all
Very few cities not letting anyone in, they're just charging smokey stuff for the privilege!

Your budget appears key here, don't think I see it?

And how much do you need to tow, into cities? Lots of big stuff pulls 3.5T, do you need that?

Alan_B

49 posts

72 months

Sunday 14th May 2023
quotequote all
If I was buying again I’d go for a Touareg.

2 months ago I bought an extremely well maintained and cared for L322 4.4TDV8. It lasted all of 1.5 days and it’s been in the mechanics since. Just bad luck but in all honestly you need to mentally prepare yourself for a Range Rover. When they are good they can’t be beaten, but when they go wrong. . . .

ZX10R NIN

27,625 posts

125 months

Sunday 14th May 2023
quotequote all
You don't say what your budget is but I'd look at the 4.2d Cayenne or the X5 M50d.

elan362

150 posts

37 months

Sunday 14th May 2023
quotequote all
X3 M40d - an awesome car smile

Anything JLR seems to be getting stolen via OBD theft redface

Edited by elan362 on Sunday 14th May 09:38

jonny996

2,618 posts

217 months

Sunday 14th May 2023
quotequote all
biggbn said:
Can you tow with a Lexus? If so, no brainer if reliability is your main criteria. Beautifully put together too, rx450 se-l 7 seater for me.
Mine has a factory fitted tow , no idea what the capacity is or if any good for towing

biggbn

23,391 posts

220 months

Sunday 14th May 2023
quotequote all
jonny996 said:
biggbn said:
Can you tow with a Lexus? If so, no brainer if reliability is your main criteria. Beautifully put together too, rx450 se-l 7 seater for me.
Mine has a factory fitted tow , no idea what the capacity is or if any good for towing
How do you get on with the car overall. I love the edgy design of the newer shape rx and they just look so well made. Would love one one day.

jonny996

2,618 posts

217 months

Sunday 14th May 2023
quotequote all
biggbn said:
jonny996 said:
biggbn said:
Can you tow with a Lexus? If so, no brainer if reliability is your main criteria. Beautifully put together too, rx450 se-l 7 seater for me.
Mine has a factory fitted tow , no idea what the capacity is or if any good for towing
How do you get on with the car overall. I love the edgy design of the newer shape rx and they just look so well made. Would love one one day.
If you accept it’s a luxury barge then you can’t go wrong, ultra reliable and very well put together

biggbn

23,391 posts

220 months

Sunday 14th May 2023
quotequote all
jonny996 said:
biggbn said:
jonny996 said:
biggbn said:
Can you tow with a Lexus? If so, no brainer if reliability is your main criteria. Beautifully put together too, rx450 se-l 7 seater for me.
Mine has a factory fitted tow , no idea what the capacity is or if any good for towing
How do you get on with the car overall. I love the edgy design of the newer shape rx and they just look so well made. Would love one one day.
If you accept it’s a luxury barge then you can’t go wrong, ultra reliable and very well put together
beer

Jumpingjackflash

Original Poster:

589 posts

179 months

Sunday 14th May 2023
quotequote all
Are the JLR products that bad? Has the new defender more reliable engines and tech? What about the big Mercedes SUV’s? I did search for a land cruiser but they are not very desirable and can be expensive. A few mentions for the VW so I might look at the Cayenne equivalent. I understand the VW will be cheaper but I also want something desirable which maybe says more about my insecurities lol.

cerb4.5lee

30,676 posts

180 months

Sunday 14th May 2023
quotequote all
Jumpingjackflash said:
What about the big Mercedes SUV’s?
We've done nearly 30k miles in a Merc GLE400d and been very happy with it. Also did over a 100k miles in a GLC350d prior to the GLE and that was a very good car too.

Donkey44

74 posts

12 months

Sunday 14th May 2023
quotequote all
Horsey folk swear by the Shogun. Big tax but they almost all are when huge, and they keep on going.

ChocolateFrog

25,410 posts

173 months

Sunday 14th May 2023
quotequote all
The answer is still diesel unless fuel economy isn't an issue at all but seeing as you've already mentioned it I'm going to assume it is.

200 Series Land Cruiser if you can stomach the asking price.